Malachy Clerkin: Mayo's decision to oust Kevin McStay was fair enough but the way they did it was foul
Kevin McStay
and his management team might well find themselves relieved to be
out of it
. Relieved to be unhooked from the
Mayo
county board, relieved to no longer have to report to a group of people who can't even find a decent way to announce the end of the tenure of someone who had very publicly stepped back for health reasons.
'A Coiste Bainistíocht Meeting of Mayo GAA was held in Hastings Insurance MacHale Park this evening, Wednesday 25th of June,' read the statement on the Mayo GAA website on Wednesday night. 'At this meeting a decision was made to relieve Kevin McStay and his management team from their roles with the Mayo Senior Football Team with immediate effect.'
And just in case you were in any doubt as to what had occurred here, the webpage itself had the headline "
Mayo Senior Football Management are Relieved from their Roles
" emblazoned across the top of the statement not once, not twice but three (!) times. The Mayo county board evidently don't want any confusion here – they're the boys who put an end to McStay, don't you worry about that.
[
Kevin McStay relieved of his role as Mayo manager
Opens in new window
]
Managers come and managers go in all sports, all the time. But there's a way to do these things. In the
Premier League
, the world's most cut-throat, unfeeling sports league on the planet, seven managers (excluding caretakers and interims, etc) got sacked last season. Here's a flavour of the statements announcing their departures.
READ MORE
'
Erik Ten Hag
has left his role as
Manchester United
manager ...' '
Leicester City
FC has parted company with Steve Cooper ...' 'Southampton FC can confirm we have taken the difficult decision to part ways with Russell Martin ...' 'West Ham can confirm that Julien Lopategui has left the club ...'
Only once, in the case of Sean Dyche getting the bull's rush from
Everton
in January, was the phrase 'has been relieved of his duties' employed. And he hadn't even had a health scare. The Mayo County Board – sacking people with less compassion than 85 per cent of the softies in the Premier League.
Ah Mayo GAA never cease to amaze the good people.
Kevin & his backroom deserved better than that 💩 statement 🤯🤯🤯
— Lee Keegan (@leeroykeegan)
Were they within their rights not to go forward with a fourth year of McStay and Stephen Rochford and their backroom team? Of course they were. Nobody would argue that the three years so far have turned out the way they or anybody else in Mayo had hoped or planned.
When McStay was appointed, Mayo had been to two All-Ireland finals and a quarter-final in the previous three seasons. They got back to the last eight in 2023 but got blown away by what we now know was the last push of the great Dublin team. After that, they didn't make it past the preliminary quarter-finals last year or out of the group stage this year. The results graph has been pointing stubbornly in the wrong direction.
Ultimately, that's what has done the damage. Mayo haven't been a bad side under McStay but they made a bad habit of freezing at the most crucial moments and being heavily punished for it. In the past two seasons alone, they have been in position, late in games, to either win or draw against Galway, Dublin, Derry and Donegal. They didn't get it done. Not even once.
These were knife-edge matches with everything on the line. They led Galway by two in injury-time in last year's Connacht final and lost. They were ahead of both Dublin and Derry in injury-time later in that season and drew them both. The first draw cost them the week off and meant they had to play Derry. The second led to penalties and they were out.
This time around, they did all they could to respond to the witless defeat against Cavan by beating Tyrone in Omagh and fighting all the way back against Donegal. But as against Dublin and Derry, they couldn't win or slow or even interrupt a final opposition kick-out and Ciarán Moore put them out.
One last-minute killer score coughed up when the other crowd are on the back foot is a mistake. Three is a pattern. Bad enough that it's so completely debilitating in the moment but there's a knock-on effect too. Everyone knew that Mayo could be chased to the very last drop. They were always gettable. That's on the management.
So too is the fact that Mayo don't have a reliable scorer beyond Ryan O'Donoghue. Jack Carney, Fergal Boland, Bob Tuohy, Darren McHale – none of them have progressed beyond the realm of solid intercounty forward. Aidan O'Shea has had some of the best seasons of his career under McStay but it's been as a provider rather than a shooter. Losing Paddy Durcan for a year meant the scores from deep dried up. Jordan Flynn drifted out to become an impact sub.
You can blame each of them individually for not kicking on or you can question the environment in which they're developing. Were they given the tactical structure in which to flourish? Was the slow, passive build-up that so frustrated Mayo supporters to blame? Should management have taken more risks with what they had?
Of course, nothing is ever easy and you wouldn't call McStay's a lucky tenure. He lost Oisín Mullen and Lee Keegan before his team ever kicked a ball. The Galway defeat last year came down to some dicey enough refereeing calls. They won a league final in 2023 and lost another this year and got credit for neither.
