Osteopath treating woman who refused chemo advised medical help, inquest hears
Her mother, Kay 'Kate' Shemirani, who rose to prominence on social media while sharing Covid-19 conspiracy theories, was involved in her daughter's alternative 'treatment programme'.
On Wednesday, osteopath Nick Gosset who saw Paloma on July 19 2024, the day that she collapsed and was taken to hospital by air ambulance, advised her to seek further medical support, the inquest at Kent and Medway Coroner's Court, in Maidstone, Kent heard.
He said that when he inspected her he could feel lumps in her right shoulder going all the way up into her neck, which he identified as lymphoid mass and that he 'had never seen anything like it' in 43 years of practice.
Mr Gosset told the court: 'It was obvious to me that I was not the right person to be helping her, normally you see a patient like that you would refer her (to a GP).
'Any referral was refused – when I suggested that the proper avenue of approach was through a normal medical channel she dismissed it.
'I felt I was presented with a young woman – and I'm not an expert in this, my field is biomechanics – a young lady who was in the last stages of a very difficult disease, and she had declined to engage with conventional treatment.'
He added that he felt 'aggrieved' that he had been put in that professional position.
'I was left with no good choices and the only choice I felt I had at the time was to offer her the opportunity to return where I might be able to persuade her of the importance of seeking further medical support,' said Mr Gosset.
Arunodaya Mohan, a consultant haematologist at Maidstone Hospital, told Paloma in 2023 that she had an 80% chance of recovery if she had chemotherapy, the inquest heard previously.
Ms Shemirani told the court that she did not believe the osteopath had that conversation with her daughter, as they were 'very close' and Paloma did not tell her after the session.
When asked how he felt when he was told of Paloma's death he said: 'I think I was horrified,' before clarifying that he was surprised by the rapidity but not by her death.
'I was well aware that she was extremely ill … I did not feel that she needed immediate medical support,' said Mr Gosset.
Yesterday, Paloma's GP told the court that conditions were in place that if Paloma felt any change in her condition, including shortness of breath, she would seek conventional medical attention.
Mr Gosset told the coroner that Ms Shemirani was exhibiting those symptoms on the day he saw her.
He said: 'May I observe that in the evidence of the GP yesterday that there was a clear understanding made that should Paloma's situation deteriorate and that included any shortness of breath that there would be an immediate response to call the emergency services or present to A&E.'
He added that 'she came to me with just such a change in situation' and told Ms Shemirani: 'I have to say that I am deeply aggrieved that you should put me in that professional position.'
The inquest continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
an hour ago
- Metro
Lyme disease destroyed my life - it all started with a tick
Nine years ago, my life turned upside down. In 2016, aged 31, I went on a solo trip travelling the world. I started in South America, followed by New Zealand, ending up in Asia and India. It was an amazing experience, but I had no idea that I would contract Lyme disease and have my life changed beyond recognition. It is because of my experience that I can empathise so whole-heartedly with Justin Timberlake, who has revealed his diagnosis. I can't exactly remember when I was bitten by a tick but, that May when I was in Thailand, I had a circular rash over the back of my legs – it wasn't painful or itchy so I put it down to an allergic reaction and carried on. But in India six months later, I fell ill with digestive issues and excruciating pains in my legs. I couldn't stand, let alone walk, and I flew back to the UK. I didn't know what was happening to me – and being alone in a foreign country I was terrified. Although I was due to start a new job back home, I felt too poorly to work and I spent several weeks in bed with flu-like symptoms. I deteriorated, and spent the next few months in and out of hospital. I was kept in isolation for a while as medics initially thought I had contracted a tropical disease – after that it was a long road to being diagnosed with Lyme disease. In March of 2017, I was initially diagnosed with Stage IV endometriosis, and I had several surgeries, including a hysterectomy. I thought my problems would be sorted. That was a year of treatment, and by the following spring my pain had hugely improved, but I was still battling a host of debilitating symptoms, including seizures, shortness of breath, migraines, and insomnia. Bites aren't always