
The staggering Whatsapp messages sent to the new Archbishop of Wales by her colleagues
When Cherry Vann was added to a Whatsapp chat, some of her more orthodox colleagues were 'dismayed and horrified' a gay bishop had been appointed to lead Church in Wales
Cherry Vann has been chosen as the 15th Archbishop of Wales
(Image: Church in Wales)
One of the largest Anglican provinces in the world has severed its ties with its Welsh counterparts - all because the new Archbishop of Wales is gay. Cherry Vann, the Bishop of Monmouth for the past five years, was chosen as the 15th Archbishop of Wales at the end of July.
Originally from Leicestershire, Archbishop Cherry Vann was elected as the the leader of the Church in Wales with a two-thirds majority and will be enthroned at Newport Cathedral in due course, she has pledged to bring "healing and reconciliation".
Yet already, she has also come into conflict with colleagues from more orthodox countries. The day after she was elected, Vann was added to a WhatsApp group containing every Anglican chief in the world.In an interview with The Sunday Times, she said two immediately criticised her appointment to their ranks.
"They were dismayed and horrified," she says. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here .
The Church of Nigeria, one of the largest Anglican provinces in the world, said it would sever ties with the Church in Wales. Henry Ndukuba, the Archbishop of Nigeria, said: "We do not recognise the so-called Archbishop of Wales and cannot share communion with a church that has departed from the teachings of the Bible."
The chairman of Gafcon, an influential conservative group of archbishops and bishops, called her election an 'act of apostasy'.
Other Christian groups and publications have also criticised her appointments. She told the journalist interviewing her that on the morning they were meeting she received a letter through the post calling her "an abomination".
But she said it didn't impact her faith, although it was "hurtful". "I just rest in the fact that a lot of people are rejoicing, and I know where God wants me to be".
In the interview, the new Archbishop of Wales criticised the institution she is part of, a "number of times", the author says with Bishop Vann saying the institution is "full of human beings who are flawed and failing"
"I think the church can so often get in the way of God," the 66-year-old said.
She was ordained into the Church of England in 1994, and was one of the first female priests, before spending 11 years as Archdeacon of Rochdale in Manchester.
But she said she knew because she was gay, she knew her career wouldn't last in England. The Church in Wales has different rules to the Church of England, gay clergy in England are permitted to enter into civil partnerships only if they remain celibate.
So, for almost 30 years, she had kept her relationship with Wendy Diamond, a retired council employee, secret with her partner "hiding upstairs" when visitors came to see them.
"It was an appalling state of affairs," says Vann. "It felt as though I was being dishonest but I didn't feel at the time that I had any choice. I was living in fear."
When she became Bishop of Monmouth, she said she finally felt comfortable enough to be open about her sexuality.
"When we first came to Wales we had a party," the new archbishop of Wales told The Times. "We invited guests to my home and for the first time Wendy was able to come to the front door with me and welcome people as my partner. That, for her and for me, signalled what a massive change it meant being here."
She has taken over after the resignation of Bishop Andy John, in the wake of two reports, commissioned by the Church in Wales over concerns about the culture surrounding the Bangor Diocese.
Bishop Vann said: "I don't think there's something rotten in the clergy themselves,' says Vann, "but the church has a culture of wanting to protect its own. It's a shocking thing to say but perpetrators have been protected and the survivors have been left to flounder".
