UN admits internet conference panel was edited after Saudi complaint
United Nations officials have acknowledged that a recording of a panel discussion featuring human rights organisations at a conference in Riyadh was edited following a complaint from the Saudi government.
The UN's Internet Governance Forum (IGF) was accused by Human Rights Watch on Thursday of censoring critical comments made by Saudi Arabian activist Lina al-Hathloul during the event at IGF's conference in the Saudi capital in December.
Asked whether the IGF had been prompted to act by Saudi Arabia, an IGF spokesperson told Middle East Eye it had 'received a request from the host nation' regarding an alleged violation of its code of conduct.
The spokesperson said it was standard procedure that the host 'may raise concerns about adherence to rules agreed upon by all participants'.
'The Secretariat's role in such cases is to review the concerns in an impartial manner, engage with the concerned party, and seek a solution that adheres to the IGF's commitment to multistakeholder dialogue.'
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
The involvement of Human Rights Watch and Alqst - a UK-based organisation that campaigns for human rights in Saudi Arabia - in the IGF's conference in Riyadh was considered significant because of the kingdom's repressive track record.
Hathloul, Alqst's head of advocacy, spoke remotely at the panel event co-hosted by HRW and Alqst because of concerns for her safety.
But last month, the IGF published an edited version of the panel on YouTube in which significant portions of Hathloul's comments as well as a moment of silence for human rights defenders punished for expressing themselves online, including several held in Saudi Arabia's prisons, were removed.
In their place was a note saying they had been removed for violating the IGF's code of conduct, particularly a section in which participants are asked to focus remarks on issues rather than on 'individuals, groups, organisations or governments, and to refrain from personal or ad hominem attacks'.
The comments that now appear where many of Lina al-Hathloul's remarks were made during the 16 December panel at the UN IGF in Riyadh (YouTube)
HRW also said that UN officials told Joey Shea, the organisation's Saudi Arabia researcher who moderated the panel, that the Saudi government had complained and asked the UN to revoke her accreditation for the conference.
The officials referred to an HRW video that cited the case of imprisoned retired Saudi Arabian teacher Mohammed al-Ghamdi "as the basis of the host country's complaint", and also said that Shea's naming of specific human rights defenders during the panel might have constituted a code of conduct violation.
Saudi Arabia plans to execute Shia youths on charges UN deems 'arbitrary' Read More »
The UN officials told Shea they would discuss whether to revoke her accreditation badge with UN headquarters in New York, HRW said. Her badge was ultimately not revoked.
HRW has said that Shea's mention of specific detained human rights activists did not comprise a 'personal or ad hominem attack' and that she did not mention which governments had imprisoned the activists.
The UN IGF noted on Friday that it had 'responded to an infringement' of its code of conduct by speaking with the civil society organisation representative concerned 'and arriving at a mutually agreed solution'.
'No retaliation in any form occurred. The secretariat's actions were taken to uphold the spirit of the rules, which is to foster democratic, multistakeholder discussions,' a spokesperson said.
The spokesperson also said that the IGF remained 'dedicated to creating a forum where diverse perspectives, including those of civil society organisations, are respected and heard'.
'The presence and active participation of human rights organisations such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, who were likely present in a major meeting setting in Saudi Arabia for the first time, reflect the IGF's broad commitment to these values.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Etihad
an hour ago
- Al Etihad
Iran launches fresh wave of missile attacks on Israel in response to airstrikes
14 June 2025 08:52 (REUTERS)Iran and Israel targeted each other with missiles and airstrikes early on Saturday after Israel launched its biggest-ever air offensive against raid sirens sounded in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, Israel's two largest cities, sending residents rushing into shelters as successive waves of Iranian missiles streaked across the skies. The military said its air defence systems were operating."In the last hour, dozens of missiles have been launched at the state of Israel from Iran, some of which were intercepted," the Israeli military said rescue teams were working at a number of locations across the country where fallen projectiles were reported, without commenting on Iran, several explosions were heard in the capital Tehran, the semi-official Tasnim news agency Iranian Fars news agency said two projectiles hit Tehran's Mehrabad airport, and Iranian media said flames were reported there. Close to key Iranian leadership sites, the airport hosts an air force base with fighter jets and transport media said a suspected missile came down in Tel Aviv, and a Reuters witness heard a loud boom in Fars news agency said Tehran launched waves of airstrikes on Saturday after two salvos on Friday night. One of the waves targeted Tel Aviv before dawn on Saturday, with explosions heard in the capital and Jerusalem, witnesses were in response to Israel's attacks on Iran early on Friday against commanders, nuclear scientists, military targets and nuclear sites. Iran denies that its uranium enrichment activities are part of a secret weapons central Tel Aviv, a high-rise building was hit, damaging the lower third of the structure in a densely populated urban area. An apartment block in nearby Ramat Gan was ambulance service said 34 people were injured on Friday night in the Tel Aviv area, most with minor injuries. Police later said one person had US military helped shoot down Iranian missiles headed for Israel on Friday, two US officials said. Israel's military said Iran fired fewer than 100 missiles on Friday and that most were intercepted or fell short. Several buildings in and around Tel Aviv were Israeli strikes on Iran throughout the day and the Iranian retaliation raised fears of a broader regional United Nations (UN) envoy Amir Saeid Iravani said 78 people, including senior military officials, were killed in Israel's strikes on Iran and more than 320 people were wounded, most of them UN envoy Danny Danon said intelligence had confirmed that within days Iran would have produced enough fissile material for multiple bombs. He called Israel's operation "an act of national preservation."Iran has long insisted its nuclear programme is for civilian purposes only. A UN nuclear watchdog concluded this week that it was in violation of its obligations under the global non-proliferation President Donald Trump has said it is not too late for Tehran to halt the Israeli bombing campaign by reaching a deal on its nuclear programme. Tehran had been engaged in talks with the Trump administration on a deal to curb its nuclear programme to replace one that Trump abandoned in 2018. Tehran rejected the last US offer. The talks are due to resume in Oman on Sunday but Iran has since signalled it might not join.
