logo
Skorts saga shows backwards thinking in Camogie Association but isn't the only example still around in Ireland

Skorts saga shows backwards thinking in Camogie Association but isn't the only example still around in Ireland

The Irish Sun13-05-2025

THERE are certain phrases which, when they appear in statements, should set off alarm bells.
They sound like they been devised by so-called communications experts and are often heard from organisations when they find themselves on the back foot.
Advertisement
2
This year's inter-county season has been flung into doubt amid continued player unrest
2
Camogie Association president Brian Molloy tried to explain his organisation's stance earlier this week while appearing on RTE Radio
They are designed to convince you that something is black when your own eyes tell you that it is, in fact, white.
'Player welfare is at the heart of everything we do' is one such phrase.
It is the sort of line might hear from a sporting federation when a player is unable to say what day of the week it is after taking a hit to the head.
Substitute animal for player and it can also be used by, say, a company transporting livestock in cramped conditions for hours on end on their way to the slaughter house.
Advertisement
Read More On GAA
Spoiler alert: The welfare of the player or animal is not always as important as they claim it is but maybe they believe if they repeat it often enough they might convince people, perhaps even themselves, that it is true.
The above line was used by the Camogie Association in the
If the likes of me are sitting up and paying attention to a row within Gaelic games, then you know you are in trouble.
I am well and truly out of my lane and I am curious to see where this drift takes me.
Advertisement
Most read in GAA Hurling
If this continues, expect opinions on farming, period dramas and golf next week.
The Camogie Association's president Brian Molloy may have had a similar sense of discombobulation when he found himself in
'It's a failure on the camogie association' - RTE GAA pundits don't sit on fence over 'no-brainer' skorts saga
We all know that, if you are explaining, you are losing.
And the crux of the matter is that you would struggle to describe this issue to a foreigner who has grown up in a liberal country —
Advertisement
Because how can you begin to explain that, in 2025, in order to compete in a sport it is a requirement for girls and women to wear a hybrid garment which the majority of players dislike?
Maybe it is because girls are used to being told what and what not to wear — how often have you heard a boy be told, 'You're not leaving the house in that'? — that there was just a weary acceptance that this is the way things were and have always been and that resistance is futile.
But, in insisting that Dublin and Kilkenny's players change out of shorts if they wanted their Leinster Championship semi-final to proceed, referee Ray Kelly may have unwittingly done them all a favour.
The Dublin County Board presumably had good intentions in instructing officials to allow matches to proceed even if teams were not donning skorts but, in reality, it was an Irish solution to an Irish problem.
Advertisement
It perpetuated rather than challenged the absurdity of the dress code but, in seeking to apply the rules, Kelly highlighted their ridiculousness to the point that they could no longer be ignored.
MATTER OF TIME
It is not a question of if they will be changed but how and when.
You do not need to be an expert on our native sports to see how the governing body has not handled this well and has suffered reputational damage which may well prove to be irreparable.
Molloy — who said he favours choice in the matter — told This Week: 'There's a process that I've got to go through.
Advertisement
'It's bottom up, not top down, I don't make these decisions, I have to go through a process.'
The process is a Special Congress this month when motions can be tabled to resolve the sport's wardrobe malfunction.
But the notion that it is 'bottom up' is in itself flawed.
Because, as has become clear, not least by the postponement at short notice of the Munster final between Cork and Waterford in an attempt to avoid a stand-off, players have not yet been listened to even though arguably they are bottom of the pile.
Advertisement
Yet it is not they who will decide on the change and there are no guarantees that their voices will be listened to.
If player welfare was, indeed, at the heart of everything they did, then the ongoing situation would not have occurred in the first place.
PLAYER SENTIMENT
Instead, prior to the vote on motions concerning players' attire at the organisation's Annual Congress last year, the opinions of players themselves would have been canvassed.
It is unlikely the results would have differed significantly from the Gaelic Players Association survey released last week which found that 70 per cent of players surveyed had experienced discomfort while wearing a skort, while 83 per cent said they should have a choice between skorts and shorts.
Advertisement
The notion of any sport knowingly endorsing a uniform code which is uncomfortable and, it is not unreasonable to extrapolate, affects performance is just bizarre.
Think of the millions of Euros invested in both kit and equipment across various sports to maximise performance and here is one code which steadfastly sticks with one which inhibits it.
To what end is not exactly clear.
Many who believe that the skort should be the only choice are not particularly good at explaining their position — a sure indication that the position is indefensible — bar mumbling about tradition and femininity.
Advertisement
That stands in sharp contrast to the ability of players to articulate the issues.
Teenage girls canvassed last week spoke of their embarrassment of having to constantly adjust the skort and the unflattering images which can result from making normal sporting movements in it.
And Dublin captain Aisling Maher,
'How are female players still having to push for permission to wear shorts while they compete at the highest level of their sport?
Advertisement
'In no other facet of my life does someone dictate that I have to wear something resembling a skirt because I am a girl. Why is it happening in my sport?'
SCHOOL EXAMPLE
But, while her last point may be true for her as an adult, it is not for thousands of girls up and down the country.
Some schools — including those which are girls-only and have a religious ethos — have had the good sense to offer their female students the choice of wearing trousers rather than skirts if they so wish.
Others have not, so the sight of teenage girls being forced to expose their bare legs to the Irish winter remains a familiar one.
Advertisement
How, in this day and age, can anyone justify that?
The truth is nobody can and, as the skorts issue has shown, all it takes is for a light to be shone upon it for people to realise that it is something which cannot be tolerated any longer.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Galway boxer 'devastated' as historic GAA Stadium bout cancelled on short notice
Galway boxer 'devastated' as historic GAA Stadium bout cancelled on short notice