Ultimately though, three years without notable progression is pretty damning. For the second year in a row, Mayo didn't play championship football in Croke Park. You have to go back to 2000 and 2001 for the last time that happened. In those circumstances, it's hard to have any massive issue with a county board deciding that time is up. The decision doubtless reflects the thinking of quite a chunk of the Mayo support base.
But you can be damn sure very few of that support base wanted it done in such a classless manner. That statement was the work of spivs and McStay deserved better.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
12 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Eight years, two All-Irelands and five All-Stars, Kerry's David Clifford takes stock of career to date
David Clifford at 26. It's an interesting time to take stock, at the halfway point of an extraordinary inter-county football career. It's eight years since Jack O'Shea, speaking after watching Clifford shoot 1-10 for the Kerry minors in the 2017 All-Ireland semi-final win over Cavan, said that the Fossa phenom was already equipped for senior duty. The Kerry seniors were preparing to play Mayo and O'Shea said he'd start Clifford if he could, 'without a doubt'. The rules prohibited it so a teenage Clifford stuck to minor duty and memorably hit Derry for 4-4 in that year's final. "I'm looking forward to watching him for the next 10 years," said O'Shea at the time. That decade has almost passed and Clifford last month claimed his second All-Ireland senior medal. He has seven Munster medals too, five All-Stars and will probably break new ground as the first three-time recipient of the Footballer of the Year award. But Jacko is still well out in front in the All-Ireland medal count, with seven. So how has the first half of his career been for Clifford, is he happy with everything he has achieved at this stage? "If I am to look back from here, it's been a very fast eight years with Kerry," said the PwC GAA/GPA Player of the Month for July in football. "Jesus, it doesn't seem like I've been playing senior for that long. I still feel 21 or 22 but it's not the case anymore. I don't know, like, you want to be winning All-Irelands and you'd love to win it every year but I suppose you're kind of realising that that's not the case and you kind of understand how hard they are to win." Clifford finished this year's Championship with 8-62 from nine games, comfortably the country's leading scorer with an average of just under 10 points per game. Even accounting for the 14 two-pointers he kicked - again, a record - it's outrageous scoring. What the schoolteacher and father of one can say for certain is that he enjoyed this All-Ireland more than the 2022 win. It was 'relief' back then, just to finally get a medal, while it was more smiles and celebrations across the 2025 campaign. There were plenty of comments about just how much Clifford celebrated his points and goals. "It probably just comes out, particularly the scores in Croke Park," he explained. "The crowd seemed to be behind us and if you can get a score and then get involved with the crowd, it just gives the crowd, and you, an extra lift again. So yeah, it probably just comes out of you at the time and sometimes you're probably over-celebrating and things but at the time it seems to be what's right." Clifford cuts a relaxed figure as his mid-20s eye up his late-20s. Lead him down avenues that he doesn't wish to travel and he's confident enough to immediately cut you off with the same ruthlessness he showed Brendan McCole on All-Ireland final day. For instance, he is asked if he'd fancy any new rules in Gaelic football. "I think we might be better off leaving them alone with all the changes over the last year," he deadpanned. He doesn't see much value in going deep into his apparent mentorship of the younger players in the Kerry panel either. "I don't think I said much to them, to be honest." Yet when Clifford felt a need mid-season to open up and encourage the supporters to get behind the team, he jumped on it. Ahead of the Armagh game, Clifford took the unusual step of publicly urging fans to turn out in big numbers at Croke Park. Did he feel the supporters weren't fully engaged? "Not really, there was a big crowd for the Meath game but we were brutal against Meath," he said. "As a team, we were miles off it. It would have been easy for people to stop coming after that game, that was the thing. It wasn't that they weren't behind us but it would have been easy to stop going to games after that because we were way off it. It wasn't good enough." The no-show against Meath will eventually be forgotten. When the story of the 2025 Championship is reflected upon, it'll be all about the smiles and scores of Kerry's lethal talisman. "There was a lot more joy and a lot more fun associated with it," acknowledged Clifford of 2025. Because of the new rules? "Obviously that made a massive difference," he nodded. "Look, the way the game had gone in the last few years, it became hard to get space. There weren't many kick-pass plays. So it was hard. You were trying to pick your way around it. At the time, maybe you didn't realise how hard it was. When you see the new game now, it's made a huge difference." Back in May, Clifford was only half joking when he lamented how quickly the four-point goal trial had been jettisoned. "I was liking the sound of the four points for a goal," he said at the time. The Football Review Committee had a look at it again recently. Presumably, given his eight goals in this year's Championship, Clifford would favour a rethink? "Possibly, yeah," he said. "Because I suppose at the moment the difference between a two-pointer and a goal isn't hectic. But still, a goal is still...I know it's only worth one more than a two-pointer, but it's just a bit different." And on the Clifford show will go, for the coming weeks and months with Fossa. After games, he will continue to be besieged by kids and autograph and selfie hunters, win or lose. "It can be hard at times, after a loss maybe with Fossa or whatever, and the kids still want their photo," said Clifford. "To try and remove yourself from the loss and understand that the kids just want their photo or whatever it is. You kind of get used to it. I'm not perfect with it. Sometimes you're just not in the form for meeting people or taking photos or whatever but I try, if I can, I try to help them out. I was a young person meeting Kerry players not that long ago, so I understand what it brings to them."
