Parents whose children were centre of concern in CHI internal review not informed, summary reveals
It said the review found that patients seen in the outpatient clinic who required ongoing treatment were placed on an already long inpatient waiting list without consideration of redistribution of patients to colleagues with a shorter waiting list.
'The examination raised the issue as to the possibility that this could have led to any negative outcomes for patients,' it said.
However, the summary, which also includes follow-up actions, said an examination of the relevant inpatient waiting list later took place and patients were re-distributed across the department to ensure equitable access to treatment.
'This action was closed out in September 2022.'
It said 'open disclosure' – informing parents about the concerns raised in the report – was not carried out 'as there is no significant scientific evidence that delaying treatment will equate to patient harm in this patient cohort'.
CHI, which has declined to publish the full report for legal reasons, said it was an internal examination commissioned by the CHI Executive. The hospital involved has been previously identified as Crumlin Hospital by CHI chief Lucy Nugent.
During meetings (2020/2021) between employees in this clinical department and members of the CHI Executive, it became evident that multiple legacy and deep-rooted issues existed that regular meetings could not address, it added.
It became clear that a more robust process was required to identify the issues that needed to be addressed
'In early 2021, an operational lead was assigned to look into these issues. However, it became clear that a more robust process was required to identify the issues that needed to be addressed.'
It led to the examination taking four months.
It said that a number of issues were raised in relation to an NTPF outpatient waiting list initiative.
The NTPF funds hospitals to carry out extra clinics and procedures.
The examination suggested that based on the documentation review, certain NTPF-funded clinics did not adhere to NTPF standards of chronological scheduling – seeing the longest-waiting patients first.
Data suggested that some of these patients could have been seen by other departmental colleagues within the existing day-to-day service and potentially managed in a more proactive way.
'Patients seen in the outpatient clinic who required ongoing treatment were placed on an already long inpatient waiting list without consideration of redistribution of patients to colleagues with a shorter waiting list. The examination raised the issue as to the possibility that this could have led to any negative outcomes for patients,' it said.
'The above raised concerns relating to the prudent and beneficial management of NTPF funding and lack of oversight of access initiatives.'
It found that interpersonal difficulties among team members led to poor working relationships and a challenging working environment.
There was a high attrition rate among support staff due to bullying issues.
A significant risk was identified where only one employee managed the needs of a complex tertiary speciality. This level of dependency on one individual for a critical service is not in line with best practice and created a vulnerability in this specialty.
The report also sets out a series of actions that were taken on foot of the report.
'A cross-city CHI Central Referral's Office was established. This system manages referrals centrally to ensure equitable distribution. Efficiencies have been gained, and this process is being rolled out across all CHI specialties,' it said.
CHI now has a robust process for NTPF-funded waiting-list initiatives
'CHI now has a robust process for NTPF-funded waiting-list initiatives which requires multiple internal stakeholder approvals both clinical and financial. CHI is regularly audited by the NTPF.'
It added: 'A review of all CHI Hospital sites leadership roles and responsibilities was commenced to provide clarity around delineation of accountability at site and executive level – this work has continued as the transformation programme has evolved in preparation for the move to the new children's hospital.'
The original report stated that a negative culture can impact service delivery, department dynamics and staff experience and has the potential to put patients at risk.
It said that CHI is a learning organisation and service improvements through internal reviews and clinical audits, which are an essential tool to support this, will continue to be a priority.
'CHI recognises the importance of transparency and the interests of the broader public in relation to the issues identified in the report,' it said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
2 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Waiting list for endoscopy test climbs by more than 4,000 in five months despite €24m fund
More than 4,000 additional people are now waiting for vital endoscopy tests which can identify disease, including cancer, than in March, new hospital data shows. The rise comes despite funding of €24m given to widen use of these scopes in the latest waiting list action plan, published in February. The figures from the National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) show 32,839 people waiting for GI endoscopies in July. This waiting list has grown every month since March when 28,663 were waiting, having shown signs of decreasing in January and February. While the majority waiting in July have waited less than six months, some 132 adults have waited longer than 18 months, 620 for between 12 and 19 months and 4,244 people have waited for between six months and one year so far. The government's Slaintecare target waiting time for these scopes is just 5.5 months. The endoscopy list also includes 368 children with nine of them waiting longer than 18 months to be seen and 30 waiting between 12 and 18 months. A further 63 have been waiting between six and 12 months with the remaining 267 waiting less than six months. This year's waiting list action plan included €24m in funding to the NTPF to offer extra endoscopy care. Patients waiting the longest were to be reached under this. A key target is to have 50% of patients waiting less than 12 weeks for a GI Scope appointment by the end of this year. They also aim to have no-one waiting longer than four weeks for an urgent colonoscopy. The HSE was also funded to boost staffing in this area. The July waiting list figures also show 100,019 waiting to get an appointment for in-patient or day-care work, up from 97,040 waiting in March and 95,983 waiting in February. Some 614,470 were waiting for their first out-patient appointment with a consultant last month, usually having been referred in by their GP. This is also up from 581,736 waiting in March - a leap of over 32,000 - and an increase on February's figures – the month the waiting list plan was published. The plan's funding for this year came to €430m including €190m for the HSE and €230m for the NTPF. It also aims to have 90% of outpatients waiting less than 12 months for their first appointment by the end of the year. In July for adults and children together this stood at 83%, the NTPF data shows, with the remainder waiting longer than that. In February there were fewer people but the same proportion - 83% - had waited less than 12 months to be seen. The Department of Health said on Friday: "There has been a 1% reduction in the total number of patients waiting over 12 months since this time last year, and a corresponding reduction of 10% in the number waiting over 18 months."
