Paedophile ex-priest to be extradited to Portugal after court ruling
O'Grady – who was featured in an Oscar-nominated documentary – will be jailed for having more than 9,000 images and 29 videos of child sexual abuse.
The 80-year-old, of Rostrevor Court, Macken Street, Dublin 2, was arrested on January 21 on foot of a European Arrest Warrant issued by a court in Faro, Portugal. Former priest and prolific child abuser Oliver O'Grady will be extradited to serve a one-year prison sentence in Portugal, the High Court has ruled. Pic: Collins Courts
The warrant states O'Grady was tried on a charge of possession of 'pornography of minors', convicted and sentenced to one year in prison in his absence by a Portuguese court after he failed to attend his trial on May 7 last year.
In opposing his surrender to Portugal, O'Grady complained his fair trial rights were not adequately protected in the process that led to his conviction. He said he had been unable to contact a lawyer appointed to defend him in Portugal.
He complained his surrender would be incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights and the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms because of a real risk of inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment in the Portuguese prison system. Judge Patrick McGrath at the High Court in Dublin found O'Grady's evidence to be 'disingenuous and self-serving' and said the former priest had tried to control proceedings. Pic: Getty Images
He said he spent time in the Prisional de Setubal in Portugal in October 2019 after he was arrested on foot with a European arrest warrant from Ireland.
He said that while incarcerated there, he was not provided with medication, facilities were unhygienic, and, as a segregated prisoner on remand in respect of sexual offences, he was abused and had apples thrown at him.
Judge Patrick McGrath at the High Court in Dublin found O'Grady's evidence to be 'disingenuous and self-serving' and said O'Grady had tried to control proceedings.
Portuguese authorities, through An Garda Síochána, notified O'Grady of his obligation to attend his trial and the consequences of failure to attend, the judge said.
He knew his inability to contact a lawyer did not excuse him from attendance, Judge McGrath said. O'Grady, from Limerick, has a long history of sexual offences against children.
In 1993 he was first convicted in California of lewd acts against children for repeatedly molesting two brothers.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
4 hours ago
- Sunday World
Widow of man killed in Creeslough explosion sues over fatal blast
James O'Flaherty was 48-years-old when he lost his life in the explosion which occurred at 3.17 pm on October 7th 2022. Emergency services at the scene after an explosion at a service station in Creeslough, Co Donegal Pic:Mark Condren 8.10.2022 Mourners at the funeral mass of Creeslough victim James O'Flaherty at St Mary's Church Derrybeg. Photo by Steve Humphreys12th October 2022. THE WIDOW of a father-of-one killed in the deadly Creeslough explosion has initiated a personal injury case in the High Court. Papers were lodged before the High Court on June 17th by solicitors Damien Tansey on behalf of James O'Flaherty's widow Tracey O'Flaherty naming 11 parties to be summonsed. The parties include Danny and Annette Lafferty, the siblings who owned the petrol station destroyed in the explosion, Applegreen, Vivo/Shell Ltd, the Duntally Wood apartment owners management company, the Commission for the Regulation of Utilities, the Registrar of Gas Installers of Ireland and Donegal Co. Council. Two other named individuals and an architecture company have also been summonsed. Mourners at the funeral mass of Creeslough victim James O'Flaherty at St Mary's Church Derrybeg. Photo by Steve Humphreys12th October 2022. Contacts from the Sunday World with solicitors Damien Tansey Solicitors did not elicit a response this week. The company, which has offices in Dublin and Sligo, is known for its expertise personal injury claims and says it helped clients 'win some of the largest compensation payouts through the Irish courts.' James O'Flaherty News in 90 Seconds - July 26th James O'Flaherty was 48-years-old when he lost his life in the explosion which occurred at 3.17 pm on October 7th 2022. Mr O'Flaherty, was originally from Sydney in Australia, but was living with his wife Tracey and son Hamish in Dunfanaghy, a village about 10 minutes' drive from Creeslough. 12-year-old Hamish was sitting in Volvo in the service station forecourt when the explosion demolished a shop, filling station and a block of apartments. Emergency services at the scene after an explosion at a service station in Creeslough, Co Donegal Pic:Mark Condren 8.10.2022 In total, the explosion caused the deaths ten people and left eight hospitalised. Investigators later identified an accidental gas leak as a possible cause. At Mr. O'Flaherty's funeral mass, tribute was paid to the caring husband and father by Fr Brian O Fearraigh. He said Mr O'Flaherty lived for his wife Tracey and son Hamish. "James showered his loving son and wife in hugs and kisses every day," he said. "James O'Flaherty was a generous and a kind man. He loved chatting to other people and he just wanted to spend all his free time with you - his family. "He had honesty and integrity in abundance. "He was a man who had high morals which I'm told are traits and values that he shared with his late father." Hamish described his father as a "great man", who worked "very hard and very long each day". "He wore a jacket with a huge paint stain on the side of it everywhere. He managed this by leaning on a wall which was still wet with paint," he said. "He wore the jacket everywhere. To the shops, to the movies, to the beach." He urged mourners to "cherish" their families. "Be grateful, for they won't be there forever… Use the time you have wisely," he said. A gardai investigation into the circumstances of the deadly explosion continues. A total of six arrests have taken place but no charges have yet been brought against any individual. Earlier this month, at the July Plenary meeting of Donegal County Council, 100% Redress Councillor Tomas Sean Devine submitted a motion calling on Donegal County Council to purchase the site where the explosion by way of negotiation with the owner or with a Compulsory Purchase Order (CPO). The motion also asked the Council to sit down with the bereaved families and design a memorial garden in memory of all those affected. However, the motion did not pass and councillors will instead hold a workshop about the future of the site.
