Claim that Malay language is under threat merely political rhetoric, say analysts
EXPERTS have described the allegation that the Malay language is being sidelined under the MADANI Government as unfounded and contradictory to the administration's ongoing efforts to strengthen the national language's status.
Universiti Malaya socio-political analyst Professor Datuk Dr Awang Azman Awang Pawi views the MADANI Government as more progressive and consistent in promoting Malay as the primary medium of administration and national discourse, as enshrined in the Federal Constitution.
'The claim that the Malay language is losing its role is merely a political strategy,' he said, commenting on a statement made yesterday by former prime minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad who alleged that the Malay language and the position of the Malays are facing mounting threats under the current government.
According to Awang Azman, the statement is also inconsistent with Dr Mahathir's administrative history, notably when he introduced the Teaching and Learning of Science and Mathematics in English (PPSMI) policy in 2003.
'The policy provoked an intense backlash, as many parties, including the Movement to Abolish PPSMI, criticised it for diminishing the Malay language as a medium of knowledge and education,' he said.
Awang Azman stated that calls to unite the Malays must be accompanied by concrete actions that are consistent with the principles of justice, inclusivity and respect for Malaysia's cultural and linguistic diversity.
Echoing this view, National Professors Council Fellow Prof Dr Azmi Hassan pointed out that this is not the first time Dr Mahathir has used the 'Malay issue' to advance his political objectives.
'There is no such thing as the Malay language being under threat. It is only a small minority who view Malay as unintellectual, but in reality, it is they who lack intelligence.
'The current situation is much more stable compared to when the ICERD issue (International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination) and the recognition of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court arose in 2018 duringDr Mahathir's administration, which at that time sparked concern among the Malay community,' he said.
Meanwhile, a lecturer at the Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyyah of Law, International Islamic University Malaysia, Associate Professor Datuk Dr Shamrahayu A. Aziz, emphasised that the rights of the Malays, including the status of the Malay language as the official language, are enshrined in the Federal Constitution.
'The King and the ruling government are responsible for implementing the relevant provisions. If anyone claims that the government is failing to uphold these provisions, they must present clear evidence.
'This issue concerning the rights of the Malays has long been used as a political argument by various parties, but its status remains steadfastly protected within the framework of the Constitution,' he said.
Shamrahayu stressed that every government is responsible for ensuring the ongoing fulfilment of Malay rights, adding that any neglect of these provisions contradicts the spirit of the Constitution. ‒ June 6, 2025
Main image: Tech Wire Asia
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
11 hours ago
- The Star
Asean News Headlines as at 10pm on Friday (June 6, 2025)
Malaysia: * Engineer loses over RM1.5mil to online investment scam * Anwar expresses hope for Pakistan and India to find peaceful solution * Hadi hints he may step down as PAS president * US judge again halts ban on foreign students at Harvard * PETRONAS job cuts mainly affect contract workers, says Anwar * Malaysia reaffirms commitment to disaster-resilient education through national policy - Ahmad Zahid * FRU crash tragedy: JPJ opens investigation paper on lorry company * E-invoicing deadlines for businesses with revenue below RM5mil revised, says LHDN * S'wak keen on global partnerships in its bid to become a clean energy leader * Abim condemns US veto of UN Security Council's call for Gaza ceasefire * No foul play in death of man hit by LRT train in Puchong, say police * Police complete recording actor-cum-singer's statement over alleged sexual assault * High-rise tragedies show a systemic failure to ensure child safety, says children's commissioner Singapore: * Former senior minister Teo Chee Hean to be next Temasek chairman, taking over from Lim Boon Heng * Four charged over suspected involvement in 'blessing' scams * S$6,000 fine for man who falsely claimed Singapore minister made offensive remarks against Malays * Growing Temasek: Lim Boon Heng's contributions as chairman over the years * S$6k fine for man who falsely claimed Singapore minister made offensive remarks against Malays * Over 200 people investigated