Deception trial of Catherine O'Brien adjourned following jury foreman's bereavement
When excusing the other 11 jurors this morning, Judge Eugene O'Kelly informed them he had given permission to the accused, Ms O'Brien, to stand, as she is suffering from a medical condition that makes it uncomfortable for her to sit.
Ms O'Brien is facing charges of deception related to a man named John Blake, and the alleged purchase, transport, and insurance of a French mare named Lingreville.
It is alleged that she 'dishonestly by deception' induced Mr Blake to pay €20,000 to purchase the horse — which the State claims was never bought; to pay €1,100 in insurance — which the State alleges was not paid; and €984 for transport from France to Ireland — which the State contends never occurred.
Ms O'Brien, of An Grianán, Ballinroad, Dungarvan, Co. Waterford, has pleaded not guilty to the three charges of making gain or causing loss by deception, contrary to Section 6 of the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act 2001.
Judge O'Kelly asked the 11 jurors to return on Tuesday, adding that the foreman is expected to return then.
He asked the jury to excuse Ms O'Brien as she 'may have to stand up or take regular breaks' on Tuesday.
Ms O'Brien stood throughout the brief hearing, wearing a black sleeveless jacket, wine jumper, and navy trousers, with her hair tied back.
She was remanded on continuing bail.
Read More
Cork woman on trial for deception feared for her and her children's lives after harassment
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
'Preferred bidder' found for MV Matthew berthed in Cork Harbour
Drug trafficking cargo ship the MV Matthew has cost the State almost €10m in maintenance, crewing, and berthing fees since it was intercepted in 2023. A buyer has been found for the drug trafficking ship, and the Revenue Commissioners are engaging with Panamanian authorities to ensure legal and regulatory compliance. The MV Matthew, a Panamanian-registered ship, was at the centre of the largest cocaine seizure in the history of the State. Eight men were sentenced to a combined 129 years in prison in July for their role in the drug trafficking operation in which some €157m worth of cocaine was seized. The MV Matthew, owned by a Dubai-based company, was boarded at gunpoint by Ireland's elite army ranger wing in rough seas off the Cork coast in September 2023. Eight men from the 21-person crew were ultimately charged with drug trafficking offences. The ship, which has since been berthed in Cork Harbour, has been costing an average of €120,000 each week to maintain. However, Revenue has confirmed that 'a preferred bidder has been identified' for the MV Matthew. 'Revenue is engaging with the Panamanian authorities to ensure compliance with maritime legislation and regulations that govern the disposal of the MV Matthew, and has received confirmation from them that it is receiving attention,' a statement said. 'Revenue hopes to have these matters finalised shortly. Revenue is required to ensure that all regulations and legal obligations are fully complied with throughout the disposal and removal process.' 'Far too long' Berthing the ship, which includes costs for unberthing and moving the vessel when necessary, has cost €2,187,950. Maintenance of the ship — including fuel costs, waste removal, and repairs — has cost €3,784,050. Crewing has cost 3,762,054. More than €9,734,054 has been spent on the ship in total. These costs were paid by the Revenue Commissioners to maintain and manage the MV Matthew from September 2023 to the end of July 2025. Fianna Fáil TD for Cork South Central Séamus McGrath said that the disposal of the MV Matthew is taking 'far too long'. 'The cost of keeping it on a weekly basis is extremely high,' he said. 'I doubt very much at this stage if the State will actually be any net better off as a result of the sale, given the amount of cost that was incurred in terms of the storage and maintenance of the ship.' The ship had been maintained to allow access for defence legal teams as it was at the centre of a major criminal trial. The Special Criminal Court authorised its release on December 2. It was only possible to dispose of the ship from that date. Mr McGrath said that it should have been ready for sale as soon as it was released by the courts. He said he has raised his concerns both with Revenue and with the Public Accounts Committee, and has requested further information on the sales process.