RTÉ News
27 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
John McGrath: Second half of final beyond 'wildest dreams'
Tipperary's John McGrath has admitted there was an "element of shock" in how the second half of their All-Ireland final victory over Cork unfolded. Liam Cahill's side - clear underdogs before the game and a long shot at the beginning of the campaign - outscored Cork 3-14 to 0-02 in a surreal second half to claim a first All-Ireland title in six years, just 14 months after they had finished bottom of the Munster SHC table. McGrath himself was at the centre of the second-half blitz, scoring the first and third goals and being instrumental in the creation of the second, winning the penalty which saw Eoin Downey sent off before Darragh McCarthy buried it to open up an eight-point gap. The Tipp full-forward, who this week collected the PwC GAA/GPA Hurler of the Month award for July, acknowledged there was an air of disbelief even among the winning team in the midst of the second half. "It's hard to put your finger on. In all the permutations that you're thinking (about) in the weeks leading up, they definitely all cross your mind," McGrath told RTÉ Sport this week. "But the manner in which we won it, I don't think anyone in their wildest dreams would have come up with that scenario. "There certainly was an element of shock. I knew we were relatively well up but to actually see the final score, it was kinda hard to believe that that had just happened. "Sport is funny like that. Everything just started to go right for us at a certain point of that second half. And the exact opposite for Cork at different stages - hitting the post, hitting the crossbar. Them little bits of luck are needed along the way. "But our lads just absolutely powered into that last 35 minutes. To save the best 35 minutes of the year for that time in an All-Ireland final... It's the kind of thing that you hope is going to happen. But how often does that actually come to fruition? It's unreal from that point of view." The prospect of a Tipp All-Ireland victory at any time in the near future seemed very remote at the start of the year. Cahill had faced questions about whether he intended to remain on after a wretched 2024 campaign, in which Tipp were eliminated from the Munster SHC with a game left to play after a frightful hammering at the hands of Cork in Semple Stadium. It was assumed they were deep in the weeds of a protracted rebuild. In that context, the 2025 success has been seen as one of the most abrupt and stunning turnarounds of modern times. Did the players believe they were realistic All-Ireland contenders at the beginning of 2025? "It's always in the back of your mind," McGrath says. "You certainly have a belief somewhere in you or I don't think you'd ever get to a stage of winning anything. "But mainly, we wanted to get competitive, first and foremost. Whatever comes from that, comes from it. We just needed to build ourselves back up. "We were losing games by double digits. More than once. It was about getting back to being competitive. "From that point of view, to where the year actually developed, it certainly is in some ways hard to believe. I'm living in Thurles and you're going down the town and the flags and colour are still up and in some ways, it feels like a bit of a dream. There's huge satisfaction. "After the last couple of years, a lot of lads could easily have let the things slip by a little bit. But I think we had a good bit of pride in ourselves. You want to be competing. We weren't happy looking at everyone else competing for trophies over the last couple of years." "We were losing games by double digits. More than once. It was about getting back to being competitive In some sense, McGrath's own fortunes mirrored that of the team generally. He finishes 2025 as the joint-leading scorer from play in the championship and as one of the contenders for Hurler of the Year. It's a far cry from much of the past three years. The Loughmore-Castleiney man ruptured his Achilles tendon in the 2022 Munster SHC defeat to Clare and the injury had dogged him in the interval. Now three-time All-Ireland champion McGrath, who turned 31 last month, had been reduced to the status of a bit-part player in the 2024 season, with just two championship appearances as a late sub. However, his illustrious club exploits in both codes had nurtured belief at a time when it might have ebbed away. Held in reserve for much of the league, it was the opening Munster SHC game against Limerick, in which he plundered two second-half goals in a rousing draw that proved a turning point. "Even before I had the injury, it [my form] was up and down a little bit for a year or two. The club form was one of the huge things that kept me going. In the back of your mind, you know it's there. "I saw very little league time. It's not as if I was tearing up trees at the time in training either. The lads [in the management team] took a small little bit of a chance on me coming into that Limerick game. "They said 'we're putting you in, you've been there, you have that little bit of experience.' "I probably put a lot of pressure on myself in that game. It was a sliding doors moment. I probably made it out to be a bigger game in my own head than it was. The couple of years before that had been on and off - and off more than on. "At the stage in my Tipperary career that I was at, I kinda needed to do something to remind myself and others what I was capable of. "Thank God, it kind of worked out for me that day. To be back stuck in it at that stage, it's something you don't want to let go of."