Article continues below
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


North Wales Chronicle
4 hours ago
- North Wales Chronicle
PM leads tributes to Welsh Labour politician who died suddenly aged 47
Mr David, who has served as the Member of the Senedd for Caerphilly since 2016, died on Tuesday. He would have turned 48 on Wednesday. Prime Minister Sir Keir called him a 'powerful voice for the people of Wales', who dedicated his life to making sure every community in the country had the 'opportunities they deserve'. Mr David's death was first confirmed by Eluned Morgan, the Welsh First Minister, who described him as a 'much-loved member of the Labour family' and an 'outstanding politician'. His partner was Vikki Howells, the Cynon Valley MS and minister for further and higher education in the Welsh Government. In a statement following Mr David's death, Sir Keir said: 'The entire Labour movement will join me in grieving the loss of Hefin David. 'He was a powerful voice for the people of Wales and a committed public servant, who dedicated his life to making sure every person and community in Wales had the opportunities and support they deserve. 'As Member of the Senedd for Caerphilly, where he was born and lived, he was incredibly proud of his community. 'Our hearts are with his family and those who knew and loved him at this painful time. May he rest in peace.' Statement by Eluned Morgan MS, First Minister of Wales on the passing of Hefin David MS. — Eluned Morgan (@PrifWeinidog) August 13, 2025 Baroness Morgan said: 'Hefin was a much-loved member of the Labour family. He served Caerphilly as a councillor and a Member of the Senedd with pride and passion. 'He was an outstanding politician, warm and enthusiastic and a great communicator – especially on behalf of his constituents. He will be greatly missed.' Mr David was first elected to Caerphilly County Borough Council at a by-election in March 2007. He worked as a senior lecturer at Cardiff Metropolitan University, teaching human resource management and professional practice to undergraduate and postgraduate students. In 2016, he was elected as Member of the Senedd for Caerphilly – succeeding Labour's Jeff Cuthbert, who became police and crime commissioner for Gwent. He served as one of the five Senedd commissioners, who are responsible for providing the Welsh Parliament with the staff and resources needed. Gwent Police confirmed a 47-year-old man was found unresponsive at a property in the Caerphilly county area on Tuesday. Paramedics attended and confirmed the man had died. His death is not being treated as suspicious. Tributes have been paid by politicians across the Senedd, with former Welsh Conservative leader Andrew RT Davies calling it 'heartbreaking and tragic news'. Rhun ap Iorwerth, the leader of Plaid Cymru, said he was 'deeply shocked and saddened' at the news. 'Hefin represented his constituency with tireless dedication,' he said. 'He brought passion, energy, and independence of thought to Senedd proceedings and our parliament will be poorer without him.' Laura Anne Jones, who recently defected from the Conservatives to Reform, described Mr David as a 'genuinely lovely person'. She said: 'Regardless of political differences, we got on well. He always had time for a kind word, a smile or a funny anecdote. 'He always cared greatly for his constituents, fought hard for what he believed in and I admired him for his passion to improve additional learning needs policy, drawing on his experiences. 'He contributed greatly to politics in Wales, and will be missed greatly, politically and personally, in the Senedd.' Elin Jones, the Senedd's Llywydd (presiding officer), said the Senedd community was devastated at the said: 'Our thoughts go immediately to his partner, our colleague and friend, Vikki Howells MS and to his cherished children and family. 'Hefin was so full of life and enthusiasm for his constituents and their causes. 'He was a passionate politician, loyal to his party, his country and constituents.' Gwent Police Chief Constable Mark Hobrough called Mr David a 'dedicated public servant to Caerphilly' whose loss would be significant. A spokesperson for Cardiff Metropolitan University, where Mr David had been a lecturer prior to becoming an MS, said: 'Anyone that met Hefin, whether it was a brief chat or a longer connection, will know of his considerable commitment to education. 'He would, rightly, talk with pride about his path in higher education: from undergraduate through to senior academic. And it was that journey that gave him such an understanding of the need to make sure that education works for all. To make sure that his path could be taken by all, rather than the preserve of a privileged few.' Tributes also came from societies and groups supported by Mr David. James Radcliffe, external affairs manager for Wales at the National Autistic Society Cymru, described Mr David, whose daughter has autism, as a 'true champion' for autistic people. He said: 'He was a member of the Welsh Parliament's cross party autism group, and frequently spoke in the chamber about his experience as a father to an autistic child. 'He championed the human rights of autistic people, calling out the unjust detention of autistic people in the mental health system, and was also a firm champion in supporting autistic people into employment, carrying out important research for the Welsh Government into what support they should be providing. 'We will miss him.' Unison Cymru regional secretary Jess Turner said Mr David's death has brought huge sadness to many people. She said: 'In addition to his role as Labour MS for Caerphilly, Hefin was also the secretary of the Unison Senedd group. 'He supported Unison Cymru with many campaigns and was a popular speaker at the union's annual Labour Link forum. 'Hefin's commitment to Unison and public service workers will long be remembered.'

