Lawmakers should consider these questions before giving a billionaire a stadium bailout
Photo viaPlus
Behind closed doors, some of our state politicians are busy negotiating to force Arizona taxpayers to fork over up to $1 billion of our hard-earned taxes. This would redirect public resources to subsidize a lucrative private sports franchise and its billionaire owner — and that raises more questions than answers.
Arizona Diamondbacks team owner Ken Kendrick is rich enough to build several stadiums without any taxpayer handout. The team is valued at $1.6 billion, having appreciated almost sevenfold since he bought it in 2004. As one economist says, 'The harsh reality for even the biggest sports fan is that arena subsidies are a terrible use of finite government resources and a ridiculously egregious redistribution of wealth from regular Americans to some of the wealthiest people and organizations on the planet.' These are simply not people and organizations that need taxpayer help.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
The entire premise of this idea is that it only takes public tax resources from people who use the stadium. But that is simply false. With the stadium giveaway lawmakers are considering, the State of Arizona, Maricopa County and the City of Phoenix would all lose tax dollars that currently help pay for things like schools and public safety. State and local budgets are already strained due to the spiraling cost of Arizona's massive tax cuts and out-of-control universal vouchers. Faced with dwindling state-shared revenues, the City of Phoenix was recently forced to raise its sales tax to avoid cuts to police, fire and libraries.
Combined Arizona state, county and city sales taxes are already among the highest in the country. Our burden ranks 11th nationwide, and it's rising. Arizona also ranks 8th lowest in the country for investment per capita, meaning our needs are vast. Finding extra public revenue to prop up the billionaire owner of a lucrative franchise means either allowing that vast list of needs to accumulate as Arizonans go without, or tapping into taxpayers' pockets in the form of tax increases.
Evidence from a wide swath of economists shows that arena giveaways are a drain, not a boon. More than three decades of studies have found stadiums to be consistent money pits, unjustified as worthwhile public investments, because the promised financial benefits fail to materialize. Proponents argue that 'if the Diamondbacks are not playing at Chase Field, there is no revenue generated at all' — but this economic fallacy ignores the fact that most spending at a stadium is a substitute for other local recreational spending. We're simply shuffling the economic deck chairs by pulling commerce from elsewhere nearby. Our taxpayer dollars could be diverted to luxury amenities or to tax-exempt hotels, restaurants, bars and retail, with little hope of public benefit. Why should taxpayers subsidize luxury amenities and tax-exempt private pockets? How would proponents of a stadium giveaway ensure taxpayer accountability and prevent misuse of public resources?
In 2017, just 19 years after taxpayers paid more than $250 million to help build the ballpark, team owner Ken Kendrick sued Maricopa County for refusing to pay $187 million for renovations. He eventually agreed to take proceeds from stadium maintenance and event bookings to pay for his desired upgrades, an agreement intended to protect taxpayers. That lawsuit settlement explicitly released the county from further financial obligation. Now, the team has come to the state Capitol with both hands out, asking for even more taxpayer money. Did the team's management fail to adequately budget for expected renovations, and if so, why should taxpayers step in to save them from their lack of financial planning?
A frequently heard argument is that we have to pay up or the team will punish us by decamping for a more lucrative pasture. But where is that, exactly? With five million residents, Phoenix is the 10th largest metro area in the nation. All comparably sized markets in the United States already have their own teams. The team would have to relocate to Montreal or Mexico City to avoid downgrading. The current 30-team league also has two expansion teams shopping for a location, further complicating any move. Perhaps this is why, at a recent closed-door meeting, a team rep 'insinuated (threatened)' that Major League Baseball would pull spring training from Arizona — relocating the 15 teams that call the Cactus League their spring home — if lawmakers don't use tax money to pay for the stadium upgrades.
There's a glaring potential conflict of interest here, too. Kendrick and his wife, Randy, are key political donors who spent nearly $1 million in 2024 to influence control of the Arizona Legislature, including funding independent expenditures to support Jeff Weninger (R-Chandler) and directly oppose his opponent. Just months after his win, Weninger sponsored the Diamondbacks' stadium funding bill and advanced it through the committee he chairs. This looks for all the world like 'pay to play,' which raises eyebrows — and serious ethical concerns.
