Give Hong Kong's students the space to showcase their spoken English
[email protected] or filling in
this Google form . Submissions should not exceed 400 words, and must include your full name and address, plus a phone number for verification
Advertisement
As a former English language teacher in Hong Kong, I have observed a number of issues with the implementation of English language school-based assessment (SBA).
First, there appear to be misconceptions about the SBA's time limit. While students' individual SBA presentations are expected to last three to five minutes, the Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority (HKEAA) indicates that the suggested duration only serves as a guide. A strict time limit creates unnecessary stress for students.
It seems that some English teachers, apart from imposing unnecessary time limits, administer the assessment in contrived settings that are too formal. Some secondary schools have all students in the same year level taking the assessment on the same day or on two consecutive days, often with the same tasks designed by the panel convenor.
Such exam-like arrangements, ostensibly made to uphold fairness, violate SBA's intention of providing 'a richer picture of what learners can do (with oral language) than the external examination'.
Advertisement
Moreover, there are concerns about how much guidance teachers should give as students prepare for the assessment. As the HKEAA noted, the assessment should not be treated as 'a separate one-off activity that can be timetabled or prepared for as if it were a separate element of the curriculum'. Simply put, English teachers should provide students with sufficient scaffolding before the assessment so they know how to prepare.
Last but surely not least, should students be allowed to request to take multiple assessments?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
3 days ago
- South China Morning Post
90% pass rate for Hong Kong's mainland-based DSE pupils, exceeding city average
More than 90 per cent of Hong Kong students from four mainland Chinese schools met the city's university's minimum requirements in the local public exams, far exceeding the overall average of 38 per cent of all assessment candidates. The four schools in the Greater Bay Area are the only institutions on the mainland approved by the Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority to register their students as school candidates for the Diploma of Secondary Education (DSE) exams. Students pursuing the curriculum elsewhere must register as private candidates. In 2024, when the first group of mainland-based Hong Kong students sat the exams in the city, there were only two such schools. Three of the current four schools also serve as designated examination centres. Following the recent release of DSE results, the four schools reported that more than 90 per cent of their graduates met the basic university entrance requirements for institutions in Hong Kong, Macau, mainland China and Taiwan. Two schools, the Minxin Hong Kong School in Guangzhou and the Shenzhen Hong Kong Pui Kiu College Longhua Xinyi School, reported that more than 90 per cent of their students met the threshold for local undergraduate programmes. The threshold, commonly known as '332A', requires a level 3 in both Chinese and English, a level 2 in mathematics, and an 'attained' in citizenship and social development.
HKFP
09-07-2025
- HKFP
10 Years of HKFP: New, free mobile news apps for Android and iOS
Founded in 2015, Hong Kong Free Press is an impartial, non-profit, award-winning English-language newspaper. Run by journalists, backed by readers and 100% independent, HKFP is governed by a public Code of Ethics. If there are uncertainties relating to safety or security, we may use an "HKFP Staff" byline. More on our Ethics & Policies.
