US appeals court revives antitrust lawsuit over Puerto Rican baseball league
The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in a ruling, opens new tab on Monday revived part of a lawsuit that was filed in 2022 against the league and others by a former owner-operator of a franchise in Puerto Rico's professional baseball league, Liga de Béisbol Profesional de Puerto Rico.
The Boston-based appeals court, which hears federal cases from Puerto Rico, said that former owner Thomas Axon could pursue a narrowed antitrust and civil rights lawsuit against the league and others.
The appeals court upheld the dismissal of U.S. federal antitrust claims, but allowed antitrust and fair competition claims under Puerto Rican laws.
In a statement, Winston & Strawn's Jeffrey Kessler, a lead attorney for the plaintiffs, welcomed the 1st Circuit's order allowing the case to proceed and said they were weighing their options over the dismissal of the federal antitrust allegations.
Francisco Colón-Ramírez, a lawyer for the baseball league, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Axon in the lawsuit said rival teams had worked to block his efforts in 2019 to restore his franchise through major new broadcast initiatives, better salaries, enhanced sponsorships and expanded merchandising.
He alleged that the baseball league seized his investor-operator interest without compensation or due process, and moved to box him out of the league.
The league and other defendants have denied any wrongdoing.
In dismissing the lawsuit, U.S. District Judge William Young in 2023 pointed to the 'baseball exemption' of federal antitrust law. The U.S. Supreme Court in a 1922 case concluded antitrust law does not apply to the business of baseball.
In the latest in a string of legal challenges involving the baseball exemption, Axon's lawyers argued it only applies to Major League Baseball and its direct affiliates, and not to the Puerto Rican league. Young disagreed.
The 1st Circuit panel — Chief Judge Barron, joined by Circuit Judges O. Rogeriee Thompson and Gustavo Gelpí — suggested the exemption is out of touch with the modern realities of baseball. But the Supreme Court, the panel said, has declined so far to overrule it.
The case is Cangrejeros de Santurce Baseball Club LLC et al v. Liga de Béisbol Profesional de Puerto Rico Inc et al, 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 23-1589.
For plaintiffs: Jeffrey Kessler of Winston & Strawn
For defendants: Francisco Colón-Ramírez of Colón Ramírez
Read more:
National Hockey League, Canadian hockey clubs defeat US class action
US judge approves NCAA baseball coaches' $49 million settlement
Bipartisan state coalition backs challenge to MLB's antitrust immunity
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Finextra
10 minutes ago
- Finextra
Tabadulat receives in-principle approval from ADGM regulator
Tabadulat Limited (Tabadulat), a UAE-based Shariah-compliant investing platform registered with ADGM, the international financial centre of the UAE Capital Abu Dhabi, has received In-Principle Approval from ADGM's Financial Services Regulatory Authority (FSRA). 0 This content is provided by an external author without editing by Finextra. It expresses the views and opinions of the author. The announcement follows the UAE cabinet's approval of its National Strategy for Islamic Finance and Halal Industry on 6 May. Under the plan, the UAE seeks to build a globally competitive national Islamic finance sector, facilitate its activities, and drive leadership in sustainable finance. Tabadulat, which is in the process of obtaining its Financial Services Permission, subject to FSRA's approval, has a committed investment of US$2.3 million. For years, Muslim investors have faced limited options when seeking truly halal investment opportunities in global markets, often relying on separate and expensive screening tools or niche local brokers. Through its advanced halal stock screener, Tabadulat will ensure that every transaction adheres to Islamic finance principles, filling a longstanding gap in halal investing. 'Tabadulat will not just be a trading platform but will be a movement. We will empower Muslim investors to invest globally without compromising their faith. Tabadulat will offer its clients control, transparency, and compliance in one seamless platform,' said Samy Mohamad, Co-founder of Tabadulat. Key features include: Global Market Access: Users will be able to invest in a wide range of international halal stocks across the US, Europe, GCC, Asia, and beyond. Advanced Halal Stock Screener: Every stock and ETF listed will be screened daily for Shariah compliance, allowing Muslim investors to instantly identify halal investments without relying on an external paid service. Ultra-low and Transparent Fees: Low transaction fees (starting at just 0.25%) with no hidden costs and absolutely no Riba, ensuring halal and cost-effective trades for retail investors. Advanced Portfolio Analytics: Cutting-edge tools, including a comprehensive Shariah report, at no additional cost. Built-in Zakat Calculator: Helping investors fulfill their religious obligations easily and accountant-free. With the global Islamic finance market estimated to reach US$7.5 trillion by 2028, Tabadulat's entry will come at a time of rising demand for accessible halal investing solutions. The company will adhere to the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI) standards, the global benchmark in Islamic finance, and will be an Islamic financial business. 'Muslim investors may soon be able to trade halal stocks with peace of mind, knowing that every asset they invest in will be to the highest standards of Islamic finance,' says Ali Abdulkadir Ali, Co-founder of Tabadulat.