Stadium subsidies impose an invisible burden on taxpayers in the form of forgone public services like police and fire services, parks, schools, libraries, roads and public transit. The opportunity costs of these missed expenditures are critically important to our communities. Why hand that money over to a billionaire-owned pro sports team?
Asking taxpayers whether we want to subsidize a multi-billion-dollar private corporation and its billionaire owner instead of forcing the giveaway down our throats behind closed doors would probably produce a decisive answer — and that's why the team and legislators don't want to go to the ballot. Voters across the nation have clearly shown they don't like stadium giveaways. In the last two years alone, voters have axed a Virginia subsidy amid fierce public opposition, vetoed a stadium handout in Kansas City, and decisively rejected a taxpayer-financed arena right here at home.
Arizonans deserve good tax policy that benefits the entire state, not just the wealthy, and embraces the spirit of public benefit. We encourage Gov. Hobbs and state lawmakers to consider all the above questions before making a decision that will weigh on taxpayers for decades to come.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
‘High-risk' ICE flight deports over 100 illegal aliens, including convicted felons, to China
Just days after violent, anti-ICE riots first rocked Los Angeles, federal immigration agents announced a major enforcement operation deporting 122 illegal aliens to China, many of them convicted of crimes including murder, rape, and drug trafficking. The June 3 deportation flight, led by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in Dallas, was part of a nationwide push to protect American communities and restore law and order. According to an official ICE press release, the group included 96 men and 26 women, ranging in age from 19 to 68. All had final orders of removal and were held in ICE detention centers across the Arrests 'Worst Of The Worst' Illegal Aliens In Los Angeles While Protesters Advocate For Criminals: Dhs ICE officials say the charter flight to China was in the interest of public safety. According to an ICE press release, many of the individuals removed had been convicted of serious felonies, including murder, rape, human smuggling, bribery, and narcotics trafficking. One man removed was a 47-year-old with a murder conviction. Another was a 27-year-old found guilty of rape. Others listed included drug dealers and smugglers. Read On The Fox News App "Through our interagency partnerships and coordination across ICE field offices, we have successfully removed these individuals, many who were convicted of egregious crimes," said ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) Dallas acting Field Office Director Josh Officials Slam Democrats For 'Dangerous' Rhetoric As Ice Agents Face Violent Mobs In La, Nyc "This operation not only enhances the public safety of our communities across the U.S. but also strengthens national security. Our colleagues at ICE come to work every day to identify, arrest and remove illegal aliens who attempt to circumvent our nation's immigration laws." The flight also reflects the tough stance President Trump has taken in his second term when it comes to China. The Trump administration has increased tariffs on Chinese imports, blamed Chinese companies for fueling the U.S. fentanyl crisis, and clamped down on tech exports. In response, Beijing has issued warnings to its citizens about traveling to American cities affected by civil unrest and imposed its own trade penalties. Americans with information about immigration violations or criminal activity are urged to contact ICE at 866-DHS-2-ICE or submit a tip online at article source: 'High-risk' ICE flight deports over 100 illegal aliens, including convicted felons, to China
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump's FTC is digging into Elon Musk's claims about an advertiser ‘boycott'
Happy Tuesday! Here's your weekly Tech Drop, a roundup of the past week's top stories from the intersection of technology and politics. Elon Musk's ostensible departure from the White House and its contentious aftermath certainly haven't stopped the Trump administration from working to further Musk's commercial interests. The Federal Trade Commission recently demanded documents from some of the world's largest ad agencies, following on from Musk's allegations that companies have been engaged in a 'boycott' when they chose not to purchase ads on X due to the prevalence of disinformation and hate speech on the platform. (Several major corporations recently asked a judge to dismiss a related lawsuit brought by X.) Read more at The Wall Street Journal. Meta is making a foray into military technology, starting with plans to develop a virtual reality–enabled headset to train U.S. troops. I laid out some glaring security concerns in a recent post that highlights the company's history of being used by illiberal