Lebanese prosecutors appeal against sentences for private Seán Rooney murder
The appeals include the sentences handed down for the attempted killing of Trooper Shane Kearney, Corporal Joshua Phelan and Trooper Nathan Bryan.
The main defendant at the military tribunal in Beirut was last month sentenced to death, but Simon Harris wrote to the Lebanese Government following the trial to express the disappointment of the Irish Government and in particular of the Rooney family at the leniency of the sentences handed down across the board.
While capital punishment is a legal sanction in Lebanon, reports suggest there has been a moratorium on executions since 2004.
The main defendant, Mohammad Ayyad, was absent from the proceedings as he was convicted at the military court last month, it is understood.
Mr Harris met with Private Rooney's family last week and committed to "holding urgent talks with the Lebanese Justice and Defence Ministers in order to press for an appeal".
Those talks took place on Tuesday, according to a statement, with Mr Harris telling Private Rooney's mother, Natasha McCloskey, that a number of steps have been taken.
This include:
- The appointment of a new military chief prosecutor who now will take over the case;
- An appeal against the sentences being formally lodged with the military Cassation Court;
- The Lebanese authorities committing to taking urgent steps to ensure the individual convicted of the murder of Private Rooney is taken into custody.
Mr Harris said: 'I very much welcome the confirmation today from the Lebanese Justice and Defence Ministers that an appeal has been formally lodged against the sentences handed down in the case of the death of Private Seán Rooney and the injuries of his colleagues.
'I have this afternoon spoken with Seán's mother, Natasha, who I was pleased also to meet last week.
'In my calls with my Lebanese counterparts, I made it clear that the sentences handed down in this case are simply not acceptable and are very disappointing.
'They have caused great upset and insult to the Rooney family and everything must be done to ensure justice is served for Seán and his colleagues who were injured.'
Pte Rooney, who was 24 and from Newtowncunningham, Co Donegal, was killed while on UN duty when the armoured vehicle he was driving from south Lebanon to Beirut came under fire in December 2022. Several others were injured in the attack.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
27 minutes ago
- Sunday World
Ian Bailey's solicitor welcomes any DNA breakthroughs in Sophie Tuscan du Plantier case
It is hoped that that any evidence obtained will allow Forensic Science Ireland to make comparisons with DNA samples The solicitor of the late Ian Bailey has welcomed any breakthrough in the case of the murder of Sophie Tuscan du Plantier that could come from an advanced method of DNA collection. A garda cold case team is awaiting a report on whether M Vac Systems, a US DNA collection expert which has been used in a number of murder cases in the US, could identify her killer, according to The Irish Times. Exhibits being tested include the flat rock and large cavity block found at the scene and Ms Toscan du Plantier's dressing gown, leggings, vest and boots. It is hoped that that any evidence obtained will allow Forensic Science Ireland to make comparisons with DNA samples from some 10 people identified as suspects during the original Garda investigation. Speaking to RTÉ's This Week, solicitor Frank Buttimer said his former client had 'voluntarily provided DNA to establish his innocence' many years ago. Solicitor Frank Buttimer He described it as 'extraordinary' and 'worrying' that any alleged link or connection could be proposed given the passage of time and the fact the late Mr Bailey is 'not around to defend his name'. Asked whether the information should be made public in the event Mr Bailey's DNA is found at the scene, Mr Buttimer said: 'I'm sure that in certain quarters there would be a rush to provide such information. "Because in my belief, and certainly in my experience, that within certain sections of the police, there is still this ongoing belief that there is some kind of a link or connection between Mr Bailey and the crime that he has denied throughout his life from the time onwards that it happened, but I suspect that that would certainly emerge into the public domain for one reason or another. He said there has 'always been a rush to put Mr Bailey's name out there as being connected with this offence in certain quarters'. Sophie Tuscan Du Plantier. Picture by Patrick Zimmermann/AFP via Getty Images Mr Buttimer said there would be legal implications in the event that a suspect is identified. "Insofar as Ian Bailey is concerned, we have this thing in Irish law called the presumption of innocence. Ian Bailey is presumed innocent by the State of Ireland,' he said. "He was never prosecuted, as we know, a completely spurious case was taken against him in France, where he was found guilty, but that was a predictable event. "Were it to be the case that DNA points the finger in some