What are public inquiries and how many are ongoing?
The announcement of this inquiry brings the total number of ongoing public inquiries to 23, more than at any time before.
Concerns have been raised by members of the public, as well as MPs and ministers, over the ever-growing number, cost and length of time they take to complete their work.
So what do public inquiries achieve, and, after this latest announcement, is the government too quick to push the inquiry button?
What is a public inquiry?
Public inquiries are set up by government ministers and aim to investigate "events of major public concern or to consider controversial public policy issues."
There are two types of public inquiry, statutory and non-statutory.
Statutory inquiries in the UK are launched under the Inquiries Act 2005 and have legal powers to compel evidence and witness testimony.
Typically, they are used for serious matters of public concern and are often led by judges.
Non-statutory inquiries have no legal powers and rely on voluntary cooperation. They are faster and more flexible, but can be less effective if key witnesses refuse to take part.
Through the analysis of documents, as well as evidence and testimony from relevant parties, inquiries seek to establish a legal record of what happened, who bears responsibility and what recommendations can be made to prevent something similar from happening in the future.
Do we need them?
There are often widespread calls for public inquiries in the wake of serious events. Many see them as a vital tool in seeking answers and bringing all responsible parties together in one investigation.
Responding to calls to reform the system, the government claimed recent public inquiries have been "considered to be an independent, legitimate and trusted method of investigating complex issues of deep public concern.
"They have shown to be a way to shed light on injustices of the past, provide a means for victims and survivors to finally have their voices heard, and to help rebuild trust in national institutions."
But cabinet minister Nick Thomas-Symonds acknowledged "there is serious and growing criticism of their cost, duration, and effectiveness."
The government claims that, in the financial year 2023/24, the cost to the public of ongoing inquiries totalled more than £130 million.
Statutory inquiries that produced their final report in the last five years took, on average, nearly five years to do so.
How many public inquiries are there?
With the announcement of the public inquiry into the Battle of Ogreave, the UK now has 23 ongoing statutory inquiries, including the Infected Blood Inquiry.
According to the Institute for Government (IfG), since 1997, there have never been fewer than five public inquiries running at any one time.
Three of the 23 - the Orgreave Inquiry, the Independent Commission on Grooming Gangs and the Finucane Inquiry - have been announced, but are yet to begin.
The IfG claims that between 1990 and 2025, 90 public inquiries have been launched – compared with only 19 in the 30 years prior.
Whilst public inquiries vary greatly in length, the shortest ever recorded was less than a year.
The Hammond Inquiry ran from September 2006 to June 2007, investigating allegations of corruption by Peter Mandelson over the handling of two foreign brothers' UK passport applications.
Currently, the longest recorded inquiry was into Hyponatraemia-related deaths, which took over 13 years to complete.
Could things change?
In 2014, the House of Lords reviewed the public inquiry process and made 33 recommendations to reform it.
The coalition Conservative and Liberal-Democrat government at the time accepted 19 of these, but failed to implement a single one.
Reporting again in 2024, the Lords' Statutory Inquiry Committee reiterated many of these recommendations but disagreed with the 2014 suggestion that all new inquiries should be established as statutory.
It concluded there were several benefits to non-statutory inquiries, particularly the ability for victims to address the chair directly, rather than through legal counsel as required by statute.
The current government has accepted the latest report's findings and agreed that the inquiry process needs to be improved.
