Medical records of Duval County Jail inmate who later died show inconsistencies with JSO report
It's been one month since Charles Faggart was taken from the jail to the hospital, where he died from his injuries days later.
The incident that happened before Faggart's death led to nine Jacksonville Sheriff's Office employees being removed from their positions and being stripped of their corrections authority.
Faggart's medical records were first obtained and reported by The Tributary, which shared the records with Action News Jax.
The Tributary is a local 'nonprofit newsroom producing high-impact government accountability and investigative journalism in the public interest,' its website states.
RELATED: Inmate who died after an incident inside the Duval Co. Jail laid to rest
The records paint a more graphic picture than what JSO unveiled when it released a redacted incident report.
According to the medical records, on April 7, Faggart was suffering from cardiac arrest when emergency medical services (EMS) first arrived on the scene at the Duval County Jail.
EMS immediately began administering CPR and intubated him.
RELATED: Report reveals incident that preceded Duval inmate Charles Faggart's death stretched over 2 hours
Faggart was transported to the hospital. When he arrived, the report then states Faggart had taser barbs removed from his back, something that was not listed in JSO's redacted report.
The records also state that Faggart did not suffer a seizure and did not have fentanyl in his system. The JSO report said officers witnessed Faggart suffer a seizure and it also says he told them he had taken fentanyl.
The medical records also state Faggart had nasal bone fractures, facial fractures, rib fractures, bruising, acute kidney and liver injuries, and he was 'unresponsive.'
RELATED: Sources tell Action News Jax what happened in Duval County Jail prior to inmate's death
We reached out to JSO on Wednesday for an interview to comment on these findings. The agency declined but did release the following statement:
'The Jacksonville Sheriff's Office understands that certain members of the public would like information about the facts gathered in the investigation into Mr. Charles Faggart's death immediately. JSO has not and will not release details of the gathered evidence nor protected medical records. Releasing information about evidence in this case before the criminal investigation is completed would be contrary to the law and the agency's duty to protect the integrity of the criminal investigation. Likewise, JSO will not comment in any way on what is being purported as evidence, as doing so would hinder the criminal investigation's integrity.
'Sheriff Waters has repeatedly stated that when the criminal investigation is completed, he will share that information with, first, the Faggart family, and then, the public. Thorough death investigations take time and multi-agency coordination. The SAO continues its independent criminal investigation. Likewise, the FBI continues to provide support. JSO's primary responsibility is to complete a comprehensive investigation and provide the Faggart family with the answers concerning their loved one's passing.'
Chris Carson is a criminal defense attorney with many years of experience. He said the type of injuries Faggart sustained, according to the report, and the setting he was in when it happened, suggest they were blunt force trauma injuries.
[DOWNLOAD: Free Action News Jax app for alerts as news breaks]
'It is suggestive that there was some type of serious potential confrontation that resulted in likely punches, kicks or some other use of force,' Carson said.
We asked Carson what, after reading the injuries in the report, he could tell about what could come from JSO's investigation.
'It means that they're going to have to take a hard look at if the force was indeed utilized by an employee of the sheriff's office, there is going to be, and there needs to be an extensive review of whether that force was legitimate force or whether that force went beyond what would be permissible,' Carson said.
[SIGN UP: Action News Jax Daily Headlines Newsletter]
We asked Carson if he saw inconsistencies between JSO's redacted report from what the medical report states.
'It's kind of hard to say from the reports, but I suspect a lot of that will be forthcoming as this all goes forward,' Carson said.
We reached out to the Faggart family attorney for a statement on Wednesday. As of the publication of this article, they have not gotten back to us.
