Evan Fitzgerald case: How ‘controlled deliveries' are used in Garda sting operations
The 'controlled delivery' of illicit items – which can include drugs and guns – is used frequently by gardaí, especially when trying to catch people attempting to import drugs into the Republic. While it is rarely spoken of, mainly because gardaí want to keep their trade craft secret, it was aired very publicly this week at an
Oireachtas
justice committee.
Garda
Commissioner
Drew Harris
confirmed Evan Fitzgerald, the armed 22-year-old who took his own life in a
Carlow
shopping centre on the June bank holiday weekend, had been charged with gun crimes after a 'controlled delivery' of firearms last year.
On that occasion, gardaí received a tip-off from international policing agency
Interpol
that unidentified parties in Ireland were active on the darknet trying to buy guns. Gardaí acted on that intelligence, going on to the darknet and offering guns to the suspects.
A face-to-face meeting was later arranged, with the guns and money exchanged. Mr Fitzgerald, who
did not realise he was dealing with undercover gardaí running a sting operation
, was arrested. The guns were two firearms that were in Garda stores and had been decommissioned.
READ MORE
Mr Fitzgerald was charged with four offences: possession of a machine gun and pistol and two different ammunition types. A search of an address linked to him yielded a variety of ammunition and powers to make explosive devices, resulting in nine other charges.
[
Carlow gunman disclosure set to lead to scrutiny of An Garda Síochána
Opens in new window
]
The case was unusual in that the source of the guns – the person who offered them for sale on the darknet – was actually an undercover detective.
Both techniques – controlled deliveries and police officers posing as criminals – are used by international law enforcement. They are also included in the
United Nations
Convention against Transnational Organised Crime.
The UN defines organised crime as three or more people working together to commit at least one serious crime punishable by at least four years in jail and from which they derive financial or material gain.
A controlled delivery occurs when illegal items are detected – usually in the postal system or in freight – on their way to the person trying to procure them. The authorities take control of the delivery in order to catch the person the items are destined for. In Ireland, this includes undercover gardaí dressing as postal workers, or couriers, to make a delivery and then arrest a suspect.
[
Undercover gardaí supplied Carlow gunman with firearms and ammunition, Oireachtas hears
Opens in new window
]
The UN also deals specifically with policing techniques in which undercover officers effectively insert themselves into a crime in the planning. It says the crime should be in the planning before the police get involved. If a police officer 'originated the idea of the crime and induced the accused to engage in it' this would be used as grounds for defence in some jurisdictions'.
A range of Garda sting operations have been reported in Ireland, including gardaí posing as drug users and even as criminals selling drugs or guns.
In 2017, Ahmed Ayadi, then aged 25 years and with an address in the Lawn, Boden Park, Rathfarnham, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to possessing a 9mm calibre Glock semi-automatic pistol in suspicious circumstances.
Gardaí learned he was involved in the drug trade and that he wanted to buy a gun. Undercover gardaí posed as criminals selling guns. He chose a Glock, paying €450. As he left the transaction location, his car was stopped and he was arrested and charged. He was jailed for five years and also admitted possessing drugs.
[
'The country is going to the dogs': How agitators exploited the Carlow shooting
Opens in new window
]
In 2013, Operation Trident saw undercover gardaí infiltrate the drug gang run by Dubliner Freddie Thompson, who became a significant figure in the Kinahan cartel's Irish operation, running it for a time. The undercover gardaí were given new identities and even moved into properties in the Crumlin area, buying and selling drugs and being arrested to help them infiltrate the gang – all with close co-operation between the Garda and the Director of Public Prosecutions.
However, after some details of the operation appeared in the media, the operation was cancelled and five undercover gardaí were withdrawn, though 29 suspects were arrested on the basis of their work.
