
Skorts saga shows backwards thinking in Camogie Association but isn't the only example still around in Ireland
THERE are certain phrases which, when they appear in statements, should set off alarm bells.
They sound like they been devised by so-called communications experts and are often heard from organisations when they find themselves on the back foot.
Advertisement
2
This year's inter-county season has been flung into doubt amid continued player unrest
2
Camogie Association president Brian Molloy tried to explain his organisation's stance earlier this week while appearing on RTE Radio
They are designed to convince you that something is black when your own eyes tell you that it is, in fact, white.
'Player welfare is at the heart of everything we do' is one such phrase.
It is the sort of line might hear from a sporting federation when a player is unable to say what day of the week it is after taking a hit to the head.
Substitute animal for player and it can also be used by, say, a company transporting livestock in cramped conditions for hours on end on their way to the slaughter house.
Advertisement
Read More On GAA
Spoiler alert: The welfare of the player or animal is not always as important as they claim it is but maybe they believe if they repeat it often enough they might convince people, perhaps even themselves, that it is true.
The above line was used by the Camogie Association in the
If the likes of me are sitting up and paying attention to a row within Gaelic games, then you know you are in trouble.
I am well and truly out of my lane and I am curious to see where this drift takes me.
Advertisement
Most read in GAA Hurling
If this continues, expect opinions on farming, period dramas and golf next week.
The Camogie Association's president Brian Molloy may have had a similar sense of discombobulation when he found himself in
'It's a failure on the camogie association' - RTE GAA pundits don't sit on fence over 'no-brainer' skorts saga
We all know that, if you are explaining, you are losing.
And the crux of the matter is that you would struggle to describe this issue to a foreigner who has grown up in a liberal country —
Advertisement
Because how can you begin to explain that, in 2025, in order to compete in a sport it is a requirement for girls and women to wear a hybrid garment which the majority of players dislike?
Maybe it is because girls are used to being told what and what not to wear — how often have you heard a boy be told, 'You're not leaving the house in that'? — that there was just a weary acceptance that this is the way things were and have always been and that resistance is futile.
But, in insisting that Dublin and Kilkenny's players change out of shorts if they wanted their Leinster Championship semi-final to proceed, referee Ray Kelly may have unwittingly done them all a favour.
The Dublin County Board presumably had good intentions in instructing officials to allow matches to proceed even if teams were not donning skorts but, in reality, it was an Irish solution to an Irish problem.
Advertisement
It perpetuated rather than challenged the absurdity of the dress code but, in seeking to apply the rules, Kelly highlighted their ridiculousness to the point that they could no longer be ignored.
MATTER OF TIME
It is not a question of if they will be changed but how and when.
You do not need to be an expert on our native sports to see how the governing body has not handled this well and has suffered reputational damage which may well prove to be irreparable.
Molloy — who said he favours choice in the matter — told This Week: 'There's a process that I've got to go through.
Advertisement
'It's bottom up, not top down, I don't make these decisions, I have to go through a process.'
The process is a Special Congress this month when motions can be tabled to resolve the sport's wardrobe malfunction.
But the notion that it is 'bottom up' is in itself flawed.
Because, as has become clear, not least by the postponement at short notice of the Munster final between Cork and Waterford in an attempt to avoid a stand-off, players have not yet been listened to even though arguably they are bottom of the pile.
Advertisement
Yet it is not they who will decide on the change and there are no guarantees that their voices will be listened to.
If player welfare was, indeed, at the heart of everything they did, then the ongoing situation would not have occurred in the first place.
PLAYER SENTIMENT
Instead, prior to the vote on motions concerning players' attire at the organisation's Annual Congress last year, the opinions of players themselves would have been canvassed.
It is unlikely the results would have differed significantly from the Gaelic Players Association survey released last week which found that 70 per cent of players surveyed had experienced discomfort while wearing a skort, while 83 per cent said they should have a choice between skorts and shorts.
Advertisement
The notion of any sport knowingly endorsing a uniform code which is uncomfortable and, it is not unreasonable to extrapolate, affects performance is just bizarre.
Think of the millions of Euros invested in both kit and equipment across various sports to maximise performance and here is one code which steadfastly sticks with one which inhibits it.
To what end is not exactly clear.
Many who believe that the skort should be the only choice are not particularly good at explaining their position — a sure indication that the position is indefensible — bar mumbling about tradition and femininity.
Advertisement
That stands in sharp contrast to the ability of players to articulate the issues.
