SFA hit back at Rangers statement as John Brown TV row takes fresh twist
The SFA have accused Rangers of issuing 'misleading comments' after the Ibrox club criticised the punishment they received for a remark made by former player John Brown on club media channels.
Rangers were fined £3,000 following a disciplinary hearing after being charged with breaching rule 38, which states clubs should not allow any criticism of match officials 'calculated to indicate bias or incompetence' or to 'impinge upon his character'.
While working as a pundit on Rangers TV, Brown claimed a decision not to award Rangers a goal at Easter Road on the final weekend of the league season was 'corrupt' amid a debate over whether the ball had crossed the line.
This week Rangers claimed they had 'flagged numerous examples of similar incidents on club channels' during the hearing and questioned a 'lack of consistency' in the SFA's approach.
In response, the governing body pointed out that Motherwell development coach Richard Foster was handed a six-match touchline ban for a similar breach last September after branding the SFA's explanation for a contentiously-awarded Rangers goal against St Johnstone as 'lies' while working as a pundit for the BBC.
They also claimed that investigations were undertaken in other cases outlined by Rangers but the potential breaches were not considered serious enough to merit more than warnings.
An SFA statement read: 'We note Rangers' response to the determination of a recent independent Judicial Panel Tribunal. In the interests of accuracy, we wish to address some of the misleading comments contained therein.
'The sanction imposed by an independent panel was entirely in keeping with the application of the rules. The most recent and relevant example of a similar breach, the sanction imposed on Richard Foster of Motherwell FC for comments of a similar nature in the media, attests to that.
'Furthermore, to address the comments regarding 'rationale behind differing outcomes', we wish to point to the fact that investigations were undertaken in previous cases outlined and that the compliance officers of the time saw fit to issue a censure by way of warning letter for potential breaches deemed insufficiently serious to be progressed to a notice of complaint.
'This system of proportionality has been adopted since the inception of the Judicial Panel Protocol in 2011. Indeed, such discretion was exercised last season when the compliance officer wrote to (Rangers) to warn of the future conduct of players following matters involving Vaclav Cerny, Dujon Sterling and Mohamed Diomande.
'We also note that Rangers intend to contact the association to seek clarity on the Judicial Panel Protocol and its application. The club is, in fact, already represented on the JPP Working Group.
'We have requested written reasons from the panel chair involved in the tribunal and in the interests of transparency will publish in due course.
'JPP Rule 38 was introduced in response to the referee strike of 2010, when match officials campaigned for greater protection after enduring sustained personal criticism from clubs and fans. Ahead of a new season, we remind clubs of their responsibilities in this regard.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
41 minutes ago
- BBC News
The town centre that turns into a 100mph racetrack
For one night each year, the normally quiet main street of Dunoon is transformed into a seaside town's Argyll Street and surrounding roads are closed, and rally drivers from across the UK take their turn racing around them reaching speeds of up to Argyll Rally is currently Scotland's only motor sporting event that sees racing take part on a town centre event returns this weekend for its fifth year and this time the start list features five local teams who have been inspired to take up the sport due to the local event. On a normal day, if 37-year-old Matt Youden saw a car speeding through Dunoon, he'd be forced to take action as a local police this weekend it is his turn to told BBC Scotland News: "When you're in a rally car, strapped in with your helmet on, it's a totally different feeling to driving about in my normal 4x4 car."It certainly is a wee bit different to going for your morning rolls."Matt grew up around rally driving as his dad used to race, but it wasn't until he was stationed in Dunoon he decided to take up the hobby for action takes place over two days. As well as the Dunoon town centre stage, drivers race on routes in some of the Cowal peninsula's most scenic locations including routes in Glendaruel and said he doesn't pay much attention to the speedometer during a race, but he expects to reach speeds of up to if the adrenaline is comparable to a high-speed police chase, Matt replied: "No, because there's usually a lot of paperwork at the end of that." The town's veteran racer is David Robertson, 53, who is competing for the third and raised in Dunoon, he took up rally driving as a result of watching the event and said racing in his home town was special."I wouldn't be doing this if it wasn't for the Argyll Rally coming to the town," David told BBC Scotland News."You know, the feeling of everybody cheering you when you come round that first corner. It's just special, it brings a tear to your eye."The rules state local drivers aren't supposed to try out the routes prior to a pre-arranged recce before the event - to make sure they aren't given an unfair David, a local courier, spends every day driving on Dunoon's roads, so he feels like he knows the roads like the back of his said this is a bonus, but driving in his van is completely different to his Ford Fiesta rally car."Every time I come up Argyll Street street, I'm analysing the road, thinking about what's the quickest line," he said."When I'm working, I'll spot a pothole and think, I'll need to watch out for that on rally night."He is piloted by his wife Jen, who gives him instructions throughout the race. As well as locals, over 100 of the country's fastest drivers head to the region for the draws hundreds of spectators but some locals aren't in favour of the event saying it is unsafe and road closures are say that strict safety protocols are implemented to ensure the safety of drivers and spectators, and the event is good for the local Moulson from Dunoon Presents told BBC Scotland News the event was worth around £500,000 to the local area through visitor spend, and it has a "tangible community feel" to it.