Al Etihad
an hour ago
- Al Etihad
UN chief Guterres calls on Israel and Iran to de-escalate
14 June 2025 09:03 NEW YORK (dpa)UN Secretary General António Guterres on Friday called on Israel and Iran to urgently de-escalate."Israeli bombardment of Iranian nuclear sites. Iranian missile strikes in Tel Aviv. Enough escalation," Guterres wrote on X."Time to stop. Peace and diplomacy must prevail."However, both Israel and Iran reported further attacks Iranian attacks were in response to the large-scale assault launched by Israel on Thursday night. According to Israeli reports, more than 100 targets were hit, including sites in the major cities of Tehran, Tabriz and Shiraz, as well as the Natanz uranium enrichment facility.
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
How Iran's 'hybrid attack' network could retaliate against Israel in Europe
Iran can call on networks of criminals and even its own agents smuggled into Europe as migrants to carry out retaliatory attacks against Israeli and Jewish targets, following Friday's strikes by Israel. Tehran has previously relied on regional allies Hezbollah, the Houthis and Hamas to attack Israel. However, with what Tehran called its 'ring of fire' degraded, it has other avenues further afield, particularly in Europe, to hit back against Israel. These include criminals networks, most notably two based in Sweden run by Kurdish gangsters Rawa Majid and Ismail Abdo, that have been accused of carrying out attacks on Israeli targets. Majid, who is nicknamed the Kurdish Fox, and his Foxtrot network were placed under sanctions by the US and the UK this year for orchestrating an attack on the Israeli Embassy in Stockholm. Three Iranian nationals were recently charged in the UK with a plot to attack an individual on behalf of Iran. An official report released in Germany on Tuesday warned that the potential threat from Iran is growing. The findings, which summarised trends in 2024, said Iranian intelligence services can be assumed to be ready to 'pursue the interests of the country's leadership by all means – including acts of violence and even assassinations'. 'The tense security situation in the Middle East and internal tensions within the Islamic Republic of Iran shape its intelligence activities,' the Ministry of Interior document said. 'Activities directed against Germany continue to emanate primarily from the Ministry of Intelligence or MOIS. In addition to the MOIS, the Quds Force of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps, which also operates as an intelligence agency, is also active in Germany. 'Intelligence services of the Islamic Republic of Iran also use state terrorist means to achieve their goals,' it added. 'This primarily involves the intimidation and neutralisation of opposition members, but also the punishment of 'traitors' or 'defectors'. 'Iran's activities go well beyond spying on the opposition Iranian diaspora and that pro-Jewish and pro-Israeli interests and institutions in Germany are the focus of Iranian activities.' Jason Brodsky, policy director of advocacy group United Against a Nuclear Iran, told The National that European nations need to be 'extra vigilant and step up alerts' given that Iran 'has long planned contingency plans for terror operations in the West'. 'That's a risk that everyone should be alert for, especially Israel and the Jewish community, and Iran still retains that capability through the IRGC or its intelligence ministry,' Mr Brodsky said. 'They will also hire criminal networks to foment terror and undertake operations. And there are also Iranian dissidents that the regime targets. These are potential risks to look at and policymakers need to make it clear to Iran that any operations will be viewed as akin to an act of war.' Speaking before Israel's attack, the UK's Foreign Secretary, David Lammy, announced the creation of a 'counter-hybrid taskforce' aimed at combating the activities of states such as Iran. Tehran has been developing hybrid warfare tactics including using cyberattacks, proxies and propaganda. Mr Lammy said Britain's diplomats 'will be ready for this murky new age of sabotage and subterfuge'. Iranian actors and criminals working for them have been known to carry court surveillance and reconnaissance, with the intention of carrying out serious violence. Announcing sanctions against Majid and his Foxtrot network, the US Treasury said Iran was 'increasingly' using criminal networks as proxies so it could maintain plausible deniability for operations against its enemies. 'Iran's brazen use of transnational criminal organisations and narcotics traffickers underscores the regime's attempts to achieve its aims through any means, with no regard for the cost to communities across Europe,' said Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. Iran has sought to assassinate dissidents through other criminal networks, including that of Iranian drug trafficker Naji Ibrahim Sharifi-Zindashti, who had sanctions imposed on him by the US last January. Known as 'the Big Guy', he allegedly organised the attempted murder for hire of two residents of the state of Maryland. Tehran has also used foreign individuals, known in the spying trade as 'disposable assets', to harass opponents of the regime, including employees of Iran International, a London -based dissident television channel. In December 2023, Magomed-Husejn Dovtaev, a Chechnya-born Austrian citizen was found guilty of spying on the broadcaster. Iran International was forced to move to new high-security studios after being shut down following alleged threats from the Iranian state. Two Romanian citizens were charged in December 2024 over the stabbing of Iran International journalist Pouria Zeraati. Iran International spokesman Adam Baillie said: 'We are watching developments closely and we remain as ever on high alert for the security implications.'
