Fire-fighting system was not working: Fire brigade
MUMBAI: The Link Square shopping complex that went up in flames in Bandra on Tuesday was a tinder box waiting to be lit. This damning preliminary finding comes from the Mumbai Fire Brigade a day after 72 fire fighters took 12 hours to contain the raging blaze and 22 hours to extinguish it.
'The fire-fighting system wasn't working, including the sprinklers,' chief fire officer, Ravi Ambulgekar, told HT on Wednesday. An assistant divisional fire officer, who was at the site on Tuesday, added that the system was not working even though the shopping complex regularly submitted Form B, which shows evidence of a working system. 'It is possible it was a manual system, which would have to be operated from the basement, but that wasn't accessible. The fire alarm kept ringing till 3pm on Tuesday,' he said.
The fire is believed to have started in the basement, a large area occupied by popular electronics store Croma. It started in the wee hours on Tuesday, and escalated from a Level 1 fire to a Level 3 fire in just 40 minutes, and then to a Level 4 fire in just over two hours (Each level denotes the severity of a fire and the number of fire tenders that needs to be deployed).
The Link Square shopping complex, on Linking Road, housed 220 shops that sold all kinds of merchandise, ranging from clothes to accessories and electronics. There were also restaurants on the third floor.
The fire brigade says hordes of combustible material in the building fueled the fire's ferocity. The intense heat and smoke in a contained space with poor ventilation made fighting the fire a tough challenge. It was also one reason it took so long to bring under control, said a fire officer present at the site.
The officer reasoned that the fire was already raging in the basement when it came to the attention of the security guard sleeping on the first floor after his shift ended at midnight. It was the security guard, Babulal Paswan, who made the first call to the fire brigade at 4:11am. When fire officers arrived, the blaze had already spread across the basement.
'I smelt the smoke,' said Paswan, 'so I went down to check it but I could only catch glimpses of the fire behind the shutters. Smoke was all around, but there was no way for us security guards to use the extinguishers as we didn't have the keys. So, we called the fire brigade.'
The flames spread rapidly through the three-storey building, leaping from the roof. A senior fire officer at the site said the stench of smoke was perceptible around 1km away, at the Khar Telephone Exchange. At 6:25am, it was declared a Level 4 fire.
'To start with, the topmost basement floor (where Croma was located) was aflame, which made the top floors like lava,' said the assistant divisional fire officer. 'The heat and smoke were so intense, there was little room for the fire fighters – as many as 73 of them – to make much of a difference. The fire had by then reached all three top floors, fuelled by poor ventilation in a building encased in glass and filled with combustible material. We had to break the glass to allow the smoke to get out. The heat and smoke threatened to blind us each time we went too close, almost trapping a few of the fire officers,' he said.
The fire fighters focused on containing the blaze from all four sides. To venture closer, they deployed a fire robot to shoot water at the burning building. The fire was finally extinguished by 1:41am on Wednesday but cooling operations continued all through the day.
The fire brigade has launched an inquiry into the cause of the blaze and the irregularities in the building's fire-fighting system.
The Mumbai Fire Brigade handed over the site to the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) on Wednesday evening. The BMC and the police will take the next steps. 'We have parked two fire engines at the site on standby since there is a huge pile of combustible material there. We are still investigating the cause of the fire and will have a report in two to three days,' said Ravindra Ambulgekar, chief fire officer.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
4 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Ghaziabad restaurant vandalised over late service; 3 held
Ghaziabad: Three people were arrested and a search was launched for others after a video clip showing a group of men vandalising a restaurant in Rajnagar Extension, Ghaziabad, with wooden sticks surfaced on social media on Sunday, police said, adding that a delay in serving food sparked the dispute. The 50-second CCTV footage clip purportedly shows the men attacking the restaurant when people are having dinner. HT, however, could not independently confirm the video's authenticity. 'On Friday night, suspects Minto Tyagi, Rajdeep Kumar, and Ravi Sharma — all in their 30s and residents of Modinagar and Sihani in Ghaziabad — had gone to have dinner at a restaurant in Rajnagar Extension. Due to delay in food service, a dispute broke out between the suspects and the restaurant owner, Akshit Tyagi,' said a police officer requesting anonymity. The matter was initially pacified by a mutual acquaintance, making the suspects leave the scene. However, on Saturday around 11.30pm, the suspects returned with seven to eight friends on motorcycles and in a car, and started vandalising the restaurant, the officer added. 'They attacked the hotel while customers were having dinner and later threatened Tyagi before fleeing the spot,' said Nandgram assistant commissioner of police (ACP) Poonam Mishra. Following Tyagi's complaint, police have registered a case under Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita sections for assault or use of criminal force, abetment of offence punishable with death or imprisonment, voluntarily causing hurt by dangerous weapons, criminal intimidation, and robbery, at Nandgram police station against three identified and seven unidentified suspects, the ACP added. Tyagi alleged that the suspects broke two laptops, one LED, a billing machine, and the counter. 'They also stole ₹1,760 from the counter and assaulted customers,' the FIR stated. 'All three prime suspects were arrested on Sunday, and efforts are underway to identify the remaining accused,' the ACP said, adding that further probe is on.
