logo
Cowboys HC Schottenheimer ID'd as one of NFL's most under-pressure people in 2025

Cowboys HC Schottenheimer ID'd as one of NFL's most under-pressure people in 2025

USA Today7 days ago
Brian Schottenheimer wasn't the most talked-about coaching hire of 2025, but he may be under more pressure than any of them.
Head coach of the Dallas Cowboys is arguably one of the most intensely scrutinized jobs in all of sports. Heading into the 2025 season, that challenge goes to Brian Schottenheimer, named the 10th head coach in franchise history in January, after Dallas parted ways with Mike McCarthy following a five-year run that concluded with a 7-10 finish last season.
No matter who roams the sidelines for Dallas, winning a Super Bowl is something no Dallas coach has been able to accomplish in three decades. Adding to the pressure is the feeling the current window could be close to shutting when considering the team's All-Pro quarterback, Dak Prescott is just days away from his 32nd birthday and , coming off another major injury. Several of the team's notable players over the past five seasons have moved on, most recently future hall of fame guard Zack Martin who retired earlier this offseason.
ESPN's Bill Barnwell reecently listed 15 players, coaches, or GMs under the most pressure in 2025, with Schottenheimer as one of four head coaches mentioned.
"I've argued that Chicago's Ben Johnson is the most-hyped first-time hire with no prior head coaching experience in decades... On the other end of the spectrum is Schottenheimer, who is a decade removed from his last head coaching interview."
Once seen as a hot coaching candidate during his time with the Chargers and Jets, "those rumors dried up," as he bounced around the league. Outside of a brief spark in Seattle during the first half of 2020, "there haven't been any hints that he was on radar as an NFL head coach."
Still, "things have a funny way of resolving themselves," and after three seasons in Dallas, Schottenheimer "went through the interview process and won over team owner Jerry Jones." Now, he's leading the Cowboys, 'the league's highest-profile job,' despite a promotion that "didn't inspire much excitement."
And while some might question the hire, history reminds that "we don't know much about head coaching hires or their chances of succeeding." Barnwell explains that for every uer-successful Sean McVay or Kyle Shanahan, there's a Adam Gase or Nathaniel Hackett cautionary tale. Schottenheimer 'might turn out to be a great coach. He might also be overmatched."
Schottenheimer, the son of the late great Marty Schottenheimer, has long waited for this moment. His credentials, however, may not have carried much weight with critics who were stunned by the move. The 51-year-old head coach has had past stints as an offensive coordinator with the New York Jets, St. Louis Rams, Seattle Seahawks, and before becoming named head coach, was the OC of the Cowboys in 2023 and 2024.
While the rookie head coach has shown flashes of promise, most notably during his run in Seattle from 2018 to 2020 when the Seahawks regularly ranked top 10 in red zone and scoring offense, his overall track record has told a different story. The 2020 season marked Russell Wilson's statistical peak, as he set career highs in completions (384), completion percentage (68.8), and touchdown passes (40) under Schottenheimer's guidance.
His first season as offensive coordinator in Dallas brought similar highs: the Cowboys led the league in scoring, ranked third in passing yards, and finished second on third downs, while Prescott concluded that season second in MVP voting, finishing with a career high in completions, passer rating, and a league leading 36 touchdown passes.
However, despite those standout campaigns, consistency has eluded him.
Across 14 years as an NFL offensive coordinator, Schottenheimer has produced just one top-10 total offense finish, back in 2019 with Seattle. Now elevated to head coach, he'll be tasked with more than just calling plays and trying to help Dallas jump back into top 10 territory. The big question: can he help Prescott rediscover his 2023 form after an underwhelming and highly paid 2024 season that saw major regression in an offense that ranked 17th overall a season ago and saw a drop-off in yards and points.
Dallas added several new pieces this past offseason most notably WR George Pickens via trade and rookie first round guard Tyler Booker, while revamping the backfield with three new faces. Schottenheimer brought in several new assistants to try and help steer the ship back into the right direction.
Only time will tell how Jones' latest coaching experiment will go for the 2025 Cowboys and beyond. On one end, Schottenheimer could surprise the NFL world the same way Sean McVay and Dan Quinn did during their first seasons leading their respective teams, or things could fly south, and the pressure could mount up quickly not just for the head coach, but for Jones, who has been rather more patient with his last two head coaches, to evaluate his decision sooner rather than later.
Follow Cowboys Wire on Facebook to join in on the conversation with fellow fans!
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early
Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early