Irish Daily Mirror

timean hour ago

  • Irish Daily Mirror

Galway boxer 'devastated' as historic GAA Stadium bout cancelled on short notice

Galway boxer Kieran Molloy has said he is 'devastated' after his Pearse Stadium bout has been cancelled just over two weeks before it was due to take place. Molloy boasts an 11-0 professional record and was set for a headline bout against Kaisee Benjamin at Galway GAA's home stadium but the bout has been called off just 17 days before it was due to take place. The Oughterard man told the Irish Mirror just last week: "I've been dreaming of moments like this since I was a kid." But now his dreams have been shattered. Molloy shared a statement on social media, saying: "I'm devastated to share that my upcoming European Title Fight at Pearse Stadium has been cancelled. The decision was made by the promoter, GBM Sports, and came as a complete shock to me and my team. "This was more than just a fight for me — it was a dream come true to headline a major event in my home county, in front of the people who've backed me from the very start." Molloy added that he sold 2,100 of the 2,500 tickets he had received and that demand was 'growing significantly each day'. "I'm really sorry for the upset, cost and frustration this cancellation has caused." Molloy said that refunds will be issued in due course and that he has parted ways with GBM Sports following the announcement. "This is a tough one to take, but we'll bounce back. Better nights are ahead — and I promise we'll bring something special to Galway one day in the future when the time is right. "Míle, míle buíochas. Gaillimh Abú." The undercard was set to include the likes of Belfast's Sean McComb, Westmeath's Joe Ward, and Hughie Fury, the cousin of heavyweight king Tyson. GBM have now put on a different fight night in Hull on the same night.

Ireland battle but fall short against World No.1 Netherlands in close first encounter
Ireland battle but fall short against World No.1 Netherlands in close first encounter

Irish Examiner

timean hour ago

  • Irish Examiner

Ireland battle but fall short against World No.1 Netherlands in close first encounter