It confirmed its intention is 'to build on this important work with a wider review of the policy and operational framework around public inquiries,' promising a further update to parliament in due course.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
05-08-2025
- The National
Labour's 'cruel' asylum returns deal with France comes into force
The treaty was published by the Home Office on Monday morning and it sets out how migrants will be detained on arrival in England to be sent back to France. In return, France will send over asylum seekers to the UK, if they pass security and eligibility checks, including having documentation. The trial will run until June 2026 and only some people arriving in small boats on the southern coast of England will be at risk of being returned. It has led to accusations that Labour are 'just as unprincipled and impractical' as the Tories before them, while concerns have also been raised about the effect of detaining people who have already fled wars and torture. Steve Valdez-Symonds, Amnesty International UK's refugee and migrants' rights director, said: 'When it comes to asylum policy, this Government is proving to be just as unprincipled and impractical as its predecessor.' (Image: Supplied) He argued that rather than 'smashing the gangs', as Labour have pledged, the policy only further entrenches the role of people-smugglers in the asylum system. 'A returns deal with France that makes access to safety in the UK – even for those with close family or connections here – dependent on someone else risking their life to cross the Channel only cements the role of smugglers in how people fleeing war and persecution must seek asylum in the UK,' said Valdez-Symonds. 'Once again, refugees are treated like parcels, not people, while the public is left to pay the price for, yet another cruel, costly failure dressed up as policy. READ MORE: Lindsay Hoyle blocks release of emails he sent to Israeli politicians 'The UK shares the same duty as other countries to provide asylum. But instead of facing that responsibility, this Government continues to swap one unworkable gimmick for another – aligning itself with the smugglers and the chaos they exploit. 'If the aim is to truly reduce dangerous journeys and the profits of organised criminal gangs, the answer is clear: we need safe accessible routes between countries not miserable deals that trade in human lives.' Natasha Tsangarides, associate director of advocacy at Freedom from Torture, said the policy relied 'on the mass detention of survivors of torture and persecution'. She added: 'We know from our therapy rooms how profoundly harmful any time in detention is for people who've been through the unimaginable horrors of torture. 'Many survivors were tortured in detention, so locking them up again reopens deep psychological scars and can set them back significantly on their road to recovery. A more secure world for everyone depends on international cooperation not only to ensure safety for survivors but also to stop repression.' In a statement, Prime Minister Keir Starmer said the deal was the result of 'months of grown-up diplomacy delivering real results for British people as we broker deals no government has been able to achieve and strike at the heart of these vile gangs' business model'. He added: 'This government has been fixing the foundations of the broken asylum system we inherited and today we send a clear message – if you come here illegally on a small boat you will face being sent back to France.' Not all those who arrive in the UK by small boat will be sent back to France, however. It is estimated that around 50 arrivals per week will be returned, which is around one in 17 of all people who make the crossing at the current rate, according to Politico.
Daily Mirror
01-08-2025
- Daily Mirror
NICK THOMAS-SYMONDS: 'We can't allow the historic fires powering our steel industry to go out'
EU Relations Minister Nick Thomas-Symonds said a deal with the EU 'will save the UK steel industry millions' by smoothing Brexit barriers and making it easier to export goods Few jobs are harder than working in a steel mill. But the physical, intense work builds resilience and pride in our historic steelworker communities. My Dad worked in Llanwern Steelworks when I was growing up in South Wales. I remember feeling a sense of awe when I went there as a child and understood what he did every working day. Growing up, I felt the pride he took in his work. The UK has a proud history of steelmaking. But its future hasn't always been clear. International over-production of steel and a spike in energy costs have created a difficult trading situation for British companies. Prices for steel have dropped just as the costs of making it have gone up. And the industry has been threatened by tariffs too. But thanks to the new relationship this government has built with the EU, tariff-free access to their market for our construction-grade steel to traditional trade levels has been restored. This will save the UK steel industry millions. We cannot allow the historic fires that power our steel industry to go out. It is a 37,000- worker strong sector, supporting thousands of families in towns across the UK. And we have made a choice to put communities across the UK first. You can see it with our Industrial Strategy and in our international negotiations. 'International negotiations' can sound distant. Something done far away that isn't always easy to explain. It can be hard to work out the tangible impacts on people's lives. But this shows it; they can save industries millions. They protect jobs. As Minister for EU Relations, I want to strike a new relationship with our largest trading partner, one built around trust and cooperation. To get rid of the approach that the Tories and Nigel Farage want to take - adversarial, fuelled by suspicion and ideology. It led to a weaker trading relationship. It risked British industry at home. They still want to reverse the deal. Putting their parties over the interest of the country. There's no denying the strength of British steel, forged over generations in Scunthorpe, the mills near my constituency in Port Talbot and many other towns and cities. Through our new pragmatic working relationship with the EU, we have provided a vital boost to this critical UK industry.
