New Study: Teacher Working Conditions Worsened After COVID — and Still Are
The University of Missouri research discovered ongoing issues including increased classroom disruptions and declining trust between teachers and parents, principal and colleagues. The researchers analyzed data from the 5Essentials Survey which collected responses about school wellness from roughly 123,000 to 130,000 teachers in more than 3,300 Illinois schools annually from 2019 to 2023.
'I would have thought the 2020-21 school year was the big disrupted year,' said Cory Koedel, a University of Missouri professor who worked on the study. 'It's quite reasonable to think that was the worst. But this data is telling us that's clearly not true. And our findings give no indication that working conditions will rebound naturally now that the pandemic is behind us.'
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
The 5Essentials survey identifies five main indicators of school success: effective leaders, collaborative teachers, involved families, supportive environments and ambitious instruction. Each year, teachers and students are asked to rate their experiences.
The most dramatic change after the pandemic began was in classroom disruptions. A 2023 EdWeek survey found that 70% of educators said students in their schools misbehaved more than before the pandemic. In 2024, the percentage increased to 72%.
Koedel's research found the quality of student discussions and professional development also declined from 2019 to 2023. The trust teachers felt toward parents, principals and other educators didn't worsen from 2019 to 2021 but deteriorated from 2021 to 2023. Teacher safety significantly improved in 2021, when most schools shifted to online learning, only to drop again in 2022 and 2023, once students returned to classrooms.
A few working conditions initially declined but improved from 2021 to 2023, including collaborative practices and student engagement in learning
The study also analyzed Illinois survey data by school demographics. Teachers from schools in wealthier communities had better working conditions, but experienced the same decline as educators in lower-income schools.
Schools where instruction was delivered online during the 2020-21 school year also had larger declines in working conditions compared with schools where learning was in-person.
Koedel said that while the study focuses on Illinois, educators nationwide have experienced similar working conditions.
Related
'There's really no reason to think Illinois is some weird place that's so different from every other [state]' Koedel said. 'In my opinion, we should expect Illinois to be like other places, because a lot of what's happening in schools there is happening everywhere.'
For example, other national studies have highlighted the link between teacher job satisfaction and educators' well-being and retention.
A 2022 study from the RAND Corp. found that teachers who had administrator support and felt they belonged in their schools were less likely to report burnout and job-related stress. Those who had strong positive relationships with their colleagues and felt their students were engaged in learning were also much less likely to report poor well-being.
'There's a deeper question of, like, 'What exactly is it that's driving this?' ' Koedel said of the University of Missouri results. 'I believe this is telling us we have made some sort of bad decisions about how we're running schools, but this doesn't tell us what decisions we made that were bad, right? So I'm trying to understand that better.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
San Francisco Unified Announces New K-8 Math Curriculum
This article was originally published in EdSource. The San Francisco Unified School District announced that it is rolling out a new math curriculum for grades K-8 this school year. According to a statement from the district, the newly adopted materials focus on three key areas: solving math problems accurately; understanding the 'why' behind the math; and learning how to apply math in everyday life. Related Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter San Francisco Unified has set a goal of increasing the percentage of eighth grade students meeting grade-level expectations from 42% in 2022 to 65% by 2027. This new curriculum was piloted last year by 84 middle school teachers and 160 elementary teachers. Early results were promising, the district said. 'San Francisco's public schools are focused on helping every student build confidence and competence in math to be set up for lifelong success,' Superintendent Maria Su said in the statement. SFUSD's math curriculum had received heavy criticism and was even the subject of a ballot measure last year. Voters supported an effort to teach algebra in eighth grade. Previously, the district pushed algebra to ninth grade in an effort to improve equity and eliminate tracking students into different math paths at the middle school level. Related Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
12-07-2025
- Yahoo
An Oklahoma Teacher Took a Leap of Faith. She Ended Up Winning State Teacher of the Year
