Good American Family review: An eye-poppingly bizarre true story that fails to come to life
Just as there are many types of crime in the world – bank robbery, money laundering,
Ed Sheeran's
Galway Girl
, etc – so there are many varieties of true crime television. From the tabloid documentary to the gritty drama, streaming has had a go at them all. But
Disney+'s
new thriller, Good American Family, has an altogether different take on a milieu built on the suffering of strangers: it is deathly dull.
Its snoozy qualities are a surprise, considering the presence of likable Grey's Anatomy star Ellen Pompeo, playing an influencer mother who may or may not be the villain of the piece. And also because the real-life case on which it is based is so eye-poppingly bizarre – involving claims of false identity, drugging, emotional manipulation and worse.
These are all terrible subjects, but none could be described as dreary. Yet Good American Family commits the egregious sin of attempting to send the viewer to sleep at every turn.
It tells the story of Kristine and Michael Barnett (Pompeo and Mark Duplass) who adopt a seven-year-old-child with dwarfism from
Ukraine
only to conclude she is in fact an adult posing as a minor. There are many twists – though Good American Family gives the ending away with the opening.
READ MORE
The tale rewinds to 2010. The Barnetts are the parents of boys but desperate for a daughter to 'complete' their family. When the girl they were looking after with a view to adoption is instead given over to the care of a blood relative, Michael is heartbroken – but Kristine appears unmoved. It's almost as if the child she had thought of as her own is now dead to her – but, never mind, there is the possibility of a second chance when an agency asks if they might be interested in adopting Natalia Grace (Imogen Faith Reid).
Viewers familiar with the real case – a genuine scandal in the
United States
– will be aware of the many twists and turns to follow. As the drama unspools, it becomes unclear who the hero or the monster is – or, indeed, which side is gaslighting the other. And yet, a potentially gripping story never comes to life – one major flaw being Pompeo's inability to bring any nuance to Kristine. Torn between depicting her as a devil posing as an angel of mercy or a well-meaning yet naive woman caught up in difficult circumstances, she settles on a state of elevated befuddlement. You never believe in Kristine as a real individual – or that Natalia's experiences are based on actual events, which is bizarre as it all really did happen – a fact Disney's bland series fails to sell.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Chelsea storm back at Real Betis to win Conference League
Uefa Conference League final: Chelsea 4 (Enzo 65, Jackson 70, Sancho 83, Caicedo 90+1) Real Betis 1 (Ezzalzouli 9) The signings will keep on coming under this voracious Chelsea ownership but it is unlikely they will ever make a smarter one than Cole Palmer. This was his stage. Palmer stood up when Chelsea needed him most. Two gorgeous assists in the space of five minutes – one for Enzo Fernández, one for Nicolas Jackson – turned the Uefa Conference League final around and brought the west Londoners their first trophy since being bought by Todd Boehly and Clearlake Capital three years ago. The first of many? The predictability of the outcome did not make the feeling any less sweet at full-time. Enzo Maresca delighted in denying his mentor Manuel Pellegrini a first European trophy at the age of 71. Real Betis dreamt of a romantic finish after going 1-0 up but the financial reality took hold long before Moisés Caicedo made it 4-1 to Chelsea in added time. It was a relief to focus on the football after two days marred by idiotic violence involving supporters of both sides in the city centre. Footage on social media showed riot police using tear gas and a water cannon to combat the disorder, resulting in 28 arrests and heightening tensions to an unnecessary degree in the hours before kick-off. READ MORE At least there was a positive vibe inside a stadium dominated by the green and white of Betis. There was no disguising the sense of longing emanating from the Spaniards, their desperation for their band of Premier League cast-offs to rise to the occasion in the club's first European final. Chelsea, an incongruous presence in a competition never meant for squads built at a cost of over £1bn, were under pressure to match that desire. Word of them failing to fill their allocation hardly hinted at a club gripped by Conference League fever. There was a surprising heaviness to Chelsea, who ought to have had a spring in their step after clinching Champions League qualification by beating Nottingham Forest last Sunday. The shape was wonky, the touches were loose and the early tactical was won by Pellegrini targeting the space left by Maresca's system, which had Malo Gusto drifting inside from right-back to play as an auxiliary midfielder. CHELSEA LEAD! WHAT A TURNAROUND 🤯 Incredible play AGAIN from Cole Palmer 👏 he beats the full back and crosses from Nicolas Jackson who gets a touch on it to send it into the back of the net ⚽️ ADVANTAGE CHELSEA! 