The Herald Scotland
31-07-2025
- The Herald Scotland
We should learn a lesson from America's can-do attitude
But rather than looking at the alleged injustices of one high-profile incident, as the Orgreave Inquiry will do, it is surely just as important to explore the wider social and economic injustices inflicted by the decline of mining and other traditional industries. The most recent State of the Coalfields report from Sheffield University, which explores the condition of former mining communities across the UK, concludes that in Scotland these areas 'still display acute social and economic disadvantage'. It is something which Westminster's Scottish Affairs Committee has also touched on in its inquiry into industrial transition across Scotland. Read More: All of which underlines the necessity of sustainable reindustrialisation, the kind which rather than delivering here today-gone tomorrow employment, instead brings good jobs, skilled work and properly rewarding pay. These things should not be too much to expect. But for those who have fallen through the cracks in society in the years since the decline of older heavy industry, it has often felt that way. Now, with Scotland and the rest of the UK well placed to drive forward the industries of the future, a new era of opportunity is before us. That is why I'm delighted that we are on the verge of securing no fewer than 1,200 jobs for Ayrshire, in a development that promises to lock in growth, opportunity and community wealth for the long term. The UK-based undersea cable manufacturer XLCC is poised to deliver 900 manufacturing-related jobs at Hunterston, making the area a key hub for European and global development of technology which will help power the next generation of renewable energy projects at home and abroad. With global demand for high voltage direct current (HVDC) subsea cables rapidly outpacing supply, the company aims to build the world's biggest and most advanced HVDC manufacturing facility here in Scotland. It is hard to overstate the importance and significance of this project. For years we have been told that Scotland, with its huge green energy potential, is on the verge of a new industrial revolution which can provide the jobs and energy security we so badly need. Too often however, it has felt like we have been waiting and waiting for that long-heralded promise to become a reality. That is why the XLCC project is so vital, and so exciting. In addition to the jobs at Hunterston, 300 additional jobs are expected to be created in Kilmarnock , with the multi-award winning HALO enterprise and low carbon innovation centre identified as the preferred location. I have developed HALO over many years in the 28-acre site of the former Johnnie Walker bottling plant in the town. These posts, including project delivery and sales teams, will drive and support the manufacturing facility at Hunterston. The XLCC development has been in the pipeline since 2020, and like HALO will only be delivered through partnership between the private sector, unions, local authorities and both the Scottish and UK Governments, all working at pace to ensure this massive opportunity is secured. There are two other points worth making in relation to this promised jobs windfall for Ayrshire. Firstly, I would urge both the Scottish and UK Governments to do more to speed up the pace of investment in regeneration and reindustrialisation, including the easing of planning laws to make such development easier. Checks and balances, along with due process, are important when it comes to planning. But too often we are forced to wait too long to turn potential into reality. And delays are one reason we see valuable jobs going to other countries instead of being created here. That links directly to the second point, which is just how important it is for the manufacturing bases for the industries that will power the rest of this century to be based in this country. Scotland may have an abundance of natural resources when it comes to our energy potential. We are blessed with huge advantages when to green power, in addition to the oil and gas which is still an important part of our energy mix. But that only counts for so much if the infrastructure and industrial gain required to exploit those resources is outsourced to other nations. The arrival of XLCC in Scotland will be a powerful counter to the notion that we have to look elsewhere for energy manufacturing. And, as Scotland and [[Ayr]]shire witnessed during the visit of US President Donald Trump, we could do worse than take a leaf from the playbook of America's can-do attitude to business, enterprise and opportunity. We have the resources, and we have the skill – we just need the political will to ensure potential becomes reality. Dr Marie Macklin CBE is a leading Scottish businesswoman and investor.
