'Ferry problems on Barra meant my child could not travel'
A mother-of-four says she was forced to travel without all of her children on an island ferry because of reduced passenger numbers. Carol-Anne Galbraith, 33, from Barra, needed to get her son Kieran, five, from the Hebridean island to a hospital appointment in Glasgow.Barra's usual ferry, which carries 600 people, has been replaced with a vessel that is running under a restricted capacity of 45 people.Her eight-year-old son, Christopher, instead made the journey by plane with his grandmother - which the family said brought additional expense.
Single mum Carol-Anne wanted to take all her children on the trip during the Easter holidays because of limited childcare options on the island.Ferry operator CalMac said an alternative route had been offered to allow all the children - who were not originally booked - to make the trip to the mainland.But Carol-Anne said this would have involved a 350-mile journey by car, two ferries and taken at least 12 hours.
Barra's usual 600-passenger ferry, MV Isle of Lewis, has been out of action for two months due to an engine fault.The replacement ferry, MV Isle of Mull, can carry 962 people.But this has been reduced to a just 45 passengers due to a broken emergency escape system.The route connecting Castlebay, Barra, with Oban on the Argyll coast is the longest in CalMac's west coast network.
Kieran has eczema and requires monthly visits to a hospital consultant in Glasgow. Carole-Anne said that being unable to rely on the ferry service was "stressful and upsetting".She said: "Originally it was me and Kieran who were booked, but our plans changed so I went to book the other three children."Due to the reduced capacity I couldn't get them on."You feel guilty as a mum because you feel you have failed and not been able to take your children away."With help from local CalMac staff, Ms Galbraith was able to get Daniel, six, and Charlotte, 11, on the ferry while Christopher travelled by plane.
Brian Currie, of Barra Transport Committee - which campaigns for connectivity improvements - accused CalMac of not meeting contractual obligations.He said: "I think over the last two months CalMac has failed to provide lifeline services to the island."Services are paid for but are not being delivered."Residents in the Western Isles have raised concerns about the reliability of services over several years.In 2023, hundreds marched through Glasgow to protest against the disruption of South Uist's ferry service.Islanders said they were left "beyond crisis" after CalMac cut sailings from Lochboisdale to Mallaig on the mainland during June.
'Offered alternatives'
CalMac said it had been in contact with Ms Galbraith about travel arrangementsA spokesperson said: "We were able to get another space for Carole-Anne to go to the hospital appointment and she travelled with three of her four children. "There was no risk of the hospital appointment being missed as we always had mother and child booked on the sailing."All alternatives offered were to allow additional children who had not originally been booked on."Transport Scotland said that under its contract with CalMac it expected essential services to be delivered. A spokesperson said: "We recognise the impact that delays and disruption have regrettably had on our island communities and we are committed to investing in our ferry services. "In the coming year, we will invest over £530m maintaining and enhancing our networks and strengthening resilience of services on the west coast and northern isles."MV Isle of Lewis is due to be back in service in time for the family's return journey.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Press and Journal
18 hours ago
- Press and Journal
Catriona and Richard's incredible home makeover near Aboyne
Who: Catriona Elson and her husband Richard, who have just acquired the Braemar Gallery. They share their home with their dogs Percy and Dolly. Their children Georgie and Robert grew up there but have since flown the nest. What: A traditional four-bedroom period property with a two-bedroom cottage located within the garden grounds. Where: A quiet spot in Birse on the edge of Aboyne just a short walk to the Boat Inn and the village. . 'We purchased the property on a cold, February day 24 years ago. Richard and I were visiting a family home in Aboyne and saw the 'for sale' sign. We fell in love with South Manse straight away as Richard loved the land while for me, the house was somewhere I wanted to bring up my children. For us, we both had a wonderful feeling about the property especially as it was well loved by the previous owner. At the time, we were moving up from the Henley on Thames area. Everyone thought we were completely mad as we bought the house before we had sold our own in Oxfordshire. But I had family in Peterhead and Aberdeen and Richard, who was originally from West Berkshire, loved Scotland and Aberdeenshire so that was it. It was a crazy time but we sold our house in Oxfordshire and made the move to Aberdeenshire. Arriving at the South Manse in early Spring was a joy and my lovely friends Steve and Shar helped move us in. In terms of