Berlinale Posts Q&A Setting Out Position On Freedom Of Expression, Antisemitism & Palestine As 75th Edition Unfolds In Politically-Charged Times
The post shuts down a rumor that the wearing of clothes or symbols showing solidarity with Palestine is prohibited at the festival but does caution against the use of certain language around the Israel-Gaza conflict.
More from Deadline
Louis Theroux Returning To The West Bank For Latest BBC Documentary
MK2 & Lucky Number Board Annemarie Jacir's 'Palestine 36'; Unveil First Stills & Jeremy Irons Casting Alongside Hiam Abbass, Saleh Bakri & Liam Cunningham - EFM
'Unconditional': Keshet Launching Sales On "Most Ambitious Drama" To Date At London TV Screenings
The 75th edition follows a tumultuous 2024 festival, riven by internal disputes, firstly over invites to members of the far-right, anti-immigrant AfD party, then over its stance on the war in Gaza, which spilled into the closing night when winners and jury members criticized Israel's military campaign, sparking accusations of antisemitism by local politicians.
This year's edition is set to unfold in equally choppy political waters.
The Middle East conflict looks likely to loom large yet again with pro-Palestinian organization Strike Germany renewing calls for cultural workers to boycott the festival and European Film Market in recent weeks, although it remains to be seen whether this campaign gathers traction.
The body has accused the Berlinale and parent body, the Berlin cultural organisation KBB, of stifling free speech around the issue of Palestine, and last year reported that they had evidence that a part-time staffer had been sanctioned for using the phrase 'from the river to the sea' in an internal email.
Local politics are also on a knife-edge due to the rise of the far-right, anti-immigrant Alternative for Germany party, or AfD, ahead of general elections on February 23, which has led to street protests in Berlin in recent weeks.
Incoming director Tricia Tuttle – who took over from co-directors Carlo Chatrian and Mariette Rissenbeek after last year's edition – appears to be seizing the ball by the horns in terms of regulating the tone of the debate at the festival.
The Q&A quashed a rumour that the wearing of clothes or symbols suggesting solidarity with Palestine was prohibited at the festival.
The Berlinale said it had been sparked by the ambiguous wording of the regulations for the KBB, and that it had sought clarification.
'The paragraph in question referred solely to a standard German legal provision regarding the wearing and use of prohibited symbols and signs that are demonstrably punishable by law, such as the swastika. Wearing or displaying other signs and symbols of national or political expression or solidarity (e.g. a watermelon pin, a Keffiyeh, etc.) is not forbidden and is fully covered by freedom of expression laws,' said the festival.
But the festival did raise a red flag over the use of certain language in relationship to the Middle East conflict, notably the phrase, 'from the river to the sea'.
Referring to the area between the Jordan River and Mediterranean, which houses both Israel and the West Bank, the phrase has been interpreted, on one hand, as calling for the end of Israel, on the other, for Palestinians to able to live freely and equally in the territory.
'As a festival team we feel great empathy for people who feel excluded by language and it is our sincere hope to create spaces where everyone feels they can join in the dialogue. Most dialogue related to the Israel/Gaza conflict is considered an expression of personal opinion and therefore protected by law.,' reads the Berlinale Q&A.
'However, the phrase 'From the River to the Sea' requires particular care, and there have been cases where it has been prosecuted in the state of Berlin,' it continues.
'More generally, some language may have additional cultural significance in Germany because of the Holocaust and the country's culture of remembrance and reconciliation. This is not to say that we avoid dialogue on these issues, but greater sensitivity in language can lead to more meaningful understanding.'
The Berlinale said the new management had reviewed what happened on the closing night from every angle and set in place a framework to favor balanced expressions of opinion.
'We understand that many people were troubled by a perceived one sidedness, rather than individual statements made by filmmakers. Ultimately, creating balance across the festival and making space for different perspectives is the responsibility of the Berlinale rather than individual films or filmmakers,' it said.
'Also, in preparation of the new festival, we have worked on our moderators training and our frameworks for creating environments for respectful and safe exchange,' it added.
Berlinale said all its guests had a right to free speech within the bounds of the law and that it stood by its filmmakers to talk about the impulses behind their work and their experiences of the world.
'The Berlinale welcomes different points of view, even if this creates tension or controversy. At the same time, we aim to create an environment in which we can listen and learn from each other, and we ask for respectful dialogue and a certain cultural sensitivity,' it said.
The festival also broached Germany's recently proposed Antisemitism Resolution, which critics say impacts free speech especially around criticism of Israel.