The Irish Sun
41 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
David Clifford urges GAA chiefs to stop tinkering with rules after Kerry's All-Ireland glory
Clifford, top scorer with a stunning 8-62, says he 'enjoyed it a lot more' this time as the Kingdom mastered Gaelic football's revamped rulebook TOO MUCH David Clifford urges GAA chiefs to stop tinkering with rules after Kerry's All-Ireland glory THE new rules that have revamped Gaelic football helped to make David Clifford's second All-Ireland SFC triumph even more enjoyable than the first. But with the Football Review Committee considering further changes, the talismanic Kerry forward reckons it is time to leave well enough alone. 2 David Clifford scooped the PwC GAA/GPA Player of the Month for July 2 The Kerry icon wants GAA brass to stop adjusting the rule in Gaelic Football Clifford thrived under the rule changes this year as the Kingdom regained the Sam Maguire. The victory over Donegal in last month's final delivered another Celtic Cross for the 26-year-old, who claimed his first in 2022. He said: "I think the first one was probably a lot of relief because you hadn't won one. This one, personally I enjoyed it a lot more. There was a lot more joy and a lot more fun associated with it." With 8-62 to his credit, Clifford finished atop the Championship scoring charts with a 33-point buffer separating him from team-mate Seán O'Shea in second. His tally was boosted by no fewer than FOURTEEN two-pointers. Addressing the role played by the rules, he continued: "Obviously it made a massive difference. "The way the game had gone in the last few years, it became hard to get space and there wasn't many kick-pass plays and there wasn't many fast plays, so it was hard. "You were trying to kind of pick your way around it and at the time maybe you didn't realise how hard it was. But when you see the new game now, it's made a huge difference." The roll of honour will forever show that Kerry were the first team to master the game since it underwent a significant overhaul ahead of the 2025 season. Clifford added: "The three-up and the fact that you can have bodies in the top half of the pitch when you turn over a ball, that you're able to kick-pass, we would have felt that would have suited us. Henry Shefflin among GAA stars at Oasis gigs where Man City tradition made its Croke Park debut "Obviously every team kind of adapts and it ends up suiting a lot of different teams. But we thought the way they were written up would have suited us alright." Further amendments to the rule book could still be made as the FRC recently put a couple more to the test in a trial game between Dublin clubs Round Towers and Fingallians. Players were unable to bring the ball back into their own half once it had crossed the halfway mark. The four-point goal, which Clifford admits to being 'not sure' about, was also given another spin after being scrapped from the agenda last winter. But the five-time All-Star said: "I think we might be better off leaving them alone with all the changes after last year. No, I'm happy with the way it is, to be honest." A third Footballer of Year award in four seasons looks likely for Clifford, who enhanced his status as an all-time great with a string of superb performances while also claiming National League and Munster SFC medals in 2025. The secondary school teacher, who made his senior debut just a few days removed from his 19th birthday, said: "I suppose if I'm to look back from here, it's been a very fast eight years with Kerry. "Jesus, yeah, it doesn't seem like I've been playing senior for that long. I still feel 21 or 22, but it's not the case anymore. 'Like, you want to be winning All-Irelands and you'd love to win it every year. "But I suppose you're kind of realising that's not the case and you kind of understand how hard they are to win so you kind of cherish the ones we've won a bit more maybe." While being tightly marked by Brendan McCole, Clifford spent just 43 seconds in possession during this year's All-Ireland final. Yet it is a mark of his magic that he still managed to rack up 0-9. He explained: "You might have only eight or nine possessions in the final and in another game you could have 30 possessions. It just depends what kind of comes in front of you. "I'm delighted if I can keep wide and let the rest of the boys do damage. I'm delighted with that. At this stage, it's just about winning as a team. "The individual stuff now doesn't really matter much. It's about winning as a team. That's kind of all that matters to me now." KINGDOM FAME As a bona fide superstar, Clifford has grown accustomed to being mobbed by young supporters in the aftermath of games, particularly with his club Fossa and divisional outfit East Kerry. On life in the limelight, he said: "It can be hard at times. Let's say after a loss, maybe with Fossa or whatever and kids still want their photo, to try and remove yourself from the loss and understand that the kids just want their photo or whatever. "You kind of get used to it. I'm not perfect with it in one sense. Sometimes you're just not in the form for meeting people or taking photos or whatever. But I try, if I can, to help them out. 'I was a young person meeting Kerry players not that long ago, so I kind of understand what it brings to them.'
