Democrats have a dirty secret - they actually like some of the tax cuts in Trump's ‘big beautiful bill'
Some of the sweeping tax cuts proposed in President Donald Trump 's massive spending package have found support among Democrats — even as they are expected to oppose the legislation over proposed cuts to Medicaid and other government services when it comes up for debate in the Senate later this month, according to a new report.
The gargantuan budget package, which House Republicans and the White House have dubbed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, passed the House by a single vote last month and is now drawing heat from fiscal hawks in both chambers as well as Tesla CEO Elon Musk, who was fresh off his months-long stint as a special government employee when he began threatening to back challengers to any legislator who votes for the bill.
Still, there are facets of the proposal that have appeal for some Democrats, the New York Times reports.
Virginia Rep. Don Beyer, a Democrat who is also a wealthy car dealership owner, told the Times his party is 'in general very much in favor of reducing taxes on working people and the working poor' when asked about Trump's plan to end taxes on service workers' tips.
'Those people are living on tips,' he added.
Trump's tip tax cut plan has also attracted attention from Sen. Jacky Rosen of Nevada, a state where service workers make up a large and powerful voting bloc that has traditionally supported Democrats but shifted to Trump in large numbers during the 2024 presidential election, handing him the Silver State's electoral votes.
Rosen, a Democrat, took to the Senate floor last month to advance a bill approving Trump's 'no tax on tips' plan. It passed unanimously even though the measure was largely symbolic because the U.S. constitution requires tax laws to originate in the House
'I am not afraid to embrace a good idea, wherever it comes from,'. she said at the time in remarks on the Senate floor.
Yet despite the support for some of the individual tax provisions in the plan, it's highly unlikely that it will be able to muster enough if any Democrats to ease the way to Trump's desk, even under a Senate procedure known as budget reconciliation, which fast-tracks some types of spending legislation without subjecting it to the upper chamber's de facto 60-vote threshold for passage.
Democrats are expected to unanimously vote against the legislation in the upper chamber, where it has also attracted opposition from some Republicans who've complained that the cuts to spending in the package don't go far enough to offset the reduced revenue caused by provisions meant to enact Trump campaign promises to end taxes on tips for service workers, as well as taxes on overtime pay for hourly workers and on social security benefits for seniors.
Nonpartisan experts such as those at the Congressional Budget Office have warned that the reduced tax receipts would blow a massive hole in the federal budget and jeopardize America's long-term fiscal outlook, but that hasn't stopped some prominent Democrats from getting behind the individuals tax cuts.
Trump and his allies hope the prominent tax cut proposals will blunt Democrats' efforts to paint the One Big Beautiful Bill Act as a giveaway to wealthy GOP donors that will gut government services while only providing limited relief for working-class voters.
To that end, the president and others in his camp have routinely taken to social media to argue that anyone who votes against the bill is effectively voting for tax increases because the legislation makes permanent a number of temporary tax cuts enacted in the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which Trump signed into law during his first term.
Democrats, meanwhile, remain opposed to the bill's massive cuts to Medicare and other measures that make it harder for people to claim tax credits meant to boost lower-income Americans' bottom lines.
Rep. Brad Schneider, an Illnois Democrat, told the Times that the whole bill had to be considered rather than any individual provision or provisiosn.
'Any one thing — a tax credit or a tax cut — might make sense, but you've got to take a look at the whole picture,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
31 minutes ago
- The Independent
New Jersey Transit train engineers OK tentative deal that ended strike which had halted NYC routes
New Jersey Transit's train engineers have overwhelmingly approved a tentative deal that ended their three-day strike last month that halted service for some 100,000 daily riders, including routes to Newark airport and across the Hudson River to New York City. The agency and the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen announced the results Tuesday. They said the seven-year agreement, covering the years 2020-2027, was supported by 398 members, while 21 voters rejected it. NJ Transit's board of directors is scheduled to vote on the agreement when they meet Wednesday. Details of the contract have not been released, but the union said it includes a 'significant pay raise' and addresses other issues for the roughly 450 engineers who serve the agency. The main sticking point during negotiations had been how to accomplish a wage increase for the engineers without creating a financially disastrous domino effect for the transit agency. The walkout that began May 16 was the state's first transit strike in over 40 years, forcing people who normally rely on New Jersey Transit to take buses, cars, taxis and boats instead or consider staying home. It came a month after union members had overwhelmingly rejected a labor agreement with management. NJ Transit CEO Kris Kolluri said the deal represents 'a fair and fiscally responsible agreement for our locomotive engineers, NJ Transit, our customers, and the taxpayers of New Jersey.' Union leaders voiced similar views. 'All along we've said we didn't want to be the highest paid engineers, we only wanted equal pay for equal work,' said Tom Haas, who works as an NJT engineer and serves as BLET's general chairman at the commuter railroad. 'This agreement brings us close to what our peers make for doing the same type of work with the same levels of experience and training. This agreement gives us the pay raises we needed, but also was done without a major hit to NJT's budget and should not require a fare hike for passengers.' NJ Transit — the nation's third-largest transit system — operates buses and rail in the state, providing nearly 1 million weekday trips, including into New York City. The walkout halted all NJ Transit commuter trains, which provide heavily used public transit routes between New York City's Penn Station on one side of the Hudson River and communities in northern New Jersey on the other, as well as the Newark airport, which has grappled with unrelated delays of its own recently.