This article was originally published in Oklahoma Voice. OKLAHOMA CITY — Those who knew Melissa Evon the best 'laughed really hard' at the thought of her teaching family and consumer sciences, formerly known as home economics. By her own admission, the Elgin High School teacher is not the best cook. Her first attempt to sew ended with a broken sewing machine and her mother declaring, 'You can buy your clothes from now on.' Still, Evon's work in family and consumer sciences won her the 2025 Oklahoma Teacher of the Year award on Friday. Yes, her students practice cooking and sewing, but they also learn how to open a bank account, file taxes, apply for scholarships, register to vote and change a tire — lessons she said 'get kids ready to be adults.' Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter 'Even though most of my career was (teaching) history, government and geography, the opportunity to teach those real life skills has just been a phenomenal experience,' Evon told Oklahoma Voice. After graduating from Mustang High School and Southwestern Oklahoma State University, Evon started her teaching career in 1992 at Elgin Public Schools just north of Lawton. She's now entering her 27th year in education, a career that included stints in other states while her husband served in the Air Force and a break after her son was born. No matter the state, the grade level or the subject, 'I'm convinced I teach the world's greatest kids,' she said. Her family later returned to Oklahoma where Evon said she received a great education in public schools and was confident her son would, too. Over the course of her career, before and after leaving the state, she won Elgin Teacher of the Year three times, district Superintendent Nathaniel Meraz said. So, Meraz said he was 'ecstatic' but not shocked that Evon won the award at the state level. 'There would be nobody better than her,' Meraz said. 'They may be as good as her. They may be up there with her. But she is in that company of the top teachers.' Like all winners of Oklahoma Teacher of the Year, Evon will spend a year out of the classroom to travel the state as an ambassador of the teaching profession. She said her focus will be encouraging teachers to stay in education at a time when Oklahoma struggles to keep experienced educators in the classroom. Evon herself at times questioned whether to continue teaching, she said. In those moments, she drew upon mantras that are now the core of her Teacher of the Year platform: 'See the light' by looking for the good in every day and 'be the light for your kids.' She also told herself to 'get out of the boat,' another way of saying 'take a leap of faith.' Two years ago, she realized she needed a change if she were to stay in education. She wanted to return to the high-school level after years of teaching seventh-grade social studies. The only opening at the high school, though, was family and consumer sciences. Accepting the job was a 'get out of the boat and take a leap of faith moment,' she said. 'I think teachers have to be willing to do that when we get stuck,' Evon said. 'Get out of the boat. Sometimes that's changing your curriculum. Sometimes it might be more like what I did, changing what you teach. Maybe it's changing grade levels, changing subjects, changing something you've always done, tweaking that idea.' Since then, she's taught classes focused on interpersonal communication, parenting, financial literacy and career opportunities. She said her students are preparing to become adults, lead families and grow into productive citizens. And, sure, they learn cooking and sewing along the way. 'I'm getting to teach those things, and I know that what I do matters,' Evon said. 'They come back and tell me that.' Oklahoma Voice is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Oklahoma Voice maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Janelle Stecklein for questions: info@
Yahoo
07-07-2025
- Yahoo
Beierle, Judith L. 1942-2025 Kingsland, Texas
KINGSLAND, Texas – Judith, 'Judy' Lee Beierle (nee Gray), 82, of Kingsland, Texas, passed away peacefully on June 12, 2025, in her home surrounded by loved ones. Judy was born on Nov. 29, 1942, in the city of St. Joseph, to Carl and Eleanor Gray. She attended Benton High School, in St. Joseph, and St. Joseph Junior College before graduating from the University of Missouri in Columbia in 1964, receiving her Bachelor of Arts in English and education. She worked as a teacher, a substitute teacher, and in retail. Judy loved playing bridge, Uno, and Scrabble throughout her life. In her younger years, she excelled in needle work, embroidery, and sewing. She sang in her church choir throughout her life and sang in the Bluebonnet Chorale of the Highland Lakes for many years after moving to the Hill Country. Judy was known for her charismatic personality, sense of style, and her indomitable optimism. She loved reading, particular classic mysteries and historical fiction. She loved collecting antique furniture, figurines, and housewares. She loved animals, particularly cats and greyhounds. She is survived by her husband of 61 years, Charles Beierle; her daughters, Robin Henning and Emily Beierle-McKaskle; and her grandchildren, Austin Henning, Abby Henning, Adeline McKaskle, and Henry McKaskle. She is preceded in death by her father, Carl Gray; her step-father, Marcus Caton; and her mother, Hope Eleanor Gray. Services will be held at her church of many years, St. Andrew Presbyterian Church, 201 RM 1431, Marble Falls, TX 78654, on July 11, 2025, at 2 p.m. In lieu of flowers, donations can be made to either: Donate Life America at Or Austin Greyhound Adoption at Online condolences may be made at: As published in the St. Joseph News-Press.