painful, so it's important to check your skin for ticks and bites after you've been outdoors The distinctive red rash associated with Lyme disease is circular and forms a pattern not unlike a bullseye Find out more I couldn't leave my flat, and I struggled to walk between rooms – my mum stayed with me throughout this time to look after me. I began to suffer from anxiety, OCD, panic attacks and depression. Between 2018 and 2020, I went back-and-forth to doctors, with none able to figure out what was wrong. My experiences were put down to the fact I was recovering from the surgeries I had and mental health issues – with one GP even telling me my symptoms were from loneliness because I lived on my own. But I knew something was seriously wrong. I could see the stark contrast in me between pre- and post-travels and – when I kept fighting for a diagnosis, it was my nutritionist Laila, who had helped me through my endometriosis, that raised the possibility of Lyme disease. She encouraged me to push for a different kind of diagnostic test; it eventually came back highly positive for Borrelia, the bacteria that causes Lyme disease, an infection caught from the bite of an infected tick. That was in March 2020, shortly before the world shut down due to Covid. I was shocked but it was also a relief to know I wasn't crazy and there was a cause to my symptoms. I had been right all along. I felt validated. I can't even begin to express how powerful it was for someone to say they believed me. Had I been diagnosed straight away or known about the risk of Lyme Disease it would have been treatable with a few weeks of antibiotics. Instead, I've been housebound, largely bedbound, for nine years and use a wheelchair for appointments. Lyme Disease when undiagnosed, or diagnosed as late as mine was, is notoriously difficult to treat, and can develop into Chronic Lyme Disease – also known as late stage Lyme Disease. Nine years on from that bite, I've still not reached remission. I have tried various treatments including oral antibiotics, five weeks of IV antibiotics, and have even tried alternative and herbal medicines. Lyme Disease has caused so much loss for me. I lost my career when I stopped working in January 2017, mine and my mum's savings were spent on private treatments, and my independence. I've lost most of my friends after being unable to see them, my social life, my self worth and confidence and my life as I knew it. But something that has really helped me, as well as my family support and counsellor, is finding a focus, which is something I stumbled on accidentally – writing poetry. I started writing one night when I was wide awake with insomnia and it was cathartic to see my thoughts just come out in a poem. I was encouraged by my mum and my counsellor to enter a UK competition – winning first place! Since then I have written countless poems – it's therapeutic to get thoughts out that I have difficulty expressing verbally. But I want to stop anyone else suffering like I have. I hope that more people become aware of what to do if they get bitten and know how to protect themselves from Lyme. More Trending There are several things you need to know like what a tick looks like, the type of rash you may get, and how to remove a tick. The best place to go for advice on all of this is the Lyme Disease UK website. Personally, while I have a long way to go, I hope one day I can reach remission like others that have been in my position and start to slowly rebuild the life that Lyme Disease has torn apart. View More » This article was fist published on July 13, 2023. Do you have a story you'd like to share? Get in touch by emailing Share your views in the comments below. MORE: The school special needs crisis that will impact every one of us MORE: Never heard of bruxism? You're probably suffering from it MORE: I played 'check-in chicken' and it backfired spectacularly – be careful Your free newsletter guide to the best London has on offer, from drinks deals to restaurant reviews.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Health Rounds: Artificial sweetener consumption linked to less effective cancer treatment