Netherlands 2-0 Ireland Ireland resumed their FIH Pro League season with a close encounter against World No.1 and Olympic champions the Netherlands in Amstelveen. A strong performance from a battling Ireland saw them enjoy long periods of possession and create several chances in front of goal. However, two fortunate goals for the Netherlands saw the home side secure a 2-0 win. The Netherlands threatened from early in the match, with defender Lee Cole called into action almost immediately to clear the ball off the line from an early chance. Ireland responded positively, holding possession well and managing to progress into the Dutch final third, with Ben Walker making his way into the circle, followed by a blocked shot from Alistair Empey. Ireland continued to dominate possession, but a rare chance for the Dutch called Jaime Carr into action to make a smart save. Thierry Brinkman thought he had broken the deadlock with a reverse stick shot but Ireland immediately opted to refer for backstick, which the video umpire agreed with chalking the goal off, seeing the sides end the opening quarter locked at 0-0. Early Dutch pressure again forced Ireland to defend resolutely, answering any questions asked from them. Luke Madeley responded by dribbling out of defence to break the Dutch press, allowing Ireland to mount an attack that ended in Ali Empey drawing a clumsy challenge and winning the first penalty corner of the tie. Luke Madeley's subsequent effort was well blocked by the Dutch first runner. Ireland continued to ask questions of the Dutch, with incisive runs from Fearghus Gibson and Daragh Walsh providing chances. However, a controversial penalty corner for the Netherlands offered them a chance to open the scoring, which Luke Dommershuijzen dispatched to score his first senior goal. Late pressure from the Netherlands in the first half threatened to widen the gap, but a superb block from Matthew Nelson and further defending denied them their second as the sides went into the break. Ireland got the second half underway and immediately looked to attack. Positive play in the final third led to a shot from Lee Cole inside the first minute, but his strike was deemed dangerous, and the Netherlands were given a free out. Patience in possession for Ireland continued to pay dividends, as Matthew Nelson attacked the circle and was unlucky not to get an outcome. The Netherlands, however, showed their goalscoring prowess to double their lead from their first chance of the second half, Steijn van Heijningen deflecting the ball into the net with the deftest of touches. Ireland, though, were determined to continue their positive performance, immediately winning a penalty corner which, again, the Netherlands defended well. Ireland followed this up with another well-worked attacking move which, again, the Dutch cleared. A late flurry of penalty corners before the end of the third quarter called the Irish defence into action again, denying the hosts on three occasions to keep the score at 2-0 at the end of quarter 3. The Netherlands found a higher gear in the final quarter, enjoying longer periods of pressure and manufacturing a handful of shots at goal which Jaime Carr was alive to. Ireland's determination would continue to show with Ali Empey winning Ireland their third penalty corner of the game. Lee Cole's resulting effort was saved and cleared. A penalty corner for the Netherlands inside the final five minutes offered the last moment of note of the game, with Jaime Carr again making a save, to see the game finish in a two-nil win for the Dutch, with the result seeing them extend their lead at the top of the FIH Pro League table to 7 points. The pair will meet again tomorrow, June 12, at 7pm.

US Open: Scheffler the man to beat, Lowry better primed than distracted McIlroy
US Open: Scheffler the man to beat, Lowry better primed than distracted McIlroy