Hindustan Times
7 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Lesson from stampedes: Communication key to crowd control, say experts
This year, stampedes at a major railway station in Delhi, at the Maha Kumbh in Uttar Pradesh, and during a cricket match victory celebration in Karnataka have led to at least 72 deaths and a few hundred injuries so far — a grim statistic which exposes the glaring gaps in crowd regulation rules, official apathy and tokenistic governance. Action taken following these tragic, largely preventable deaths does little to avert such incidents in the future — after the June 4 stampede in Bengaluru, the state leadership, replicating the action of its counterparts in other parts of the country, suspending the city's top cop and other police staff, and ordered a magisterial inquiry. Later, the Karnataka high court also took suo motu notice. In light of these developments, HT spoke with veteran police officers, planners, urban designers, and academics to dissect the anatomy of stampedes and how to prevent them. Prakash Singh, a retired IPS officer who was the state police chief of Assam and Uttar Pradesh and the director-general of the Border Security Force, said the Bengaluru tragedy appears to be a case of overriding political desire overruling reservations from the police. Multiple reports, including by HT, suggest that the police had initially dismissed the idea of a parade due to paucity of time. But as some players from the overseas were scheduled to return home, there was a rush to hold the celebrations on June 4 itself, according to people aware of the matter. 'But this should have never been made part of the consideration. No event can be organised without the clearance from the police,' Singh said. The second issue, he pointed out, was the inconsistent messaging. 'There were multiple versions of when and where the parade will be held.' The most significant lapse, however, was the police's alleged failure to react when the crowd started trickling, Singh said. 'Around 200,000-300,000 people tried to make their way towards the stadium when the capacity was only 36,000. It was a policing failure, given that there are enough surveillance measures that would have indicated swelling of crowds.' Police should have, through existing intelligence and surveillance measures, prevented the crowd from converge from all directions. Another lapse was the inadequate deployment of forces, he added. 'Ideally, civic volunteers, armed battalions, and the fire brigade should have been mobilised. If there was fatigue, police from outside the commissionerate should have been engaged, he said. While Karnataka home minister G Parameshwara has announced that the government will formulate a new SOP for crowd control, these mechanisms are not alien to India, where heavy footfall events such as the Maha Kumbh are held regularly. They have been part of the police manual since colonial times, and even the National Disaster Management Agency (NDMA) has issued guidelines to manage crowds at events. To prevent stampedes, the administration — be it government, private organisers or temple trusts— should actively control the 'hype' through constant messaging, said Monika Vij, a geography professor at Delhi's Miranda House, who has researched extensively on crowd management at religious events. Referring to the Kumbh tragedy in January, where the official death toll was 30, she said, while the authorities made 'excellent arrangements', the hype of a historical event overshadowed everything. Authorities could not effectively communicate with the crowd when the stampede took place, she said. 'There has to be greater control and responsibility over disseminating information.' On the Bengaluru stampede, she said it was the 'lack of clarity over the venue and ticketing' which led to the tragedy. Similar confusion was seen at the February 15 stampede at the New Delhi Railway Station over train departures, Vij said. Another retired IPS officer Nazrul Islam, who was the ADGP in West Bengal, said a crowd, by default, is fuelled by frenzy and not rationality — be it a religious procession or a sports event. 'Visible, prompt policing is important to keep the crowd disciplined. Staggered movement of crowds is essential, and for that, checkpoints are installed in all directions from approaches to the event venue,' he said. KT Ravindran, founder of the Institute of Urban Designers India, said, for any kind of gathering, authorities must ensure that designing standards, such as entry and exit points and emergency exit, are followed. 'At any point in time, the potential to disperse should be higher than the potential to gather.' Ujan Ghosh, the former president of the institute, said the combined action of authorities, including police, along with the architecture, either prevents or causes a stampede. He also questioned if the Bengaluru stadium was the right choice as the venue for the cricket felicitation event. Spaces, such as streets and pavements, are often designed for specific purposes, he said, suggesting that stadiums are usually for ticketed events.
Time of India
12 hours ago
- Time of India
Rakhial man nabbed for credit card data fraud
Ahmedabad: A 28-year-old man from Rakhial was detained in Makarba in the city for allegedly being involved in cyber fraud activities using stolen credit card data provided by a network based in Jharkhand, said city police officers on Sunday. Acting on a tip-off, police reached a cafe in Makarba and located the suspect. Upon checking his mobile phones, the police suspected that the devices contained data related to cyber fraud. Preliminary questioning revealed that the suspect was purchasing mobile phones through e-commerce platforms like Croma, Vijay Sales, and Zepto using credit card data shared with him via a contact saved as Sagar J K. He then used to sell the phones, retaining a commission, and sending the remaining cash to Jharkhand using CDM (cash deposit machines). Police said he also admitted to using the stolen credit card data to pay utility bills, such as electricity bills of Torrent Power. The suspect's WhatsApp chats, Gmail IDs, and other stored data on his phones were examined, leading to the seizure of two mobile phones. Screenshots of WhatsApp chats, contact numbers, and Gmail credentials linked to fraudulent transactions were documented as part of the evidence. The suspect was brought to the Cybercrime police station for further questioning. He admitted that he acted on instructions from Jharkhand-based individuals and was involved in multiple financial frauds through e-commerce purchases and utility bill payments. A case was registered under relevant sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and Information Technology Act. Investigation is ongoing to identify other accomplices and trace the full extent of the fraud network.