HKFP
15-06-2025
- HKFP
From waste to ‘superfood': Hong Kong dietitians turn kitchen scrap into healthy protein source for low-income families
At a communal living space tucked away on the top floor of the Tsuen Wan Market building, a group of women gathered in a spacious, well-equipped kitchen. They tried out a few recipes under the guidance of two registered dietitians and a handful of trained volunteers. From omelettes and kimbap – Korean seaweed rice rolls – to oatmeal cookies and banana pancakes, these homely, unostentatious dishes all featured a crumbly yet moist ingredient, which the women poured from palm-sized, unlabelled silvery sachets. The creamy beige ingredient – the soy pulp – was the centrepiece of the hands-on workshop. Also known as tofu dregs, or okara in Japanese, it is the solid leftover from filtering soybean puree during the production of soya milk and tofu. The workshop, designed and led by dietitians Joyce Chan and Hannah Wong, is part of a pilot programme called the Okara Project in English. Its Chinese name translates as the Tofu Dreg Project – a wordplay on a term coined by China's Premier Zhu Rongji to describe shoddy construction work and later popularised by Chinese netizens after jerry-built structures collapsed during the 2008 Sichuan earthquake. However, there is nothing inferior about the real tofu dregs. 'What we want to do today is show you how to turn something we usually think of as kitchen waste into a 'superfood,'' said Pui, a recent university graduate in food and nutrition. Pui, who only disclosed her given name due to privacy concerns, helped lead the briefing session that day after Chan and Wong trained her as a community ambassador. With each slide displayed on the screen, Pui explained in everyday language the many little-known nutritional benefits of this common soy by-product, from its protein- and fibre-rich profile to its low glycaemic index and minimal saturated fat. The participating women were all subdivided flat residents, mostly mainland Chinese who recently immigrated to Hong Kong to care for their husbands and children. They find joy in the extended living space administered by the charity Caritas, where they can cook, share meals, do laundry, make friends, and enjoy a momentary reprieve from their caregiving responsibilities. Food insecurity remains a pressing issue in some of Hong Kong's poorest districts, where cost and substandard living conditions prevent many low-income residents from accessing adequate, nutritious meals. In 2024, for instance, a survey conducted by the Hong Kong charity Food Grace found that around 44 per cent of low-income residents in Kwai Tsing and Sham Shui Po, two of the city's poorest and most densely populated areas, had gone hungry in the previous six months, with one-third regularly skipping meals to cut costs. Over 46 per cent said they didn't get enough nutrients daily, mainly because healthy food was too expensive. Two University of Hong Kong scholars wrote in 2023 that fresh pork in Hong Kong was around four times more expensive than in Shenzhen. Hong Kong was also ranked as the second most expensive market for chicken fillet across the Asia-Pacific region, with the average price per kilogramme more than 40 per cent above the regional average. Apart from soaring food prices, many surveyed by Food Grace also cited the lack of proper cooking facilities in inadequate housing units as a major barrier to preparing balanced meals. With these challenges in mind, Chan and Wong designed a pilot programme to cater specifically to underserved communities, drawing on their experience providing dietary consultation services to at-risk groups managing chronic conditions such as prediabetes and hypertension. 'In our work with subdivided flat residents and the elderly, I often hear people say how expensive meat is, or how difficult it is for older adults to chew and swallow it,' Chan said in Cantonese. These encounters prompted her to think about alternative ingredients that could help make up for the protein deficiencies without adding to their financial burden. Nutrient-rich, low-cost alternative The idea began to take shape during Chan's temple stay at Japan's famed Mount Koya in early 2024. She was served a vegetarian side dish made from spinach mixed with okara, a common meat substitute used in many Japanese recipes. Around the same time, public debate in Hong Kong intensified over the government's now-delayed municipal solid waste charging scheme. 'Everything is aligned,' said Chan. 'It gave me the idea to repurpose a protein source and make it affordable.' She later teamed up with Wong, and together they secured a HK$100,000 grant from the Hong Kong government's Social Innovation and Entrepreneurship Development Fund to launch the Okara Project, promoting recycled soy pulp as a low-cost, nutritious protein source for low-income households. Thanks to its well-documented nutritional benefits and vegan-friendly versatility in cooking, interest in soy pulp is growing among international food manufacturers. The global okara market was valued at US$2.68 billion (HK$21 billion) in 2024 and is poised to reach US$3.2 billion (HK$25.1 billion) by 2030, according to a recent market analysis. In countries such as Germany and the US, companies are incorporating soy pulp flour into baked goods, while researchers in Singapore have developed a probiotic drink made from okara that boasts a longer shelf life without the need for refrigeration. In contrast, soy pulp is largely treated as food waste in Hong Kong and is rarely featured in local cuisines. And while it has traditionally been used as animal feed or fertiliser – and more recently repurposed into products like cat litter or mushroom-growing mediums – Chan and Wong's initiative may be the city's first to tap into its potential as a nutritious source to help address food insecurity. 