The Independent
31 minutes ago
- The Independent
Associated Press seeks full appeals court hearing on access to Trump administration events
The Associated Press on Tuesday asked for a hearing before the full U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington, seeking to overturn a three-judge panel's ruling that allowed the Trump administration to continue blocking AP access to some presidential events — a four-month case that has raised questions about what level of journalistic access to the presidency the First Amendment permits. Three judges of that court on Friday, in a 2-1 decision, said it was OK for Trump to continue keeping AP journalists out of Oval Office or other small events out in retaliation over the news outlet's decision not to follow his lead in changing the Gulf of Mexico's name. He had sought a pause of a lower court's ruling in AP's favor in April that the administration was improperly punishing the news organization for the content of its speech. 'The decision of the appellate panel to pause the district court's order allows the White House to discriminate and retaliate over words it does not like, a violation of the First Amendment,' AP spokesman Patrick Maks said. 'We are seeking a rehearing of this decision by the full appellate court because an essential American principle is at stake.' A hearing before the full court would change the landscape — and possibly the outcome as well. The two judges who ruled in Trump's favor on Friday had been appointed to the bench by him. The full court consists of nine members appointed by Democratic presidents, and six by Republicans. The news outlet's access to events in the Oval Office and Air Force One was cut back starting in February after the AP said it would continue referring to the Gulf of Mexico in its copy, while noting Trump's wishes that it instead be renamed the Gulf of America. For decades, a reporter and photographer for the AP — a 179-year-old wire service whose material is sent to thousands of news outlets across the world and carried on its own website, reaching billions of people — had been part of a small-group 'pool' that covers a president in places where space is limited. Now, an AP photographer routinely gets access to these events, while text reporters rarely do. ___ David Bauder writes about media for the AP. Follow him at and
The Independent
32 minutes ago
- The Independent
Stephen Miller meeting with ICE officials was the spark for LA protests and National Guard call-up: report
White House aide Stephen Miller has repeatedly branded the Los Angeles protests an 'insurrection' after fierce backlash to immigration raids. California 's leadership is now 'siding with insurrectionist mobs,' and Democratic officials are 'in open rebellion' against the government, according to Miller. But the far-right architect of Donald Trump's anti-immigration agenda appears to have himself lit the fuse, after reportedly rallying Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials to 'just go out there and arrest illegal aliens.' Late last month, Miller pressed ICE officials to ramp up arrests after following short of the president's ambitions for record-breaking daily deportations, according to The Wall Street Journal. Federal law enforcement officers needed to 'just go out there and arrest illegal aliens,' Miller told top ICE officials, according to WSJ, citing people familiar with the meeting. Rather than develop a list of targets for arrest, Miller told agents to raid Home Depot parking lots and 7-Eleven convenience stores, the newspaper reported. Miller 'eviscerated everyone,' according to recent reporting from The Washington Examiner. ''You guys aren't doing a good job. You're horrible leaders,'' Miller reportedly said. 'He just ripped into everybody. He had nothing positive to say about anybody, shot morale down,' an official told the outlet. Miller also allegedly bet that he and a handful of agents could arrest 30 people in the streets of Washington, D.C. 'Who here thinks they can do it?' Miller reportedly said. Days later, on June 6, ICE agents descended on a Home Depot in the predominantly Latino Westlake neighborhood of Los Angeles — kicking off a weekend of protests centered around a federal detention center in the city's downtown and in the nearby Paramount and Compton neighborhoods. The next morning, Border Patrol agents gathered in a gated industrial office park in Paramount, while word spread on social media that raids were imminent at another nearby Home Depot. Trump later signed a presidential memorandum deploying 'at least' 2,000 National Guard troops to Los Angeles, with U.S. Marines standing by, despite objections from Governor Gavin Newsom, who joined officials and other critics sounding the alarm that the administration is needlessly escalating unrest. Miller and Newsom have spent several days trading blows over X. In response to Newsom's renewed lawsuit calling on a federal judge to block the 'unnecessary militarization' of Los Angeles, Miller accused the governor of saying that ICE officers must withdraw from the state if they 'don't want to get assaulted or worse by insurrectionist migrant mobs.' 'The Governor's position is that Stephen Miller has no peer when it comes to creating bulls****, strawmen arguments,' Newsom's office replied. The Independent has requested comment from the White House. Miller — who is from nearby Santa Monica — routinely characterizes the city and greater Los Angeles area as a 'third-world nation' overrun by immigrants. 'A ruptured, balkanized society of strangers,' he said this week. 'Los Angeles is all the proof you need that mass migration unravels societies,' Miller said. 'You can have all the other plans and budgets you want. If you don't fix migration, then nothing else can be fixed — or saved.' In recent days, he has repeatedly accused state officials of criminal activity for supporting immigrant communities, claiming that the entire state has 'aided, abetted and conspired to facilitate the invasion of the United States' and is now supporting a 'violent rebellion' against the federal government. 'Los Angeles and California are demanding the nullification of the election results, of federal law, of national sovereignty, and of the bedrock constitutional command of one national government,' Miller said. Trump appointed Miller as a senior policy adviser during his first term, where he emerged as an influential driving force behind the several key policies, including a ban on travel to the United States from majority Muslim countries and a 'zero tolerance' policy to separate migrant children from their parents or guardians. After an election fueled by Trump's pledge for the 'largest deportation operation in American history,' Miller has become a fierce proponent of the administration's agenda in media interviews and in volatile confrontations with reporters as the president advances a more robust anti-immigration campaign. Miller has also endorsed the concept of 'remigration,' or forcible removal of immigrants and their families that has taken hold among Europe's far-right parties and
