Tesla heads to Miami court for wrongful death trial involving Autopilot system
The fatal crash took place in April 2019, when a Model S Tesla equipped with the Autopilot technology struck a parked vehicle in Key Largo, Florida, killing one woman and gravely injuring a man.
The lawsuit, originally filed in April 23, 2021, in the 11th Judicial Court of Florida in Miami-Dade County, marks the first wrongful death case against Tesla to make it to trial. The plaintiffs, Dillon Angulo, and the family of Naibel Benavides Leo, who was killed in the accident, are requesting punitive damages and compensation for medical costs and other expenses.
The trial will be a major test for the EV maker which has had to contend with slumping sales and a hit to its stock price after CEO Elon Musk took on a central role within the Trump Administration as head of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE).
Musk has since stepped back from leading DOGE, although earlier this month after renewing a squabble with President Trump over the recently signed One Big Beautiful Bill Act, he floated launching a third party, dubbed the "America Party" — a move experts say could further imperil the billionaire's company's future. Tesla is also in the midst of rolling out its self-driving Robotaxis, which were part of a pilot in Austin Texas last month.
The lawyers representing the plaintiffs in the case did not respond to CBS MoneyWatch's request for comment.
Autopilot's reputation at stake
According to recent court filings connected to the case, Tesla-owner George McGee had the Autopilot function of his 2019 Tesla Model S activated as he was driving on two-lane rural road in Key Largo on April 25, 2019. McGee dropped his phone as he was approaching an intersection, and lost sight of the road as he bent down to pick it up, court documents state.
In that moment, McGee's car allegedly plowed through the T-shaped intersection at over 60 miles per hour failing to break before crashing into the side of Chevrolet Tahoe truck parked on the side of the road, killing Naibel Benavides Leon, 22, and seriously injured her boyfriend, Dillon Angulo who were standing by the truck, which was owned by Angulo.
At issue is whether the car's Autopilot system was defective and contributed to the death of Benavides. In a court filing, Todd Poses, one of the plaintiff's lawyer claims that design defects in the car's Autopilot system failed to detect obstacles, such as the profile of the Chevy Tahoe, resulting in the death of Benavides.
In its Motion for Summary Judgement, filed on June 26, Tesla argues that the Autopilot feature "did not make the car 'self-driving'" and that McGee was aware "was high aware that it was still [his] responsibility to operate the vehicle safely even with Autopilot activate."
"The evidence clearly shows that this crash had nothing to do with Tesla's Autopilot technology. Instead, like so many unfortunate accidents since cell phones were invented, this was caused by a distracted driver. To his credit, he took responsibility for his actions because he was searching for his dropped cell phone while also pressing the accelerator, speeding and overriding the car's system at the time of the crash. In 2019 when this occurred, no crash avoidance technology existed that could have prevented this tragic accident," Tesla said in a statement to CBS MoneyWatch.
Trial Details
The trial begins July 14.
Mary Cummings, a George Mason University professor and expert on advanced driver-assistance systems is likely to testify at the trial, documents from the lawsuit's docket indicate. McGee, the driver of the car, is also expected to testify.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Entrepreneur
9 minutes ago
- Entrepreneur
Couple's Weekend Hobby Turned Into Business With $4M+ Revenue
Husband and wife Mickey and Vicky Popat went all in on PlantOGram in 2007. Mickey Popat worked in finance, and his wife, Vicky Popat, was a teacher when their weekend gardening hobby led to more than 80 fruit trees planted in their Orlando, Florida, backyard — and the idea to turn the passion into a business. Image Credit: Courtesy of PlantOGram. Vicky Popat, left, and Mickey Popat, right. " I grew up with all kinds of amazing tropical foods, guavas and mangoes and lychee," Mickey, who immigrated to the U.S. from South Africa in the early 1990s, says, "and I was surprised [because] a lot of family and friends would come over [and ask], 'Oh my God, what is a guava? I've never tried one.' And then they'd say it was the best-tasting thing they'd ever had." Soon, those same family and friends asked the Popats if they could help them plant their own fruit trees. Mickey and Vicky both "came from a long line of entrepreneurs," and the business concept began to take root. In 2007, the couple decided to go all-in on PlantOGram, a luxury fruit tree gifting company. Related: 'We Got So Many DMs': This 27-Year-Old Revamped Her Parents' Decades-Old Business and Grew Direct-to-Consumer Sales From $60,000 to Over $500,000 "To start this business, we had to give back all the luxury items we had." The Popats quit their day jobs to dedicate themselves fully to the business. They planned to