Rhyl Journal
4 hours ago
- Rhyl Journal
Welsh Labour politician Hefin David dies aged 47
Backbench Welsh Labour politician Hefin David has died suddenly aged 47, the First Minister of Wales has confirmed. Eluned Morgan, the Welsh Labour leader, paid tribute to the Caerphilly MS, who has been a member of the Welsh Parliament since 2016. Baroness Morgan described Mr David as a 'much-loved' member of the Labour family, who will be greatly missed. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer called him a 'powerful voice for the people of Wales', who dedicated his life to making sure every community in the country had the 'opportunities they deserve'. Mr David's partner was Vikki Howells, the Cynon Valley MS and minister for further and higher education in the Welsh Government. Baroness Morgan said: 'We are extremely saddened by the sudden death of Hefin. Our thoughts are with his family at this terrible time. 'Hefin was a much-loved member of the Labour family. He served Caerphilly as a councillor and a Member of the Senedd with pride and passion. 'He was an outstanding politician, warm and enthusiastic and a great communicator – especially on behalf of his constituents. He will be greatly missed.' In a statement following Mr David's death, Sir Keir said: 'The entire Labour movement will join me in grieving the loss of Hefin David. 'He was a powerful voice for the people of Wales and a committed public servant, who dedicated his life to making sure every person and community in Wales had the opportunities and support they deserve. 'As Member of the Senedd for Caerphilly, where he was born and lived, he was incredibly proud of his community. 'Our hearts are with his family and those who knew and loved him at this painful time. May he rest in peace.' Mr David, who was born in the Caerphilly constituency, was elected to Caerphilly County Borough Council at a by-election in March 2007. He worked as a senior lecturer at Cardiff Metropolitan University, teaching human resource management and professional practice to undergraduate and postgraduate students. In 2016, he was elected as Member of the Senedd for Caerphilly – succeeding Labour's Jeff Cuthbert, who became police and crime commissioner for Gwent. Gwent Police said a 47-year-old man was found unresponsive at a property in the Caerphilly county area on Tuesday. Paramedics attended and confirmed the man had died. His death is not being treated as suspicious. Tributes have been paid to Mr David by politicians across the Senedd, with former Welsh Conservative leader Andrew RT Davies calling it 'heartbreaking and tragic news'. Delyth Jewell, Plaid MS for the South Wales East region, said: 'The news about Hefin David is so desperately tragic. Hefin was always steadfast in his views, loyal to his roots, and he represented this area diligently. 'We were from different parties but worked together on many local issues. I will miss him. What a sad and dreadful loss.' Plaid Cymru leader Rhun ap Iorwerth MS said: 'I'm deeply shocked and saddened to learn of the passing of Hefin David. 'Hefin represented his constituency with tireless dedication. He brought passion, energy, and independence of thought to Senedd proceedings and our parliament will be poorer without him. 'On behalf of Plaid Cymru I send our profound condolences to Hefin's family and friends at this desperately sad time.'

