Ramasamy wants Penang EXCO reprimanded for unilateral decision on Indian Muslim housing discount
I am bewildered that Penang state Housing and Environment Committee chairman Datuk Seri S. Sundarajoo could announce a 5% housing discount for Indian Muslims under the Madani housing scheme without apparent consultation with his other EXCO colleagues.
Sundarajoo justified the move on grounds of low participation among Indian Muslims in state housing.
But can he furnish data to back this claim? What are the comparative participation rates of Malays, Chinese, Indians and Indian Muslims?
He also stated that this discount would not affect allocations for the Malays – yet he seems to overlook the complex identity overlap where some Indian Muslims are classified as Malay/Bumiputera while others maintain their distinct ethnic identity.
Has there been any study quantifying the percentage of Indian Muslims who qualify under the Bumiputera category versus those who identify separately?
Jumping the gun?
Without such data, it's hard to justify a policy decision that could result in dual benefits for a segment of the population, raising questions of fairness and equity.
Had this proposal been tabled in an EXCO meeting, its flaws could have been debated and possibly avoided.
But instead, Sundarajoo proceeded based on consultations with developers – not the state government – casting doubt on the integrity of Penang's housing policy framework.
This was a poor decision made without transparency and without consideration for other equally deserving communities. The policy lacked sound rationale and undermined public confidence.
In this regard, I commend Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow for stepping in to reverse the decision and broadening the discount to all eligible Malaysians.
I urge Chow to go a step further – reprimand Perai state assemblyman Sundarajoo for bypassing proper procedure and acting irresponsibly on a matter of public policy. – June 9, 2025
Former DAP stalwart and Penang chief minister II Prof Ramasamy Palanisamy is chairman of the United Rights of Malaysian Party (Urimai) interim council.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
Voice of doubt in Nvidia's H20 chips grows louder in China
US chip giant Nvidia faces increasing mistrust in China over its H20 chips, after the company secured a licence from Washington to export the tailor-made processors by agreeing to pay 15 per cent of its revenues to the US government. On Sunday, a Chinese state media outlet labelled Nvidia's H20 chip as unsafe and urged Chinese buyers to boycott the artificial intelligence processors designed for the Chinese market. Despite Nvidia's repeated denials of 'back-door' vulnerabilities, Yuyuan Tantian, associated with state broadcaster China Central Television, said the H20 chip could not be trusted because of the US government's alleged efforts to embed 'back doors' in the chips. 'When a chip is neither environmentally friendly nor advanced or safe, as consumers, we certainly have the option not to buy it,' the outlet said in a commentary. It suggested that the H20 chip could be remotely controlled through hardware and software exploits, citing Washington's attempts in 1992 to implement surveillance via chip back doors and a recent bill proposed in May requiring US chipmakers to incorporate tracking features. Nvidia's chief security officer David Reber Jnr published a blog post last week titled: 'There are no back doors in Nvidia chips. No kill switches. No spyware.' Chinese state media's allegations come as the US Department of Commerce has begun issuing licences to Nvidia for exporting H20 chips to China. Nvidia and rival Advanced Micro Devices agreed to pay the US government 15 per cent of their revenues from chip sales to China as part of a deal with the Trump administration to secure export licences, the Financial Times reported on Sunday. Yuyuan Tantian's article reflects Nvidia's struggle to establish trust in China, which accounted for 13 per cent of its revenues in the last financial year despite escalating technology rivalry between Beijing and Washington. Last month, the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC) summoned Nvidia for discussions about the risks associated with potential tracking and remote control functions of its H20 chips. In an opinion piece titled 'How can we trust you, Nvidia?' earlier this month, the People's Daily, the official newspaper of the Central Committee of the Communist Party, called on the US chipmaker to provide proof of its security measures to regain the trust of Chinese customers. In response, Nvidia said it 'does not have 'back doors' in our chips that would give anyone a remote way to access or control them'. The H20, an AI graphics processing unit released by Nvidia last year specifically for China to comply with US export restrictions, has become a focal point in the tech war between the two countries after Washington lifted a sales ban on the chip last month. While the resumption of H20 sales is expected to provide a near-term boost to China's AI development, Nvidia faces challenges amid Beijing's scrutiny and a push from domestic firms to adopt home-grown processors, such as those developed by Huawei Technologies. The CAC's review served partly 'as a reminder to domestic firms to avoid over-reliance on a single chip and to always be prepared to use alternatives', Chinese semiconductor research firm ICwise said in a note last week, which has since been deleted. The firm also said that China's interest in the H20 chip was likely to 'continue to wane' as the country's chip sector advanced. - SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST
The Sun
4 hours ago
- The Sun
Laman Malaysia MADANI promotes sustainable values and national unity
PUTRAJAYA: Laman Malaysia MADANI, a newly launched landscaped area at the Botanical Garden, embodies national identity through design elements reflecting sustainability, well-being, innovation, respect, trust, and compassion. Chief Secretary to the Government Tan Sri Shamsul Azri Abu Bakar emphasised that the garden serves as an educational platform for visitors to grasp MADANI's principles and aspirations. He described the site as a tangible representation of an inclusive, sustainable, and unifying national vision. The garden features a prominent MADANI logo sculpture symbolising trust in the nation's direction, alongside a unity mural and iconic flowers representing love and togetherness. Senior officials, including Public Service Department director-general Tan Sri Wan Ahmad Dahlan Abdul Aziz, attended the launch alongside the unveiling of the publication 'Shamsul Azri: 365 Days of Upholding the Trust'. Shamsul Azri highlighted the garden's creative and sustainable elements, such as recycled-material benches and solar-powered lighting. He announced plans to expand the project to 10 public parks in Putrajaya to further embed MADANI values within the community. The special publication by INTAN documents public service reforms and leadership insights from Shamsul Azri's tenure. He noted that leadership involves listening, understanding, and making tough decisions for collective progress. The upcoming Public Service Premier Address (MAPPA) will gather 3,000 civil servants to align government policies with Malaysia MADANI aspirations. MAPPA aims to strengthen unity and commitment in advancing public service reforms. – Bernama
Borneo Post
5 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Sabah PH-GRS seat talks still unsettled
TAWAU (Aug 12): Negotiations on seat allocations between Sabah Pakatan Harapan (PH) and Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) for the 17th state election remain unresolved. Sabah DAP deputy chairman Datuk Chan Foong Hin dismissed claims that GRS demanded 50 seats while PH would contest 23, labelling them 'political speculation'. 'The seat negotiations are not finalised. I don't even know the numbers,' said Chan, who is also Deputy Plantation and Commodities Minister. 'We'll enter the 'ring' respectfully once a decision is made.' He was speaking to reporters after officiating at a pepper cultivation promotion programme here Tuesday. Commenting on speculation that the election (PRN17) could be held on September 7 following Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's planned visit to Sabah, the Kota Kinabalu MP stated the dissolution date falls under the Chief Minister's authority. 'I don't know when the Prime Minister will visit, let alone the dissolution date.' Separately, Chan expressed Sabah DAP's confidence in defending all six seats it won in the last election, including Sri Tanjung and Elopura – now held by Warisan after the incumbents defected. Earlier, Chan said the local pepper industry recorded continuous price increases in the first seven months of this year. He said the average price for black pepper has increased by 51 per cent to RM27,240 per tonne compared to RM18,066 per tonne last year. 'Meanwhile, the average price for white pepper also increased by 43 per cent to RM37,407 per tonne compared to RM26,164 per tonne last year. 'This encouraging pepper price trend is expected to persist until the third quarter of this year following the recent strengthening of the ringgit,' he said. He said the pepper commodity is an economic resource generator for 39,449 pepper farmers in Malaysia who cultivate about 8,293 hectares of pepper. 'The total includes 248 farmers in Sabah who cultivate 41 hectares of pepper plantation. I encourage more Sabahans to take the opportunity to get involved in pepper cultivation to increase their income. 'I am of the view that the development of pepper cultivation in Sabah can be implemented by taking into account the advantages of the terrain and hilly topography suitable for pepper cultivation,' he said. Chan said the Ministry of Plantation and Commodities together with the Malaysian Pepper Board are committed and actively working to guide pepper cultivation entrepreneurs in this country, including through outreach programmes such as in-situ training and Tuesday's programme.