Aug 1 (Reuters) - (This is an excerpt of the Health Rounds newsletter, where we present latest medical studies on Tuesdays and Thursdays. To receive the full newsletter in your inbox for free sign up here.) In patients with melanoma or non-small cell lung cancer, consuming high levels of the artificial sweetener sucralose contributes to diminished responses to immunotherapy and poorer survival, researchers reported in Cancer Discovery, opens new tab. When the researchers had 132 patients with advanced melanoma or non-small cell lung cancer answer detailed diet history questionnaires, they found that high consumption of sucralose was linked with lower effectiveness of immunotherapies across a range of cancer types, stages and treatment methods. In experiments with mice, the researchers found that sucralose shifts the composition of microbes in the intestines, increasing bacterial species that degrade arginine, an amino acid that is essential for key immune cells called T cells. 'When arginine levels were depleted due to sucralose-driven shifts in the microbiome, T cells couldn't function properly,' study leader Abby Overacre of the University of Pittsburgh said in a statement. 'As a result, immunotherapy wasn't as effective in mice that were fed sucralose.' Laying the groundwork for a solution to the problem, the same researchers also found in the mice that supplements that boosted levels of arginine mitigated the negative effects of sucralose on immunotherapy, an approach they now hope to test in humans. 'It's easy to say, 'Stop drinking diet soda,' but when patients are being treated for cancer, they are already dealing with enough, so asking them to drastically alter their diet may not be realistic,' Overacre said. 'That's why it's so exciting that arginine supplementation could be a simple approach to counteract the negative effects of sucralose on immunotherapy.' LOW-GRADE IS NOT THE SAME AS LOW-RISK IN PROSTATE CANCER A low-grade prostate tumor is not necessarily low-risk, new research suggests. Biopsy results showing low-grade prostate cancers can sometimes lead to underestimation of disease risk and omission of surgery or radiation in patients who might benefit from such treatments, researchers warned in JAMA Oncology, opens new tab. Among roughly 117,000 men in their study with prostate biopsy results indicating a Grade Group 1, or GG1, tumor – the slowest-growing kind - one in six had intermediate- or high-risk cancer when other factors such as prostate-specific antigen levels in the blood and tumor sizes were also considered, according to the report. Such higher risk cancers are often treated with radiation therapy or removal of the prostate, the researchers noted. 'We don't want to miss aggressive cancers that initially present as Grade Group 1 on biopsy,' study coauthor Dr. Bashir Al Hussein of Weill Cornell Medicine said in a statement. 'Such underestimation of risk could lead to undertreatment and poor outcomes.' Current guidelines that advise regular monitoring – rather than treatment – for men with low-grade prostate tumors were based on studies that examined entire prostate glands after removal from patients. Biopsies test only small areas of the prostate, so they can miss more advanced or aggressive cancer cells, providing an incomplete picture, the researchers said. Some cancer experts have been suggesting recently that GG1 tumors are so slow-growing that they shouldn't even be considered malignant. The new study results could help inform those discussions, the researchers said. 'There is a misunderstanding that low grade and low risk are the same," study coauthor Dr. Jonathan Shoag of Case Western Reserve University said in a statement. "Here, we show clearly that they are not.' (To receive the full newsletter in your inbox for free sign up here)
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
‘Suspicious' antivax mum accuses paramedics of ‘killing' model daughter after she refused ‘lifesaving' cancer treatment
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) CONSPIRACY theorist Kay "Kate" Shemirani has accused paramedics of killing her daughter after she refused lifesaving cancer treatment, an inquest has heard. Paloma Shemirani, a 23-year-old University of Cambridge graduate, collapsed on July 19 last year and was taken to Royal Sussex County Hospital. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 9 Paloma Shemirani died from a heart attack after being diagnosed with cancer Credit: Facebook 9 Paloma's mum, Kate, is a notorious anti-vaxxer and conspiracy theorist Credit: Alamy 9 The 23-year-old turned down treatment for non-Hodgkin lymphoma Credit: Facebook She died just five days later, on July 24 of a heart attack. Just months earlier, Paoloma, who was a finalist in Miss Universe Great Britain 2021, had declined treatment for non-Hodgkin lymphoma - a type of blood cancer which starts in the lymph nodes. Her mother, Kate who rose to prominence on social media while sharing Covid-19 conspiracy theories, said her daughter "deteriorated catastrophically" when paramedics intervened. Kate, who was involved in Paloma's "alternative treatment" called her friend before calling an ambulance the day her daughter collapsed, the inquest at Kent and Medway Coroner's Court in Maidstone, heard. Read more on Paloma TRAGIC DEATH Mum 'sacrificed' daughter for her anti-vax views' after she turned down chemo On Wednesday, reading a prepared witness statement, she accused the inquest of "attempting to shift focus" from the "real" cause