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Rangers set to offer star man bumper new deal as Russell Martin plans to build team around fan favourite
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) RANGERS are preparing contract talks with top asset Nico Raskin. New Ibrox boss Russell Martin wants to build his team around the Belgian midfield dynamo. Sign up for the Rangers newsletter Sign up 3 Nico Raskin is set to be handed fresh terms at Ibrox Credit: Willie Vass 3 Russell Martin has high hopes for the midfielder Credit: Willie Vass 3 He's attracting interest from clubs across Europe Credit: Willie Vass Raskin is approaching the final two years of his current deal — and a growing number of clubs are looking at him. The Belgium international cost £1.75million when arriving from Standard Liege in January 2023 and his value is soaring. Both sporting director Kevin Thelwell and the club's new US owners are determined to construct a far better transfer model. And they recognise there's a need to protect the club's interests while rewarding Raskin with increased terms. SunSport understands Thelwell is keen to tie down the 24-year-old for longer — and ensure any club coming in with bids know they'll have to be serious with their offers. Discussions have yet to kick off, but they are on the agenda. There is a belief the player is happy at Gers and open to agreeing an extended stay. News on Raskin came as Martin completed his first signing with a season-long deal for Bournemouth's Max Aarons. The clubs reached agreement last night for the 25-year-old defender but it's been reported there ISN'T a clause allowing for a permanent move. Aarons managed only four appearances for the Cherries last season before going on loan in January to La Liga outfit Valencia where he played five games. Rangers star Nicolas Raskin spotted at Disney World - before Wag turns trainer by putting him through his paces SunSport revealed Martin's interest in the full-back, a former England under-21 ace, at the start of the week. Now it's believed he's homing in on the signing of Peterborough United attacker Kwame Poku, 23, who is out of contract but will cost a cross-border fee in the region of £350,000. Having the ambitious Raskin put pen to paper would be welcomed by the supporters and viewed as a statement of intent equal to a new signing. Originally signed by Michael Beale, the tenacious Raskin was one of few stand-out performers in a trophyless 2024-25. He captained Gers to a remarkable 3-0 victory over bitter rivals Celtic in January. He then brilliantly opened the scoring in a 3-2 win over the champions at Parkhead in March. Even more impressively, Raskin is now beginning to establish himself as a key part of Belgium boss Rudi Garcia's plans. In World Cup qualifying earlier this month, Raskin shone in a 1-1 away draw against North Macedonia before proving a super sub in a thrilling 4-3 victory over Wales. Keep up to date with ALL the latest news and transfers at the Scottish Sun football page
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
'Rangers fans can be assured that Russell is a guy who leaves no stone unturned': Charlie Mulgrew hails thorough approach of his former Scotland team-mate
The searing heat in the Balearics contrasted with the lukewarm reception for the breaking news back in Scotland. For all we know, Russell Martin's imminent appointment as manager might well have satisfied a silent majority of Rangers supporters. However, most of those who preferred to air their strident views in public weren't willing to give the former Southampton boss the benefit of the doubt. Two weeks after his unveiling, the 39-year-old's reputation as a thoughtful and progressive football coach evidently still hasn't cut the ice with all the light blue legions. Those who would rather have seen a more exotic or experienced name given the nod appear disinclined to look beyond Saints' disastrous return to the Premier League under Martin's stewardship last season. The brand of possession-based football he plays has been used as a stick to beat him with. Rangers CEO Patrick Stewart is confident Martin can help steady the ship and win trophies From the other side of the Old Firm divide, Charlie Mulgrew might seem like an unlikely source of support for the new man at Ibrox. But the testimony of a former Scotland team-mate is compelling. 'I actually met him in Palma the day before he took the job,' said the former Celtic defender. I'm sitting in a coffee shop and he came walking in. He was flying back to take the job. 'Having met the guy and spent time with him, I know he leaves no stone unturned. He's absolutely brilliant at his job. 'I know he sticks to his style and how he sees the game. I've always been impressed by that. 