bootstrap the venture using their savings, so it was time to get lean — and make some strategic moves. "To start this business, we had to give back all the luxury items we had," Vicky says. "We turned in all of the cars, the Lexus, the Jags, the fancy clothing. Everything had to go. We sold everything and bootstrapped our idea." Mickey and Vicky put the money made toward a practical business purchase: a $1,500 Ford Econoline work van. Related: This 43-Year-Old Started a Side Hustle at a Farmer's Market — Then She Quit Her Job and Built an 8-Figure Brand Sold in Costco On early weekend mornings, the couple scoured farmers markets for plants, buying a variety to test the market. The Popats loaded those plants into their van and drove door-to-door to find customers. Sometimes they'd set up as many as 50 plants on someone's driveway to display all of their options. Eventually, Vicky created a book of their offerings to streamline the selection process. The "self-taught" co-founders undertook their door-to-door strategy without marketing skills, but they learned some along the way, turning to "YouTube University" for guidance when necessary, they say. The couple had success with printing business cards and leaving them on people's doors. Whenever the Popats received an inquiry about the business in those days, they recorded it in a book by hand — tracking the client's name, what kind of tree they wanted and how they'd heard about the business. "We realized early on that [for] a lot of the consumers, this was more of an experiential gift." The one-on-one engagement with PlantOGram's customer base proved invaluable, allowing the Popats to learn more about what people wanted. "We realized early on that [for] a lot of the consumers, this was more of an experiential gift," Mickey says. "They were growing with their kid, with their children, their grandchildren. They [were] generational gifts because these plants are here for decades." About a year into their business's launch, the Popats established a web presence. That, too, was executed with a lean mentality. The Popats didn't hire a developer; they built the website themselves. Initially, the website was just a source of information. People could learn more about the business, but they couldn't input a credit card or place an order. One particularly determined customer would change that. A woman in Georgia wanted a specific tree she couldn't find elsewhere, and she was "adamant" that the Popats send it to her. She sent them a check, and the couple tried to figure out the best way to ship the tree, ultimately landing on bare rooting, where the plant's roots are dug up, cleaned of soil and transported without any soil. "It got there [and] lived for maybe a week and a half," Vicky recalls. "And then she called me and said, 'I'm sending another check. I'm sending checks until you figure it out.'" Related: 'Beyond Our Wildest Dreams': This Founder's Scrappy Startup Has Raised More Than $39 Million — and Counting — for Small Businesses 'Facing an Extinction Event' The couple consulted their fathers, who had a bit more mechanical experience, about how to proceed. Those brainstorms led to the standardized shipping approach that PlantOGram still uses today, nearly two decades later. The company ships plants in their containers with no bare roots and has a 99.9% success rate, Mickey says. " I always say when our plants arrive and they take that box off of it, [it's] like how you have someone [hiding] in a box [as a] surprise. That's how our plants arrive because the leaves come out flushed and they're just like, 'We're here,'" Vicky says. "We loved being in the driver's seat and having that full control." PlantOGram enjoyed steady growth up to its website launch, but the new ability to ship gave the business the additional boost of gaining customers nationwide. These days, the company is online exclusively, and in the last year and a half, PlantOGram entered the international market, shipping to Europe, Asia and the Middle East, with plans to continue expansion. PlantOGram saw $4.2 million annual revenue in 2024, per the company. Even as they successfully grew the business, the Popats intentionally avoided taking outside investment. The founders wanted full control over "all of the decisions, all of the wins and all of the failures." " I know it's not for all entrepreneurs," Mickey says, "but for us, we loved being in the driver's seat and having that full control. With some businesses, when you bring in outside capital, sometimes that comes with a lot of strings and a [loss of] power." Vicky agrees, adding that bootstrapping has also allowed them to sharpen their problem-solving skills — the importance of which she first learned from her entrepreneurial parents. " I watched my mom and dad become real problem-solvers in [the] moment," Vicky explains. "You're able to think a lot more clearly [and say], Okay, well, we've got to do this. We have to get from here to here. How do we do it? We have X amount of dollars. How do we use this? And we stretch." Related: I Revamped a Men's Product for Women. The Bootstrapped Business Was a Hit — and Pledged $20 Million to Support Women Entrepreneurs. PlantOGram saw