Doug Ford's Bill 5 is now law in Ontario. Here's what happens next
Social Sharing
Now that Ontario's controversial Bill 5 is law, all eyes are on what Premier Doug Ford does with the new powers it gives his government.
Bill 5, also called the Protecting Ontario by Unleashing Our Economy Act, empowers the government (among other things) to create special economic zones, where cabinet can exempt companies or projects from having to comply with any provincial law, provincial regulation or municipal bylaw.
Ford pitches Bill 5 as a way of shoring up Ontario's economy in the face of Donald Trump's tariffs by speeding up major infrastructure and resource projects.
Ford's officials insist the government won't exempt any company in a special economic zone from Ontario's minimum wage rules or other labour laws.
But the wide-open way the legislation is written would allow cabinet to hand out exemptions from any law, whether labour, environmental or operational.
Asked this week which laws he's considering overriding with Bill 5 — and whether any laws are off the table for such exemptions — Ford offered no specifics.
WATCH | Your quick guide to Bill 5:
Breaking down the Ford government's controversial Bill 5
8 days ago
Duration 7:16
The Ford government has been receiving criticism from Ontario's opposition parties, as well as environmental and Indigenous leaders on their controversial Bill 5. CBC's Mike Crawley breaks down what you need to know about the legislation.
"I just want to speed up the process," he said during a news conference on Thursday, moments after Bill 5 received Royal Assent, making it law.
Ford then talked of how long it takes for a mine to get into production, an issue that is actually tackled in a different part of Bill 5: revisions to the Mining Act designed to shorten Ontario's approval process to two years from the current four years.
Pressed again on which laws he would exempt companies from in the special economic zones, Ford said every situation is different.
Ford wants to move 'as quickly as possible'
"Let's see what companies come to the table, and depending on how quickly we can get opportunities and jobs, we'll reveal them," Ford said.
Ford wants Ontario's first special economic zone to be the Ring of Fire mineral deposit, some 500 kilometres northeast of Thunder Bay, in the heart of Treaty 9 territory. The area is said to be full of so-called critical minerals, such as cobalt, lithium and nickel, in high demand for the tech industry.
The premier said on Thursday that he wants to make the Ring of Fire a special economic zone " as quickly as possible" but has also said he won't do so without consulting with First Nations
Energy and Mines Minister Stephen Lecce says the province is already "consulting meaningfully" with First Nations and will continue to do so over the coming months.
"We're all going to be part of this endeavour to really listen to those voices and help build a common vision for responsible resource development that unlocks the bounty of the resource, to change the lives of northerners and to ensure Indigenous share in that bounty," Lecce said alongside Ford at Thursday's news conference inside Queen's Park.
The skepticism from many First Nations leaders is palpable.
The Chiefs of Ontario invited Ford to attend their annual assembly June 17 to 19 and sent Ford a message that his attendance would mark the start of consultations on Bill 5.
"This legislation, introduced without prior consultation with First Nations rights holders, raises serious concerns due to its far-reaching implications on inherent Treaty rights and community obligations to the land, waters, and wildlife," says the invitation letter from Ontario Regional Chief Abram Benedict.
The Chiefs of Ontario, the umbrella group representing more than 130 First Nations across the province, are warning of "resistance, on the ground, and in the courts" against Bill 5.
WATCH | What the 'duty to consult' First Nations means for governments:
What is a duty to consult — and how will it affect Bill 5?
2 days ago
Duration 8:45
One thing to watch for in the months to come is whether the provincial government's push to fast-track the Ring of Fire is replicated by the federal government.
Ford put the Ring of Fire at the top of his list presented to Prime Minister Mark Carney for consideration as a potential nation-building project.
Ford calls Carney 'Santa Claus'
Carney asked all the premiers to come to last Monday's First Ministers Meeting in Saskatoon with their ideas of projects that would be "in the national interest," either by helping to diversify the Canadian economy or to reach new export markets. It's now up to Carney to decide which projects merit federal backing, whether through fast-track approvals or funding.
Ford described Carney as Santa Claus for this approach. But to make the metaphor accurate, it means Ford and his fellow premiers have merely written their letters to Santa Claus, and they now have to wait until Christmas comes to find out whether Santa brings them what they asked for.
The other items on Ford's list are also projects that could be designated special economic zones: new nuclear power plants, a new deep-sea port on James Bay, Ford's vision of a tunnel under Highway 401 through Toronto, and an expansion of the GO Transit network.
If Carney endorses any of these, you can expect the Ford government will use its Bill 5 powers to speed up the process of moving that project from endorsement to reality.