Teenage girls canvassed last week spoke of their embarrassment of having to constantly adjust the skort and the unflattering images which can result from making normal sporting movements in it.
And Dublin captain Aisling Maher,
'How are female players still having to push for permission to wear shorts while they compete at the highest level of their sport?
Advertisement
'In no other facet of my life does someone dictate that I have to wear something resembling a skirt because I am a girl. Why is it happening in my sport?'
SCHOOL EXAMPLE
But, while her last point may be true for her as an adult, it is not for thousands of girls up and down the country.
Some schools — including those which are girls-only and have a religious ethos — have had the good sense to offer their female students the choice of wearing trousers rather than skirts if they so wish.
Others have not, so the sight of teenage girls being forced to expose their bare legs to the Irish winter remains a familiar one.
Advertisement
How, in this day and age, can anyone justify that?
The truth is nobody can and, as the skorts issue has shown, all it takes is for a light to be shone upon it for people to realise that it is something which cannot be tolerated any longer.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Irish Sun
26 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Katie Taylor rival gives definitive prediction on who will win third fight versus Amanda Serrano
CLARESSA Shields has backed Katie Taylor to make it 3-0 against Amanda Serrano, citing the Puerto Rican's stubbornness as her kryptonite. The Bray Bomber Advertisement 2 The rivals will throw down for a third time on July 11 Credit: Getty 2 Shields and Serrano are two of only three female boxers to have won world titles across five divisions Credit: Getty Despite having been victorious on both occasions they've duked it out, the close nature of each contest has It will be held at Madison Square Garden just like And Shields reckons a similar result will unfold before the massive global audience that tunes in to watch it on The two-time Olympic gold medallist told Advertisement Read More On Irish Boxing "I mean, Amanda has some underlying issues with me, and saying that I downplay her career. Whatever the f*** she's talking about. "So I don't know what that's about. What I will say is, from my knowledge, Katie Taylor is the better fighter. "And Amanda can beat her! Amanda can beat her. But she won't. You can't teach an old dog new tricks. "And Amanda — I'm not calling her old, because I don't know how old she is. I just know she's older than me — she's stuck in her ways. Advertisement Most read in Boxing "And I think that not only is she stuck in her ways, but her coaches are stuck in their ways too. "You have to look at what the judges saw, and think, 'Okay, even though we feel like we won, we need to fix X, Y, and Z.' But I don't think that she's mentally capable of doing that." Deontay Wilder shows off incredible state-of-the-art home boxing gym ahead of former world champ's return fight Since turning pro in November 2016, the same month as Taylor did, Shields has gone on to The 30-year-old has compiled a record of 16-0 with her last boxing bout coming in February when she cruised to a decision against Danielle Perkins. Advertisement She has fought since then, however, as she Last month though she announced her retirement from Mixed Martial Arts as she intends to go back to putting her full focus on the sweet science of boxing. She mostly fights at light middleweight (154lbs) so between her size and age advantage, it's unlikely she'll ever be matched up against the Wicklow wonder. The most recent news around Taylor's looming fight card came over the weekend when a fighter on the undercard Advertisement Dina Thorslund withdraw from her title unification bout against IBF bantamweight holder Shurretta Metcalf as the unified bantamweight champ revealed that she is expecting her second child. She has relinquished her WBO title. Upon her return to the ring Thorslund may request to be designated mandatory challenger.