another uptick in sales in 2020 amid the pandemic. People across the country wanted to learn more about growing and bringing plants into their indoor and outdoor spaces. "We had plants going out like crazy, especially in New York," Vicky recalls. "And those people from the pandemic times are still gardening today. They didn't stop. They're still more aware of their surroundings. They're more aware of their carbon footprint. They're more aware of everything now." These days, mango trees — which boast more than 2,000 varieties to choose from — are surging in popularity, and avocado and olive trees are also having a moment, Vicky notes. Olive trees, with their symbolic representations of peace and prosperity, are especially hot within the corporate gifting space right now, she says. "If you're really serious about it, go and get a license." The Popats have learned a lot about what it takes to make a business flourish over the years, and to aspiring entrepreneurs who might want to transform their hobbies or passions into ventures of their own, they offer two key pieces of advice. First, don't just talk about your business idea ad nauseam: Take action. During a recent conversation with their daughter, who asked how exactly PlantOGram came to be, Vicky explained that once inspiration struck, she made sure they went down to acquire the business license — no hesitation. "If you're really serious about it, go and get a license," Vicky says. "Get an LLC, go get an S corp. Go do something. And then you can start talking about your ideas [and] really put it down. Don't overthink it." Related: The Definitive Guide to Licensing: When You Get a Great Idea, What Do You Do Next? Finally, don't underestimate the value of staying lean whenever possible — after all, it's the approach that laid the foundation for where PlantOGram is today. "We watched every penny, [and] being lean allowed us to be profitable," Mickey says. Ready to break through your revenue ceiling? Join us at Level Up, a conference for ambitious business leaders to unlock new growth opportunities.
Business Insider
11 minutes ago
- Business Insider
We visited the first Tesla Diner. It was surreal and heavy on nostalgia, but we'd go back.
Dozens of Teslas — of all models and colors — packed into the lot of Elon Musk 's new diner on Monday evening as West Hollywood's newest restaurant celebrated its grand opening with fanfare, curiosity, and at least one protester. The retro-futuristic eatery drew a pedestrian crowd that at times circled the block and provided a promenade for tricked-out electric vehicles. Diehard Tesla fans and curious onlookers alike stopped in for a bite to eat and a selfie with a popcorn-serving humanoid robot. The unusual atmosphere paired a mix of nostalgia and science fiction: "The Twilight Zone" played on giant screens, servers dashed by on roller skates, and EVs and robotics were proudly on display. "Aiming to be a fun experience for all, whether Tesla owners or not. Will keep improving," Musk wrote on X following the Tesla Diner's official opening. While the buzzy diner was a bit chaotic, Business Insider's Ben Bergman and Katherine Tangalakis-Lippert agreed: the architecture was eye-catching, the atmosphere was intriguing, and the menu, served up by celebrity chef Eric Greenspan, was tasty enough to warrant more visits. Representatives for Tesla did not immediately respond to a request from Business Insider for comment. A past-meets-future design Tesla applied for permits for a "Tesla restaurant and supercharger station" in Santa Monica in 2018, just months after Musk first hinted at his plans to build a retro diner at a charging station. After years of waiting for construction to be completed, one would expect the Tesla Diner to be worth ogling — and it didn't disappoint, especially at night. The diner sits on a corner of Los Angeles's famous Santa Monica Boulevard, aka the historical Route 66, and it features sleek, curved edges, a rooftop patio overlooking two 45-foot-tall drive-in screens, and retro neon signs. The expansive parking lot has V4 80 Supercharger stalls, making it the largest urban charging hub in the world. Dozens of Cybertrucks — some polished, several modified for off-roading, and one adorned with a DogeCoin-themed vinyl wrap — paraded through the lot on opening night while other models of Tesla vehicles honked their horns or blew bubbles. Inside, the restaurant looks like what you might expect an animator from "The Jetsons" would dream up: a vintage perspective on the future. The crisp white walls and shiny white tile floor stand in stark contrast to the black ceilings with neon blue lighting. The seating is familiar to anyone who's been to a diner, though few patrons stayed in the main dining area. Large clusters of customers formed around the "pick-up" area of the bar, waiting for their orders, while others ate upstairs on the Skypad. Large, rounded windows fill many of the building's walls, and artwork includes prototypes of humanoid robots created by Tesla: Bumblebee, a 2022-era droid, and iterations of Optimus, which the company is working to bring to market. A classic diner menu, reimagined Chef Greenspan, a James Beard award