Mayo hotel refused permission to convert function room into residential accommodation
The nine-bedroom hotel began providing emergency accommodation to homeless people after it closed in November 2024.
At one point, 16 people were being accommodated at the hotel, which is owned by Pat and Mary Mulhern, who invested over €1 million in the premises after purchasing it in 2017.
Mayo County Council refused retention permission as the facility had inadequate parking and would lead to an increase in traffic that would endanger public safety.
Mary Gordon, Head of Planning Administration with Mayo County Council, said that converting the function room into residential accommodation 'would constitute an overdevelopment of the site, resulting in a sub-standard development which would alter the existing character of the immediate area in an undesirable manner and depreciate the value of the adjoining properties in the vicinity.'
The proposal to convert the function room to residential accommodation attracted widespread local opposition. Over 100 people attended a public meeting in the town to discuss the proposed the development earlier this year.
A total of 78 public submissions were lodged to Mayo County Council before the development was refused planning.
This included submissions from local county councillor Michael Loftus and former Mayo footballer Peadar Gardiner.
The local soccer club, Crossmolina FC, also lodged an objection.
Cllr Loftus said in his submission that the function room 'has a low ceiling and limited natural light, making it an unsuitable environment' for residential accommodation.
ADVERTISEMENT
Speaking to the Irish Independent, Cllr Loftus said the local community were 'thrilled' with the council's decision to refuse the retention application.
'We want our hotel back so we can have functions in it, like we used to have. This location that was being proposed by Mr Mulhern was totally unsuitable for putting anybody into, regardless of who they were,' said the Fianna Fáil councillor.
Tom Gilligan, Mayo County Council's Director of Services for Housing, told the Irish Independent that there would be no change to the existing residents' living arrangements.
'There is no change to the guests that are currently availing of the facility. We are still utilising rooms in the hotel for the provision of temporary emergency accommodation,' he said.
The refusal of retention permission at the Dolphin Hotel was welcomed by Mayo TD Paul Lawless, who said the decision should set a precedent for how IPAS centres and emergency accommodation should be handled.
'Too often we see inappropriate developments pushed through without regard for local infrastructure, services, or the long-term sustainability of the area. If a development isn't suitable in terms of scale or services then it shouldn't go ahead, whether it's a hotel conversion or an IPAS centre,' said the Aontú TD.
'We must ensure that planning decisions reflect the needs of both the existing community and any new residents. That means rejecting unsuitable developments and insisting on equal standards for all developments as well as community consultation at every stage. This should be the norm, not the exception.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
New hotel owners dismiss plans for IPAS centre in Meath
In recent weeks, The Pillo Hotel in Ashbourne was purchased by The McDermott Group, which also owns the Ashbourne Court Hotel and the Carnegie Court Hotel in Swords. Owner Richard McDermott issued a statement confirming there were no such plans for an IPAS centre in the 156-room hotel. "I wish to confirm that The Pillo Hotel was recently purchased by the McDermott Group.' 'I also wish to clarify that The Pillo Hotel is not housing any International Protection Applicants nor does it have any plans whatsoever to do so in the future,' Mr McDermott said. 'We remain fully committed to operating as a 4 star Hotel in all markets and contrary to recent social media speculation, we will not be accepting IPAS now or in the future.' 'The recent speculation on the hotel and the false and misleading rumours regarding same have been and furthermore can be very harmful to our business and very disruptive and unsettling to all of our 150+ staff.' 'We wish to clarify and hereby commit to the following... There are massive and exciting plans ahead to invest in the property. We have already engaged the relevant specialists to assist us refurbish all of our bedrooms, expand our leisure club gym space including replacing all gym equipment and enhance our bar and restaurant.' 'As the new owners of The Pillo Hotel we would like to ensure both the local and national communities of our intent to deliver and improve the present and successful offering at The Pillo Hotel.' The statement added: 'We look forward to building and producing continued success and greatly appreciate the support of all of our guests and patrons." In correspondence to elected members, Meath County Council confirmed it had received no approach from the Department of Justice on the matter. 'Regarding the purchase of the Pillo Hotel and the potential conversion into an IPAS centre. It is important to clarify that this is a matter for the property owner and the Department of Justice, Meath County Council's position is not to comment on speculation or on commercial transactions or decisions made by the Department of Justice,' the local authority said. 'We can however confirm that Meath Council Council has not received any correspondence from the Department in relation to the Pillo Hotel being used for IPAS accommodation.' Ashbourne councillor Helen Meyer said: 'This is positive news. The hotel is vital and integral to our town and the surrounding areas.' 'I want to take this opportunity to remind everyone to be cautious about the sources of their news. There are people online who spread misinformation deliberately and without facing any consequences. Such unverified information can have a damaging impact on our community,' she added. Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme.