Rhyl Journal
5 hours ago
- Rhyl Journal
PM leads tributes to Welsh Labour politician who died suddenly aged 47
Mr David, who has served as the Member of the Senedd for Caerphilly since 2016, died on Tuesday. He would have turned 48 on Wednesday. Prime Minister Sir Keir called him a 'powerful voice for the people of Wales', who dedicated his life to making sure every community in the country had the 'opportunities they deserve'. Mr David's death was first confirmed by Eluned Morgan, the Welsh First Minister, who described him as a 'much-loved member of the Labour family' and an 'outstanding politician'. His partner was Vikki Howells, the Cynon Valley MS and minister for further and higher education in the Welsh Government. In a statement following Mr David's death, Sir Keir said: 'The entire Labour movement will join me in grieving the loss of Hefin David. 'He was a powerful voice for the people of Wales and a committed public servant, who dedicated his life to making sure every person and community in Wales had the opportunities and support they deserve. 'As Member of the Senedd for Caerphilly, where he was born and lived, he was incredibly proud of his community. 'Our hearts are with his family and those who knew and loved him at this painful time. May he rest in peace.' Statement by Eluned Morgan MS, First Minister of Wales on the passing of Hefin David MS. — Eluned Morgan (@PrifWeinidog) August 13, 2025 Baroness Morgan said: 'Hefin was a much-loved member of the Labour family. He served Caerphilly as a councillor and a Member of the Senedd with pride and passion. 'He was an outstanding politician, warm and enthusiastic and a great communicator – especially on behalf of his constituents. He will be greatly missed.' Mr David was first elected to Caerphilly County Borough Council at a by-election in March 2007. He worked as a senior lecturer at Cardiff Metropolitan University, teaching human resource management and professional practice to undergraduate and postgraduate students. In 2016, he was elected as Member of the Senedd for Caerphilly – succeeding Labour's Jeff Cuthbert, who became police and crime commissioner for Gwent. He served as one of the five Senedd commissioners, who are responsible for providing the Welsh Parliament with the staff and resources needed. Gwent Police confirmed a 47-year-old man was found unresponsive at a property in the Caerphilly county area on Tuesday. Paramedics attended and confirmed the man had died. His death is not being treated as suspicious. Tributes have been paid by politicians across the Senedd, with former Welsh Conservative leader Andrew RT Davies calling it 'heartbreaking and tragic news'. Rhun ap Iorwerth, the leader of Plaid Cymru, said he was 'deeply shocked and saddened' at the news. 'Hefin represented his constituency with tireless dedication,' he said. 'He brought passion, energy, and independence of thought to Senedd proceedings and our parliament will be poorer without him.' Laura Anne Jones, who recently defected from the Conservatives to Reform, described Mr David as a 'genuinely lovely person'. She said: 'Regardless of political differences, we got on well. He always had time for a kind word, a smile or a funny anecdote. 'He always cared greatly for his constituents, fought hard for what he believed in and I admired him for his passion to improve additional learning needs policy, drawing on his experiences. 'He contributed greatly to politics in Wales, and will be missed greatly, politically and personally, in the Senedd.' Elin Jones, the Senedd's Llywydd (presiding officer), said the Senedd community was devastated at the said: 'Our thoughts go immediately to his partner, our colleague and friend, Vikki Howells MS and to his cherished children and family. 'Hefin was so full of life and enthusiasm for his constituents and their causes. 'He was a passionate politician, loyal to his party, his country and constituents.' Gwent Police Chief Constable Mark Hobrough called Mr David a 'dedicated public servant to Caerphilly' whose loss would be significant. A spokesperson for Cardiff Metropolitan University, where Mr David had been a lecturer prior to becoming an MS, said: 'Anyone that met Hefin, whether it was a brief chat or a longer connection, will know of his considerable commitment to education. 'He would, rightly, talk with pride about his path in higher education: from undergraduate through to senior academic. And it was that journey that gave him such an understanding of the need to make sure that education works for all. To make sure that his path could be taken by all, rather than the preserve of a privileged few.' Tributes also came from societies and groups supported by Mr David. James Radcliffe, external affairs manager for Wales at the National Autistic Society Cymru, described Mr David, whose daughter has autism, as a 'true champion' for autistic people. He said: 'He was a member of the Welsh Parliament's cross party autism group, and frequently spoke in the chamber about his experience as a father to an autistic child. 'He championed the human rights of autistic people, calling out the unjust detention of autistic people in the mental health system, and was also a firm champion in supporting autistic people into employment, carrying out important research for the Welsh Government into what support they should be providing. 'We will miss him.' Unison Cymru regional secretary Jess Turner said Mr David's death has brought huge sadness to many people. She said: 'In addition to his role as Labour MS for Caerphilly, Hefin was also the secretary of the Unison Senedd group. 'He supported Unison Cymru with many campaigns and was a popular speaker at the union's annual Labour Link forum. 'Hefin's commitment to Unison and public service workers will long be remembered.'