It agreed with the resolution's warning of growing antisemitism in Germany and internationally, but pushed back on the powers included in the proposed bill which has yet to be ratified into law.
'We share the opinion along with other people in Germany, that, if legally enforced, other aspects of the resolution would interfere with the fundamental rights of free art and speech. We also disagree with the sweeping categorisation of the Berlinale 2024 in the resolution as 'antisemitic'. The Berlinale has no tolerance for antisemitism.'
Best of Deadline
Everything We Know About Christopher Nolan's Next Film – 'The Odyssey': Release Date, Cast And More
2025 Awards Season Calendar: Dates For Oscars, Spirits, Grammys, Tonys, Guilds & More
2024 Hollywood & Media Deaths: Photo Gallery & Obituaries
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
an hour ago
- Miami Herald
U.S. citizen dies following Israeli settler arson attacks in the West Bank
A U.S. citizen died in the West Bank on Thursday morning, the U.S. State Department confirmed to the Miami Herald. According to his family, Khamis Abdul Latif Ayyad, 41, died of smoke-related injuries, after Israeli settlers set fire to cars in his village in the middle of the night. A U.S. State Department official confirmed Ayyad's death and citizenship in a statement to the Herald, but did not provide information about his cause of death. 'We can confirm the death of a U.S. citizen in the town of Silwad in the West Bank. We offer condolences to the family on their loss and are providing consular assistance to them. We condemn criminal violence by any party in the West Bank,' a State Department spokesperson said. Ayyad is the second known U.S. citizen to die this month in the West Bank, as residents tell reporters that the assaults from Israeli settlers have become nearly a daily occurrence. Just one town over from Silwad, 20-year-old Florida-born Sayfollah 'Saif' Musallet was beaten to death on Jul. 11 by Israeli settlers, who also shot and killed a second man. Musallet's death sparked outrage among Americans and Muslim groups in Florida who called for an investigation from the DeSantis administration and the Department of Justice. Mike Huckabee, the U.S. ambassador to Israel, wrote on X on July 15 that he asked Israel to 'aggressively investigate' Musallet's death. 'There must be accountability for this criminal and terrorist act,' he wrote. 'Saif was just 20 yrs old.' The Herald reached out to Huckabee but has yet to receive a response about Ayyad's death. A national Muslim advocacy group, the Council on American-Islamic Relations, called for an investigation on Friday. Ayyad grew up in Silwad, a small village in the West Bank, but moved to the United States in 2008 with his wife, also a U.S. citizen, and settled in Chicago. Together they raised four sons and one daughter, ages 6 to 15. At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, he moved back to the West Bank, and continued working remotely for an IT company, according to his brother, Ayman Ayyad. The Herald reached out to Palestinian and Israeli officials, including the Israeli Defense Forces, but has yet to receive a response. Around 2:30 a.m. Thursday morning Khamis Ayyad called his brother, Ayman Ayyad, who didn't pick up. Ayman Ayyad received a call around 4 a.m. from another brother who informed him that Khamis Ayyad had been transferred to a nearby hospital in Ramallah. He arrived to find that his brother had died. Khamis Ayyad had rushed to his brother's aid after settlers set fire to a car under the family house, Ayman Ayyad said. He died from smoke inhalation, according to his family and a Palestinian news agency. The family said the fire was started by Israeli settlers who came into Silwad, a village in the central West Bank near several Israeli settlements, in the middle of the night and set cars and homes ablaze. A funeral took place on Friday, and relatives are waiting for an autopsy to determine his official cause of death. The family has strong ties in the United States. Khamis Ayyad is one of nine children – seven of whom are U.S. citizens, according to his brother Ayman Ayyad, who live in Chicago and Philadelphia. They have cousins in Tampa, Fla. Ayman Ayyad described his brother as a family man. Whenever he wasn't working, he was with his wife and children. He was well-liked in his community, and focused on his family and building his career. 'He was loved by everyone,' he said. 'He caused no problems at all.' Ayman Ayyad had little to say to U.S. officials. He said that the 'whole world' already knows about the attacks in the West Bank and Jerusalem. 'What, is it something people can't see? The whole world already sees it,' he said. This story was produced with financial support from Trish and Dan Bell and from donors comprising the South Florida Jewish and Muslim Communities, including Khalid and Diana Mirza, in partnership with Journalism Funding Partners. The Miami Herald maintains full editorial control of this work.