'I didn't realise you could make so many delicious dishes out of soy pulp,' said Xiaoyun, a full-time caregiver and mother who participated in the workshop. She, too, declined to give her full name. 'I used to make soy milk at home from time to time, but we usually just threw the soy pulp away without giving it much thought,' she said in Mandarin. After relocating to Hong Kong from Fujian province about a year ago, Xiaoyun met other immigrant women like herself at the Caritas-run shared space and bonded through group activities, like cooking sessions organised by Chan and Wong. 'This gives me a feeling of being at home,' she added, describing the experience as a welcome break from the often 'depressing' reality of staying in their cramped living quarters all day. Low environmental footprint To make their project sustainable, Chan knew early on that she wanted to source the soy pulp locally, meeting the community nearby. Proximity to the source became a key priority for the project's logistical planning. She specifically wanted to pilot the project using Caritas' communal space as the venue, with the wet market situated on the building's ground floor. In Tsuen Wan Market, she managed to meet the owner of a tofu stall, who agreed to give away the otherwise discarded soy pulp for free. Her team then shipped the ingredient to a food factory, where it underwent ultra-high temperature sterilisation before being packaged in sealed sachets, ready to be distributed to community members participating in their cooking workshops. Another mission of their project is to raise awareness of how plant-based diets can be beneficial not only to human health but also to the planet. 'Producing a kilo of plant-based food gives off around 0.3 to 4 kilos of carbon, while a kilo of beef can release as much as 60 kilos' of carbon, Pui told the participants in the briefing session in Cantonese, as she explained food's environmental footprint. Apart from reducing food waste by repurposing soy pulp, they could also help reduce environmental impact one food item at a time by eating more sustainably, said Pui. Experts previously estimated that globally, switching to plant-based diets could shrink the amount of land used for food by 76 per cent and cut food-related greenhouse gas emissions nearly in half. However, for low-income communities in Hong Kong, cost remains the primary factor in choosing food, according to the same survey by Food Grace. Fewer than one in three respondents considered sustainability or environmental impact in their food choices. For Chan, food sustainability has always been integral to her vision for the project. She chose soy pulp precisely because it's 'affordable,' 'sustainable,' and simple to use in home cooking. Empowering community Chan and Wong's vision also extends beyond cooking workshops and community education. As part of their pilot programme, they've trained around 30 community nutrition ambassadors – 10 of whom are now active team members. 'Most of them are retired women who are passionate about cooking and eager to give back to their communities,' said Chan. After completing the training, the ambassadors went on to brainstorm recipes, help co-lead workshops, and gradually take on bigger roles in spreading the project's message, while also receiving a paid wage for their efforts. For some, the experience has been transformative. 'I usually get anxious when speaking in front of people,' said Jay, a retired teacher who trained to become an ambassador last year. Jay, who did not want to give her surname, was co-leading a session with Pui that day. Speaking to people from diverse backgrounds and varying levels of understanding was vastly different from teaching children, Jay explained. 'But they always encourage me and praise my efforts, which helps me keep going.' The project has also drawn interest from young, aspiring professionals like Pui, who hope to promote healthy and environmentally conscious diets. 'I was originally more focused on sports nutrition,' Pui said. 'But after engaging with these communities, I realised I could do more by helping prevent chronic diseases through modifying their diet, especially since many people don't have access to reliable nutrition advice.' Meanwhile, Chan is looking to scale up their community-driven model and turn soy pulp into an accessible and commercially viable protein alternative. 'At our talks, people became curious about where they could get soy pulp near them so they could bring it home and try the recipes themselves,' the dietitian said. Having already developed recipes and conducted training sessions, the key question now is how to help communities source soy pulp more consistently and on a larger scale. 'Imagine a space where all the trainings and soy pulp exchanges take place under one roof,' said Chan, outlining her vision for a community hub dedicated to sharing soy pulp recipes and knowledge. She also hopes to create an online platform to help people find nearby locations where they can collect soy pulp, either for free or at a low cost. 'Something like a WhatsApp group or a Google Maps listing,' Chan said.