In 2013 a CIÉ bus driver – Sunny Idah, then aged 36 – was jailed for 13 years. He was trying to recruit people to smuggle cocaine from Brazil to Ireland by swallowing the drugs. Two undercover gardaí posed as would-be couriers and when they recorded Idah – with addresses at Lipton Court, Dublin – offering them €5,000 to take on the task, he was charged.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘Burn them all out': The prejudice bubbling under Ireland's thin veneer of normality
On Tuesday, by way of marking the death of the legendary American musician Sly Stone , John Kelly plays a selection of tunes by the late funk-rock visionary on Mystery Train (Lyric FM, Sunday-Thursday), starting with the yodelling psychedelic soul track Spaced Cowboy. 'Probably not the obvious choice to begin,' the presenter remarks with a wry chuckle, 'but that's from the album There's a Riot Goin' On'. Kelly may not say it, but an album with such an insurrectionary title is, unfortunately, an obvious choice in a week when Irish and American streets are convulsed by scenes of unrest. At least Sly's revolutionary impulses were musical, as Kelly's well-chosen set testifies to stirring effect. (With the death of Brian Wilson of The Beach Boys on Wednesday, Kelly has a busy week paying tribute to departed greats, this time playing the Pet Sounds album in its entirety.) On the other hand, the rioters setting fire to houses and cars of immigrant families in Ballymena are malignantly destructive in intent, as the presenter Cian McCormack learns on News at One (RTÉ Radio 1, weekdays). READ MORE Following the second night of racist rampages in the Co Antrim town, sparked by two teenage boys from migrant backgrounds being charged with sexually assaulting a girl, McCormack talks to the local Alliance MLA Sian Mullholland, who shares harrowing tales of migrant families hiding in attics and bedrooms as marauding thugs ransacked their homes downstairs. The RTÉ reporter Conor Macauley captures a disturbing snapshot of the virulent intolerance driving the disorder when interviewing a local Ukrainian woman about her fears. Amid the conversation a voice can be heard bellowing in the background; Macauley tells McCormack that it belongs to a man in a passing car, who is shouting 'Burn them all out' while driving by. It's a grim illustration of the prejudices bubbling under what Macauley calls the 'very thin veneer of normality'. Further evidence of this ominous atmosphere comes on The Hard Shoulder (Newstalk, weekdays) when its host, Kieran Cuddihy, talks to the reporter Josh Crosbie about the 'eerie, tense feeling' in the town, with Union Jacks proudly fluttering in some neighbourhoods, burnt-out homes pockmarking others. Crosbie canvasses the view of local residents, which range from shame and fear to support for the rioters. 'It's not racism, it's protecting our own people,' one woman says. Another is more tactful in her sympathies, claiming that there has long been harassment of women by groups of men, presumably from immigrant backgrounds: 'I don't know how to say this without sounding racist,' she says before hastily adding that violence ruined initially peaceful protests in the town. Either way, it's a tacit admission of the racist impulses underpinning the trouble. And, as Crosbie glumly notes, there's ample fuel for the rioting to continue: 'We're coming into marching season, so tensions are already high.' Good vibrations are also in short supply in California, as Cuddihy hears about Donald Trump's crackdown on protests against large-scale deportation raids against illegal immigrants in Los Angeles. The BBC reporter Peter Bowes said the unrest has been sporadic in intensity, hardly enough to justify the American president's decision to call in the US marines. And Bowes emphasises that the disorder has been so far confined to a small area of the city: 'The image that all of LA is in chaos is completely incorrect.' In a divided United States, such facts would seem to count for little, particularly with the Maga base. Not that people here can be afford to be complacent about such inflammatory situations. Appearing on Cuddihy's weekly Bookshelf slot, the former People Before Profit TD Bríd Smith picks To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, as her favourite book, citing it as a powerful portrait of systemic racism. (The host gently posits that it also works as a fine piece of fiction.) Perhaps inevitably, conversation turns to the growth of anti-immigrant sentiment in Ireland. Cuddihy plays the tentative optimist, suggesting that children mixing at school might make them more colour blind. Smith isn't so sure, worrying about the influence of online disinformation; she points to a pro-Palestinian demonstration by families in Dublin being disrupted by young children hurling insults and shouting, 'What about the Irish?' But despite such depressing anecdotes, it's an engrossing segment, as guest and host thoughtfully discuss the joys of Hilary Mantel's Wolf Hall trilogy. Cuddihy can't help stirring things up a bit, however. 