
The 3 preseason San Francisco Giants predictions I wish I'd made
Advertisement
It's probably for the best that I don't remember any of the predictions my corporate overlords forced me to make before this season, because I'm sure they're already shot to heck. What I do remember, though, are the educated guesses and half-baked hunches about the Giants that I had before the season. Some of them came close to happening. If I had any courage at all, I would have published them as predictions and ended up looking smart.
I didn't. They're only the preseason predictions I wish I made.
To be fair, I at least hinted at the idea in a predictions article, but that was even more wishy-washy than my normal stuff. These were the actual words that were in my brain all winter: This dude might struggle something fierce. Every time I clicked on his Baseball Savant page, it was like a blinking red siren. He wasn't just making weak contact; he was making some of the weakest contact in the league. He wasn't just swinging and missing; he had some of the worst strikeout and whiff rates in the league.
Then there was his batted-ball profile, which has him as one of the most extreme pull hitters in baseball. It all adds up to the profile of a hitter the league will catch up with. Then you get to the evidence that the league already did catch up to him at the end of his breakout season: His OPS for September of last season was under .700, and his strikeout-to-walk ratio was all cattywampus.
It's a shame, because there's so much already right with him as a player. His speed, instincts, pull-side power and versatility are all helpful to a major-league team right now, which helps explain why Baseball-Reference's WAR still has him as the fourth-most valuable position player on the Giants this season, behind only Matt Chapman, Mike Yastrzemski and Willy Adames. He's still young, and there's still time for him to make the adjustments he needs to.
Advertisement
It was always unlikely for him to repeat what he did last year, though. It was unlikely for him to come close, even.
That's pretty much what's happened. His OPS vs. lefties is 22 points lower than his OPS against right-handers this year, which is both great and horrible news, but his overall production is roughly the same. His adjusted OPS was 25 percent better than the National League last season, and it's 22 percent better this season. He's still as streaky as hitters get, but he's at least shown that last season's second half was just a slump, not a result of the league solving him.
The caveat to all this is that I did not see the defensive calamity coming. There have been rough defensive patches for Ramos throughout his Giants career, but nothing like the rough defense he's shown all season. Ramos is between Fitzgerald and Christian Koss in WAR this season, according to Baseball-Reference, which gives you an idea of just how much Ramos' defense is hurting him. And I can't disagree with the numbers, either. They match the eyeball test, and the eyeballs hurt.
Still, the offense is a welcome not-surprise. Ramos is a healthy part of a balanced lineup, just like he was last year. Not only is that welcome for this season, but the Giants can start expecting it for future seasons, too.
I'd imagine there's quite the generational split among Giants fans when it comes to expectations for pitching prospects. In one corner, you have the old guard, the ones who spent decades expecting doom. Between the Bob Knepper trade in 1980 and Matt Cain's debut in 2005, there wasn't a more dangerous job on the planet than 'exciting young Giants pitcher.' Every time a pitcher would start to fly, they'd fly too close to the sun on shoulders made out of wax. Can you believe there was a time when the Giants had five starting pitchers in the top-100 prospects, including the best pitching prospect in baseball? Only one of them lived up to expectations, and only after he was traded for A.J. Pierzynski. It was always doom for the young pitchers. Doom, doom, doom.
Advertisement
And in the other corner, you have newer fans, who watched the Giants thrive beyond their wildest dreams because of young pitching. They understand that pitching is a cruel profession, and they know that success can be fleeting, but they're not terrified of young pitchers in general. Sometimes they work. Look at Logan Webb over there. Came up, got good, stayed good for a long time. What's the big deal? That happens with young pitchers sometimes.
I'll always be the one in the first example, though. It doesn't surprise me when other teams develop pitchers. The Mariners had a couple seasons where they were consistently making homegrown pitchers out of glowing dirt they dug up behind old Boeing test grounds, and that made sense to me. When it comes to the Giants, though, I always hold my breath. Young pitchers, you say? Sounds risky.
There was a point this season where the Giants had too many young pitchers. They sent an incumbent starter to the minors. They had a battle for the one and final spot in the rotation. They had to use starting pitchers as relievers because, well, there were just too many young pitchers.
I was scared for them. 'There's no way it will work,' the oldest, crustiest lobe of my brain croaked. And I nodded in agreement. For these were promising young Giants pitchers we were talking about.