Click here to download the free Action News Jax news and weather apps, click here to download the Action News Jax Now app for your smart TV and click here to stream Action News Jax live.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Democratic Texas lawmaker spent night on state House floor after refusing GOP demand for law enforcement escort
Democratic Texas state Rep. Nicole Collier spent the night on the Texas House floor in protest after refusing a Republican demand to be placed under the watch of the state Department of Public Safety. When Texas House Democrats returned to the Capitol in Austin on Monday, after having fled the state earlier this month in order to prevent a vote on a controversial Republican redistricting plan, House Speaker Dustin Burrows put constraints on their movements. Burrows announced that the Democrats could only leave the House floor if they received written permission and agreed to be under law enforcement escort until the chamber reconvenes on Wednesday morning. The Democrats who skipped out on previous attempts to meet quorum for a special session to approve the redrawn congressional maps will have an around-the-clock DPS escort to ensure their presence when the House convenes Wednesday, a legislative aide told CNN. Democrats had fled to blue states — including Illinois, New York and Massachusetts — as they faced civil arrest warrants pushed by GOP officials in Texas to force them back into the House chamber. The majority of the Democrats complied with the law enforcement escort, showing reporters what they called 'permission slips' they received to leave the House floor and pointing to the officers escorting them around the Capitol. But Collier refused to enter into that agreement and has been confined to the House floor since returning. She can only leave the floor to return to her office under the watch of a law enforcement officer, an aide said, and cannot leave the state Capitol unless she agrees to outside supervision. State Reps. Gene Wu and Vince Perez plan to stay on the House floor with her overnight, the aide said. Wu posted a photo on X detailing some of their snacks for the long stretch ahead - dried peaches, freeze dried grapes, popcorn and ramen. 'My constituents sent me to Austin to protect their voices and rights,' said Collier. 'I refuse to sign away my dignity as a duly elected representative just so Republicans can control my movements and monitor me with police escorts. My community is majority-minority, and they expect me to stand up for their representation. When I press that button to vote, I know these maps will harm my constituents — I won't just go along quietly with their intimidation or their discrimination.' Texas Democrat Beto O'Rourke celebrated Collier's protest on Monday, writing on social media, 'A true hero, refusing to submit, fighting these fascists by herself if she has to. We are with you Nicole!' The Texas House established a quorum Monday afternoon, for the first time since most members of the Democratic minority fled the state 15 days earlier to prevent it from having the two-thirds quorum necessary to advance new congressional maps aimed at creating five more Republican-leaning seats ahead of next year's midterm elections. Early in their boycott, Burrows had signed civil arrest warrants for those Democrats. But DPS officers could not carry out those warrants because the Democrats were out of state. At President Donald Trump's urging, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott and Republicans who control the state House and Senate launched the effort to redraw the state's congressional districts mid-decade — a break from most states' typical practice of redistricting once a decade, after the completion of the US Census. It's part of the party's effort to hold onto its narrow House majority in next year's midterm elections — one that also includes lobbying GOP officials in Indiana and Missouri to change their maps to turn Democratic-held seats into favorable ground for Republicans, and could see the party add more GOP-leaning seats in Ohio, which is required by state law to redistrict. The Texas effort has set off a nationwide gerrymandering arms race. In California, Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom has vowed retribution, proposing a measure that would trigger new maps that could help Democrats pick up five more seats in the state — but only if Texas moves forward with its redistricting plan. This story and headline have been updated with additional details.
CBS News
25 minutes ago
- CBS News
Wyoming airman accused of manslaughter weeks after another airman at base arrested in separate shooting death
A second airman in a month at a U.S. Air Force base in Wyoming stands accused of involuntary manslaughter for a shooting death. F.E. Warren Air Force Base Airman First Class Jadan Orr, 20, remained jailed on Monday after he allegedly shot a man in a Cheyenne apartment early Saturday, according to police and sheriff's officials. Orr and several friends had been drinking at the apartment for most of the night when Orr and two others went into another room and Orr began handling an AK-47 rifle, according to a Cheyenne Police Department statement. "While manipulating the firearm, Orr charged it and fired it through the wall into the living room, striking the victim in the torso," police said Police arrived to find several people outside trying to help the 23-year-old man, who died at the scene, the statement added. Orr was charged with involuntary manslaughter, according to Laramie County Circuit Court. He did not have an attorney on file to comment on his behalf. "Our thoughts are with the family, friends, and teammates affected by this tragic loss," Col. Terry Holmes, commander of the 90th Missile Wing, said in a statement. "We are fully supporting the investigation and remain committed to taking care of our Airmen and their families during this extremely difficult time." Neither Cheyenne police nor the Laramie County coroner had publicly identified the victim as of Monday. Police referred questions about the victim's identity to coroner Rebecca Reid, who did not immediately return a phone message. Officials at the base just outside Cheyenne announced on Aug. 12 that an airman had been arrested on suspicion of involuntary manslaughter, obstructing justice and making a false statement in connection with the July 20 shooting death of another airman. The victim was identified as Brayden Lovan, 21, of the 90th Security Forces Squadron, 90th Missile Wing. "The incident involved a firearm discharge" that is currently being investigated by multiple Air Force agencies, the base said in a statement last month. "At this time, no determination has been made regarding the nature of the discharge." The shooting led the U.S. Air Force Global Strike Command to suspend use of Sig Sauer's M18 handgun. The weapon has been the subject of lawsuits in which plaintiffs allege the gun is susceptible to firing without the trigger being pulled. Other military branches have continued to use the gun. Unlike in the latest case, the airman stood accused in military, as opposed to civilian, court. The Air Force had not yet released the identity of the accused airman and other details of the earlier shooting, saying Monday it was still under investigation.