history, the property was previously owned by a retired vet and before that Miss Wishart who was the last minister's daughter who was apparently quite a character. The house is such a happy place and we have had children playing and laughing in the gardens since they were babies. With all of the land the kids ran around making camps, climbing trees and enjoyed Easter egg hunts in the woods. We also kept lots of animals including hens. They were the best especially one called Rose who came into the kitchen to lay her daily egg. The property also enjoys beautiful views overlooking Morven and down the Dee Valley while the river and village can be seen from the upstairs windows. Set in three acres of land, South Manse is the main house. Inside, there are four bedrooms, three receptions rooms and a kitchen. Built around 1837, the property was a Manse for the Church until the 1980s. In terms of interiors, they have been updated with the help of Leonie Bosher, my friend who is an interior designer. With my love of antiques, art and interior design the South Manse and Coo Hoose were a dream to decorate. We wanted to create a family space which was homely but with formal spaces with high ceilings in the sitting room and dining room. I adore wallpapers so many rooms have fun twists on more traditional styles. Some of my favourite designer wallpaper brands are Cole and Son, Barneby Gates and House of Hackney. In terms of paint, we used Farrow & Ball. Some of the shades we used included 'mizzle' for the front door, 'green smoke' for the hall and 'pigeon' in the kitchen. For the woodwork, we used 'strong white' which has a tiny touch of grey so it's a lovely soft white. In the bedrooms and bathroom we used 'cornforth' and 'skimming stone'. For all the bathrooms and kitchen, we used beautiful handmade tiles from a company called Fired Earth. In the country kitchen we used handmade Bastide French solid oak with complementing black lava polished work surfaces which works well with the cream Aga range cooker. Thirteen years ago, we decided to convert the steading/barn which was in danger of falling down. We transformed it into a two-bedroom annex where friends and family could stay. After a time we started running the property as The Coo Hoose, a very successful self-catering business. It was designed by Andrew Keir, a local architect and friend, who did an outstanding job as he managed to convert the property into a wonderful quiet spot full of light and warmth. Interior designer Leonie Bosher also helped with all the interiors and with the finishing touches. Now it's a wonderful open plan living area for guests to enjoy. Life now takes us to Braemar where we've decided to put down roots. We have also just acquired the Braemar Gallery and with my background in art, antiques, design and retail, that will help enormously. I have huge shoes to fill as the present owners have done an amazing job creating a wonderful business for us to inherit and take forward. As a collaborator, Leonie Bosher will also be bring her unique inspiration to the business. She has worked on many UK and international properties- both residential and hotels – and was a finalist in the prestigious SBID Awards, for her work on The Draycott development in London. So 24 years after moving to South Manse and the Coo Hoose, it's time to hand the house over to the next lucky person who can enjoy taking the house to the next level. Whoever lives here will absolutely love it. It's been a joy to live here as we have lovely neighbours and a garden full of wildlife with plenty of space for children to play. Our children have sadly left the nest and I have just recovered from Breast Cancer so it's time to make a change. We have exciting times ahead.' South Manse and Coo Hoose, Birse, Aboyne, Aberdeenshire, is on the market for offers over £950,000. To arrange a viewing, check out the website And if you enjoyed this story, you may also like: Couple turn Tomatin home into dream house after amazing makeover French couple put their historic Braemar home on the market for £395,000
BBC News
3 days ago
- BBC News
Turkish-built CalMac ferry completes first sea trials
The first CalMac ferry being built by a shipyard in Turkey has completed its initial set of sea Isle of Islay is one of four new ferries being built for Scotland's west coast routes by the Cemre shipyard at Yalova. The contract was awarded in March 2022 with delivery expected last October but after a series of delays it is now likely to enter service later this year. CalMac has extended the charter of the catamaran Alfred for a further five months to provide extra capacity while it awaits the arrival of new vessels. Representatives from CalMac, ferries procurement body CMAL and UK regulators were present as MV Isle of Islay underwent eight days of technical trials off the Turkish coast. CMAL said it now hoped to provide an updated delivery date once a second set of sea trials have been conducted during the summer. Director of vessels Jim Anderson added: "There is a great feeling of momentum following the successful completion of this first phase of sea trials."CMAL has previously said the delays in construction