📺 — Football on TNT Sports (@footballontnt) It was not clear why Chelsea's strategy seemed to hing on Gusto's turn as a quarterback. The Frenchman, who was one of five changes from Maresca, endured a torrid first half and was culpable when Betis went ahead after nine minutes. A slack ball into midfield invited trouble and Isco duly meted out the punishment, swivelling on the edge of the area and confounding Chelsea's defenders with a beautiful disguised pass to Abde Ezzalzouli, free on the left and unchallenged as he drove a low shot past Filip Jörgensen. Chelsea were shambolic. Maresca had gambled in defence, Benoit Badiashile and Trevoh Chalobah preferred to Levi Colwill and Tosin Adarabioyo in the middle, but nothing worked. Simple tasks were beyond Chelsea and Ezzalzouli delighted in tormenting Gusto. Isco, a European champion on five occasions with Real Madrid, was also a joy to watch; everything went through him. Betis called the shots. Marc Bartra stepped out of defence and tested Jörgensen from long range. Badiashile made a vital block to deny Johnny Cardoso. Maresca, who calls Pellegrini his footballing father, grew frenzied on the touchline. Chelsea had offered nothing in attack and were booed off at half-time. Maresca used the break to correct his error of leaving out Reece James. The captain replaced Gusto, who retreated having produced one of the most calamitous performances in European final history, and gave Chelsea more poise. Still, though, there was little from Palmer and his fellow creators. Pedro Neto was irritable with himself on the right. Noni Madueke was quiet. Jackson needed better service. TAKE A BOW JADON SANCHO 🤩 What a finish from the on-loan winger, as he cuts inside and fires expertly into the far corner to give Chelsea a 2-goal lead - is that the game for the Blues...? 🏆 📺 — Football on TNT Sports (@footballontnt) But Betis were less vibrant at the start of the second half. Marc Cucurella was doing well against Antony, who was in Manchester United mode, and it was a relief for Chelsea when Ezzalzouli limped off. The mood changed, Chelsea stepping up, Fernández and Caicedo taking charge in midfield. Betis looked tired. They could not get out. Palmer took over. His influence grew, culminating in the moment when he cut in from the right and feathered a cross into the middle, the ball floating away from Bartra and in off Fernández's head. Chelsea's superior pace and power came to the fore. Palmer was irrepressible. There he was again in the 70th minute, twisting and turning past the Betis substitute, Jesus Rodríguez. This time the cross was firmer; it found Jackson, who chested past Adrián to give Chelsea the lead. This was the only European trophy missing for Chelsea. They knew it was theirs when two substitutes combined, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall dribbling through and finding Jadon Sancho, whose whipped a shot past Adrian. Caicedo then capped it off, firing in from 20 yards. – Guardian
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Iga Swiatek dismantles Raducanu to maintain quest for fourth French Open title in a row
Just a couple of weeks after stressing the importance of facing the best players in the world more frequently in order to improve her own game, Emma Raducanu's hopes were unfortunately realised. She walked on to Court Philippe-Chatrier on Wednesday afternoon for the toughest challenge in her sport. The task of facing Iga Świątek at the French Open , her fortress, was unsurprisingly too much for Raducanu and in the second successive grand slam tournament she was dismantled by her imperious opponent, the fifth seed, who eased into the third round at Roland Garros with a 6-1, 6-2 win. As she chases down one of the greatest achievements in the open era of women's tennis – an unprecedented fourth consecutive title at Roland Garros – Swiatek's astounding record at the tournament now stands 37-2 (95 per cent): 33 of those wins have been effortlessly earned in straight sets. After demolishing her 6-0, 6-1 in the third round of the Australian Open in January, Swiatek now holds a 5-0 record against Raducanu. Before the match, during an interview with Tim Henman for TNT Sports, Raducanu's ad hoc coach Mark Petchey was asked what his charge would have to do well in order to defeat Swiatek. His answer was immediate and blunt: 'Everything.' READ MORE The pressure that Swiatek places on her opponents to play past their limits was immediately evident on Raducanu's serve as she went big at the very first moment. After missing a 180km/h first serve on the opening point, the same speed as her fastest first serve after nearly three hours on court in her first-round match, Raducanu successfully landed a 158km/h second serve. The 22-year-old confidently navigated her first service game well, immediately looking to impose herself with her forehand. Those positive feelings did not last. On Swiatek's serve, Raducanu took an advanced return position on both first and second serves as she particularly tried to put pressure on Swiatek's second serve, an essential tactic for any player who wishes to hurt the Pole. In the end, even dealing with the topspin behind Swiatek's second serve on the high-bouncing red clay was a struggle. Emma Raducanu. Photograph: Adam Pretty/Getty Although she was relatively erratic early on in tough breezy conditions, Swiatek gradually settled down and established total control of the exchanges. The 23-year-old continually forced Raducanu into defensive positions, suffocating her opponent with the weight of her heavy topspin forehand. Raducanu tried to step forward and take the ball on the rise, but Swiatek's topspin constantly spun up high outside her strike zone and neutered her ball. It is easy to suggest that a clear underdog should be able to swing freely and without pressure, but Swiatek