On Friday, Carney's Liberals tabled a bill in the House of Commons called the One Canadian Economy Act, designed in part to speed up the approval process of major infrastructure projects, a goal similar to Ontario's Bill 5.
One line in the text of Bill 5 says its purpose is making Ontario "the best place in the G7 to invest, create jobs and do business."
Economic Development, Job Creation and Trade Minister Vic Fedeli, whose chief role is attracting companies to the province, says investors around the world are hoarding capital in hopes of some economic certainty.
Will Bill 5 attract investment?
"That capital that's building up needs to unleash, and we want them to know that when they come to Ontario, it can be unleashed very quickly here," Fedeli said at the news conference alongside Ford and Lecce.
Having Bill 5 powers on the books means Ontario could try to entice investors to set up shop in a special economic zone, but officials won't say whether that incentive is now being dangled at any particular companies.
More questions remain on how exactly the government will use other powers it obtained through Bill 5, such as the power to ignore the independent scientific committee that determines whether a species is endangered or threatened in Ontario.
You can expect a backlash from conservation groups whenever the government uses that power, for instance by scrapping measures that would protect the habitat of a species at risk. What's unknown is when, where and with what species the government will take such a step.
Another 'watch this space' related to Bill 5: what happens with the expansion of a landfill on the edge of the southwestern Ontario town of Dresden, which the legislation exempts from having to go through a comprehensive environmental assessment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
24 minutes ago
- CBC
N.W.T. art centre looks to build on former site of Akaitcho Hall, wants community input
The group spearheading a project to build a new art centre in the N.W.T. is considering putting the facility on the site of a former government-run hostel and wants to know how others in the territory feel about that. The N.W.T. Art Centre Initiative is working to build a non-commercial art gallery in Yellowknife, and after a recent assessment of where it might go, the former site of Akaitcho Hall — a residence for students attending Sir John Franklin High School — emerged as a top contender. The group is now holding two gatherings later this month to hear what the public thinks. Sara Komarnisky, the development specialist with the project, said the Akaitcho Hall site is attractive for its proximity to Yellowknife's downtown, and to existing art amenities and education facilities. It also has access to outdoor space, a view of Great Slave Lake and a large enough location for potential future expansion. Komarnisky also recognizes the importance of honouring the site's legacy. "We can't really move forward without having a conversation about what it means to people who went to the school, and to the public, about building an art centre in this space," Komarnisky said. Akaitcho Hall operated from 1958 to 1994, run first by the federal government, then by the territorial government, without church involvement. It's among the institutions listed in the federal Residential Schools Settlement Agreement. Four students died there over the years, according to the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation. Crystal Fraser, a Gwichyà Gwich'in scholar and consultant on the art centre project, said there's a lot to talk about and learn when it comes to Akaitcho Hall's legacy. "It resonates with familiar residential school narratives, and that includes the forced relocation of Indigenous children, questionable living conditions," she said. She pointed to how, in 2021, Yellowknifers left shoes at the former Akaitcho Hall site to honour the memory of children who died at residential schools. Fraser also said RCMP were called to investigate multiple times throughout Akaitcho Hall's history, and there was overcrowding with 300 students living there when its capacity was closer to 250. She also said the facility was unique in not having ties to the church and that it had a fairly large non-Indigenous population. "So we're really hoping that folks can come out, in community. We're going to have wellness supports available. Share your stories, your thoughts about that site being re-purposed, and just add to this larger conversation about truth and reconciliation that we're having in the North," Fraser said. The first gathering is being held in person at the Tree of Peace in Yellowknife on June 17 from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m. The second will be held virtually on June 25 from 7 p.m. to 8 p.m. Participants can register through the art centre's website. Komarnisky said there are a lot of ways to reflect the history of residential schools at the site, if that's where the art centre is ultimately built. She said that could be through the design of the building, the naming of the space, its programming, or something outside the facility on the grounds. She said they're open to any other suggestions from the public. Komarnisky said the centre, once built, will likely have two galleries and a community space for gathering. She said it's too soon to say when the centre might open.
