logo
Trump Wants to Fulfill His ‘No Tax On Tips' Promise. The Details Get Tricky.

Trump Wants to Fulfill His ‘No Tax On Tips' Promise. The Details Get Tricky.

New York Times19-05-2025

Several of the proposals that House Republicans have outlined in their expansive tax bill have drawn concern from the public and within the party itself. But one tax cut provision within the House majority's plan is receiving an unusual level of public, bipartisan approval — a rule to eliminate federal income taxes on tips.
'No Tax On Tips,' which was one of President Trump's most buzzy, populist campaign pledges in 2024, polls quite well. An Ipsos survey found roughly three in four Republicans, Democrats and independents were in support. The proposal, which would reduce federal revenues about $11 billion a year, currently appears likely to end up in whatever final bill moves through Congress and heads to the president's desk to be signed into law.
Tipped workers in the bottom 60 percent of the income distribution would receive an average tax cut of $1,260 if tips were excluded from income taxes. A broad chunk of restaurant workers and bartenders, a large share of hotel staff, barbers, salon workers, tour guides and delivery and Uber drivers are among those who most likely stand to benefit.
The policy push has created odd bedfellows. The National Restaurant Association, the powerful business trade group that often lobbies against minimum wage increases for workers, has been supportive of the policy for tipped workers, who are subject to a lower minimum wage than others in the vast majority of the United States.
Yet a unique mix of labor economists, budget hawks aligned with liberals and conservatives, and even some restaurant interest groups have come out against the No Tax On Tips idea.
'The Fair Labor Standards Act specifies that you can only receive tips if you are customer facing, so that means cooks, dishwashers, porters and bussers, in some cases, are all not receiving tips,' said Erika Polmar, the executive director of the Independent Restaurant Coalition, a group that represents the small and midsize market.
'What this means,' Ms. Polmar argues, 'is that servers are suddenly going to get a substantial tax credit, whereas cooks and such are not, and restaurants can't afford to just keep increasing minimum wages to make up that difference.'
If tipped workers at a restaurant make more than their colleagues who don't get tips, those workers could either demand more money or take up tipped-eligible roles themselves elsewhere.
That could put a significant amount of wage pressure on the service industry, Ms. Polmar said, at a time when many businesses in her coalition are worried about maintaining their profit margins, which are relatively low compared with other industries.
For some workers, though, the pressure that No Tax On Tips may put on restaurants to give greater compensation to everyone involved in the operation is a feature not a bug — even if it causes some headaches for managers and owners at first.
'My opinion on the whole No Tax On Tips thing is I'm working based on a salary of $2.50 per hour as a server, right? So it's me working my butt off for my tips; why are they taking money from me when I'm the one who is putting in the work,' said Chase Morales, a waiter, bartender and host, working in Midland, Texas. 'I'm still paying my taxes for my hourly wage,' he added.
The U.S. tax code has long been filled with different nooks and crannies that treat one type of business, or a certain form of income, more or less favorably than others. But several analysts at influential think tanks based in Washington oppose the Trump-led tips provision because it appears primed to add yet another special tax exemption.
'We're not a huge fan of doing tax policy that's just for one industry, having special sets of rules that advantage one industry over another,' said Alex Muresianu, a senior policy analyst at the nonpartisan Tax Foundation. But Mr. Muresianu acknowledged the 'market distortions' of the policies could lead to near-term gains for workers, as people potentially flock into 'tipped-eligible' roles to earn more take-home pay.
Still, the details of who exactly will benefit from the proposed gratuities tax break can get complicated.
'If a low-income taxpayer already has zero taxable income due to the standard deduction, the tip deduction would provide no additional benefit,' said Kyle Pomerleau, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, a right-leaning think tank. In other words, many lower-income Americans already owe nothing in federal income taxes (even though they pay local, state, sales and other taxes) and the No Tax On Tips provision, as currently written, will not give them any extra federal tax relief.
'It's more of a middle income benefit, not a low-income benefit,' Mr. Pomerleau said.
Putting aside potentially confusing details for tax filers, there is also the question of whether No Tax On Tips would lead to less pressure on employers to raise wages — not more.
Most employers in the leisure and hospitality industry are already granted the remarkably unique state subsidy of being allowed to pay workers a sub-minimum hourly wage by law. No Tax On Tips would extend another carve-out to them, Stan Veuger, a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute with Mr. Pomerleau, argued, because it would put less pressure on firms to raise pay when efficiency gains or higher sales lead to greater productivity.
But in an interview Mr. Veuger also acknowledged the straightforward outcome for most tipped workers, especially those who are single. For a tipped worker in any given American city, he said, 'If you make $60,000 and you do not have kids, it definitely benefits you.'
Brendan Duke, the senior director for federal budget policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, who previously served as a policy adviser in the Biden administration, sees flaws in the No Tax On Tips provision that mostly have to do with scale. To him, the tax cut amounts to an understandably popular but inefficient means of providing tax relief to working class households overall.
Mr. Duke and Mr. Veuger both said they would prefer a tax break for lower-income households that applied across the board, regardless of role, such as an increase in the earned-income tax credit.
House Republicans are 'touting this as their working class tax break and it just doesn't deliver a lot because the vast majority of working class folks don't work for tips,' Mr. Duke said. 'I think it mostly serves as a shield for all those trillion dollar tax breaks tilted toward wealthy people that cost a lot more.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump's spending bill heads to Senate where Republicans plan strategic adjustments to key provisions
Trump's spending bill heads to Senate where Republicans plan strategic adjustments to key provisions

