NYC has become so unaffordable that residents are being forced to give up their pets

Independent

23-07-2025

New York City animal shelters are becoming overwhelmed as residents surrender more and more pets amid an ongoing affordability crisis, according to a new report.
The Animal Care Centers of New York City — a network of public animal shelters in Manhattan, Queens and Staten Island — told The New York Times they have 1,000 animals in their system as of last week. The shelter network is now caring for hundreds of cats, dogs and kittens. The network is also housing 50 rabbits, a dozen guinea pigs and several birds.
The increase in surrenders comes as pet owners are increasingly unable to afford their furry friends, according to the Times. People are surrendering animals 'nonstop,' and the shelters are struggling to keep up, Animal Care Centers' Communications Director Katy Hansen told the newspaper.
'Not everybody is surrendering their pet because they just don't have time,' Hansen said. 'There's a lot of people that are just, like, really struggling. And it's sad. You know, they come in, they're crying.'
'I think it's just people are broke,' she added. 'The wealth gap is hitting hard.'
It can cost pet owners thousands of dollars per year to take care of their animals. The ASPCA estimates cat owners pay more than $1,100 in the first year they own their pet, while large dog owners pay more than $2,000 in the first year.
Meanwhile, about half of New York City households are unable to make ends meet, and the cost of basic needs is rising faster than earnings, according to a 2023 report by the non-profit United Way New York City.
An ASPCA spokesperson told The Independent the agency's New York City adoption center has also seen an uptick in animals in recent weeks.
'This uptick is the result of a variety of factors, including an increase in 311 calls, criminal complaint reports and criminal cases, as well as ongoing capacity challenges that many shelters across the country are facing,' the spokesperson said.
'Summer is also generally a busier time of year for shelters as it coincides with kitten season, when shelters nationwide are flooded with vulnerable, newborn kittens who require specialized care,' the spokesperson added.
It's not cheap for shelters to care for the animals, either.
The Dakin Humane Society, a shelter based in Springfield, Massachusetts, estimates it costs their shelter about $950 per animal they care for. That's because animals that pass through shelters often have extra medical and behavioral needs, the Dakin Humane Society says.
The Animal Care Centers of New York City says it has suspended intake as a result of this uptick, except for animals that were sent in by government agencies, animals that pose threats to the public and animals having medical emergencies.
' We can't adopt our way out,' Hansen told the Times. 'I mean, unless we did a thousand adoptions this weekend, but that's pretty unrealistic. So what is it that we can do? I don't know. I think everyone's trying to figure it out.'