RTÉ News
21 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Bafta-nominated actor Micheal Ward charged with rape and sexual assault
Bafta-nominated actor Micheal Ward has been charged with rape and sexual assault. The 27-year-old, who has starred in Blue Story and Top Boy, is accused of offences against one woman in January 2023, the Metropolitan Police in London said. The force said he is charged with two counts of rape and three counts of sexual assault. Ward, of Cheshunt, Hertfordshire, will appear at Thames Magistrates' Court on 28 August, the Crown Prosecution Service said. Following the charges, Detective Superintendent Scott Ware said: "Our specialist officers continue to support the woman who has come forward - we know investigations of this nature can have significant impact on those who make reports." The Jamaican-born actor was awarded the Bafta Rising Star honour in 2020 and was nominated for the Best Supporting Actor Bafta for his role in BBC's Small Axe in 2021 and the 2022 film Empire Of Light. Ward, who has 1.2 million followers on Instagram, played in the Soccer Aid match at Stamford Bridge last year and gave a reading at the Christmas Eve carol service hosted by the Princess of Wales in 2023. He is due to star in the American film Eddington alongside Joaquin Phoenix and Pedro Pascal, which is due to be released in the UK next month.
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
Enoch Burke wins court appeal over disciplinary panel bias in dismissal case
Teacher Enoch Burke has won an appeal over the composition of a disciplinary panel set up to hear his appeal against his dismissal from Wilson's Hospital school. Mr Burke claimed a member of the three-person appeals panel, Association of Secondary Teachers in Ireland (ASTI) general secretary Kieran Christie, was a 'promoter of transgenderism'. The appeals panel denied his claim. Ms Justice Mary Faherty, on behalf of the three-judge Court of Appeal, said with "a great deal of reluctance", she would grant an injunction to Mr Burke restraining the appeals panel, as presently constituted, from from holding a hearing. Mr Burke spent more than 500 days in prison for repeatedly disobeying High Court orders not to attend at Wilson's Hospital school in Co Westmeath, where he had been employed as a history and German teacher. When he was dismissed in 2023, he sought an appeal through the normal employment process but then brought a High Court challenge claiming appeals panel member, Mr Christie, was an activist for transgenderism within the ASTI and was personally or objectively biased. In December 2023, the High Court rejected his challenge, saying Mr Burke had not discharged the burden on him of establishing there was a fair question to be tried of a reasonable apprehension of bias. He appealed to the Court of Appeal and the panel opposed his appeal. On Friday, Ms Justice Faherty, for the Court of Appeal, said while accepting Mr Christie does not sit on the appeals panel in his capacity as general secretary of the ASTI, it must nevertheless be the case that Mr Christie's role in the ASTI, which has advised schools to use a transitioning student's preferred choice of pronoun, would be influential to the reasonable independent observer. In those circumstances, she could not agree with the High Court judge that there was not a fair question to be tried in relation to any issue of which it was claimed the ASTI had taken a position. She rejected Mr Burke's suggestion that if his objection to Mr Christie was well-founded, the objection must similarly be well-founded in relation to any other person nominated by the ASTI. The judge said there remained the question as to whether Mr Burke, with his history of contempt of court, "gets to pick and choose how and when he gets to invoke the court's protection and jurisdiction'. Mr Burke, apart from spending more than 500 days in prison over a number of periods, was also the subject of daily €700 and later €1,400 fines for every time he turned up at the school. Recently, the High Court made orders permitting the seizure of money to pay the fines from the bank account into which his school salary continued to be paid pending the Court of Appeal decision. Ms Justice Faherty said she considered his contempt no less egregious now than when he was before the High Court challenging the appeals panel. However, the distinguishing feature of the present case was the spectre of unfairness that will hover over the disciplinary appeal process if he has to face that body as presently constituted given he has made out a case of a reasonable apprehension of objective bias, she said. While it was normal for the loser in a case to pay the winner's costs, the court was "not in normal territory" here. The judge said there would be no costs order in Mr Burke's favour, save an order setting aside the costs order made against him in the High Court.
