A Brooklyn auto shop held a man's SUV for two years as the man got more than $2K in parking fines. Here's what went down
It's not uncommon for car repairs to turn into a costly headache, but Louis Denory's experience with a local repair shop can easily be described as a nightmare.
As the Brooklyn man shared with CBS New York, his Ford Flex was held hostage for nearly two years by an auto repair shop that refused to return it. After an accident in April, 2023, Denory's SUV was towed to A9's Automotive in Brooklyn. That shop later changed its name to State to State Automotive, but kept the same management team.
I'm 49 years old and have nothing saved for retirement — what should I do? Don't panic. Here are 5 of the easiest ways you can catch up (and fast)
A near-record number of Americans are grappling with $1,000 car payments and many drivers can't keep up. Here are 3 ways to stay ahead
Home prices in America could fly through the roof in 2025 — here's the big reason why and how to take full advantage (with as little as $10)
Meanwhile, Denory says he spent months trying to get his vehicle back while the shop offered excuse after excuse. 'They would give excuses, talking about 'Oh, the parts, there was a delay on the parts,'' Denory shared with CBS. 'And then the guy talking about he had a death in the famiy… and nobody knew where the car was.'
While the shop stalled, the city of Brooklyn apparently knew exactly where Denory's SUV was. After receiving more than $2,000 in fines, Denory learned that his vehicle had been illegally parked down the street from the body shop for months, collecting parking ticket after parking ticket.
This sent Denory on a mission to get his SUV back, and CBS News New York's Tim McNicholas was there to help.
As the days turned into months following his accident, Denory couldn't get a clear answer on when his vehicle would be fixed. And then the fines started showing up in the mail.
By August, 2024, a judge ruled that State to State Automotive was responsible for paying the parking tickets, but the shop still hasn't paid the fines. Denory and McNicholas went to State to State's shop around this time to ask about the SUV.
"Where's this guy's car?" McNicholas asked a man at the shop, to which the man replied, 'We don't have a Ford Flex here.'
In October, 2024, Denory finally tracked down his vehicle, which was at a parking lot near the auto shop. But when he arrived to take it back, Denory was met with more bad news — the SUV wouldn't start, had flat tires and a truck was blocking the exit to the lot.
When he demanded his vehicle back, Denory said an unidentified worker brought up 'storage fees.'
'I'm not paying no storage. I don't care what you're saying,' Denory said. 'Then you're not getting the car back,' the man replied.
Later, Denory and McNicholas revisited the lot and found someone had moved his vehicle closer to the exit. With help from his insurance company, which sent someone to jumpstart the vehicle and pump up the tires, Denory was able to drive his SUV home for the first time in 20 months. But the fight apparently isn't over.
Denory still doesn't know if his vehicle was properly fixed despite Geico Insurance's claim that the shop cashed the $6,000 check to cover the repair costs. He is now working with the sheriff's office to try to get the funds from the shop for the unpaid parking tickets.
The Department of Motor Vehicles is also investigating State to State Automotive, though they declined to offer details.
Read more: Rich, young Americans are ditching the stormy stock market — here are the alternative assets they're banking on instead
Denory finally has his Ford Flex back, but other customers of the same auto shop say their vehicles are also being held hostage. No one wants to experience this kind of frustration, so what can you do to avoid finding yourself in a similar situation?
You can start by checking out the auto repair shop's online reviews. After that, extend your research to the Better Business Bureau, where you can see if the shop has any negative complaints. If anything in your research gives you pause, find another auto shop in your area and conduct your research over again.
When you land on an auto shop that's earned your confidence, request a written estimate that includes the costs, as well as a projected completion date before agreeing to the repairs. This can help you hold the shop accountable if things go wrong.
These steps can help you avoid Denory's fate, but sometimes all the research in the world isn't enough to prevent you from doing business with an unscrupulous company.
If you ever happen to find yourself in a similar situation to Denory's, you can always file a complaint with the BBB or another government agency, such as the Division of Consumer Protection, the AG's office or your state's version of the Department of Motor Vehicles.
You can also take legal action. In extreme cases like Denory's, you may need to get legal assistance, and if hiring a lawyer is too expensive, you can always take the issue to small claims court.