for suspected roles in scams in Singapore involving more than RM19.20mil in losses * Queues at VEP application centres in Singapore, JB after news of enforcement from July 1 * Ex-Singapore transport minister S. Iswaran completes home detention scheme, no longer under prison custody * Barge grounded off Tanjong Beach in Singapore's Sentosa, no reports of damage, injuries or pollution: MPA * Hong Kong branch of Singaporean 1880 club in liquidation with HK$20 million debt * Singapore can leverage on its trust premium * Asian equities see largest monthly foreign inflow in 15 months * Oil prices headed for rebound this week as US-China trade talks resume Indonesia: * Joyful aidiladha celebrations in Indonesia, communal spirit at embassy deepens brotherhood * Indonesia may install permanent stairlift at Borobudur Temple: Minister * Economic hardships subdue the mood for Eid al-Adha (Hari Raya Haji) in Indonesia this year * Indonesian legendary band Sheila on 7 returns to Malaysian for Latihan Pestapora super concert now at Bukit Jalil * Indonesian diva and pop princess Bunga Citra Lestari all set to bring her love tunes to KLCC on sept 27 * Indonesia wealth fund considers stake in Grab-GoTo deal, Bloomberg News reports * Badminton -- Superb comeback as Tang Jie-Ee Wei reach Indonesian Open semis * Woman thrives in cattle trading dominated by men Thailand: * Thailand conducts evacuation drills in seven border provinces amid tensions with Cambodia * Thai Airways shuts down Thai Smile after 12 years of losses * Thailand to begin trade talks with US — high-level negotiations underway * Thailand inflation remains negative in May; government cuts 2025 forecast * Asean remains a credible partner on global stage, says Thai minister * Thai military prepared for 'high-level operation' if Cambodia border row escalates * Thailand urges positive engagement after Cambodia threatens to take dispute to World Court * M'sia, Thailand tackle flood risks - Countries agree on early warning plan to enhance disaster response Filipino Muslims preparing butchered goats during the celebration of Eid Al-Adha at the Blue Mosque in Taguig, Metro Manila on June 6, 2025. - AFP Philippines: * Holding Sara Duterte trial isn't a choice, it's our constitutional duty, says senator * US military's logistics drill aims to burnish its East Asia crisis response * Philippines' jobless rate rises to 4.1 per cent in April * Filipino actress Michelle Dee bitten in the face by pet dog * Philippines: Sara questions impeachment trial Vietnam: * Cannes-winning film to compete at Danang Asian Film Festival 2025 * US Indo-Pacific commander calls PLA moves in strait 'rehearsals', not exercises * Vietnamese say no to more kids even after two-child limit scrapped; many prefer small family * Tariff War - Washington, Hanoi to fast-track trade negotiations * Vietnam's Vingroup seeks loan to buy KKR's Vinschool stake/ Foreign investment surges in five months Myanmar: * Six-year-old girl among Myanmar group arrested for killing retired general * 75 years of China-Myanmar ties commemorated in Myanmar with emphasis on bilateral cooperation, support Cambodia: * Cambodian troops deploy 12,000 soldiers near Chong Bok border: Source * Cambodia rejects Thai request for withdrawal of border forces * Cambodia's bold pledge to eliminate plastic pollution * Chinese and South-East Asian experts led by Cambodia share dolphin conservation strategies Laos: * Lao PM calls for united efforts to protect the environment * Laos takes steps to enhance irrigation development Brunei: * Malaysia, Brunei boost disaster, security cooperation * Brunei celebrates World Environment Day and its youth leadership * Brunei launches environment platform for youth AseanPlus: * Hong Kong tracks system that may develop into first 2025 typhoon * Japan curry shops see record bankruptcies as rice prices soar * Australian bouncy castle operator cleared over accident that killed six children * Hong Kong activist Joshua Wong charged under Beijing-imposed security law for second time * Australian cities offer free public transport to fill empty seats, ease cost of living pain * US visa hurdles put international students on edge * Japan allows longer nuclear plant lifespans * 'Elon Musk is not the father of my kids': J-pop diva Ayumi Hamasaki sets the record straight * India vows to keep up development in Kashmir after tourist attack * OECD: America emerges as biggest loser in Trump's trade war * Nepal ex-PM faces graft charge over land deal with Indian yoga guru's firm * Chinese tourist drowns at Pulau Perhentian * Over 70 delegates expected for Asean council meeting on drug menace next week in KL * Local actress Saidah Kamarudin cancels wedding, claims ex has only RM500 in his bank account * Trump says call with Xi produced 'very positive conclusion' * 14 