'He tried to sign me when he was at MK Dons as well, so I got an insight into how he wants to play. 'He was thorough. As a player that he was looking to sign, he sent me a profile on how he saw me playing — a PowerPoint presentation of what he saw and what I could bring to his team. 'It was so impressive. I'd never been sent that before. Knowing him, I think he's a great appointment for Rangers.' Before he's so much as taken charge of a single training session, Martin stands accused — by some — of advocating a style of football which is too easily countered. Mulgrew believes that's a gross misrepresentation of the reality. 'No matter what happens, Celtic and Rangers need to be possession- based, because that's what the fans demand,' he said. 'They can't be at home at Ibrox and let Motherwell have 60-per- cent possession. The place would be booing. 'They're going to have possession. If you've got possession, you've got more chance of scoring a goal. The tricky bit for Celtic and Rangers has always been the final third. You need to have killers in that final third. I'm sure he'll know that.' Martin will also appreciate that certain fans will view him with scepticism purely on the basis that he's Russell Martin. A decent defender who rang every last drop out of his professional career is always going to be a hard sell to those more concerned with style than substance. 'Listen, I'm not surprised because I know the mentality up here at Celtic and Rangers,' said Mulgrew. 'There's a high standard and expectation in the names that were mentioned for the Rangers job. 'Jose Mourinho was mentioned at one stage and Carlo Ancelotti's boy [Davide], who has coached at Real Madrid and has quite a high stock as well. 'When you've not looked too much into Russell Martin, on the surface it can maybe disappoint people. But having been down to see him, having spent time with him, having played with him, I don't see it like that.' Martin's impending joust with former Norwich team-mate and now Motherwell manager Jens Berthel Askou makes for an intriguing opening day of the new Premiership season. Hearts are also under new management in Derek McInnes. On the opening Monday, they face an Aberdeen side still basking in Scottish Cup glory. Champions Celtic, who host St Mirren the previous day, will start as strong favourites to retain their crown. There remains an air of invincibility, however, with the four league defeats suffered by Brendan Rodgers' side last season all coming after the turn of the year. With the benefit of hindsight, perhaps losing the cup final to Aberdeen at Hampden wasn't quite such a seismic shock. While his former club still enjoyed a successful season by claiming the League Cup on top of the Premiership crown, Mulgrew feels that one major disappointment will have festered. 'I don't think anybody gave Aberdeen a prayer in the game,' he said. 'It just shows you, though, what can happen if you don't turn up and show the right attitude. First and foremost, you need to show up and compete. 'I'm sure that'll keep them on their toes this year. Brendan Rodgers, being the competitive winner that he is, will be fuming with the fact he never won the Treble, having come so close. It was Rodgers' first final he'd been beaten in. So, every team needs that wee edge.' With Jota sidelined for the foreseeable future and the void left by Kyogo Furuhashi still to be filled, Rodgers needs to get new faces in the door. Mulgrew contends that the much-anticipated return of Kieran Tierney is pretty much the perfect starting point. 'It's brilliant,' he said. 'He's somebody who's probably coming into their prime in a few years. Celtic are lucky to have him back. He's a brilliant, brilliant player. There are maybe question marks over injuries, but I'm sure they'll manage him well in that way.' Tierney's been away from the madhouse for six years, but the changes in Scotland's top tier in the past six weeks have been bewildering enough. There are two new additions to the top flight in Falkirk and Livingston and new faces at the helm at Rangers, Motherwell, Hearts, Dundee and Kilmarnock. Barring something extra-ordinary, the title will be a two-horse race as usual, although Mulgrew senses it might not quite be the canter most are expecting. 'It's going to be interesting to see how Rangers go this year,' he said. 'Celtic have been dominating for so long. Now Rangers have a new manager, Celtic will obviously have a bit of a wariness about what that's going to bring. 'Celtic need that challenge. They're going to be wary of that. So, it's interesting and exciting.' Charlie Mulgrew appeared courtesy of William Hill and the Warm-Up, SPFL Title Sponsor.