other quarter, perhaps the French who were so vigorous in their pursuit of him might take time to reflect upon what happened to Ian Bailey during the course of his life." He said Mr Bailey was 'always hounded and pursued over the 27 or 28 years from the time of that dreadful crime to the time of his death, it destroyed his life.' Asked whether the DNA testing could provide a breakthrough in the case, Mr Buttimer said his understanding is that the technology has not been tested in the Irish courts. "The one thing that would be of concern to me would have been the idea that he's just not around to defend himself, if there was any suggestion of any connection between him and the sampling.' He said DNA evidence can be 'challenged' in certain circumstance and it is 'not the be all and end all of criminal investigation and forensic assessment'. "I would absolutely say that every avenue should be pursued of any inquiry that's available to get to the truth of this appalling crime,' he added. "It's a stain on on us, really, and it's a stain on our policing and our system. And if anything can be done, even at this late stage, I would absolutely welcome that.' British journalist Ian Bailey. Photo: Collins Today's News in 90 Seconds - 17 August
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Group that helped Ukrainians and hosts warns of rise in exploitation since it got defunded
A GRASSROOTS SCHEME that was contracted to help provide accommodation to Ukrainian people in Ireland has said that its contract with the Irish Red Cross has not been renewed. The group, Helping Irish Hosts, says it fears that exploitation of both hosts and Ukrainian people could rise as a result. Helping Irish Hosts was formed by a group of hosts in response to the crisis that arose following the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. For 18 months it has operated a hotline that gave advice to hosts and temporary protection beneficiaries in Ireland and received more than 80 calls a day on average. They also helped Ukrainians and hosts to connect and provided ongoing supports and resources to people living in Ireland under hosting arrangements. Angie Gough, the CEO and founder of the organisation, told The Journal that Helping Irish Hosts had made the case to continue on its work as the number of payments being made to households under the scheme is at its highest level ever. 'We had 26 people working part-time and a hotline that operated for 40 hours a week. We are still operating that for two hours a week on a voluntary basis. We were working on a scale equivalent to the National Women's Council, and had an average of 85 calls a day. The demand didn't go, but that hotline is gone now,' she said. She said that the organisation made the case for continuing on its work due to ongoing demand but its contract was not renewed. The Irish Red Cross told The Journal that the charity is the lead service provider for the Ukraine Pledged Accommodation Programme and that it operates the programme under 'specific direction' from the Department of Justice. A spokesperson said that earlier this year, Helping Irish Hosts shared its desire for a 'strategic shift in the programme', adding 'which is their right'. 'This change did not align with the agreed direction of the programme. The programme's scope of work and funding remain unchanged,' the Irish Red Cross added. Advertisement It said that it wants to acknowledge the work Helping Irish Hosts has done in placing people in accommodation and supporting their placements. The Department of Justice has allocated €4,538,506 to the Irish Red Cross for 2025 for providing supports including the management of accommodation pledged by the Irish public. The Department of Justice said that the Accommodation Recognition Payment (ARP) scheme is being administered by the Department of Social Protection on its behalf and that while the Irish Red Cross has no role in the administration of that scheme, it is contracted to support the State's humanitarian response to the Ukraine crisis. 'The Department has funded the Irish Red Cross to deliver a programme of accommodation and integration supports for those who fled the war in Ukraine,' a spokesperson said. They added that information on the amount of funding provided to the Irish Red Cross in previous years is not available. Last month The Journal reported that there has been a considerable rise in the numbers involved in the scheme. Since January of this year, an additional 3,125 payments have been made to property owners. At the same time, the Government has ended contracts with over one hundred accommodation centres that have returned to their original use, which has led to Ukrainian people seeking hosted accommodation in areas where they have integrated over the last two years. Sinn Féin has called for a review of the scheme . Gough has previously stated that a rise in the number of 'solo hosts' who are not arranging their accommodation through the Irish Red Cross register of pledged accommodation means that there is now more room for both hosts and Ukrainians to be exploited. In cases that Helping Irish Hosts dealt with in the past, Ukrainian people were being charged rent and excessive 'top-up payments' despite property owners receiving payments under the scheme. 