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Student accommodation scams: ‘People try to get you to pay deposits for a viewing'
A limited supply of accommodation has left students working against the clock to find a place to live during their studies . Jamie McGinty (19), a second-year engineering student from Achill, Co Mayo, says his 'stress levels are through the roof' as he commits to 'a full-time thing checking groups and websites constantly' while working six or seven days a week to afford staying in Galway. In addition to facing a limited supply of expensive housing, the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) this week warned students to be cautious of rental scams. Last year, An Garda Síochána reported that about one third of all accommodation fraud reports occur during August and September, with 34 per cent of victims aged under 25, and 66 per cent aged under 33. READ MORE McGinty has come across plenty of posts online which he believes to be scams: 'So many people are trying to get you to pay deposits or a booking fee for a viewing.' One red flag noted by Muriel Dolan, deputy director of financial education at the CCPC, is landlords claiming 'to be out of town or living abroad and cannot show the property in person'. Maria Balan (23) has just completed a four year art degree at IADT 'This one's quite common', says Maria Balan (23), who has just finished a four-year art degree at IADT. 'It's somebody who poses as a landlord from a different country, in the sense of like, 'Oh I live in London right now, so I cannot come down to see you for a viewing if you don't send me some money,'' says Balan. While Balan is aware that no reputable landlord 'will ask you for money before a viewing', she said it can be difficult to filter out scam advertisements, especially on Facebook and Gumtree. [ Where will vital student housing come from? Opens in new window ] Balan, who is from Romania, feels that her nationality has added to the difficulties of finding a place to live in Dublin. 'The moment that they [landlords] realise I'm from abroad, they would kind of, you know, shy away a little bit, and probably just not talk to me any more,' she says. During her third year of studying, Ms Balan paid €600 per month to live in a 'very small space' which housed three other people. Ronan Meleady (20), a law student at the University of Limerick, says some accommodation advertisements 'don't have any pictures' and don't offer viewings until a payment is given. Meleady, originally from Waterford, secured accommodation in Limerick through a family connection. He is beginning a mandatory placement for his degree in Cork in September and has found 'reasonable enough' digs in the city at €650 a month. [ Student housing investors 'spooked' by ghost of Zoom University Opens in new window ] 'Worst-case scenario, I could have commuted. It would have been quite difficult, but I could have done it. I'm not in the same scenario as someone who has no accommodation and desperately needs it,' he said. Ronan Meleady (20) studies Law at the University of Limerick He is concerned that the 'number of students going to college every year is increasing, and we're not really seeing an increase in the amount of student accommodation that's actually affordable for people, and that's actually accessible for people'. Commuting is not an option for Cora Howson (18) from Carrick-on-Shannon, who is going into the second year of an arts degree in Maynooth University this September. Her mother Rachel Howson says that because her daughter doesn't drive, 'It's not feasible for her to commute. She would be doing 12- to 14-hour days [by train] and wouldn't be able to put the focus on her studies.' The search for accommodation is 'absolutely just a nightmare' for the family. Cora is the first in the family to attend university and her mother says the family is having to navigate the market by themselves. Scams on Facebook are rampant, according to Howson: 'Every time I put up a new post on Facebook I get two comments with links. I wouldn't touch anything with a link. I would make sure I can have a viewing, and that deposits are only handed over after we've met the landlord. 'If we don't find something, we'll have to look at taking a year out.'
