Penang High Court upholds coroner's open verdict in Australian's death case
Jenkins' remains were discovered on June 24, 2020, at a construction site near where she was last seen alive.
According to New Straits Times, Judge Rofiah Mohamad stated that the court had no grounds to overturn the coroner's court decision, as it was based on the evidence presented.
She emphasised that Gregory Steven Jenkins, the deceased's son, had requested in May 2023 for the court to revise the verdict to align with Australian authorities' conclusion, which noted signs of blunt force trauma on his mother's left side.
However, Judge Rofiah noted that the deputy public prosecutor could instruct further investigation into Jenkins' cause of death under the Criminal Procedure Code.
'The site where Annapuranee's bone fragments were found suggests the potential involvement of a third party.
'We will leave it to the prosecutor to decide on further investigation into the cause of death,' she said.
The coroner's court had been unable to determine the cause of death in May 2023 and issued an open verdict.
Judge Rofiah explained that while Gregory had sought a homicide ruling, there was insufficient evidence to make such a determination.
'While the distance where the deceased was last seen and where the remains were found raised the possibility of third-party involvement, this remains speculative and was not proven. No criminal investigation was conducted.'
As a result, the court upheld the open verdict.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
EXPLAINER: How an inquest works and what it means in Zara's death probe
KUALA LUMPUR: The death of Zara Qairina Mahathir has gripped national attention — not only for its tragic circumstances, but also for what comes next: an inquest. Under Malaysian law, an inquest is one of the most important tools for answering the pressing questions after a sudden or suspicious death: What happened? How? And could it have been prevented? Zara, 13, a student at SMKA Tun Datu Mustapha in Sabah, was found unconscious in her dormitory compound in the early hours of July 16. She died the next day in hospital. Today, the Attorney-General's Chambers (A-GC) ordered an inquest into her death, following her family's request to determine whether any criminal element was involved. SUBHEAD: What is an inquest? An inquest is a judicial inquiry conducted by a coroner or magistrate to determine how, when, and where a death occurred — particularly when the circumstances are sudden, unnatural, or suspicious. It is a fact-finding process, not a criminal trial. The coroner does not assign blame or determine guilt, but instead delivers an authoritative account of the events leading to the death, based on witness testimony, forensic reports, and other evidence. SUBHEAD: When is an inquest held? • Sudden, unnatural, or suspicious deaths – such as accidents, suspected suicides, unexplained falls, or possible homicides. • Deaths in custody or official care – including police lock-ups, prisons, immigration detention centres, or psychiatric facilities, to rule out misconduct or negligence. • Cases attracting public interest – where intense public debate or speculation has arisen, an inquest can help clarify facts and dispel misinformation. SUBHEAD: How does an inquest work? When a death meets the legal criteria, Malaysian law mandates an inquest under Section 339(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code. A magistrate acting as coroner conducts open-court hearings to establish the cause, manner, and circumstances of death. Witnesses — from family members to medical experts — may be called to testify. Post-mortem and laboratory reports are examined, and families often engage lawyers to ensure their questions are addressed. At the conclusion, the coroner delivers a verdict such as death by natural causes, misadventure, suicide, homicide, or an "open verdict" if the cause remains unclear. In some cases, coroners also issue recommendations to prevent similar tragedies. SUBHEAD: Why does it matter in Zara's case? Criminal lawyer Datuk N. Sivananthan had said that given the high level of public interest and the swirl of online allegations, an inquest is the most effective way to address concerns and uncover the truth. Even without clear signs of foul play, he said, the inquiry could explore whether factors such as bullying, negligence, or unsafe conditions contributed to Zara's death. The findings, while not directly resulting in criminal charges, may guide police and prosecutors in deciding whether further action is warranted — and will provide an official record for the family and public. SUBHEAD: Learning from past inquests: The Gunung Tahan case In June this year, courts began hearing the Gunung Tahan inquest into the 2022 death of hiker Raja Azlan Shah, affectionately known as Ian. What began as a trek through Malaysia's pristine wilderness ended in tragedy, raising questions about expedition safety and preparedness. During hearings, lawyers for other hikers objected to public commentary about the case, prompting the judge to caution all parties against making statements while proceedings were ongoing. At the heart of that inquest are issues of safety standards, accountability, and whether preventive measures could have saved Raja AzIan's life. In some cases, coroners' recommendations have led to reforms — offering hope that lessons learned might protect others in the future.
The Sun
3 hours ago
- The Sun
AGC orders inquest into Zara Qairina's death
PUTRAJAYA: The Attorney General's Chambers (AGC) has decided to conduct an inquest to determine the cause and circumstances surrounding the death of Form One student Zara Qairina Mahathir. In a statement today, the AGC said the decision was made after reviewing the investigation report submitted by the Royal Malaysia Police in connection with the death of the Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Agama (SMKA) Tun Datu Mustapha student on Aug 12. According to the AGC, the inquest proceedings aim to establish the cause of death and determine whether there were any criminal elements involved. 'This process will be conducted at the Coroner's Court independently and transparently under the provisions of the law,' the statement read. The AGC said the decision to proceed with an inquest was in line with subsection 339(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code [Act 593]. On Aug 8, the AGC said that Zara Qairina's remains needed to be exhumed to allow for a post-mortem to be carried out. It said further investigation by the police was necessary to ensure a thorough probe. Following this, the remains of the 13-year-old, who was buried at the Tanjung Ubi Muslim Cemetery in Kampung Mesapol in Sipitang, Sabah, were exhumed on Aug 9 and taken to Queen Elizabeth I Hospital for the post-mortem before being reburied early Monday at the same cemetery. Zara Qairina was pronounced dead at Queen Elizabeth I Hospital, Kota Kinabalu, on July 17. She had been taken there after being found unconscious in a drain near her school dormitory in Papar at about 4 am on July 16.- Bernama
Daily Express
3 hours ago
- Daily Express
Zara Qairina's family lawyers to seek role in inquest
Published on: Wednesday, August 13, 2025 Published on: Wed, Aug 13, 2025 Text Size: For illustrative purposes only. KOTA KINABALU: Zara Qairina Mahathir's family legal team will apply to be included in the inquest proceedings into her death. They welcomed the Attorney-General's Chambers' decision to hold the inquest under Section 339(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code to determine the cause of death and whether any criminal elements were involved. The lawyers — Shahlan Jufri, Rizwandean M Borhan and Mohd Luqman Syazwan Zabidi — said in a statement on Wednesday that the decision met all the requests made in their 5 August 2025 letter to the Chambers. They expressed hope that the inquest would proceed smoothly and conclude within a short timeframe. The legal team reaffirmed that justice for Zara remains their primary aim in all actions taken on her behalf. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