Except this prediction makes it in here because it's both correct and incorrect. Yes, Hayden Birdsong is caught in a developmental maelstrom right now, and Kyle Harrison is currently on the Pawtucket Red Sox, but Landen Roupp has been stellar. It's been enjoyable to watch his changeup develop as the season progresses, and you can see the curveball become even more effective the less he has to rely on it.
Sometimes it's better to be wrong. Maybe there's a way to scoop this lobe of the brain out and replace it with something more optimistic. 'Oops! All Lincecums!' or something like that. I wish I were more wrong in public about the Giants' plan to rely on young pitchers, which I was quietly skeptical about. If the Giants make the postseason this year, young pitching will be a major reason why. Sometimes young pitchers end up helping, and they don't have to stop for a long time.
(Top photo of Tyler Fitzgerald: Emilee Chinn / Getty Images)
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Associated Press
28 minutes ago
- Associated Press
A year after they were (to a degree) deadline sellers, the Blue Jays are soaring
Even when they traded away a handful of established players at last year's deadline, the Toronto Blue Jays clearly believed a rebound was possible. A year later, they have a comfortable lead atop the AL East. It's hard to say that last year's deadline jump-started Toronto's turnaround, but the important thing is the Blue Jays didn't give up on their core despite being on their way to a last-place finish in 2024. They dealt players like Yusei Kikuchi and Justin Turner — but Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette remained with Toronto. Keeping those two was something of a risk given that both could become free agents after this season. Bichette still can, but the Blue Jays were able to sign Guerrero to a $500-million, 14-year contract in April. Guerrero, Bichette and George Springer are part of a Toronto team that ranks third in the American League in OPS while leading the majors in batting average and on-base percentage. Even after a lopsided loss to Detroit on Sunday, the Blue Jays have a 5 1/2-game lead over the second-place New York Yankees — although Toronto also has the second-worst run differential in the division. The Blue Jays have the best record in baseball by a half-game over the Chicago Cubs and Milwaukee Brewers. Toronto has won 21 of its last 27 games, and included in that stretch is a 6-1 record against the Yankees. The Blue Jays are 7-3 against New York, meaning they have clinched that season series should it become a tiebreaker. New York is just 11-18 against the AL East. Trivia time The Blue Jays last made the World Series in 1993. Who are the only other American League teams with longer droughts since their most recent pennants? Tumbling Tigers Detroit's 10-4 win over Toronto on Sunday snapped a six-game skid for the Tigers — and that does not do justice to how poorly they were playing. Detroit had lost 12 of 13, being outscored 89-33 in the process. Ace Tarik Skubal can only do so much. The lone win during that stretch came in one of his starts — a 2-1 victory over Texas on July 20. When he took the mound six days later against Toronto, he threw six scoreless innings, only to have the Tigers go on to lose 6-1. Before Detroit fans panic too much, the Tigers had built up such a big lead that they still have an eight-game advantage over second-place Cleveland in the AL Central after Sunday's victory. FanGraphs gives them a 95.9% chance to make the playoffs. But their chances of earning a first-round bye — by having one of the top two records among AL division winners — is down to 52.6%. Line of the week More like line of the decade. Or perhaps the century. A's rookie Nick Kurtz went 6 for 6 with four home runs, eight RBIs and six runs in a 15-3 rout of Houston on Friday night. Kurtz became the 20th player in major league history — and first rookie — with a four-homer game. He also doubled and singled, so he tied the single-game record for total bases with 19. Comeback of the week Minnesota had a one-run lead at Los Angeles in the bottom of the ninth Wednesday — and Griffin Jax retired the first two batters for the Dodgers. Then it all unraveled for the Twins. Mookie Betts singled, Shohei Ohtani was walked intentionally, Esteury Ruiz drew another walk and then Freddie Freeman singled home two runs for a 4-3 win. The Twins had a win probability of 95.6% after the second out, according to Baseball Savant. Trivia answer The Orioles (1983), Athletics (1990), Twins (1991) and Mariners (never). ___ AP MLB:

Washington Post
28 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Maryland firefighter under review after viral video shows water soaking field
In its 25 years, the Silver Spring-Takoma Thunderbolts baseball team has received limited media attention. Its championship season in 2006 was covered. A no-hitter garnered stories, as did players skilled enough to make the major leagues. Then came July 17. From just beyond the outfield fence at the team's field in suburban Maryland, a Montgomery County firefighter reportedly climbed aboard a county fire truck and fired a high-pressure hose over the fence and into center field for about eight minutes.