Fox News

time31 minutes ago

  • Fox News

Trump's spending bill heads to Senate where Republicans plan strategic adjustments to key provisions

The "Big, Beautiful Bill" may face major changes when the Senate begins debate next week. Look for Senate Republicans to pare down state and local tax deductions—known as SALT—which are important to House Republicans from California and New York. Almost no Senate Republicans care about SALT. Rep. Mike Lawler, R-N.Y., says he'd oppose the bill if the Senate strips SALT. Fiscal hawks want further Medicaid changes to achieve additional savings, but Sens. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., and Jim Justice, represent states with high percentages of their constituents on Medicaid. Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., wants to alter the no-tax-on-tips provision, arguing it's unfair to workers outside tipped industries. The Senate may also cut House provisions on AI and federal judges, as these policy issues don't comply with special Senate budget rules.

Trump border czar responds to Newsom's 'arrest me' challenge as California riots over ICE raids
Trump border czar responds to Newsom's 'arrest me' challenge as California riots over ICE raids

Fox News

time37 minutes ago

  • Fox News

Trump border czar responds to Newsom's 'arrest me' challenge as California riots over ICE raids

Trump border czar Tom Homan fired back at California Gov. Gavin Newsom after the Democrat dared Homan to arrest him while defending the state's handling of anti-ICE riots in Los Angeles. "He's a tough guy, why doesn't he do that [arrest me]? He knows where to find me," Newsom told MSNBC Sunday. "Come after me, arrest me, let's just get it over with. Tough guy. I don't give a damn, but I care about my community… and I'm sorry to be so clear, but that kind of bloviating is exhausting. So Tom, arrest me." The governor's taunt came after Homan warned Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass could face federal charges for trying to impede ICE operations throughout the city, according to The New York Post. Homan told "Fox & Friends" on Monday that he had told an NBC reporter that "no one's above the law," but there was no discussion about arresting Newsom. "What we discussed was for those protesters that crossed the line… you can protest, you get your First Amendment rights, but when you cross that line, you put hands on an ICE officer or you destroy property or I'd say that you impede law enforcement, or you're knowingly harboring and concealing an illegal alien, that's a crime, and the Trump administration is not going to tolerate it," he said. "Then the reporter asked me, well, could Governor Newsom or Mayor Bass be arrested? I said, 'Well no one's above the law. If they cross the line and commit a crime, absolutely they can,' so there was no discussion about arresting Newsom." Homan lambasted the blue state's response to riots against the Trump administration's immigration raids that rocked Los Angeles over the weekend, with some protesters throwing projectiles at law enforcement and torching American flags and cars. President Donald Trump deployed 2,000 National Guard troops to the city in an effort to quell some of the unrest, much to the dismay of Democratic officials. "It showed what [Newsom has] done. He's failed that state. He waited two days of that city burning and people getting hurt, officers being assaulted before he made any declaration of an unlawful assembly," Homan said. "He's late to the game. President Trump isn't late to game. The men and women of ICE are not late to the game." The violent protests erupted as ICE officials carried out plans to remove individuals illegally residing in the left-wing city, which dubbed itself a "sanctuary" for illegal immigrants in November before Trump was sworn back into the Oval Office. Homan explained that ICE was serving criminal warrants at a business being investigated for money laundering, consumer fraud and "serious violations" of sending money to criminal cartels in Latin American countries. ICE raids began on Friday, with Mayor Bass issuing a statement supporting illegal immigrants in the city and bucking the Trump administration's deportation efforts. Newsom similarly criticized ICE efforts, branding the immigration raids "chaotic and reckless." "Continued chaotic federal sweeps, across California, to meet an arbitrary arrest quota are as reckless as they are cruel. Donald Trump's chaos is eroding trust, tearing families apart, and undermining the workers and industries that power America's economy," a statement from the governor read.