National Post
33 minutes ago
- National Post
Conrad Black: A repulsive antisemitism plagues U of T profs
Article content I live in a prosperous suburb of Toronto inhabited by people of many ethnicities, including a significant percentage of Jewish families. It has apparently become a routine event where cars are left in the driveway of nearby residences and there are mezuzahs by the doors of those residences, for the windows of the cars to be smashed. This happened to many neighbours last week. They have discovered from experience that nothing useful is achieved by calling the police. Nothing like this should be happening to anyone or any group anywhere in this country and it must be possible to conduct some sort of a follow-up given the profusion of security cameras. This doesn't directly affect me but it is disturbing and outrageous that this, or any neighbourhood in this country is plagued by such problems. Article content I commented in this space two weeks ago about the Canadian government joining with the governments of the United Kingdom and France in condemning Israel for conducting its offensive in Gaza. This all appears to be of a piece with the implicit and profoundly mistaken theory that what is going on in Gaza is a disproportionate response to a border skirmish. On October 7, 2023, Israel was invaded and assaulted and more Jews were killed on that day than at any time since the liberation of the death camps in Europe in 1945. The attack was intended to be, was, and has been replied to as an act of war that created a state of war. In wars there is no discussion of proportionality. The bombing of Dresden, like the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and innumerable actions of our enemies were disproportionate, but wars have nothing to do with proportion and are conducted until a comfort level has been achieved that the act that began the war will not be repeated. Article content Now, the RCMP, an organization that has appeared to be incapable of anything more challenging than a musical ride for the last 50 years, has been tasked with a 'structural investigation' (which we are told is quite distinguishable from a criminal investigation) into alleged war crimes committed in the Israel-Gaza war. It is difficult to imagine a more unpromising and redundant mission. Does the RCMP imagine that it possesses the ability to assess what goes on in Gaza and by what standard will a Canadian police force purport to judge the conduct of armed forces engaged in mortal combat in the Middle East? This has all the dreary ear-marks of more pandering to the not overly numerous but ever-more noisy and obnoxious Jew-baiters in our society. Article content I believe most Canadians remain tolerant and civilized, as they have always been. But leaders at all levels of government throughout the country have failed in all of these related areas. The former prime minister, Justin Trudeau, acquiesced in this country falsely labelling it as genocidal because of historic treatment of the Indigenous, which had many failings, but no aspects of genocide. The government of Quebec has been actively engaged for decades in trying to exterminate the English language in that province, often with the passive cooperation of the federal government. This is an outage that is only made less obvious because of the comparative prosperity and ability of the English-speaking population of Quebec to manage its own affairs, despite blunderbuss official suppression from the so-called National Assembly of Quebec. Article content Now we are clambering aboard the tawdry bandwagon of antisemitism, the most ancient, contemptible, and frequently wicked of all forms of collective hate and persecution. Where are our leaders while the national mission of 'peace, order, and good government' is mocked? And where is the solid, sensible, decent majority of Canadians when our leaders have so conspicuously and cravenly failed us, with the complicity of much of our painfully inadequate media? Answer, comes there, none. Article content
National Post
33 minutes ago
- National Post
Chris Selley: Earth to Liberals — First Nations are not an anti-development monolith
Sean Fraser — the federal Liberals' supposed master communicator who did a bad job as immigration minister, and then a bad job as housing minister, and then said he wasn't running again to spend time with his family, and then opportunistically changed his mind and was rewarded with the justice and attorney general portfolio — laid his first dog's egg of the Mark Carney era this week. Article content Article content Fraser said Indigenous groups don't have a 'complete veto' over natural-resource projects or any other government decisions — but that wasn't the turd in question, because it was absolutely true. Article content Article content The turd came later, apparently after getting his ears boxed by Assembly of First Nations National Chief Cindy Woodhouse: Fraser disavowed his entirely truthful statement. Article content 'I think even accepting the premise of the question that was put to me (about a 'veto') really made people feel like there may be an attempt by the government to work unilaterally, not in partnership (with First Nations),' Fraser told reporters in a public apology. 'Despite innocent intentions, I think my comments actually caused hurt and potentially eroded a very precarious trust that has been built up over many years to respect the rights of Indigenous people in this country,' he said. Article content Coming up on 500 years since Jacques Cartier first set foot here and named it Canada, and 150-plus years after the Crown concluded the first treaties with First Nations, and with President Donald Trump suddenly bringing our crippling dependence on the United States into very sharp focus, if we can't even speak the plain truth to each other in plain language, we might be in even bigger trouble than we realized. Article content Article content But I think we can speak the plain truth to each other in plain language, so long as we rightly marginalize fringe and unreasonable voices. While apologizing for speaking the truth, Fraser also accurately pointed to 'a frankly dangerous trope that paints a false picture of Indigenous peoples as being anti-development.' Article content Article content Media mostly portrayed the Ktunaxa Nation case, which wound up at the Supreme Court in 2017, as a matter of Indigenous people opposing the proposed Jumbo ski resort in eastern British Columbia on religious grounds: They felt the development would chase a spirit bear from their traditional lands. Receiving much less attention was the fact that the equally interested local Shuswap Nation supported the project, believing their concerns had been properly addressed and being eager to reap the financial benefits.