'People opt to go outside of the scheme and make their own arrangements as they feel that the scheme is too onerous and there can be a lack of response from agencies involved, and it will be worse now that we aren't there in that space. 'We could see the rise in independent hosts from early doors, and it was matched in the amount of difficult cases we would see, because we were the only ones servicing that space,' Gough said. She said that the landscape for hosting has changed in Ireland and that 'opportunities have been lost' in terms of widening the scheme out and offering it to people who want to host refugees from countries like Palestine and Afghanistan. 'How the Government thinks that everybody can be accommodated in people's homes indefinitely without support and resources and someone helping them to identify clear pathways forward, I don't know,' she added. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Indian community celebrates independence day in Dublin
HUNDREDS OF PEOPLE have participated in an event marking India Day in Dublin, as gardaí and the government sought to assure the community it was taking action against racially motivated crime. The free event at Merrion Square came despite a separate celebration being called off following concern over recent attacks on the Indian community. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has expressed concern over 'totally unacceptable' attacks on the Indian community, adding that the majority appear to have been carried out by young people. O'Callaghan said he engaged extensively with the Garda commissioner on the matter, and senior investigating officers had been assigned to investigate all reported incidents. Sunday's celebration, organised for India's 79th independence day, featured music, dance, food stalls, exhibition stands and a range of cultural activities. Sanjeeb Barik, the secretary of organising group the Federation of Indian Communities in Ireland, said the event had gone well amid 'fantastic and beautiful weather'. 'Lots of people are here, there's food and dancing and lots of fun.' Asked about the engagement with government and gardaí, Barik said the event had received 'good support'. Speaking to the PA news agency, he said: 'Naturally, because there has been so many incidents there was some concern. 'We have been actively discussing with ministers, junior ministers and the Minister of Justice and they have all assured us that appropriate safety measures would be in place – and they are. 'We're working very closely to make sure everyone would be safe and, importantly, that it would be enjoyable for everyone.' Barik said they wanted to go ahead with the celebrations to send a message about the importance of standing together. Advertisement 'It has been a challenging time but the main thing is to come together as a community and celebrate our heritage 'There are people from all backgrounds here – Indian, Irish and others – from all over the the island. 'It is about the strength of bonding and sowing the richness of India and Ireland's multicultural spirit.' He added: 'We are saying come together, stand together. Celebrate unity and diversity – and I hope that will continue.' L-R: Areet Kaur Chandi, seven, Japleen Kaur, 10, and Preety Singh, eight, join People attending the India Day Festival at Merrion Square Park, Dublin. PA / Alamy Stock Photo PA / Alamy Stock Photo / Alamy Stock Photo Inspector Ciaran Nunan from the Garda diversity unit said hate crimes are attacks on the whole community. 'The mission statement of An Garda Siochana is keeping people safe, and this refers to individuals, families, communities and society as a whole. 'It also now includes hate crime. Hate crime is not just an attack on a person, it's an attack on the community. 'An Garda Siochana is very aware of the impact that hate crime has upon individuals and communities, and we take it very, very seriously. 'Since our last India Day celebration last year, we now have hate crime legislation in force and we're applying that legislation at every opportunity – but we need people to report incidents of hate crime to us so that we can then take them on board and react to those.' He added: 'So I would encourage everybody or anybody that perceives to be a victim of a hate crime to please report it to An Garda Síochána, and allow us to continue what we're doing and work with our communities to keep people safe.' The Dublin event was attended by Akhilesh Mishra, ambassador of India to Ireland, and Minister of State Emer Higgins. The Ireland India Council, a separate group, said there had been an organised social media campaign against the Indian community in the country and the number of violent attacks has intensified since January. Last week, it said it took the 'difficult' decision to postpone its planned event at Farmleigh House over concerns for the safety of the community.