CBS News
26 minutes ago
- CBS News
San Bernardino protesters denounce immigration operation after shots were fired at family's car
A group of protesters gathered in San Bernardino on Monday to denounce the federal immigration enforcement operation that included shots being fired at a family's vehicle over the weekend. It happened at around 8:40 a.m. on Saturday, when U.S. Customs and Border Protection agents pulled a car over during what they called a "targeted immigration enforcement operation." They say that the man behind the wheel, an undocumented immigrant, drove his vehicle at the agents and struck two of them before driving away from the area. In response, at least one of the agents opened fire on the car, which had three passengers. No one was struck by gunfire. In a statement, the Department of Homeland Security says that the CBP officer was forced to discharge his firearm in self-defense. Video from the backseat of the vehicle, taken by the driver's son-in-law, Martin, shows the masked agents shattering the driver's side and passenger side windows moments before the car speeds off. He claims that the video is proof that the agents were never in harm's way and that his father-in-law fled because he feared for his life. He says that the agents refused to identify themselves, present a warrant or explain why they had pulled them over at any point during the interaction. "I was thinking the bullets were gonna run through the back window and hit any one of us," Martin said on Saturday while speaking with CBS News Los Angeles. A short time later, agents arrived outside of the family's home, where they waited for several hours before leaving without making any arrests, the family told CBS News Los Angeles. They said that they refused to allow the agents in, as they were never presented with a warrant or reason for their presence. They have not provided the man's identity out of concern for their safety. Demonstrators said that Saturday's series of events was another in an unnecessary escalation of violence during immigration operations in Southern California. "We know what it looks like when someone is coming in and using violence against our communities under the blanket of keeping the community safe," said Mary Valdemar, one of the protesters. "I think that speaks volumes on the integrity of this federal department," said Luv Kaur, another demonstrator. The protesters were gathered outside of the San Bernardino Police Department, denouncing what they believed was police collaboration with the federal agents after officers were called to the family's home for assistance with a growing crowd. Police said that, though they're unable to assist with immigration operations under the California Values Act, there was a risk to the safety of the public as a crowd of people began to form outside of the home. "In this case, federal agents requested assistance during a lawful arrest for assaulting a federal officer when a crowd created a potential officer safety concern," police said on Saturday. "This was not an immigration-related arrest, which would be prohibited under California law." The DHS statement says that San Bernardino police briefly took the driver into custody on Saturday but released him shortly afterwards. "This decision was made despite the subject refusing to comply and wounding two officers — another terrible example of California's pro-sanctuary policies in action that shield criminals instead of protecting communities," DHS said in its statement. San Bernardino Mayor Helen Tran took to social media on Monday to address the weekend's events. She called the account of what happened by DHS "unverified and deeply troubling." "Here in San Bernardino, we stand firm. Justice must be transparent; trust must be earned—not forced. We call for a full and impartial investigation, the release of all available footage and accountability if procedures were violated," said a social media post from Tran. "We deserve answers, protection and peace of mind."