These 5 money moves will boost you up America's net worth ladder in 2025 — and you can complete each step within minutes. Here's how
Jamie Dimon issues a warning about the US stock market — says prices are 'kind of inflated.' Crashproof your portfolio with these 3 rock-solid strategies
This self-made $500M real estate mogul reveals his 'essential' US portfolio that he says Amazon 'can't hurt' — here's how everyday investors can copy his secret formula
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
33 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Karine Jean-Pierre Leaves Democratic Party Ahead Of Her Book About 'Broken White House'
Former White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre has a book out this fall that promises a close look at President Biden's decision not to run for reelection and calls for thinking beyond the two-party system. Jean-Pierre herself has switched her affiliation to independent after working in two Democratic administrations, according to Legacy Lit, a Hachette Book Group imprint that will publish 'Independent: A Look Inside a Broken White House, Outside the Party Lines' on Oct. 21. 'Until January 20, I was responsible for speaking on behalf of the President of the United States,' Jean-Pierre, the first Black woman and openly gay person to hold the position of White House press secretary, said in a statement released Wednesday. 'At noon on that day, I became a private citizen who, like all Americans and many of our allies around the world, had to contend with what was to come next for our country. I determined that the danger we face as a country requires freeing ourselves of boxes. We need to be willing to exercise the ability to think creatively and plan strategically.' Jean-Pierre, 50, succeeded Jen Psaki as press secretary in 2022 after previously serving as deputy press secretary and also working as a senior adviser during Biden's victorious 2020 campaign. During President Barack Obama's first term, she was a regional political director. Jean-Pierre was criticized at times for being evasive about Biden's physical condition. Wednesday's announcement from Legacy Lit says that she will take readers 'through the three weeks that led to Biden's abandoning his bid for a second term and the betrayal by the Democratic Party that led to his decision.' 'She presents clear arguments and provocative evidence as an insider about the importance of dismantling the torrent of disinformation and misinformation that has been rampant in recent elections and provides passionate insight for moving forward,' the announcement said. Alina Habba Forgets One Critical Fact In 'DEI' Smear Of Karine Jean-Pierre Karine Jean-Pierre Reveals She Had 'Second Full-Time Job' While Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre Hits Fox Business Reporter With Brutally 'Honest' Reality Check On Trump
Yahoo
34 minutes ago
- Yahoo
How To Save Hundreds per Month With 3 Steps, According To Ramit Sethi
When paring down a budget, some might think that means eliminating anything fun — especially when there's debt to pay off. Entrepreneur and author of 'I Will Teach You to Be Rich' Ramit Sethi insists that's not true, even if a consumer has unpaid debt. In a recent video Sethi posted on his Instagram, he said, 'I believe in living a rich life today and living a rich life tomorrow, even if you have debt.' His video went on to detail three ways that consumers can find some wiggle room in their budgets. These are things that Sethi said most people 'won't even miss.' Read on to find out how to find these hidden savings. Read Next: Check Out: Sethi's first suggestion was for people to look at their subscriptions and see if there are any they wouldn't mind canceling — or didn't even remember they were subscribed to. According to a recent statistic from Self, around 85% of people have at least one paid subscription that they don't use every month. This comes out to about $32 a month, or almost $400 a year. This could be a tremendous savings that consumers can net without changing their routine at all. Check bank and credit card statements for recurring charges during an entire month to see every subscription, then determine if there are any that can get the boot. See More: Sethi recommended that individuals call their insurance companies (car, renters', pet, etc.) and say 'I'm shopping around for a better rate. What can you do for me?' If the insurance company is unable to offer a better deal, switch carriers. Most consumers who switched carriers in the past five years had a median savings of $461, according to Consumer Reports. It's a good idea to look into competitors' rates about every six months or so to make sure you have the lowest price. Impulse spending can be anything from a DoorDash order or a cute shirt in the mall. Americans spend about $150 in impulse purchases every month, per a post from Ramsey Solutions. Keeping those to a minimum can save consumers more than $1,000 a year. These types of purchases are typically fueled by emotions. Maybe shoppers will splurge on a cookie during a bad day, or buy a magazine in a checkout line because the cashier is taking a long time. It's important to determine the reason behind these purchases and see if there are other ways to solve that problem. Finding free or cheaper ways to fill time or cheer someone up is key to spending less on impulse. More From GOBankingRates 6 Big Shakeups Coming to Social Security in 2025 6 Popular SUVs That Aren't Worth the Cost -- and 6 Affordable Alternatives This article originally appeared on How To Save Hundreds per Month With 3 Steps, According To Ramit Sethi Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