forces to spread disinformation and promote propaganda linked to violence. Read more at MSNBC. Amid protests in Los Angeles over the Trump administration's authoritarian, anti-immigration raids, several MAGA world figures, including Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas, spread videos on social media that they falsely claimed depicted the city in a state of chaos. In reality, many of the images they shared don't come from the protests at all but were either taken at different times or in other countries entirely. Read more at Meidas Touch. Khaby Lame, a TikTok influencer who is reportedly the most followed person on the app, was forced to leave the U.S. after being detained by ICE agents last week. The agency said that Lame had overstayed his visa and was given the opportunity to leave voluntarily. Read more at MSBNC. Far-right influencer Steve Bannon's podcast, 'WarRoom,' has been welcomed back to Spotify. The audio streaming platform removed Bannon's content in 2020 after he said he'd like to see government officials — like then-FBI Director Christopher Wray and leading immunologist Anthony Fauci — beheaded and their heads put on pikes 'at the two corners of the White House as a warning to federal bureaucrats.' 'Following its temporary suspension and a constructive dialogue with the show's team, new 'Bannon's WarRoom' episodes are available on Spotify,' a spokesperson said in a statement. Read more at the New York Post. In a report released last week, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., highlighted more than 100 instances of possible corruption by Musk and other White House officials who appear to have advanced his business interests during his time as a 'special government employee.' A White House official referred to the report as 'toothless' in a statement to MSNBC and claimed Musk has done more than Warren to improve Americans' lives. But the statement didn't address any specific allegations. Read more at MSNBC. The University of Michigan says it is ending its contracts with outside vendors that provide plainclothes security, including a technology-focused security company, the Guardian reports. The outlet had previously reported that private investigators had been trailing and recording pro-Palestinian demonstrators. The university said it ended its contract after one of the company's employees engaged in behavior the school said went 'against our values and directives.' Read more at The Guardian. The Trump administration's rush to install AI tools across the federal government continues to run into some snags. An artificial intelligence tool developed by the so-called Department of Government Efficiency has caused some problems at the Department of Veterans Affairs over its tendency to spit out false information. Read more at ProPublica. A new report in Wired highlights how the term 'nonlethal,' used in reference to weapons that are often deployed against protesters, doesn't give the full picture of how harmful these weapons can be — or the extent to which their use on civilians is frowned upon in other nations. Read more at Wired. This article was originally published on
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Ohio governor has not called up the National Guard before 'No Kings' protests
With the National Guard and U.S. Marines deployed to protests in Los Angeles, some Akronites worried the same thing may soon happen here after noticing increased activity at the Ohio National Guard Recruiting Center on North Hawkins Avenue. Dan Tierney, a spokesman for Gov. Mike DeWine, on June 10 said the governor has not activated the National Guard and that the state is unaware of any federal deployment. Guard members are likely gathering in Akron for routine training, something that regularly happens in Akron and other locations across the state, Tierney said. The activity at the North Hawkins site comes four days before the scores of 'No Kings' protests that will compete for attention with an enormous military parade in Washington D.C. to honor the 250th birthday of the Army and the 79th birthday of President Donald Trump. The elaborate parade, which will feature U.S. tanks and war weapons, will cost taxpayers an estimated $45 million. The No Kings protests — happening locally in Akron, Cuyahoga Falls, Kent, Hudson and Cleveland — are citizen driven and do not involve tax money. 'They've defied our courts, deported Americans, disappeared people off the streets, attacked our civil rights, and slashed our services,' the No Kings website says. 'The corruption has gone too far. No thrones. No crowns. No kings.' The military parade is scheduled to begin in D.C. at 6:30 p.m. June 14, with a concert and fireworks to follow. No Kings protests will happen at various times throughout the day. More information about times and locations are available on the group's website. This article originally appeared on Akron Beacon Journal: National Guard not called up ahead of 'No Kings' protests in Akron