The Independent
10 minutes ago
- The Independent
Lottie Woad under no extra pressure at Women's Open after first professional win
Golf sensation Lottie Woad insisted she was under no extra pressure at the AIG Women's Open at Royal Porthcawl after winning her first tournament as a professional. Woad tees it up at a major as a pro for the first time in South Wales on Thursday, having won the Women's Scottish Open title by three shots last weekend. The 21-year-old from Surrey picked up a 300,000 dollars (£223,000) cheque after being prevented from profiting financially from her victory at the Irish Open and tied-third finish in The Evian Championship earlier this month because of her amateur status. United States-based Woad revealed at her pre-Open press conference how she would spend some of her first career earnings – saying, 'I need to get a car in America' – and the bookmakers are expecting another windfall to come her way on the Harry Colt links layout. 'I don't know how they do it, but I feel like I'm playing well,' Woad said in response to being priced as the pre-tournament favourite. 'So I guess I was going to be one of the favourites. Obviously everyone's so good, so I feel like anyone can win really. 'You've seen it this year, so many – I think every winner has been different. So there's many people it could be. 'There's always pressure obviously, but I don't think there's any more than there was, like from my perspective, before any of the last fewweeks. 'Kind of still was wanting to contend there and that's still the aim.' Woad's last appearance at a major – the Evian Championship in France three weeks ago – saw her narrowly missing out on becoming the first amateur to win one in 58 years. She finished one shot off making the play-off with eventual champion Grace Kim and Atthaya Thitikul after posting a final round 64. Woad said: 'I think it gave me a lot (of confidence). 'Some of the majors I made the cut, I didn't really have the best weekend on. So I was hoping to capitalise a bit more on that one. 'The final round was also very good. Yeah, it definitely gives me confidence in that and knowing that I can chase it down on Sunday. 'I don't feel too different. I've got a lot of confidence from the last month really and I'm just trying to continue to ride that.' World number one Nelly Korda, Open runner-up to Lydia Ko at St Andrews 12 months ago, praised Woad's composure and maturity, with the American saying she was 'definitely high up there right now' as a title contender. Woad said: 'I don't think I've reflected too much, to be honest (on the last month). 'I think after this big week, I've got a week before I go out to America. That's probably when I'll look back at the last few months and kind of reflect on that.'
Reuters
11 minutes ago
- Reuters
Exclusive: India buys record soyoil from China in rare move, sources say
MUMBAI, July 29 (Reuters) - Indian importers have bought a record 150,000 metric tons of soyoil from China in rare purchases, as a supply glut prompted Chinese crushers to sell at a discount to India's traditional suppliers from South America, four trade sources said. The exports to India will help Chinese crushers cut inventories that surged after the country's soybean imports hit a record peak in May, boosting processing and stockpiles while demand slowed. China is the world's biggest importer of soybean. Indian importers bought the soyoil for shipment between September and December, with sellers offering a $15 to $20 a ton discount compared with South American supplies, said the sources who declined to be named because they were not authorised to speak to the media. "Chinese soybean crushers are struggling with excessive soymeal and soyoil. To reduce inventories, they are shipping oil to India," a New Delhi-based dealer with a global trade house told Reuters. India, which mainly imports soyoil from Argentina and Brazil, began buying from China due to the price advantage, the dealer said. China is traditionally a net importer of soyoil and palm oil. Chinese crushers offered crude soyoil at around $1,140 per ton, including cost, insurance, and freight (CIF), for shipments in the December quarter, compared with $1,160 from South America, another dealer said. Lower freight costs have given China the upper hand too, as shipments from South America take more than six weeks to reach India, while those from China arrive in two to three weeks, a Mumbai-based dealer said. India meets nearly two-thirds of its vegetable oil demand through imports - by private companies - of palm oil, mainly from Indonesia and Malaysia, as well as sunflower oil and soyoil from Russia and Ukraine in addition to Argentina and Brazil. In India and elsewhere, soyoil is trading at a premium over palm oil, but in China, soyoil is trading at a discount due to the supply glut, a Kuala Lumpur-based dealer said. India's annual cooking oil requirement is huge, and it could buy even more from China if offered at competitive prices, said Sandeep Bajoria, chief executive of the Sunvin Group, a Mumbai-based vegetable oil brokerage.