Sunday World
a day ago
- Sunday World
Drugs kingpin got 'tired' of life of crime, court hears
Jamie Rothwell has vowed to turn his life around after living in "isolation, loneliness and fear" Rothwell had now turned away from a life of crime Rothwell had boasted about his life of crime The head of a British organised crime gang who ordered rivals to be shot on the streets of the UK from his Barcelona bolthole has given up living a life of crime, a court has heard. Jamie Rothwell who organised shootings and traded assault rifles from his flat in Spain has pleaded guilty at Manchester Crown Court to a string of drugs and firearms offences. Rothwell, who was found by police "hiding out" at the apartment had vowed to turn his life around after living in "isolation, loneliness and fear", his barrister, Chris Henley, KC, said. The 38-year-old Rothwell, from Salford in Greater Manchester, is due to be sentenced on Thursday along with nine other men. He was arrested after being identified as the man behind the "livelong" handle on EncroChat phone network that was hacked into by French police in 2020. Jamie Rothwell News in 90 Seconds - August 14th Thousands of organised criminals, who were oblivious to the fact they had been compromised, carried on sending messages that were intercepted and shared with British police forces. The messages exposed Rothwell's "command over a sprawling criminal enterprise and his involvement in the trafficking of high-powered weapons, including AK-47 rifles', Greater Manchester Police said. Prosecutor Jaime Hamilton, KC, told how some of the messages revealed the violence 'that is the hallmark and by-product of his business". In one chilling message Rothwell said: "When you have fire in your heart you don't stop... you get addicted, you lose everyone, you turn cold, no emotions." In another, Rothwell bragged of how he was "sending constant" consignments of Class A and B drugs and weapons including 'an RPG, M16, AKs, and Glocks'. Mr Hamilton said Rothwell also discussed how he had fallen out with other criminals and engaged in a "six-month war" with one. Rothwell had boasted about his life of crime The court heard how Cheshire man Liam Byrne was told by police that his life was under threat in April 2020 after Rothwell and another man discussed finding his address and that of his father. Rothwell soon got these details along with photographs of the men and images of their addresses from a satellite mapping application. Mr Byrne's stepfather was later shot in the leg on the doorstep of his home by a gunman posing as a pizza delivery driver. Following the infiltration of EncroChat, Rothwell was tracked down to an apartment in Barcelona in 2020 where he had fled after police in the UK handed him a "threat to life" notice. Having been extradited back to the UK Rothwell pleaded guilty to conspiracies to possess firearms and ammunition with intent to endanger life, conspiracies to supply cocaine and ketamine, and two counts of conspiracy to inflict grievous bodily harm with intent. Rothwell had now turned away from a life of crime In mitigation, Mr Henley said Rothwell had spent five years thinking about his life since his arrest. He now felt feelings of "remorse and regret", including for "breaking the hearts" of his family. The defence barrister added: "He is tired of the life he has lived. "He has expressed that all he has really achieved is isolation, loneliness, fear and a life away from his family." Mr Henley said he wanted to put "aside the bravado, the hype, and glamorisation around serious offences, and communicate some hard truths to people about what life really looks like". He added that Rothwell would "like to share with others - perhaps younger people who perhaps stand on the edge of some sort of offending precipice". Mr Henley asked the judge to "acknowledge the steps [Rothwell] had already taken" when passing sentence. "He is now a much older and wiser man than he was when he was 33 when these offences took place," he said. Rothwell, who was flanked by four security guards in the dock, will appear via video link on Thursday for sentencing.
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
Man who lost 'beautiful souls' does not want driver 'consumed by guilt'
A man who lost 'two beautiful souls' — his daughter and her mother — in a road accident just over a year ago has assured the driver of the other vehicle involved that he does not hold him responsible for the tragedy, a double inquest was told. The 'heartfelt' message, written by Arnaud Tournié, who is French-based, was read in full by the coroner for Mayo, Eleanor Fitzgerald, at a hearing in Ballina into the deaths of Aisling Moore, a 46-year-old beautician, and her eight-year-old daughter Abbigael Tournié Moore on July 2, 2024. The mother and daughter, who lived in Swinford, were travelling on the N26 between Foxford and Swinford in a Toyota car when they were involved in a collision with a Scania truck tractor unit and trailer at Callow, Foxford, and died instantly after suffering devastating injuries. The pair had earlier enjoyed a break at the Ocean Sands Hotel in Enniscrone and intended returning there, according to John Burke, the hotel's accommodation manager, who chatted with Aisling before she set out on her ill-fated journey. In his evidence to Thursday's inquest, the West Coast Express truck driver, Martin Crean, said he had been travelling towards Foxford with a 45ft trailer when the car came around a bend at speed on the wrong side of the road. 'I thought it possible to go into a side road, but the vehicle kept coming towards me," Mr Crean said. Mr Crean gave details of harrowing scenes at the impact site, and said he had been traumatised and shocked by the accident and what he witnessed afterwards. In a deposition read to the hearing, eyewitness PJ Wall said he had been travelling to Swinford to pick up a generator travelling behind a silver car when the car went on the wrong side while negotiating a left hand bend. Mr Wall said the driver of the car tried to correct herself, but the truck hit her and pushed her along the road before jack-knifing and pushing the car into a ditch. No defects Sergeant Gabriel McLoughlin examined both vehicles in the aftermath of the collision. In a written statement read to the inquest by Sergeant Sean McHale, Sgt McLoughlin outlined no defects had been found in either vehicle that would have contributed to the collision. Pathologist Tamas Nemeth gave evidence that the medical cause of death in Aisling's case was extensive fatal injuries including multiple fractures and head injuries. The medical cause of Abbigael's death was extensive head injuries sustained in a road traffic accident. After recording verdicts of accidental deaths in both cases, the coroner read into the record Arnaud Tournié's letter to Mr Crean. Mr Tournié wrote: 'No words can express the depth of my grief. Yet, despite this immense pain, I want you to know I do not hold you responsible for this tragedy. 'I want to extend my heartfelt support to you. I know you must carry this image with you every day, and that it cannot be easy for you or your loved ones. 'I do not want you to be consumed by guilt, because this accident was neither the result of any wrongdoing or negligence on your part. 'You did what you could and no one is ever truly prepared for such a moment — unfathomable and unfair — for all of us. 'Please receive these words as a gesture of compassion, of humanity, and, I hope, a small measure of solace. 'I wish you with time the inner peace needed to move forward and to honour, in your own way, the memory of these two beautiful souls.'