The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
GAA fans ‘loved seeing and hearing' the late Micheal O Muircheartaigh as he features in RTE documentary Hell for Leather
GAA documentary series 'Hell for Leather' premiered last night on RTE and featured huge GAA stars. The documentary, which can be streamed on the Advertisement 2 The GAA community has truly missed the Kerryman and his iconic commentary 2 There was delight throughout the country as Ó Muircheartaigh took to our screens again Credit: RTE ONE Fans were particularly delighted to see the great Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh who The legendary commentator shared his insight into the origins of the sport of Gaelic Football in the first episode of the documentary series. He explained what Caid was in the documentary which is believed to be the building blocks of Gaelic football. He said: "Kerry had a game of it's own going way back. This is hundreds of years ago. All you needed was a Caid, a pig's bladder. Advertisement Read more on GAA "There was no control of the numbers that would be involved. "Played on open territories. Parishes would meet in the centre, and then the game would start "It was a hard game, there was no real strict rules." Fans took to social media to praise the first episode of the documentary series. Advertisement Most read in GAA Football Exclusive One fan said: "Loved seeing and listening to Micheál Ó Muircheartaigh once more on this Hell For Leather documentary" Former Down and Kilcoo captain Darragh O'Hanlon simply put: "Hell for Leather what a show." Brendan Cummins defends time-keeping in Munster GAA hurling final between Cork and Limerick Sports journalist Daniel Hussey said: "Excellent first episode of Hell For Leather. Well worth a watch back on RTÉ Player." The documentary series took seven years to reach the screens as it began production as the natural successor to hurling series The Game in 2018. Advertisement The series was unfortunately delayed due to Covid, an All-Ireland final played during a lockdown and the consequences for sport, film-making and life in general during that time. The project was part funded by Coimisiún na Meán, the Department of Finance, the Gaelic Athletic Association and sponsors Collen. The series featured stars such as Brian Fenton, Colm Cooper, David Clifford and Cora Staunton. But fans were most excited to hear legend of the game Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh. The Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh Cup was unveiled Advertisement The Cup is to be given to the winners of the Allianz Football League Division 1 Final. It was unveiled in the build up to the Fittingly, Kerry were crowned champions and captain Gavin White was the first to lift the Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh Cup at Croke Park.


RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Will Smallbone: Ireland players must buy into Heimir Hallgrimsson's belief
Republic of Ireland midfielder Will Smallbone feels the squad must buy into a belief that World Cup qualification is possible ahead of the final warm-up match before the clash with Hungary in September. Amid some of the most miserable times for the nation in terms of both results and performances in this decade, Heimir Hallgrimsson will begin his first outright group campaign with six matches to come in the space of 10 weeks. Hungary, Armenia and new Nations League champions Portugal stand in Ireland's way, with the Boys in Green considered an outsider in the bid to top the group or even secure a play-off. For now, Luxembourg await Ireland tonight in a friendly. Hallgrimsson has referenced reducing the schedule of some players in this window with a view to being fresher for tournament football 12 months later, an eye-opening viewpoint given the current outlook for the side ranked 60th in the world and without qualification for a World Cup since 2002. Smallbone, who played 81 minutes of the 1-1 draw with Senegal after an injury-hit season, believes the mindset is something the players have to pass heed to. "I think the manager's views will always transfer onto the players," he said in an exclusive interview with RTÉ Sport ahead of tonight's friendly. "We've got a real tight-knit group that are looking towards the same goal. "I think we need to believe we can be there. I think we've shown a steady progression over the last few camps and even on Friday, I think against the top nation, it was a good performance from us. "I think we need to be positive, forward-thinking and give ourselves the best opportunity to be there next June. "Winning is what's going to get us to the World Cup. So we need to have winning become a habit. And going into these games, the performance is nice, but I think ultimately winning and getting in the habit of winning is what's best, starting with Luxembourg." Smallbone played in a more defensive midfield role against Senegal, despite the manager indicating he sees him being utilised in a more advanced location on the pitch. The Southampton man, who has 12 caps to his name so far, is happy to operate in either role. The Irish midfield could be about to evolve with Bosun Lawal, Killian Phillips and Jack Taylor making strides in this camp with call-ups and appearances. The competition is welcome, says Smallbone. "Maybe I did end up in more of a defensive role on Friday, but I'm just happy to do whatever. "I think we play with two almost 'old school' midfielders is the best way to describe it, with a licence for one of us to get forward and join up with the attacking play and get in the box. It's enjoyable. "We have our ways when we get the ball to free up our wingers and get crosses into the box and then when defending, it's a bit of a slightly different shape. "The goal for everyone is obviously going to the World Cup and winning games is what's going to get us there. "So I think being defensively sound is a good platform to build off." Smallbone was called up in the Ireland manager's first squad, but having sat out most of the English season, he also lost out on caps in a green shirt. Returning to the squad now, he has noticed some differences. "Obviously it has been a little while for me since I've been in the camp because of injury. "The first camp for me [under Hallgrimsson] was September, so it was all about just starting off the new ideas under the new manager. I missed all the camps in between and to come back here, I could see a real progression in the team strength and the way the team's going. "I think being a bit more harder to beat is one of the main ones. "We've got a lot of the squad maybe coming into their mid to late-20s. "I think that is a good age to really take onus on ourselves, to get ourselves through these [qualification] games. "And we've got enough experience now between us to be able to solve problems on the pitch ourselves and leave ourselves in better situations overall."