logo
Trump Wants to Fulfill His ‘No Tax On Tips' Promise. The Details Get Tricky.

Trump Wants to Fulfill His ‘No Tax On Tips' Promise. The Details Get Tricky.

New York Times19-05-2025

Several of the proposals that House Republicans have outlined in their expansive tax bill have drawn concern from the public and within the party itself. But one tax cut provision within the House majority's plan is receiving an unusual level of public, bipartisan approval — a rule to eliminate federal income taxes on tips.
'No Tax On Tips,' which was one of President Trump's most buzzy, populist campaign pledges in 2024, polls quite well. An Ipsos survey found roughly three in four Republicans, Democrats and independents were in support. The proposal, which would reduce federal revenues about $11 billion a year, currently appears likely to end up in whatever final bill moves through Congress and heads to the president's desk to be signed into law.
Tipped workers in the bottom 60 percent of the income distribution would receive an average tax cut of $1,260 if tips were excluded from income taxes. A broad chunk of restaurant workers and bartenders, a large share of hotel staff, barbers, salon workers, tour guides and delivery and Uber drivers are among those who most likely stand to benefit.
The policy push has created odd bedfellows. The National Restaurant Association, the powerful business trade group that often lobbies against minimum wage increases for workers, has been supportive of the policy for tipped workers, who are subject to a lower minimum wage than others in the vast majority of the United States.
Yet a unique mix of labor economists, budget hawks aligned with liberals and conservatives, and even some restaurant interest groups have come out against the No Tax On Tips idea.
'The Fair Labor Standards Act specifies that you can only receive tips if you are customer facing, so that means cooks, dishwashers, porters and bussers, in some cases, are all not receiving tips,' said Erika Polmar, the executive director of the Independent Restaurant Coalition, a group that represents the small and midsize market.
'What this means,' Ms. Polmar argues, 'is that servers are suddenly going to get a substantial tax credit, whereas cooks and such are not, and restaurants can't afford to just keep increasing minimum wages to make up that difference.'
If tipped workers at a restaurant make more than their colleagues who don't get tips, those workers could either demand more money or take up tipped-eligible roles themselves elsewhere.
That could put a significant amount of wage pressure on the service industry, Ms. Polmar said, at a time when many businesses in her coalition are worried about maintaining their profit margins, which are relatively low compared with other industries.
For some workers, though, the pressure that No Tax On Tips may put on restaurants to give greater compensation to everyone involved in the operation is a feature not a bug — even if it causes some headaches for managers and owners at first.
'My opinion on the whole No Tax On Tips thing is I'm working based on a salary of $2.50 per hour as a server, right? So it's me working my butt off for my tips; why are they taking money from me when I'm the one who is putting in the work,' said Chase Morales, a waiter, bartender and host, working in Midland, Texas. 'I'm still paying my taxes for my hourly wage,' he added.
The U.S. tax code has long been filled with different nooks and crannies that treat one type of business, or a certain form of income, more or less favorably than others. But several analysts at influential think tanks based in Washington oppose the Trump-led tips provision because it appears primed to add yet another special tax exemption.
'We're not a huge fan of doing tax policy that's just for one industry, having special sets of rules that advantage one industry over another,' said Alex Muresianu, a senior policy analyst at the nonpartisan Tax Foundation. But Mr. Muresianu acknowledged the 'market distortions' of the policies could lead to near-term gains for workers, as people potentially flock into 'tipped-eligible' roles to earn more take-home pay.
Still, the details of who exactly will benefit from the proposed gratuities tax break can get complicated.
'If a low-income taxpayer already has zero taxable income due to the standard deduction, the tip deduction would provide no additional benefit,' said Kyle Pomerleau, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, a right-leaning think tank. In other words, many lower-income Americans already owe nothing in federal income taxes (even though they pay local, state, sales and other taxes) and the No Tax On Tips provision, as currently written, will not give them any extra federal tax relief.
'It's more of a middle income benefit, not a low-income benefit,' Mr. Pomerleau said.
Putting aside potentially confusing details for tax filers, there is also the question of whether No Tax On Tips would lead to less pressure on employers to raise wages — not more.
Most employers in the leisure and hospitality industry are already granted the remarkably unique state subsidy of being allowed to pay workers a sub-minimum hourly wage by law. No Tax On Tips would extend another carve-out to them, Stan Veuger, a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute with Mr. Pomerleau, argued, because it would put less pressure on firms to raise pay when efficiency gains or higher sales lead to greater productivity.
But in an interview Mr. Veuger also acknowledged the straightforward outcome for most tipped workers, especially those who are single. For a tipped worker in any given American city, he said, 'If you make $60,000 and you do not have kids, it definitely benefits you.'
Brendan Duke, the senior director for federal budget policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, who previously served as a policy adviser in the Biden administration, sees flaws in the No Tax On Tips provision that mostly have to do with scale. To him, the tax cut amounts to an understandably popular but inefficient means of providing tax relief to working class households overall.
Mr. Duke and Mr. Veuger both said they would prefer a tax break for lower-income households that applied across the board, regardless of role, such as an increase in the earned-income tax credit.
House Republicans are 'touting this as their working class tax break and it just doesn't deliver a lot because the vast majority of working class folks don't work for tips,' Mr. Duke said. 'I think it mostly serves as a shield for all those trillion dollar tax breaks tilted toward wealthy people that cost a lot more.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Los Angeles mayor slams vandalism during protests
Los Angeles mayor slams vandalism during protests