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Netanyahu postpones decision over military action in Gaza to next week, source says
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has postponed making a decision on the actions his country's military will take in Gaza if Hamas does not agree to a ceasefire deal, a source familiar with the matter told CNN on Friday. A decision will no longer come this week, the source said. This comes amid internal disagreements in the Israeli government about its preferred course of action in the enclave. One idea on the table, if the militant group does not agree to a deal, is to encircle Gaza City and other population centers, while another is to 'conquer' the city, the source said. Different ministers are in favor of different plans, the source added. On Thursday, a senior Israeli official said that Israel and the United States are forming a new understanding on Gaza, as Hamas reportedly withdrew from ceasefire and hostage deal negotiations. 'At the same time, Israel and the United States will work to increase humanitarian aid, while continuing military operations in Gaza,' the official added. The shift comes as Hamas has disengaged from ceasefire and hostage negotiations, according to two sources familiar with the matter. Hamas' disengagement follows the US and Israel pulling their delegations from talks in Doha, Qatar, with US special envoy Steve Witkoff at the time accusing Hamas of negotiating in bad faith. Despite that move, a senior Israeli official had told CNN they would be prepared to return to Doha if Hamas changed its position. On Thursday, Hamas said it was committed to continuing negotiations toward a permanent ceasefire and complete withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza, but conditions in the enclave would first have to improve 'significantly.' The faltering peace talks come amid a catastrophic humanitarian situation in Gaza, where scores of people are starving to death. All of Gaza's 2.1 million people are now food insecure, without reliable access to enough affordable, nutritious and healthy food, the United Nations said this week. According to the enclave's health ministry, 900,000 children are going hungry, and 70,000 show signs of malnutrition. 'It is essential to improve the catastrophic humanitarian situation significantly and to obtain a written response from the enemy regarding our response,' Basem Naim, a senior member of Hamas' political bureau, told CNN. 'This is a condition to go back to negotiations.' In a separate statement, Hamas said it was ready to 'engage immediately in negotiations again upon the arrival of aid to those in need and to end the humanitarian crisis and famine in Gaza.' The statement added that continuing negotiations 'under the conditions of starvation loses its substance and effectiveness.' CNN previously reported that Hamas was considering hardening its position in negotiations. Senior Hamas official Mahmoud Mardawi said Wednesday there was no point in continuing to engage in negotiations as long as Gaza's starvation crisis continues.
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Netanyahu postpones decision over military action in Gaza to next week, source says
The Middle East Israel-Hamas warFacebookTweetLink Follow Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has postponed making a decision on the actions his country's military will take in Gaza if Hamas does not agree to a ceasefire deal, a source familiar with the matter told CNN on Friday. A decision will no longer come this week, the source said. This comes amid internal disagreements in the Israeli government about its preferred course of action in the enclave. One idea on the table, if the militant group does not agree to a deal, is to encircle Gaza City and other population centers, while another is to 'conquer' the city, the source said. Different ministers are in favor of different plans, the source added. On Thursday, a senior Israeli official said that Israel and the United States are forming a new understanding on Gaza, as Hamas reportedly withdrew from ceasefire and hostage deal negotiations. 'At the same time, Israel and the United States will work to increase humanitarian aid, while continuing military operations in Gaza,' the official added. The shift comes as Hamas has disengaged from ceasefire and hostage negotiations, according to two sources familiar with the matter. Hamas' disengagement follows the US and Israel pulling their delegations from talks in Doha, Qatar, with US special envoy Steve Witkoff at the time accusing Hamas of negotiating in bad faith. Despite that move, a senior Israeli official had told CNN they would be prepared to return to Doha if Hamas changed its position. On Thursday, Hamas said it was committed to continuing negotiations toward a permanent ceasefire and complete withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza, but conditions in the enclave would first have to improve 'significantly.' The faltering peace talks come amid a catastrophic humanitarian situation in Gaza, where scores of people are starving to death. All of Gaza's 2.1 million people are now food insecure, without reliable access to enough affordable, nutritious and healthy food, the United Nations said this week. According to the enclave's health ministry, 900,000 children are going hungry, and 70,000 show signs of malnutrition. 'It is essential to improve the catastrophic humanitarian situation significantly and to obtain a written response from the enemy regarding our response,' Basem Naim, a senior member of Hamas' political bureau, told CNN. 'This is a condition to go back to negotiations.' In a separate statement, Hamas said it was ready to 'engage immediately in negotiations again upon the arrival of aid to those in need and to end the humanitarian crisis and famine in Gaza.' The statement added that continuing negotiations 'under the conditions of starvation loses its substance and effectiveness.' CNN previously reported that Hamas was considering hardening its position in negotiations. Senior Hamas official Mahmoud Mardawi said Wednesday there was no point in continuing to engage in negotiations as long as Gaza's starvation crisis continues.