has produced these dominant results against almost every single player on the tour at one time. Time and time again, she has shown that the incessant pressure she imposes on her opponents is usually enough. Not only did she dictate the vast majority of the match from the baseline, when Raducanu tried to take control of points Swiatek soaked up Raducanu's first strike with her supreme defence. Forced to attack as early as she can and aim closer and closer to the lines, Raducanu's errors piled up. As Raducanu neatly stated before the match, Swiatek makes her side of the court feel narrow due to her defensive skills and her opponents' side feel wide thanks to her massive weapons. This was plain for all to see on another difficult afternoon for Raducanu, as the four-time French Open champion marched on. Talking positives from such an emphatic defeat is difficult, but Raducanu's progress over the past few months, both on clay courts and within her game in general, has been undeniable. She will return to the top 40, around number 37, and she should head to the grass court season confident in her abilities to make deep runs on one of her favourite surfaces. Still, these emphatic defeats against the best players in the world have shown how wide the gulf remains between them and the significant work Raducanu has ahead of her to narrow it. Elsewhere, Carlos Alcaraz survived a scare to beat unseeded Hungarian Fabian Marozsan 6-1 4-6 6-1 6-2 to reach the third round. The Spaniard powered through the first set and had moments of vulnerability thereafter but ensured there would be no unwanted encore ending his bid for a fifth Grand Slam title. Former French Open finalist Stefanos Tsitsipas blamed his own immaturity for a shock second-round loss to qualifier Matteo Gigante of Italy on Wednesday and said he would need to go back to the drawing board to get his career back on track. The 26-year-old Greek, a six-time Grand Slam semi-finalist, was outclassed by his opponent, ranked 167th in the world, in a 6-4 5-7 6-2 6-4 defeat for his earliest exit in Paris since 2018. – Guardian
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Influencers Andrew and Tristan Tate to face 21 charges in UK
UK prosecutors have confirmed they have authorised 21 charges against influencer brothers Andrew and Tristan Tate, including rape, actual bodily harm and human trafficking. Andrew Tate (38) faces 10 charges including rape, actual bodily harm, human trafficking and controlling prostitution for gain; charges connected to three alleged victims. Tristan Tate (36) faces 11 charges including rape, actual bodily harm and human trafficking; charges connected to one alleged victim. The two British-Americans are under investigation in Romania, facing a number of charges, which they deny. READ MORE A Crown Prosecution Service spokesperson said: 'We can confirm that we have authorised charges against Andrew and Tristan Tate for offences including rape, human trafficking, controlling prostitution and actual bodily harm against three women. 'These charging decisions followed receipt of a file of evidence from Bedfordshire police. 'A European arrest warrant was issued in England in 2024, and as a result the Romanian courts ordered the extradition to the UK of Andrew and Tristan Tate. 'However, the domestic criminal matters in Romania must be settled first. 'The Crown Prosecution Service reminds everyone that criminal proceedings are active, and the defendants have the right to a fair trial. 'It is extremely important that there be no reporting, commentary or sharing of information online which could in any way prejudice these proceedings.' An international arrest warrant was issued by Bedfordshire police for the siblings over allegations dating back to between 2012 and 2015, which they deny. They are already facing prosecution in Romania over allegations of trafficking minors, sexual intercourse with a minor and money laundering. A separate case against them, in which they are accused of human trafficking and forming a criminal gang to sexually exploit women, has been sent back to prosecutors. The pair are due to be extradited to the UK after the conclusion of proceedings in Romania. Andrew Tate is also being sued by four other women after the Crown Prosecution Service decided not to prosecute in 2019. He has denied the allegations. Lawyer Matt Jury, representing several alleged British victims of Andrew Tate, said: 'We welcome the clarity from the Crown Prosecution Service that our authorities are working to ensure the Tates face justice here in the UK – they cannot be allowed to escape extradition. 'At the same time, we ask once more that CPS admit its mistake in failing to prosecute Tate when he lived in the UK and finally charge him for the rape and assault of the other three women, our clients, who originally filed criminal complaints against him as long ago as 2014 but were failed by the system. They deserve justice, too.' The allegations were subject to a Hertfordshire police investigation, which was closed in 2019. The Tates are the sons of an American chess master, who also served in the US air force as a sergeant, and a British catering assistant. The brothers were raised on an estate in Luton, Bedfordshire. Andrew Tate is a former professional kickboxer who has amassed more than 10 million followers on X, sharing his lifestyle of supercars, expensive watches and private jets. He runs an online academy where he says he teaches young men how to get rich and attract women. - Guardian