The 42

time2 hours ago

  • The 42

US Open: Scheffler the man to beat, Lowry better primed than distracted McIlroy

YOU'LL BE HEARING a lot this week about 'the greatest test in golf', as the organisers of the US Open take their historic championship back to Oakmont in Pittsburgh, whose founding principle was to be the most challenging golf course in America. And so the 2025 US Open may cross the threshold from test to outright trial. The rough is long and knottier than the tree lights you took down from your attic last Christmas; the greens are slippery and more sloped than even those at Augusta National; and the eighth hole is the longest par-three in major championship history. Speaking on Golf Channel on Tuesday, the long-serving former head pro Bob Ford was asked to describe the typical member at Oakmont. 'Sadistic', he replied. The whole set-up is designed, ultimately, to have pro golfers break out in the kind of cold sweats they otherwise reserve for the prospect of a tougher tax regime in Florida. Jon Rahm said on Tuesday he expects the winning score to be over-par if the rain stays away. Rory McIlroy played a practice round last Monday week and birdied the final two holes to card an 81. While the course has been deluged by rain in the weeks leading up to the tournament, the forecast for the opening days of action is more agreeable, although the weekend face the risk of disruption from thunderstorms. Without this rain, says McIlroy, the course would have been 'impossible.' There are only two Irish golfers in the field, as all of Seamus Power, Graeme McDowell, Tom McKibbin and Padraig Harrington failed to make it through qualifying. Organisers have handily paired them together, and so McIlroy and Shane Lowry will play alongside each other and Justin Rose, teeing off early on Thursday and among the late wave on Friday. McIlroy playing alongside Rose evokes easily-accessed memories of the Masters, and trust McIlroy to take the aftermath as interesting as it could possibly have been. He spoke from Augusta in April of feeling freed from the burden of his long major drought; McIlroy was, in his own words, now playing with house money. Er, not so. He barely made the cut at a bizarrely surly PGA Championship, at which he swerved media interviews amid annoyance at the leaking of the fact he had to change his non-conforming driver, and then missed the cut by a mile at last week's Canadian Open with what was, in strokes gained terms, the second-worst round of his career. McIlroy missed the cut the last time this tournament was held at Oakmont, which started a three-year run of missed cuts at the US Open. His reaction to this run is one of the more underrated aspects of his career, and he has been freakishly consistent at the tournament since. He has been in the top-10 in each of the last six years, finishing as runner-up in each of the last two editions. Advertisement Maintaining that consistency this week rests on him finding form off the tee. His driving accuracy across each of his last three events has been abysmal, and a failure to find fairways at Oakmont will mean an early end to his challenge. Having tried a new driver in Canada, McIlroy has switched up his equipment once again this week. 'I feel a little better with the driver over the weekend at home and even today playing a practice round, so hopefully I can hit a few more fairways than I have been hitting and give myself some opportunities', said McIlroy at his Tuesday afternoon press conference. A bigger question is the inner drive. McIlroy admitted ahead of the Canadian Open he had been finding it hard to have the same motivation to grind on the range now that he's achieved all he had set out to do. Speaking to the press this week, McIlroy didn't give the impression of a man who has re-fixed a maniacal focus on golf. 'I think chasing a certain goal for the better part of a decade and a half, I think I'm allowed a little bit of time to relax a little bit. But here at Oakmont, I certainly can't relax this week', before then talking of how one of his goals this year was to take up more hobbies and see more of the world, and so he's joined caddie Harry Diamond and manager Niall O'Connor for their on-the-road tennis matches. His playing partner, by contrast, arrives in much more consistent form, albeit appearing increasingly tortured by his inability to get over the line on Sunday. Lowry had a galling close shave at the Truist Championship the week before the PGA Championship, at which he missed the cut on one of his least favourite courses on Earth. He made a stunning Sunday start in Canada last week – five-under through his first four holes – only to cool off too early to catch the later starters. Lowry is less daunted than most by Oakmont, where in 2016 he took a four-shot lead into the final day only to shoot a round of six-over 76 to finish in a tie for second, three shots off winner Dustin Johnson. Lowry is a much better player now, though, and this is a course which will reward his accuracy off the tee – where he ranks among the top-30 on the PGA Tour – along with the quality of his iron play and his hands around the green, where greenside rough will reward only the very best. His contention will rest, though, on how he performs on the greens: he has shown an ability to catch fire with his putter, but these sprawling, sloping greens are redolent of those at Augusta National, on which Lowry has occasionally struggled. That said, Lowry arrives in a better position to contend than McIlroy. Their biggest issue for all may not be the brute of the course, but Scottie Scheffler. Having made a slow(ish) start to the season after hand surgery in the off-season, Scheffler is once again the dominant man in the sport: he has won on three of his last four starts and arrives exuding that air of apparent invincibility. Given Scheffler's awesome form, the brutality of the Oakmont test may ultimately be a favour to everybody else in the field. Scheffler has never won this championship, though victory this week will see him rocking up to Portrush next month seeking to complete the career Grand Slam. Scottie Scheffler: 2025 PGA Championship winner. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo Who can stop him? Jon Rahm finally returned to relevance at a major championship with his Sunday charge at Quail Hollow, where his finishing score did not reflect the pressure he exerted on Scheffler. He has the muscle to deal with the Oakmont rough, along with the form to compete. Bryson DeChambeau has meanwhile 3D-printed a new set of irons in the hope he can successfully defend his title this week: at the Masters and Quail Hollow, he contended despite his ball-striking, rather than because of it. Oakmont, though, is going to be too tough to hide any aspect of your game. DeChambeau is now undoubtedly the most popular player in the game, thanks mainly to his YouTube videos, which he says has given him a new lease of life on the course. 'I view my legacy as not just winning golf tournaments', DeChambeau told the press on Tuesday. 'I view it as how much good can I do for the game outside of playing professionally. That's a metric that I hold myself up to. 'The start is YouTube, but there is so much more that's coming down the line, and that's also what gets me up every day, as well.' Elsewhere within that press conference he began some megaphone negotiations with LIV over a contract renewal – 'They see the value in me. I see the value in what they can provide' – explained if he hadn't been a golfer he would be working on how AI will be integrated into biomechanics and hailed his own business sense with the deathless line that his Crushers LIV team have been 'EBIDTA positive for the past two years.' (LIV golf is hardly leaning into the traditional partisanship of other team sports. EBIDTA positive. . . you'll never sing that.') DeChambeau will be the most popular man on the golf course, though Scheffler is, as ever, the man to beat. The greater the test, the more likely the best player is to emerge from the field. And the best player by a street is Scottie Scheffler. Tips Gavin Cooney A winner not named Scottie Scheffler: Jon Rahm (9/1) A solid, make-your-money-back e/w bet: Harris English (55/1) A wild outsider who might make you a fortune: Aaron Rai (75/1) Fintan O'Toole A winner not named Scottie Scheffler: Xander Schuaffele (18/1) A solid, make-your-money-back e/w bet: Harris English (55/1) A wild outsider who might make you a fortune: Rasmus Hojgaard (150/1)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store