emergency cardiac procedures in Saudi Haj hospital unit * Private lunar lander close to touchdown on moon's far north Models of the lunar lander Resilience (centre, left) and the lunar rover Tenacious (centre, right) operated by Japanese private company ispace are displayed at the Moon landing event venue in Tokyo on June 6, 2025. - AFP * Japan space ambitions dealt another blow after Ispace moon landing fails * Trump and Musk's relationship flames out just as intensely * From bros to foes: how the unlikely Trump-Musk relationship imploded * China's scientists unlock secrets of how early birds conquered the skies and publicly as it started * 'Treated like a criminal': Fury over Hong Kong student's Australian deportation * Harvard speech sparks China debate on elite education access, privilege * Tech giants' indirect emissions rose 150% in three years as AI expands, UN agency says * China's first foreign-owned hospital seeks medical tourists * More leave to address declining birth rates in China * Japan curry shops see record bankruptcies as rice prices soar * Indian police arrest four people for cricket fans stampede * South Korean conservatives looking for rebirth after election loss * Google's new AI-powered search has arrived. Proceed with caution * Is Labubu the next Hello Kitty? Analysts debate Pop Mart's limits * Burning ship abandoned in Pacific carried several Chinese car brands * Hong Kong bank robbery suspect's 'illogical' target sparks online debate * Taiwan's Pegatron says it is in final stage of evaluating US factory plan * 'Man mums' in China sell five-minute hugs for US$7, gain popularity among lonely women * Olympics - US travel ban will not hinder Los Angeles Olympics, LA28 CEO says * Soccer - Japan's Moriyasu mourns end of unbeaten run after loss to Australia * Ex-US envoy to China warns of Beijing involvement in Ukraine-Russia talks * Australian accused in mushroom murders searched for deadly strain before deaths, court hears * Another forced break as Tze Yong goes for knee surgery but he's staying positive * Tennis - Laser-focused Gauff ends Boisson's dream run to reach French Open final * Tennis - Finally conquering Paris clay would mean the world to me, says Sabalenka
Free Malaysia Today
15 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Madani economic reforms earn 50% score from Khairy
The number of people who pay taxes in Malaysia is disproportionately smaller than our peers, said Khairy Jamaluddin. (Bernama pic) PETALING JAYA : Former minister Khairy Jamaluddin has given the Madani government a 50% score for its performance on structural economic reforms since its formation in November 2022. Khairy pointed to three key areas that he believed demanded changes – widening the tax base, rationalising subsidies and pension reforms. He said the unity government has yet to carry out meaningful tax reforms to widen its revenue base, which he added was significantly lower even compared with peers in terms of gross domestic product. 'The number of people that pay taxes in Malaysia is disproportionately smaller than our peers, and that creates a problem for the government because your revenue base is too small. That's why we introduced the GST (goods and services tax),' he said, referring to the tax scheme introduced by the Najib Razak government in 2015. He pointed out that the planned expansion of the sales and service tax has been repeatedly delayed, while maintaining that a consumption tax like the GST was the way to go. (Government figures show that GST raised RM43.8 billion in 2018, while SST for 2024 is estimated at 44.7 billion) On subsidy rationalisation, Khairy said the biggest hurdle was targeting the RON95 petrol subsidies, which cost Putrajaya RM20 billion in 2023. The former Rembau MP said the last major reform needed was pension reforms, which is expected to balloon to around RM30 billion in the next decade. 'And it's going to rise because of the number of civil servants retiring, and life expectancy has also gone up,' he said, adding that the solution was getting rid of pensions for new government hires and shifting to EPF contributions. 'So if out of three big structural reforms, it's one and a half. So it's 50%,' he said in an episode of the Game of Impossible podcast with former minister Idris Jala and his son, Leon. The government is set to implement targeted subsidies for RON95 in the second half of the year, though details have not been released yet. Putrajaya has also announced that new civil servants would no longer get pensions but would contribute to EPF and the Social Security Organisation. Khairy reiterated that these reforms were important to ensure the country had enough funds for public services like health, education, and transport. 'You don't have enough money to make all the changes you want,' he said.