nominee and Food Network personality known for his imaginative takes on old-school favorites, took control of the kitchen for the Tesla Diner's opening service. The menu, available 24 hours a day, highlights classic diner fare: smash burgers, hot dogs, tuna melts, club sandwiches, chicken and waffles, tallow fries (wagyu chili and cheese optional), and milkshakes. Breakfast options, also available around the clock, include breakfast tacos, avocado toast, biscuits and gravy, yogurt parfaits with berries, and cinnamon rolls. Prices range from $9 to $15 for entrées, which come in Cybertruck-themed packaging, and sides run from $4 to $12. Kids' meals are $13 a piece, and drinks start at $4. No alcohol is served on-site. Though some on social media were quick to critique the price point, prices are comparable to other nearby restaurants, including the classic Astro Burger joint down the street, established in 1972, which offers similarly priced grub and retro vibes. For dinner, one BI reporter and their date tried the Tesla Burger, Fried Chicken & Waffles, Tallow-fried fries with wagyu chili and cheese, Hash Brown Bites, Epic Bacon, and two milkshake flavors. At breakfast, another BI reporter had breakfast tacos, a cinnamon roll, and an iced latte. Everything sampled was worth a second bite — there were decidedly no disappointments on the menu items tried. However, the food was somewhat inconsistent, as one might expect from a grand opening, when the kitchen is still working out the kinks. Half of the Tesla Burger had a classic smash burger texture, while the other was so thick it was medium rare in the center. The bacon had some burned bits and some chewy ones, and the tallow fries varied in texture. The breakfast taco was tasty, but it was overpowered by too much cheese. Several customers during the dinner service complained that their meals took upward of 45 minutes to be served. Eater reported that Musk himself demanded every item on the menu be "epic" or be removed from its list of offerings. The "epic" bacon — with maple glaze and black pepper — was perhaps the least exciting bite of the meal, in one reporter's view. All told, however, the menu was solid diner fare: nothing revolutionary, but it hit the spot. Still working out the kinks The Tesla Diner was bustling within hours of its opening, with trash already strewn on the floor and foot scuffs highly visible on the light-colored flooring. Greenspan could be heard shouting through the restaurant during dinner service, calling out orders to be re-fired or rushed as the kitchen dealt with wave after wave of guests flowing through its doors — typical for a grand opening. For a place emphasizing technology and robots, there was also a lot of human help. Scores of helpful and friendly staffers guided drivers to their spots and helped handle all the traffic. As one reporter was eating their meal, a worker came over to ask: "How are you enjoying everything?" Upstairs on the Skypad, an Optimus robot was serving popcorn to guests. Staff gave conflicting information on whether the bot was controlled by a human operator. One said the bot was "legit" serving up the treats on its own, while another — who was serving as security for the bot when BI stopped by — said its human operator was no more than 30 feet away. The demonstration was meant to "mimic" what the real operations would look like when the bots were fully operational, the second staff member said. Tesla representatives did not immediately respond to questions about Optimus' autonomy. The diner is open 24/7, and for Tesla owners, it's useful to have somewhere nice to go and grab a bite or just work on your laptop during the 45 minutes or more it can take to charge your vehicle. During the opening, idle fees — which Tesla charges when a vehicle remains plugged into a Supercharger after reaching its limit and the station is at least half full — were waived. Tesla drivers are supposed to be able to order food directly from the screen in their cars, though that feature was not available as of Tuesday. One worker said it would be ready on Wednesday after a "software update." Fans and curious passersby outweighed critics by a large margin. At least one anti-Musk protester was spotted outside during the dinner service, with a sign that read "Workers should have power, not the billionaires!" While it remains to be seen how long the novelty of the Tesla Diner will linger at this location, Musk has said this is just the first of many souped-up Supercharger stations to come. On Monday, shortly before the Los Angeles location opened its doors to the public, Musk confirmed in a post on X that he's planning to build a second drive-in near SpaceX's Starbase spaceport in Texas. "If our retro-futuristic diner turns out well, which I think it will, @Tesla will establish these in major cities around the world, as well as at Supercharger sites on long distance routes," Musk said in a separate post. "An island of good food, good vibes & entertainment, all while Supercharging!" Whether the diner guests are primarily Tesla drivers or inquisitive onlookers, the Tesla Diner makes it clear that Musk is expanding his EV brand — and the food was pretty good.