'Will I really worry you now?' he asks before delightedly noting that Mantel's trilogy was also chosen by Smith's ideological opposite, the former Progressive Democrats leader Michael McDowell. To her credit, Smith sounds only slightly thrown by discovering this common ground: 'Bedfellows,' she says with a sighs. A little tolerance goes a long way. Not always an oasis of reflection, The Ray D'Arcy Show (RTÉ Radio 1, weekdays) proves a font of wisdom – from unlikely sources, to boot. 'We're having a series of 1990s frontmen this week,' the host jokes as he introduces Paul Linehan, leader of the veteran Cork indie band The Frank and Walters. Linehan recounts the origin story of his biggest hit, After All: he wrote it for his then girlfriend, Katie, with whom he would break up when moving back to Ireland from London. It's a simple story – Linehan is back in contact with her after many years – but his unassuming manner imbues it with an oddly affecting and even contemplative quality. 'It's about realising what you have, and celebrating it,' the singer says. There are further life lessons on offer when D'Arcy speaks to the second of his 1990s frontmen, Jarvis Cocker of Pulp . The host sounds genuinely delighted to be speaking to the Sheffield singer – 'What a wonderful surprise' – while Cocker, always an articulate interviewee, is at his droll best. Amid rueful explanations for long gaps between albums – 'I'm just a very slow worker' – Cocker seems in authentically upbeat form, seeking out the positive as the years advance. 'To me growing up is learning more about life, learning more about yourself,' he says. 'Growing old is more like giving up.' No surrender indeed. Moment of the week Always looking for a story with bite, Seán Moncrieff (Newstalk, weekdays) sounds suitably enthusiastic about a new podcast about cinematic sharks, notably the Steven Spielberg classic Jaws, from 1975. But as he starts his introductory spiel for the podcast's host, Jon Harvey – 'Fifty years ago, a film was released...' – the presenter abruptly halts his flow. 'Well, I could tell you about it, but apparently your man isn't on the phone,' he says, slightly peevishly. A couple of awkward minutes pass by, with Moncrieff filling the time by reading various texts; then, finally, his guest appears on the line. Just in time: for a moment it sounds as if Moncrieff had bitten off more than he could chew.
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Analysts ‘did not identify' DNA of Dublin firefighter accused of raping woman in Boston hotel, US court hears
Analysts 'did not identify' the DNA of the Dublin firefighter arrested on rape charges over St Patrick's Day weekend last year in samples collected from the complainant, a US court has heard. The complainant, a 29-year-old attorney, claims she was raped last year by Terence Crosbie (38) while his Dublin Fire Brigade colleague Liam O'Brien slept in a separate bed in a shared hotel room. She says she had consensual relations with Mr O'Brien after meeting him at the Black Rose bar in Boston. She later fell asleep in a separate bed but then awoke to Mr Crosbie raping her. Mr Crosbie denies the charges and has pleaded not guilty. READ MORE Alexis Decesaris, a DNA analyst, testified on Thursday that a process was conducted to eliminate female DNA and isolate male DNA from samples collected from the complainant. She said the results were 'consistent' with there being 'two individuals' separate from the complainant who are both male. Earlier in the day, the court heard from a Boston police crime lab analyst that there was a high likelihood that one of those male profiles belonged to Mr O'Brien. However, Ms Decesaris, an analyst at Bode Technology,said it was unclear if the second set of male DNA, collected from the complainant's genitals, was deposited by Mr Crosbie. [ Dublin firefighter accused of raping woman in Boston hotel says he 'didn't touch' her, US court hears Opens in new window ] Ms Decesaris then faced cross-examination from defence lawyer Patrick Garrity. Addressing her, he said: 'Your testing did not identify Terence Crosbie's DNA on that genital swab, did you?' Ms Decesaris said that was 'correct'. Under questioning from Suffolk assistant district attorney Erin Murphy, Ms Decesaris again confirmed the finding of 'two distinct male contributors' in a sample collected from the complainant. The jury previously heard a Boston police detective testify that the complainant did not recall Mr O'Brien's name and did not recall meeting Mr Crosbie before the alleged assault. The court was told the detective