New York Times
28 minutes ago
- New York Times
Can Kerry Carpenter's return help the Tigers get right?
DETROIT — Kerry Carpenter wheeled his suitcase through a set of double doors and entered the Detroit Tigers' clubhouse Sunday morning. You could practically feel the atmosphere in the room lighten. Here, finally, was good news. Here, finally, was real help. At his best, Carpenter is the Tigers' most dangerous left-handed hitter. He is a powerful chess piece, the queen on A.J. Hinch's managerial board. He's a hitter opposing managers target, a player who can enter a game off the bench or get flipped for a pinch hitter in a crucial spot. Advertisement 'The look of the lineup, the feel, the strategy, everything is better with Kerry Carpenter in it,' Hinch said. Carpenter's presence was sorely missed during a brutal stretch in which the Tigers lost 12 of 13 games. Really, it's been missing since the start of June, when Carpenter was playing through a hamstring injury and clearly wasn't right. He hasn't drawn a walk since May 23, and he hit .194 after June 3. Carpenter finally went on the injured list July 2 after tweaking the right hamstring again. The All-Star break provided a clear time for a reset. Carpenter worked his way back. Said he began feeling better quickly. He went on a rehab assignment, took a couple of games to find his timing and his mechanics. Before Saturday's game in Triple A, Hinch texted Carpenter. 'Call me after your game,' he wrote. Carpenter ended up connecting on a pair of line drives and hit a home run Saturday. Afterward, he called his manager. Told him he was feeling good. He asked Hinch what he needed to see next. 'We need you in the lineup,' Hinch told him. Sunday morning, Carpenter was back in Detroit, back at his locker and back in the middle of the Tigers' order. 'That's the worst, is not being able to do anything to help,' Carpenter said of the Tigers' losing streak. 'We got a bunch of good hitters on this team. Whatever we can do to get out of this, I'm sure it's gonna come pretty quickly. I'm just excited to be in the middle of it and be back with these guys.' Carpenter's arrival proved to be a harbinger of good things Sunday. In the series finale against the Toronto Blue Jays, the Tigers won 10-4 and snapped a six-game losing streak. Jack Flaherty was in sync, commanding his stuff with precision and mixing his arsenal to devastating results. He threw six scoreless innings and even ended the day by pumping a 96.1 mph fastball — tied for his fastest pitch this season — past Ernie Clement. GL3YB3R TORR3S 💣 — Detroit Tigers (@tigers) July 27, 2025 Flaherty was able to pitch with the lead because Gleyber Torres hit a three-run home run in the third inning. The Tigers had started the inning getting hits from Dillon Dingler and Parker Meadows. Javier Báez and Colt Keith followed with two flyouts, both too shallow to score Dingler from third. So there with two outs, Torres was in the midst of an 0-for-16 slump. The hitter who has been a consistent contributor all season then delivered the big swing his team has been waiting for. With Carpenter lurking behind him in the order, Torres launched a challenge fastball from Max Scherzer high over the opposite-field wall. Advertisement Again, you could practically feel the exhale reverberating from the dugout up through the Comerica Park stands. Scherzer still shut down the Tigers, retiring his final 13 batters. But the lineup came alive in the eighth inning, good at-bats strung together like this team has not done for the bulk of July. The Tigers scored seven runs, six coming with two outs. 'It feels like we hadn't seen that in a while, right?' Hinch said. 'We really had a hard time showing our identity and what we're about when we're not collecting hits.' A small detail to consider: Carpenter's presence forced the Blue Jays to bring in left-hander Justin Bruihl with two outs in the eighth. Hinch inserted right-hander Matt Vierling, who singled, in Carpenter's place. After a base hit from Riley Greene, the Tigers had a run of favorable matchups against the lefty and kept upping the number on the scoreboard. Carpenter went 0-for-3 Sunday, but his return will play a large role in the Tigers' quest to get back to their winning identity. 'Kerry's presence matters,' Hinch said. 'It changes how they navigate our lineup. He's a really big threat. It plays into how Gleyber is getting pitched because Kerry's a threat. When you can impact a game and not necessarily be the feature of a game, that's a middle-of-the-order bat. … Our lineup just looks different and functions differently with him in it.'