A Texas Republican new to Congress, Brandon Gill has a knack for getting noticed
A Texas Republican new to Congress, Brandon Gill has a knack for getting noticed

Yahoo

time37 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

A Texas Republican new to Congress, Brandon Gill has a knack for getting noticed

WASHINGTON — Rep. Brandon Gill knows how to get attention. Now a 31-year-old Republican freshman in Congress, Gill has been courting President Donald Trump's favor since he founded the DC Enquirer, a conservative outlet in 2022. He calls liberals "deranged," says Biden unleashed "chaos" across the country, and considers Dinesh D'Souza, his father-in-law who was federally convicted of making illegal campaign contributions, a political mentor. Gill, of Flower Mound, appears regularly on conservative platforms including Fox News, OAN and high-profile podcasts — and clips of his House hearing questions have racked up more than a million views on YouTube. After moving back to Texas, and winning in his first campaign for office, his main focus, Gill said in an interview with The Texas Tribune, is to codify Trump's executive orders. 'What we want to do is make sure that all of the great work that the president is doing remains permanent,' Gill said. 'So that a future Democrat doesn't unleash the same kind of chaos on our country that Joe Biden did.' In his first five months in Congress, Gill has introduced bills to impeach a federal judge who attempted to stop some deportation flights, codify Trump's 'Remain in Mexico' immigration policy, and put Trump's face on the $100 bill. His bills have not yet made it to the House floor, and most – except his Remain in Mexico bill – have failed to garner significant support. Gill's intertwined legislative and media strategy, however, has burnished his reputation among MAGA supporters and earned him praise from other Republicans in the Texas delegation. In many ways, Gills' early political career is modeled after the path of other political figures who have made unfettered statements and disruptive moves as they made their way into the spotlight. Each in his own way tests how and if attention can translate into influence, and Gill says he draws lessons from D'Souza, a longtime conservative agitator. Such a group would also include former Rep. Matt Gaetz of Florida, Trump's first pick to be Attorney General, as well as Representatives Dan Crenshaw, Keith Self and Chip Roy, all Texas Republicans. Gill himself made a political debut as a Dartmouth student leading a conservative student publication – The Dartmouth Review. After a few years working as an investment banker and a hedge fund analyst in New York, he founded and led a conservative publication, the DC Enquirer, known for right-wing framed articles, conspiracy theories and commentary pieces. Trump posted DC Enquirer stories or reposted links to the outlet more than 100 times on his social media accounts. Gill said his role there taught him how to handle the media, which he says 'sets the parameters of debate' in Washington. 'You learn how to communicate in a way that resonates with a broader audience outside of the DC bubble,' Gill said. He stepped down from his editorial role with DC Enquirer when he began his congressional campaign and the outlet has not posted any articles since Gill was sworn into Congress in January. Gill married conservative author Danielle D'Souza in 2017. Dinesh D'Souza is known for his books and films that emphasize false conspiracies about Democrats and the accuracy of the 2020 election. He was pardoned in 2018 by Trump after he pled guilty to making illegal campaign contributions in other people's names. Gill said his father-in-law has taught him how to be precise while speaking about politics and how to 'push the bounds of discussion.' 'I learned a ton from him,' Gill said about his father-in-law. 'He's sort of a political mentor of mine.' He worked with his father-in-law on the film promoting the false idea that 2020 election was stolen, '2000 Mules,' and was a producer on Dinesh D'Souza's 2023 film, 'Police State'. Gill announced his candidacy for Congress in November 2023 and received Trump's endorsement within two weeks. Trump posted on Truth that Gill is an 'America first,' candidate, 'as loyal and tough as they come,' while also highlighting Gill's connection to his father-in-law. The endorsement in the race, left open by Rep. Michael Burgess's retirement, cleared the way for Gill to sweep the Republican primary. Others who supported Gill's campaign included Gaetz, then a Florida Representative; Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan, and Sen. Ted Cruz. Later on, Gaetz would post that Gill once told a SuperPAC that Gaetz was the member of Congress he most wanted to emulate. In the November election, Gill won 62% of the vote against Democratic candidate Ernest Lineberger. Throughout the election, Lineberger said, Gill would be personable at candidate forums – talking about family or saying that it was nice to see him. But, when Gill spoke to the audience, he would – as Lineberger put it – quickly flip into 'demonizing the Democrats.' 'He is a professional disinformation spreader, and that is what he has continued to do,' Lineburger said in an interview. In his second month on Capitol Hill, Gill sent out a fundraising email that included a petition to deport Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minnesota. Omar was born in Somalia and has been a U.S. citizen since 2000, when she was 17 years old. 'We should have never let Ilhan Omar into our country,' the email said. 'And frankly, America would be a much better place if she were to be sent back to Somalia.' Rep. Greg Casar, D-Austin, told the Tribune that he has had conversations with Gill related to this incident, including about how members of Congress should take their jobs seriously and that disagreements will happen, but that there is a line. 