tracked down Mr Crosbie with the help of hotel security footage as well as images of Mr O'Brien and Mr Crosbie provided to him by a federal agent. He said that on March 16th, 2024 – a day after the woman reported the alleged rape – he approached Mr Crosbie by the lift of the hotel. [ US woman awoke in Boston hotel to 'somebody on top' raping her, jury in Dublin firefighter trial told Opens in new window ] Detectives initially asked Mr Crosbie of his whereabouts on March 14th and March 15th. Mr Crosbie said he was one of 10 members of Dublin Fire Brigade who travelled to Boston to march in the city's St Patrick's Day parade. Mr Crosbie said he had interacted with the woman in the bar and again briefly when she went up to the hotel room with Mr O'Brien. He told detectives he waited in a chair in the corridor outside of room 610 while the complainant and Mr O'Brien were inside, jurors heard. He told detectives he later knocked on the door, used his phone as a torch and 'didn't see anybody in the bed'. Mr Crosbie said he removed his trousers and shirt, pulled the bed covers off and got into the bed. A minute and a half later, he said, he 'heard a girl moving' and saw her collect her belongings in the dark and leave. He told detectives he did not have any interactions with the complainant before she left. When detectives asked whether Mr Crosbie had sex with the woman, he replied: 'No, I didn't touch her.' Mr Crosbie was arrested later that evening after booking an early flight back to Ireland and boarding an aircraft. The woman has told the court through tears that she 'woke up to somebody on top of me' raping her. She testified that she told him to 'stop' and that she eventually managed to manoeuvre her legs off the side of the bed and break free. According to the complainant, Mr Crosbie continued to follow her around the hotel room. When she collected her clothes and went to the bathroom, she said Mr Crosbie tried to get in and 'was jiggling the handle' after she locked the door.
Irish Times
12 hours ago
- Irish Times
Puska family trial: jury to continue deliberations on Friday
A Central Criminal Court jury will continue their deliberations on Friday in the trial of four family members charged with offences relating to obstructing the arrest of the man who murdered schoolteacher Ashling Murphy . Jozef Puska murdered 23-year-old Ms Murphy by stabbing and slashing her neck after attacking her while she exercised along the canal towpath outside Tullamore on the afternoon of January 12th, 2022. A jury later convicted him of that murder and he is serving a life sentence. His brothers, Lubomir Puska jnr (38) and Marek Puska (36) are charged with withholding information. Their wives, Viera Gaziova (40) and Jozefina Grundzova (32) are charged with impeding the apprehension or prosecution of Jozef Puska by burning his clothes. READ MORE All the accused were living with Jozef Puska, his wife Lucia, and 14 children at Lynally Grove, Mucklagh, Co Offaly, when the offences are alleged to have occurred in January 2022. All accused have pleaded not guilty to all charges. The jury originally began its deliberations on Wednesday, but an amendment was made to the indictment on Thursday. The amendment relates to the charge that the accused knew that Jozef Puska had committed the offence of murder or some other arrestable offence. The amended indictment now reads that they knew he had committed the murder of Ashling Murphy or some other arrestable offence. In her closing speech earlier this week, prosecutor Anne-Marie Lawlor SC told the jury that Marek and Lubomir jnr knew what Jozef had done shortly after 9.30pm on the night of the murder because Jozef told Marek. Despite this, Ms Lawlor said Marek and Lubomir jnr failed to disclose vital information when they spoke to gardaí. Their wives burned Jozef's clothes to impede his arrest or prosecution, she said. The jury had previously heard from defence counsel Karl Finnegan SC, who said in his closing speech that Marek Puska was entitled to remain silent to avoid incriminating himself. Mr Finnegan said there was a real risk that the information his client had could implicate him in an offence of assisting his brother after the murder. He said the legislation regarding withholding information was introduced following the Omagh bombing to force people with knowledge of that atrocity to come forward. However, Mr Finnegan said, the legislation does not remove a person's right to remain silent if they believe that they could incriminate themselves. At the time, Mr Finnegan said, there was a real risk that his client would be arrested for assisting Puska after the murder by arranging to get him out of Tullamore or because he knew of the plan to burn Jozef's clothes. The jury of seven men and five women will continue their deliberations on Friday.