CNBC
11 minutes ago
- CNBC
Tesla set to report second-quarter earnings after the bell
Tesla will report second-quarter results after the close of regular trading on Wednesday. Here's what Wall Street expects, according to an average of estimates compiled by LSEG: Revenue in the period is expected to drop 11% from a year earlier, marking a second straight quarterly decline. In early July, Tesla reported a 14% year-over-year slide in vehicle deliveries to 384,000 for the second quarter. Deliveries are the closest approximation of EV sales reported by Tesla but aren't precisely defined in its shareholder communications. Tesla's slump this year is partly due to a backlash against the company in the U.S. and Europe, after CEO Elon Musk spent heavily to help reelect President Donald Trump, endorsed Germany's extreme anti-immigrant AfD party, and then led the Trump administration's Department of Government Efficiency. At DOGE, Musk helped to slash the federal workforce, roll back regulations, and eliminate USAID. Other automakers saw their electric vehicle sales increase, eating away at Tesla's market share during the second quarter. General Motors' U.S. sales of EVs rose 111% year-over-year to nearly 46,300 units in the period for an estimated market share of 16%, still far behind Tesla. Musk's political activism hasn't been the only factor weighing on the brand. Tesla has put off the production of a more affordable "model 2" EV, while other automakers are now offering a greater variety of vehicles, and China-based competitors are selling affordable EVs with high-tech self-driving features as a standard rather than premium option. Tesla shares are down about 17% for the year, the worst performance among tech's megacaps. The Nasdaq is up more than 8% in 2025. Musk has tried to keep fans and investors focused on Tesla's future, which he envisions as being dominated by the company's robotaxis, and humanoid Optimus robots. Musk sees Tesla's robotaxis as working for their owners, making them money while they sleep. Optimus robots, he says, will be so sophisticated they can serve as factory workers or babysitters. Tesla opened a diner and charging station in Los Angeles this week, where fans can see the Optimus robots at work on a simple task, slowly scooping popcorn. The company faces massive competition in robotics from developers including 1X Technologies, Agility Robotics, Apptronik, Boston Dynamics and Figure AI. In June, Tesla began testing a robotaxi service in Austin, Texas, which operates in a limited area with a human valet on board. The service is accessible only to select riders, generally Tesla and Musk enthusiasts. The robotaxi rollout is seen by bulls as a positive sign for the company, but Bank of America analysts cautioned in a recent report that it would have "immaterial financial ramifications" in the near term. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, meanwhile, has pressed Tesla for information about reported incidents where the vehicles appeared to violate traffic laws. In one incident, a Tesla robotaxi scraped a parked vehicle at a pizzeria parking lot in Austin, and in another, a robotaxi veered out of its lane briefly into oncoming traffic. In a note earlier this month, Barclays analysts said Tesla has shown "weak fundamentals" heading into its earnings report. Still, shareholders have remained excited about Tesla's "robotaxi narrative," wrote the analysts, who have the equivalent of a hold rating on the stock. Wednesday's report will be the first for Tesla since Musk officially left his role in the Trump administration and immediately preceded to publicly slam the president, mostly for the Republicans' spending package that he endorsed. Musk has since promised to start a new political party in the U.S. which he calls The America Party. One retail investor submitted an anonymous question via the Say platform, which Tesla uses ahead of earnings calls, to ask, "With Elon Musk now more publicly involved in U.S. politics through the new America Party, is Tesla taking any steps to manage potential risks, whether from shifting political alliances, regulatory perception, or public opinion?" Most questions submitted to the platform sought updates from Tesla about its robotaxi test in Austin, self-driving ambitions and its plans for a more affordable EV model. Tesla's automotive gross margins are also likely to be in focus, along with commentary on how the company will weather Trump's tariffs and the end of federal tax credits for EV buyers. Company executives will host an earnings call with analysts at 5:30 p.m. ET.