Yahoo

time4 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early

OXNARD, Calif. (AP) — The hits keep on coming for the Dallas Cowboys' offensive line, after left guard Tyler Smith came out of practice early on Thursday. Smith is dealing with tendinitis in his knee, Cowboys owner and general manager Jerry Jones told the Dallas Morning News. Smith left practice with about 30 minutes remaining and told reporters he was fine as he walked down the sideline back to the team's training camp setup. A first-round draft pick in 2022, Smith has started 47 games in his three seasons with the Cowboys. He was a second-team All-Pro in 2023 and has made the Pro Bowl twice. Smith is the third Dallas offensive lineman to be injured in less than a week. Starting left tackle Tyler Guyton was hurt Monday, one day after reserve guard Rob Jones broke a bone in his neck. Coach Brian Schottenheimer described Guyton's right knee fracture, which will keep him out four to six weeks, as the best-case scenario given the circumstances. 'We need to have a physical camp,' Schottenheimer said Wednesday. 'We need to pop and hit and wrap and thud in pads. You look at the play that happened to Tyler, it was a blitz and just some bodies got tangled up, and that happens in football. You hate to see it, but again, at the end of the day, as you look at it now, it's like, 'Hey, I think we got away with one.'' Jones had been competing to start at right guard and will require two to three months to recover. The extended absences of Guyton and Jones won't change how offensive coordinator Klayton Adams approaches the rest of camp and the preseason. The Cowboys' emphasis on building depth and having as many players capable of contributing as possible has become that much more important. 'We create as much competition as we can, that's the easy answer to it,' said Adams, who was the offensive line coach for the Arizona Cardinals the past two seasons before joining Schottenheimer's staff in January. 'Obviously, it's unfortunate any time you got guys that are going to miss (time), but it's also one of the reasons that we don't really believe in kind of that old mentality of get the starters ready to play. We need to get everybody ready to play, and everybody on this roster needs to be getting better.' Nate Thomas, a second-year player from Louisiana Tech, is getting the first look at replacing Guyton at left tackle. Thomas is 6-foot-4 and weighs 330 pounds, and that size carries over to the field. 'So again, Nate, the power jumps off the film,' Schottenheimer said. 'I mean, the power of the man and his body, so the first thing that jumps out is his ability to get displacement in the run game. He's able to move the dot, we call it. That's the guy who the backs are reading.' Thomas spent his rookie season on injured reserve because of a partial tear of his patellar tendon after being drafted in the seventh round. The Cowboys originally expected him to move inside to guard, but Schottenheimer said Thomas' footwork was so good during offseason workouts this spring that it prompted a return to his more natural position. But that doesn't mean Thomas will focus exclusively on left tackle. Adams stresses versatility over specialization. The swing tackle needs to be able to play both spots, and being able to move inside if needed can make a lineman all the more valuable. 'You know, we tell all of our guys that unless you are an All-Pro at left guard or right tackle or whatever, you need to be able to play as many spots as you can possibly play,' Adams said. Thomas credits a conversation with quarterback Dak Prescott this summer for helping him adjust to sudden changes. 'He told me straight up, like, you need to be ready, you know?' Thomas said. 'And I just took that in stride, and just make sure I go about every day just knowing that, hey, I need to treat this as if I'm a starter because you never know when my number is called. And, you know, here I am.' The Cowboys are exploring all options to bolster their numbers on the offensive line, including scheduling a workout with La'el Collins. Collins played six of his first seven seasons in the NFL with Dallas but has been out of the league the past two years. 'I just saw him back there actually, and it was a very joyous reunion,' Prescott said after practice Thursday. ___ AP NFL:

Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early
Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early

Washington Post

time6 minutes ago

  • Washington Post

Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early

OXNARD, Calif. — The hits keep on coming for the Dallas Cowboys' offensive line, after left guard Tyler Smith came out of practice early on Thursday. Smith is dealing with tendinitis in his knee, Cowboys owner and general manager Jerry Jones told the Dallas Morning News . Smith left practice with about 30 minutes remaining and told reporters he was fine as he walked down the sideline back to the team's training camp setup.

Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early
Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early

Associated Press

time6 minutes ago

  • Associated Press

Cowboys' need to build offensive line depth stressed again with Tyler Smith exiting practice early

OXNARD, Calif. (AP) — The hits keep on coming for the Dallas Cowboys' offensive line, after left guard Tyler Smith came out of practice early on Thursday. Smith is dealing with tendinitis in his knee, Cowboys owner and general manager Jerry Jones told the Dallas Morning News. Smith left practice with about 30 minutes remaining and told reporters he was fine as he walked down the sideline back to the team's training camp setup. A first-round draft pick in 2022, Smith has started 47 games in his three seasons with the Cowboys. He was a second-team All-Pro in 2023 and has made the Pro Bowl twice. Smith is the third Dallas offensive lineman to be injured in less than a week. Starting left tackle Tyler Guyton was hurt Monday, one day after reserve guard Rob Jones broke a bone in his neck. Coach Brian Schottenheimer described Guyton's right knee fracture, which will keep him out four to six weeks, as the best-case scenario given the circumstances. 'We need to have a physical camp,' Schottenheimer said Wednesday. 'We need to pop and hit and wrap and thud in pads. You look at the play that happened to Tyler, it was a blitz and just some bodies got tangled up, and that happens in football. You hate to see it, but again, at the end of the day, as you look at it now, it's like, 'Hey, I think we got away with one.'' Jones had been competing to start at right guard and will require two to three months to recover. The extended absences of Guyton and Jones won't change how offensive coordinator Klayton Adams approaches the rest of camp and the preseason. The Cowboys' emphasis on building depth and having as many players capable of contributing as possible has become that much more important. 'We create as much competition as we can, that's the easy answer to it,' said Adams, who was the offensive line coach for the Arizona Cardinals the past two seasons before joining Schottenheimer's staff in January. 'Obviously, it's unfortunate any time you got guys that are going to miss (time), but it's also one of the reasons that we don't really believe in kind of that old mentality of get the starters ready to play. We need to get everybody ready to play, and everybody on this roster needs to be getting better.' Nate Thomas, a second-year player from Louisiana Tech, is getting the first look at replacing Guyton at left tackle. Thomas is 6-foot-4 and weighs 330 pounds, and that size carries over to the field. 'So again, Nate, the power jumps off the film,' Schottenheimer said. 'I mean, the power of the man and his body, so the first thing that jumps out is his ability to get displacement in the run game. He's able to move the dot, we call it. That's the guy who the backs are reading.' Thomas spent his rookie season on injured reserve because of a partial tear of his patellar tendon after being drafted in the seventh round. The Cowboys originally expected him to move inside to guard, but Schottenheimer said Thomas' footwork was so good during offseason workouts this spring that it prompted a return to his more natural position. But that doesn't mean Thomas will focus exclusively on left tackle. Adams stresses versatility over specialization. The swing tackle needs to be able to play both spots, and being able to move inside if needed can make a lineman all the more valuable. 'You know, we tell all of our guys that unless you are an All-Pro at left guard or right tackle or whatever, you need to be able to play as many spots as you can possibly play,' Adams said. Thomas credits a conversation with quarterback Dak Prescott this summer for helping him adjust to sudden changes. 'He told me straight up, like, you need to be ready, you know?' Thomas said. 'And I just took that in stride, and just make sure I go about every day just knowing that, hey, I need to treat this as if I'm a starter because you never know when my number is called. And, you know, here I am.' The Cowboys are exploring all options to bolster their numbers on the offensive line, including scheduling a workout with La'el Collins. Collins played six of his first seven seasons in the NFL with Dallas but has been out of the league the past two years. 'I just saw him back there actually, and it was a very joyous reunion,' Prescott said after practice Thursday. ___ AP NFL:

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store