'He can stand out based on his opinions, if he wants to, but he shouldn't stand out by saying things that put the life at risk of people that he works with,' Casar said. Gill has continued to set off sparks at House committee hearings – leading to clips that have gone viral in conservative circles – with pointed lines of questions directed at the CEO of NPR, the mayor of Chicago and the head of USA Fencing. Cruz praised Gill on his podcast, 'Verdict with Ted Cruz,' calling the freshman representative a 'rising star in the House,' and Gaetz, in a social media post, called Gill the better version of himself following the NPR hearing. Rep. Wesley Hunt, R-Houston, who serves with Gill on the oversight committee, praised the freshman. 'He's making very big waves,' Hunt said in April. 'He's doing a very good job. He's speaking our language.' In committee hearings Gill says his job is 'to highlight and to call out some of the crazy things that these deranged leftists have been promoting for so long.' Gill wrote on X in March that 'multiculturalism will tear our country apart.' The post has more than 23 million views on the platform. The congressman elaborated to the Tribune adding that immigrants need to 'assimilate to our culture and adopt our customs and adhere to our traditions,' to preserve the American identity. Gill posted on X last month that he was against House Republican social media pages posting in Spanish. He has also supported bills that would bar Chinese nationals from attending U.S. universities and from purchasing farmland in the country. Gill represents the Republican stronghold of District 26, which covers the north Dallas-Fort Worth suburbs and extends to the Texas-Oklahoma border That includes Cooke County, a rural area where the Republican chair is Chris McNamara. He told the Tribune that while Gill's method of rising politically is not how he would do things, the Republican base in his county does get excited about Gill's strategy. 'Within the district, he gets a lot of support from that,' McNamara said. 'He's probably, I would think, trying to get some national attention, some leverage attention.' Trump's endorsement during the primary was 'big,' for Gill's local support, McNamara said, adding that 'it can't hurt to be on the President's good side'. While Gill has introduced a bill to add more zip codes in the district, which has areas that experienced a population boom, and claims to have the 'best case-worker team in the country,' some local political figures told the Tribune they would like Gill to focus more on issues impacting the area – such as rural hospitals and passenger train route cancellations. On Capitol Hill, Gill has more of a position than the average freshman. He was voted by his colleagues to be the Republican freshman class president, acting as a representative for the members. Fellow freshman House Republican Rep. Craig Goldman, R-Fort Worth, said Gill has used this ceremonial role as an 'action position,' bringing the class together. Gill has also positioned himself on key committees, including the committees on the judiciary, budget and oversight – where he also serves on the Delivering on Government Efficiency Subcommittee. Roy and Self are members of the hardline House Freedom Caucus and have recently served as crucial holdouts to win policy promises from House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-Louisiana, and Trump before joining the majority on key votes. Gill was endorsed by the Freedom Caucus's PAC in his House primary and said that he would join the caucus on his first day. He told Politico that the member he most wanted to be like was Jordan, of Ohio, the first chair of the caucus, also known for provocative statements. The freshman representative has not yet been a holdout against key Republican legislation, but he went further than Johnson and party leadership in March regarding the federal judge, James Boasberg, who was attempting to stop deportation flights. Gill advocated for impeachment, while party leadership looked for other options, such as ending national injunctions. He also told the Tribune that the Freedom Caucus holdouts on the budget reconciliation package had 'excellent points,' and that the holdouts were fighting to include Trump's agenda into the final tax and spending bill. Gill had returned to Washington early, a week after his son was born in May, in an attempt to move the Republican megabill out of the House Budget Committee. The legislation was temporarily blocked by Roy and other holdouts in the committee as they pushed for more reforms. Gill has plans to continue focusing on his push to permanently defund NPR and PBS, lower border crossings, codify cuts to the federal workforce, and eliminate some of the Biden administration's climate policies. 'We should be doing … all the things that we told voters we were going to do,' Gill said. 'The things that voters saw us talking about and said, 'We need to give these people a majority in Washington.' ' Disclosure: Politico has been a financial supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that is funded in part by donations from members, foundations and corporate sponsors. Financial supporters play no role in the Tribune's journalism. Find a complete list of them here. First round of TribFest speakers announced! Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist Maureen Dowd; U.S. Rep. Tony Gonzales, R-San Antonio; Fort Worth Mayor Mattie Parker; U.S. Sen. Adam Schiff, D-California; and U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett, D-Dallas are taking the stage Nov. 13–15 in Austin. Get your tickets today!

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store