are partly due to the impact of the 2023 Turkish earthquake and global supply chain problems. The new "Islay-class" ferries have conventional diesel engines, used to generate electricity for electric motors, and also large batteries which can provide power when manoeuvring in harbour. They will be the first large vessels in the CalMac fleet fitted with a Voith Schneider propulsion system, which uses vertical spinning blades instead of a traditional propeller and rudder. The next stage of construction will involve installing the batteries and testing how the ships perform in harbour. When will CalMac's ferry shortage ease? CalMac has warned it faces another difficult summer due a shortage of vessels and potential breakdowns of its ageing fleet. MV Glen Sannox, built by the Ferguson shipyard, entered service in January on the Arran route but other large vessels have been out of action, and one vessel, MV Hebridean Isles, was retired in situation should start to ease next week when the old Arran ferry MV Caledonian Isles returns to service after 16 months of 32-year-old ship is expected back from 12 June, providing the first Arran sailings out of Ardrossan since January because Glen Sannox is too large to fit and has to sail from Troon instead. CalMac has also extended the charter for MV Alfred from Pentland Ferries until October at a cost believed to be around a million pounds a month. The catamaran has been on charter now since the spring of 2023, meaning the charter fees are far in excess of the £14m which the vessel cost to build. MV Isle of Mull is currently in dry dock for the fitting of a replacement evacuation chute system after a fault left it restricted to carrying just 45 passengers. While no date for the arrival of the new ferry MV Isle of Islay has been announced, it should be in service later this year, with three similar vessels following on at six monthly intervals. MV Glen Rosa, sister ship of MV Glen Sannox, is still being fitted out at the Ferguson shipyard in Port Glasgow. The two ships are larger and have more complex dual-fuel gas propulsion systems, but Glen Rosa is now expected to be delivered between April and June next year.
Scotsman
4 days ago
- Scotsman
CalMac's newest ferry Isle of Islay completes first sea trials in Turkey - but will be almost a year late
Sign up for the latest news and analysis about Scottish transport Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The first of four CalMac ferries being built in Turkey is expected to carry its first passengers around a year late after the opening stage of sea trials were completed behind schedule in the latest of a series of delays. Isle of Islay, which is earmarked for the main route to the Hebridean island, completed the tests in the Sea of Marmara on May 30, it was announced on Thursday. The vessel should have been ready for sea trials by the start of the month. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Isle of Islay on its sea trials off Turkey late May | Cmal Scottish Government ferry-buying firm Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (Cmal) said a second set of sea trials would not take place until 'later this summer' and the vessel is scheduled to be delivered between July and September. It was originally due to have been finished in October last year, but was delayed to December, then March, then June. Cmal chief executive Kevin Hobbs has said the vessel would take two weeks after completion to reach Scotland, then need three to four weeks of port trials before entering service, which suggests it will not be carrying passengers until at least the autumn. The ferry, along with its sister vessel for the Kintyre-Islay route, Loch Indaal, and two others for the Skye-Harris-North Uist routes, have suffered a series of delays because of parts supply problems caused by the Ukraine war and instability in the Middle East. Shipyard workers were also being deployed for recovery work following a huge earthquake. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Cmal said the sea trials had been carried out 'successfully' by Cemre Marin Endustri yard in Yalova from May 22 to 30, with Cmal and CalMac staff on board. The body said: 'The first part of the sea trials saw the set up of the propulsion systems, generators, thrusters, stabilisers and associated electrical systems. These were then tested, trialled and measured with [certification authority] Lloyd's Register and the Maritime Coastguard Agency [safety regulator] in attendance. 'Testing evaluated the vessel's performance at full load, including speed, stability, manoeuvrability, anchor deployment/recovery and endurance. The trials also established the effectiveness of the vessel's propulsion plant, automation and navigational systems. 'The second set of sea trials will take place later this summer following the installation of the vessel's battery system and harbour acceptance trials of the hybrid system.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Cmal director of vessels Jim Anderson said: 'This is a great step forward in the build programme of the Isle of Islay. The team at Cemre are working hard to prepare the vessel for delivery.