USA Today
39 minutes ago
- USA Today
Ford recall could force over 1 million drivers to use this safety technique
Ford recall could force over 1 million drivers to use this safety technique The Blue Oval's software issue hints at larger problem for automakers. Show Caption Hide Caption Safety recall on your car? Here's how to find out, what to know Almost all repairs are free when your car faces a recall. Ford models are being recalled over software issue that affects rearview cameras. The recall affects over one million vehicles including the best-selling F-150 pickup truck. Modern vehicles include several standard safety and driver assistance features that drivers have become reliant on. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) recently issued notices for over 1 million vehicles under the Ford Motor Company umbrella including Ford and Lincoln nameplates. The huge Ford recall is due to a major software issue that extends to several best-selling models including the 2021-2024 Ford F-150, 2021-2024 Ford Bronco, and more. This software issue raises a major question for American drivers. Have cars become too advanced for our own good, simplifying driving to a point where our skills as drivers have dulled? Furthermore, is a reliance on new safety and driver assistance features potentially dangerous? Ford recall extends to over one million vehicles due to rearview camera issue Why are over a million Ford models included in NHTSA's recent recall notices? A "frozen or missing rearview camera image can reduce the driver's view behind the vehicle, increasing the risk of a crash", according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's safety report. A whopping 1,075,299 units are potentially affected by this issue, making this recall one of the largest of 2025. Ford is remedying this issue by updating vehicle software at authorized dealers or through over-the-air updates free of charge. Letters notifying owners of the potential safety risk are expected to be mailed by June 16. Why is this such a serious issue for American drivers? The rise of the rearview camera: How backup cams changed driving for Americans Driver assistance and safety features have evolved over the past decade. Today, many American drivers have access to standard technologies such as front and rear parking sensors, blind-spot monitors, lane-keeping assist, and even rear cross-traffic alert with automatic braking — all designed to help prevent potential collisions while reversing. These features have arguably made driving safer than previous years due to automatic braking and increased alerts/awareness, but what did drivers do before these features became so popular? "Backup cameras, which are also referred to as reverse cameras and rearview cameras, have been a required safety feature in all new American-made cars since May 1, 2018" according to Hagerty, an American automotive lifestyle and membership company. Prior to the rise of rearview cameras in America, many drivers had to reverse by turning their heads to look through their rear windshields or rely on rearview mirrors. Drivers of older vehicles still rely on this technique, and over one million Ford owners affected by this recall could be forced to as well (until their vehicles are repaired). Rearview cameras changed the way Americans drive because they simplified a process that drivers had practiced for decades. Suddenly parallel parking and reversing had become both easier and safer for drivers because rearview cameras give better indications of proximity than a rearview mirror. The addition of front and rear parking sensors, blind-spot monitors, and 360-degree cameras make reversing even easier. Rearview cameras reduce reversing crash rates, says the Insurance Institute of Highway Safety, thus a sudden loss of rearview camera accessibility could increase reversing crash rates. Has driving become too simplified? Ford's recall hints at a wider issue for the entire industry and American drivers. Has driving become too easy in the eyes of Americans due to innovative new features? Driver attention warning features are becoming standard on many popular nameplates because of the potential for drivers to become distracted. Operating a motor vehicle has gotten easier over the last few decades, possibly to the detriment of drivers. Vehicles can now be parked remotely and driven semi-autonomously (with a strong emphasis on "semi"). Most semi-automated vehicle systems "fall short on safety" according to a 2024 report on vehicle safety tests by CBS News. Between all the new sensors, warning indicators, automatic braking, and advanced cruise control, drivers are growing increasingly reliant on technology to make driving safer and more convenient. What happens when that technology or software fails? Read more about recalls from Ford and other major automakers here.