Focus Malaysia
17 hours ago
- Focus Malaysia
No buy-in from Malays to Tun M's Malay unity alliance movement; even Akmal says 'No thanks'
SUCH is the reception that twice former premier Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad gets after having mooted a movement to unite Malays with Bersatu and PAS in a bid to resolve issues faced by Malays that he alleges the current government has failed to address. A big 'slap in the face' would probably have to be that even the firebrand Malay rights defender in UMNO Youth chief Datuk Dr Muhamad Akmal Saleh has turned down the centenarian's invitation to UMNO members to join his Jawatankuasa Sekretariat Orang Melayu (Malay People's Secretariat Committee). 'But the same people also wanted to ban UMNO when they were in power … Now when they are not in power, the style is different,' he reacted in a Facebook post. 'Thank you, Tun, we appreciate your invitation but we still have not forgotten what happened. If you want to unite this nation, let it come from a sincere heart because you love the religion of the nation, not just want to get a position for yourself.' Although Dr Mahathir claimed that the movement is not politically motivated and will serve as a platform to resolve issues faced by the Malays by grouping them under a payung besar (big umbrella), he did caveat that the ultimate objective can only be achieved if it regain control of the government. Also present at the unveiling of the movement were Bersatu president Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, deputy president Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainuddin and vice president Radzi Jidin as well as PAS deputy president Datuk Seri Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man. Opposition-slant UMNO member Datuk Zaid Ibrahim foresees the Malay unity alliance initiative as merely another effort to consolidate Malay political forces which has thus far failed to achieve meaningful electoral success. 'This is unsurprising. Major parties like UMNO and PAS continue to prioritise their own agendas, often at the expense of broader unity,' observed the former de facto law minister on X. Dear Tun Dr Mahathir, You have been relentless in your pursuit of uniting the Malays, and I fully understand your concerns about their future and well-being. Your commitment to the cause is admirable. However, the effort to consolidate Malay political forces has, so far, failed… — Zaid Ibrahim (@zaidibrahim) June 5, 2025 'Bersatu has lost momentum. The anticipated exodus from UMNO never happened and the party now finds itself adrift. While still commanding its loyal base, PAS has not adapted sufficiently to meet the expectations of a more informed and demanding electorate.' Zaid went on to counter propose 'the formation of a leadership cohort: a group of 20 capable Malaysians, preferably under the age of 50 with demonstrated integrity and success in their respective fields – politics, business, academia, civil society and entrepreneurship'. 'This group should be publicly presented as the nucleus of a future national leadership,' he pointed out. 'Crucially, this group must come from a broad and inclusive spectrum. They must not be the usual suspects – party officials with worn-out ideas and questionable reputations – but fresh, untainted voices with the courage to speak and act in the national interest.' The bottom line is not only that man-on-the-street Malays have wised up by not wanting to fall for yet another sinister initiative in the guise of uniting them but even blamed Dr Mahathir for disuniting them at the end of the day: – June 6, 2025 Main image credit: Malay Digest (@malaydigest)/X