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Long-awaited Sligo Greenway may be in jeopardy over Irish Rail objections
A long-awaited greenway in the west of Ireland to which €1.6 million of public money has already been committed looks to be in jeopardy because of Irish Rail objections. The 37.5km Sligo Greenway from Claremorris (Bellaghy) to Collooney is proposed to be built on the tracks of the disused railway line, which has been closed since 1975. There have been three public consultations on the issue already. The reopening of the line was not part of the All-Island Strategic Rail Review, which means it will not be considered until 2050 at the earliest. However, Irish Rail claims demand for the Limerick to Galway service is such that the section of line between Claremorris in Co Mayo and Collooney in Co Sligo will be 'strongly considered' in the first review of the All-Island Strategic Rail Review. READ MORE Irish Rail said in a statement: 'It is clear from our engagement with stakeholders that there has been a significant change in momentum towards reinstating the Western Rail Corridor, with Athenry to Claremorris indicated to be advanced as a short-term intervention under the All-Island Strategic Rail Review. 'Our judgment – based on these engagements, and which experience of the growth in demand for Limerick to Galway services would support – is that this increases the likelihood of Claremorris to Collooney being strongly considered in any first review of the All-Island Strategic Rail Review. 'Our first consideration has always been based on an assessment of public policy as it relates to the potential for reinstatement of an alignment as a rail route, and this informs our position on this matter.' A Department of Transport spokeswomen said: 'To proceed with the scheme requires the agreement of Irish Rail, as owners of the rail line.' She added that the greenway has not yet been cancelled and the final decision will be for the Government. [ 'It's cheaper to drive': Commuters react to Irish Rail fare rises Opens in new window ] Converting the existing rail tracks into a greenway was first approved in 2014 by Sligo County Council. In 2021 Irish Rail chief executive Jim Meade told the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Transport that he supports greenways on disused railways provided the government does not request the line for possible future rail routes. He described it as a 'win-win' as Irish Rail would have the option to take back the line at a future date if needed. Yet on December 20th, the last day of submissions for the latest public consultation, he objected to the use of the existing rail track for a greenway. Supporters of the Sligo Greenway say building the greenway parallel to the rail tracks is a non-starter as it would mean the compulsory purchase of land, making it financially unviable. Independent Sligo Cllr Marie Casserly said the about-face by Mr Meade and Irish Rail is 'inexplicable and he (Mr Meade) needs to be asked what new information caused his change of stance, who gave him this new information, and why it was not shared with all the interested parties'. [ Why has it taken so long to develop a greenway for Dublin Bay? Opens in new window ] 'This so-called recommendation only appeared late last year,' Cllr Casserly said. 'There was no prior mention of it in any documentation, and no indication that the project would be halted. Where did this recommendation come from? Who inserted it? Who stands over it?' Ms Casserly said the €1.6 million already committed to the project includes €300,000 from the Department of Transport in December 2020, €400,000 to TII in January 2022 and a further €700,000 in February 2024. She added that the Sligo Greenway has huge support in towns that is proposed to pass through – Coolaney, Tobercurry and Bellaghey – and it could eventually link up with the proposed cross-Border route from Sligo town to Enniskillen, making one of the most comprehensive greenway circuits in Europe. 'This project is a win-win for everyone – delivering a greenway on the old Bellaghy to Collooney railway line that will boost tourism, community wellbeing and sustainable transport. To our knowledge, neither the Minister for Transport, the Taoiseach, nor the Tánaiste have been fully briefed on the matter,' she said. 'This is a unique opportunity to turn past investment into a lasting benefit for the region – creating jobs, attracting visitors, and enhancing quality of life for local communities – a true example of public money delivering real public value.' A spokesman for Mr Canney said the Minister 'has no reason to disagree with Irish Rail', but the decision to cancel had not been made.