CNN

time25 minutes ago

  • CNN

Los Angeles mayor slams vandalism during protests

Los Angeles mayor slams vandalism during protests Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass criticized people who are vandalizing the city amid widespread protests. CNN correspondent Stephanie Elam gets a closer look at some of the looting and vandalism in downtown LA. 01:08 - Source: CNN Vertical Top News 14 videos Los Angeles mayor slams vandalism during protests Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass criticized people who are vandalizing the city amid widespread protests. CNN correspondent Stephanie Elam gets a closer look at some of the looting and vandalism in downtown LA. 01:08 - Source: CNN Tanks arrive in DC ahead of US Army parade As the 250th anniversary celebration for the US Army approaches, a freight train of tanks was seen making its way into the nation's capital. The long-planned celebration in Washington will coincide with Trump's 79th birthday and include thousands of troops. The Army had said it has no plans to recognize the president's birthday. 00:40 - Source: CNN Colombian presidential hopeful Miguel Uribe shot in Bogota A Colombian senator and presidential hopeful is in a critical condition after being shot twice at an event in Bogota, according to national police and prosecutors. Police arrested a 15-year-old carrying a Glock pistol, according to the Attorney General's Office. Miguel Uribe expressed intentions to run in the 2026 presidential election for the country's largest opposition party, the center-right Centro Democrático, or Democratic Center. 01:05 - Source: CNN Immigration protests break out in Los Angeles President Donald Trump signed a presidential memorandum deploying 2,000 National Guardsmen to disperse the protests that began in the Los Angeles area in response to immigration raids. Law enforcement authorities and demonstrators have clashed for two days. CNN's Julia Vargas Jones reports. 01:34 - Source: CNN Coco Gauff reacts to winning the French Open Coco Gauff claimed her second career grand slam singles title, defeating world No. 1 Aryna Sabalenka in the French Open women's final. 00:46 - Source: CNN Protesters confront authorities following ICE raids in Los Angeles Federal immigration operations in Los Angeles were met by protests. ICE declined to discuss the details of its operations. 00:43 - Source: CNN Attorney for mistakenly deported man talks to Erin Burnett CNN's Erin Burnett talks with Simon Sandoval-Moshenberg, attorney for Kilmar Abrego Garcia, the Maryland man mistakenly deported to El Salvador in March, who has been returned to the United States to face federal criminal charges. 02:37 - Source: CNN Trump Admin targets LGBTQ+ community during Pride Month CNN's Ben Hunte breaks down how the Trump Administration has targeted the LGBTQ+ community with its policies in just the first few days of Pride Month. 02:09 - Source: CNN Former 'Diddy' girlfriend reveals 'love contract' A former romantic partner for Sean 'Diddy' Combs using the pseudonym 'Jane' described feeling financially coerced and revealed Combs is still paying for her rent, even as she testified against him at trial. Prosecutors hope the testimony by 'Jane' will drive home charges that include sex trafficking, racketeering conspiracy and transportation to engage in prostitution. Combs has pleaded not guilty to all charges. 01:30 - Source: CNN Trump's border czar on 3 US children leaving the country with their deported mothers White House border czar Tom Homan defended the Trump administration's move to deport three US citizen children last week. Homan told CNN's Priscilla Alvarez the children's parents, who were in the US illegally, made a "parental decision" to leave the country together. Gracie Willis, an attorney with the National Immigration Project, denies that the mothers were given a choice whether their children could remain in the US. 01:07 - Source: CNN Trump on Musk: 'The poor guy's got a problem' In a phone call with CNN's Dana Bash, President Donald Trump said he is 'not even thinking about' billionaire Elon Musk and won't be speaking to him in the near future. The comments come a day after Trump and Musk traded barbs on social media as their relationship deteriorated in spectacular public fashion. 00:43 - Source: CNN No aliens here: Research disputes possible 'signs of life' on another planet In response to hints of "biosignatures" found on a world called K2-18b, new research suggests there's a lot of uncertainty surrounding the exoplanet. CNN's Ashley Strickland reports on the ongoing scientific discourse around the search for extraterrestrial life. 00:43 - Source: CNN Reporter: Trump made $1 billion in crypto in 9 months CNN's Erin Burnett talks with Forbes Magazine's Dan Alexander about President Donald Trump's stunning ownership of billions of dollars worth of crypto. 02:19 - Source: CNN Russia launches strikes across Ukraine Russia launched waves of drones and ballistic missiles at multiple targets across a broad swath of Ukraine overnight killing at least four people in the capital Kyiv and wounding around 40 across the country. 00:32 - Source: CNN