Irish Examiner
3 days ago
- Irish Examiner
CHI issue tender for 'world-class hospitals' outside Ireland to treat spina bifida and scoliosis patients
Proposals from Children's Health Ireland (CHI) to treat spina bifida and scoliosis patients in 'world-class hospitals' outside its remit have been cautiously welcomed. Tender documents published by CHI on Wednesday have called for applications by hospitals to carry out a minimum of 10 spinal surgeries by the end of the year. The call for hospitals to carry out spinal surgeries comes as a bid to cut the number of children on spina bifida and scoliosis surgery waiting lists. David Cullinane, Sinn Féin's health spokesperson, said while he welcomed the proposal from CHI, it must not be used as a stand-in for building more capacity for spinal surgeries at Irish hospitals. In the tender documents, CHI have said hospitals from outside Ireland will be permitted to apply, but it is 'only willing to entrust the treatment of CHI patients to hospitals of the highest quality in terms of the clinical team and the hospitals' facilities and resources'. 'The ability of the hospital and its clinical team to provide the highest level of care to the patient and their accompanying parent/guardian or carer is of paramount importance,' the tender reads. 'I would imagine this is being done to widen the net, to have more options and to have more hospitals. Obviously, all of that is to be welcomed as it goes, but it is not a substitute for increasing capacity here,' Mr Cullinane said. 'We really need to be looking at what we need in this State to provide the services that are needed. 'They also need to be putting a plan in place to beef up domestic capacity because its still unfair that children who are that sick and who require that level of surgery would actually have to get onto a plane and go elsewhere to get the treatment that they need.' Mr Cullinane said the Government must be 'putting everything possible' into recruiting the highly-skilled surgeons to work in the Ireland's health service. 'Then making sure we have the theatre capacity and the ability to provide the pre-care and after-care , because that's what's missed in all of this as well,' the Waterford TD said. He added high-dependency beds are required in hospital wards in case of complications with spinal surgeries, with delays possible if this capacity isn't available. Figures from June outline there were 132 children ready for surgery and awaiting a scheduled date. In total, there are 245 children on the waiting list for spinal surgeries.
Irish Times
3 days ago
- Irish Times
Children's Health Ireland spent years challenging ‘defiant' staff, says resigning doctor
The board of Children's Health Ireland (CHI) and the Health Service Executive (HSE) spent years challenging 'defiant' and influential staff at Ireland's children's hospitals before allegations of a toxic working culture came to light. As former CHI board member Dr Gavin Lavery resigned from his role amid a number of controversies at the hospital group earlier this year, he warned Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill that threats to safe care of children could not be resolved in the 'current climate,' and the situation was unlikely to improve in the near future. It comes as CHI told the Public Accounts Committee it believed the 'unsubstantiated allegations' in a 2022 report did not meet the threshold of a criminal act. The report, which CHI is refusing to publish for legal reasons, found a 'negative and toxic' work culture and allegations of irregularities in the waiting list management system within the paediatric hospital group. READ MORE The report, which led to a number of resignations from the CHI board, came after two other separate controversies within the organisation over the use of unapproved coil springs in spinal operations and questions about the threshold for hip operations. Dr Gavin Lavery was one of four board members who resigned in May of this year. The departures of Dr Lavery, Brigid McManus, Catherine Guy and Mary Cryan followed the resignation of the board chair, Dr Jim Browne, in April. In his resignation letter to Ms Carroll-MacNeill on May 27th, which was released under Freedom of Information, Dr Lavery said dealing with 'challenging situations and behaviours' had been a part of his professional life for many decades. Dr Lavery said, while the 'vast majority' of those working in CHI go beyond expectations, the actions of 'a small number' were questionable and 'not in the interests of children'. 'These individuals are defiant and, when challenged by the Board and the Executive, have used their position to influence and distract – both inside and outside CHI. The 'noise' has made normal business impossible and has subsumed huge amounts of our energy and resources,' Dr Lavery said. [ Children's Health Ireland report referred to gardaí Opens in new window ] He said the CHI board and the HSE 'have been challenging the above for several years and have had some successes', adding that they had always acted against any known 'threat to the safety of children'. 'However, some of these issues are complex and arise from long standing behaviours. When such threats to safe care are called out, the solutions sometimes require time and space for the necessary processes to play out. The current climate does not allow that time and space, and the situation is not going to improve in the near future.' In her resignation letter on the same day, Ms McManus said the CHI board had worked hard at 'investigating and responding to difficult clinical issues that came to attention'. Ms Guy, in her resignation letter, told the Health Minister the CHI board 'deserves the support of Government in its ongoing work and in dealing with further challenges to come'. Ms Cryan's resignation letter, sent on May 21st, was only one line: 'I wish to advise you that I am bringing forward my retirement from the board of CHI, which is due in December 2025, to take effect immediately.' And as he stepped down, Dr Browne described his time as chair as a 'rewarding if challenging experience'. Separately, CHI has sent a number of documents to the Dáil's Public Accounts Committee following additional questions that TDs had for the hospital group. CHI chief executive Lucy Nugent shared legal advice that CHI had received which it said supported its decision not to publish the internal report. The legal advice was shared on the condition it was not circulated beyond PAC. Ms Nugent said it was 'not in any way our intention to hide the truth, or hide behind legalities to avoid disclosure'. PAC had also asked CHI if it had considered if the issues raised in the report had broken the law. The HSE has separately decided to refer the unpublished report to the gardaí. 'The unsubstantiated allegations in the report were investigated by CHI and they did not meet the threshold for criminality,' Ms Nugent said.