of Paloma's death. "Any attempt to place responsibility on me is false - the people who need to be answering are those who failed to confirm diagnosis, administered drugs without her consent which could have damaged her heart," said Kate. Kate told the court that a "sequence of medical actions" caused her daughter's death, which she claimed amounted to "gross negligence manslaughter". She claims that while in hospital in December 2023, Paloma was given medication without her consent and felt "pressured and bullied" by medical staff. "I became very suspicious and deeply concerned about what was happening," Kate told the coroner. Paloma's twin brother, Gabriel Shemirani, suggests that when Paloma was first diagnosed, she was considering chemotherapy, before their parents started to pressure her against it. Son of anti-vax nurse being probed by cops for comparing NHS medics to Nazis slams 'arrogant' mum Kate was struck off as a nurse in 2021, having qualified in the 1980s and a Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) committee found she had spread Covid-19 misinformation that "put the public at a significant risk of harm". After her stay in hospital in December 2023, Paloma began an alternative treatment programme which included daily coffee enemas, a strict diet and green juices, the inquest heard previously. "Paloma made her own treatment choices based on her values, research and experiences," said Kate. She added that her daughter was "never a victim of coercion" and that she "continued to improve physically" under her alternative medicines. "She was determined to get well on her own terms and this is well documented in her own high court statement which was read out in this coroner's hearing" said Kate. On the day she collapsed, she had an appointment with an osteopath, Nick Gosset, who described her on Wednesday as "a young lady who was in the last stages of a very difficult disease" and said he advised she seek medical help. 9 Paloma's twin brother, Gabriel Shemirani, previously blamed Kate for her death Credit: PA 9 Paloma was considered chemo before her parents got involved, Gabriel claims Credit: Facebook 'She's dying' Today, her mother disagreed saying: "On the morning of July 19 Paloma was well. "She looks healthy and good colour ... she was smiling and laughing, she was not as described yesterday by the osteopath." Paloma collapsed at home later that day, and her mother called her friend who then called an ambulance while they initiated CPR. On the 999 call played to the court, Kate was heard shouting "she's dying" to the operator before the paramedics arrived. She also told the ambulance operator "it's difficult to lie her on her front because she has a medicinal mass" in her throat, the inquest heard. In her evidence, Kate told the court that when the paramedics arrived they administered adrenaline "then everything went horribly wrong" following their intervention and her daughter went into "full circulatory collapse". "I knew at this point that they'd done something, given something that had caused this," she said. 9 Paloma began an alternative treatment programme which included daily coffee enemas, a strict diet and green juices Credit: Facebook 9 Kate told the court that a 'sequence of medical actions' caused her daughter's death Credit: Facebook 9 Kate has has accused paramedics of killing the Cambridge grad Kate added: "She deteriorated catastrophically upon their arrival and their intervention." Dr Anderson said Paloma received a standard adult dose of adrenaline during the cardiac arrest, and that this was acceptable even given how thin she was at the time. Paloma was taken to Royal Sussex County Hospital in Brighton on a ventilator, and brain stem death was declared on the afternoon of July 24, 2024 after a series of nationally advised medical checks. 'Trying to conceal cause of death' Kate said the decision taken was rushed and said that the brain stem testing was not the same in the UK as it was in the US, and wanted an MRI. Intensivist and anaesthetist Dr Peter Anderson, who was on shift when Paloma died, explained: "I thought the risk of deterioration and uncontrolled death was extremely high." Dr Anderson noted that on the 999 call, Kate called out Paloma's oxygen saturation which was "critically low" at 36 then 35. He told the coroner that if Paloma's 'sats' were that low for a significant time then the brain damage was done before the paramedics arrived. Kate said: "We are deeply concerned this inquest is attempting to shift focus on the cause of death." Later she added: "We believe this to be an attempt to pervert the course of justice and conceal the cause of Paloma's death." The inquest continues. 9 Paloma received a standard adult dose of adrenaline during the cardiac arrest from the paramedics, a doctor said Credit: Facebook