Donald Trump is front and center for Army's big DC birthday parade
Donald Trump is front and center for Army's big DC birthday parade

USA Today

time28 minutes ago

  • USA Today

Donald Trump is front and center for Army's big DC birthday parade

Donald Trump is front and center for Army's big DC birthday parade Trump is poised to be president during the 250th anniversary of the nation's founding, the FIFA World Cup in 2026 and the LA Summer Olympics in 2028. Show Caption Hide Caption Military equipment headed to DC ahead of Trump's birthday parade Battle tanks, fighting vehicles and infantry carriers departed Texas for D.C. for President Trump's military parade. The June 14 parade reflects the president's vision of his role and of the nation's power. Some predict an inspiring moment of patriotism; others see an alarming echo of authoritarianism. WASHINGTON − Donald Trump loves a parade. Also palace-in-the-sky planes, gold decor in the Oval Office, the adulation of huge rallies, the company of kings (British, Saudi), and the general aura that surrounds power, wealth and royalty. The president's determination to stage a procession of America's troops and its military hardware, with 28 Abrams tanks thundering up Constitution Avenue in the nation's capital and 50 military helicopters thumping overhead, reflects his vision of his role and the nation he leads. Asserting sweeping and sometimes unprecedented powers for the presidency, he is commanding a go-it-alone United States, ready and willing to flex its muscle in the world. The last big national event, Trump's inauguration on Jan. 20, was a demonstration of tradition and shared powers: The incoming president stood on the Capitol steps, the chief justice gave the oath, members of Congress and former presidents witnessed the peaceful transition of authority. Five months later, the celebration on June 14 marking the 250th anniversary of the founding of the U.S. Army will put Trump alone front and center. Also: The parade just happens to be taking place on his 79th birthday. Trump is the happy beneficiary of the calendar. He is poised to be president not only during the 250th anniversary of the nation's founding but also the FIFA World Cup in 2026 (co-hosted with Canada and Mexico) and the Summer Olympics in Los Angeles in 2028. The confluence of events is no coincidence, he suggests. "I have everything," he boasted at a Memorial Day event at Arlington Cemetery. "Amazing the way things work out. God did that." The good fortune of Trump's 2020 defeat Whether or not it was a case of divine intervention, Trump's electoral defeat in 2020 has, with the benefit of hindsight, turned out to be serendipitous for him. The four-year interregnum not only put him in a position to preside during historic and high-profile celebrations, but it also gave him a Democratic predecessor as a whipping boy when things go wrong. It also provided the opportunity for him to solidify control of the Republican Party and for supporters to create ambitious blueprints like Project 2025 to tap when he landed a second term. It even opened the door for the parade he had set his heart on when he watched French tanks roll down the Champs-Élysées in Paris on Bastille Day in 2017. "One of the greatest parades I've ever seen," he marveled, telling French President Emmanuel Macron he wanted to "top" it. During Trump's first term, though, the Pentagon resisted. Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, a retired Marine Corps four-star general, objected to the idea as a politicization of the military. In 2020, when Trump pushed again despite concerns about the coronavirus pandemic, Mattis' successor, Mark Esper, arranged instead for an array of warplanes to fly down the East Coast in an "air parade." Now, Pete Hegseth, a Trump loyalist and former Fox News host, is leading the Defense Department. The Army's plans for a low-key birthday celebration of festivals, fun runs and a commemorative stamp have now been dramatically expanded to include what the White House might call a big, beautiful parade. The sight of more than 100 combat vehicles on the ground and dozens of vintage and modern warplanes in the air should be staggering. The troops plus 34 horses, two mules, a dog named Doc Holliday and some of the vehicles will start at the Pentagon in Virginia, cross Arlington Memorial Bridge, then head to the parade route along the National Mall, joined there by the tanks. Trump will be watching from a reviewing stand just south of the White House that is now being constructed for the occasion. Paratroopers from the Army's Golden Knights are set to parachute in, land on the Eclipse and present Trump with an American flag. The president will then preside over the enlistment and reenlistment of 250 soldiers. There will be fireworks. Is it inspiring or alarming? The United States has staged military parades before, of course. At the end of the Civil War, the bloodiest conflict in American history, the Grand Review of the Armies lasted two days and featured 145,000 soldiers from the victorious Union forces marching through Washington and sometimes breaking into song. President Andrew Johnson, who had been sworn in after Abraham Lincoln's assassination a month earlier, presided. During the Cold War, President Dwight D. Eisenhower, a retired five-star general and hero of World War II, had troops, tanks and warplanes in his inaugural parade. His successor, John F. Kennedy, included troops in his inaugural parade in 1961. The last major military parade in the capital was in 1991 to mark the end of the first Gulf War, when George H.W. Bush was president. But there is not much precedent in the United States for such a massive military parade in peacetime. Like many things involving Trump, reactions clash between those who predict a stirring moment of patriotism and those who see it as an alarming echo of authoritarianism. The ritualized display of armaments and troops is more routine in places like Russia, China and North Korea, where strongmen show their force to their own citizens and the world. In the USA, liberal and pro-democracy groups have declared a "No Kings" day of protests on June 14, with anti-Trump demonstrations planned in more than 1,500 communities across the country. Trump has never been shy about demanding attention and claiming credit for his presidential record, putting himself in the top rank of the 45 men who have held the job. In his State of the Union address in March, he said that "many" believed he had just recorded the most successful first month of any presidency − with George Washington in second place. Last month, on the facade of the Agriculture Department that faces the Mall, a huge banner of Trump's face was draped between the columns alongside one of Lincoln. By the way, that's the building where thousands of the troops who will be marching in the parade will bivouac, sleeping on cots and bringing their own sleeping bags. Agriculture employees have been directed to work from home for the first three weeks of the month to clear the way for them. $45 million? 'Peanuts,' Trump says The parade's price tag? The Army has estimated the cost at $30 million to $45 million, in addition to the promise to help the D.C. government deal with the aftermath. Huge steel plates are being embedded at some intersections to protect the asphalt, but at 140,000 pounds each, the Abrams battle tanks are expected to, well, leave an impression. That could add as much as an estimated $16 million. "Peanuts," Trump said of the cost on NBC's "Meet the Press" last month, "compared to the value of doing it."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store