Alberta First Nations elders say they weren't properly consulted on new education curriculum
Tsuut'ina Nation member Bruce Starlight thinks the knowledge gap between elders like himself and young people is growing, marking a disservice not only to Indigenous, but also non-Indigenous youth in their ability to learn an accurate history of Alberta's original inhabitants.
The solution? Incorporating more Indigenous knowledge into provincial K-12 curriculum, something Starlight said the government has not effectively achieved in its recent rounds of education revisions.
Those include new math, social studies, physical education and wellness curricula for both elementary and junior high students.
"We're not going to take this lying down anymore," said Starlight, who's been a longtime education advocate for his community.
Starlight said he and other First Nations elders have not been adequately consulted by the Ministry of Education in the development of new elementary and middle school curriculum.
Over the last weekend, Starlight organized a two-day summit at Tsuut'ina Nation that brought together elders, educators and leaders from treaty territories across the province.
The meeting's goal was to develop a new strategy to address the province over those shortcomings, and develop alternative solutions.
"Nobody's actually carried the torch to Alberta and said 'this is what we want,'" said Starlight.
"So what [the summit] is is to push our agenda forward."
'A critical issue': First Nations elders say they weren't properly consulted in revisions of provincial education curriculum
4 days ago
Duration 2:29
The province is currently working on a new middle school curriculum for the 2026 fall semester.
In November 2024, it said it was planning to take early drafts of the Grade 7 to Grade 9 math and social studies and Grade 7 to Grade 10 phys-ed and wellness curricula and consult with school board trustees, superintendents, First Nations education directors and "subject matter experts," according to a government news release at the time.
Education minister Demetrios Nicolaides said in an interview with CBC News that, since then, there has been ongoing consultation with education authorities with different First Nations organizations.
"I'm happy to take that feedback and see how we can use that to strengthen engagement for the next round for the junior high curriculum," said Nicolaides.
"I did have an opportunity to have several conversations myself personally with education authorities, with different First Nations organizations and others. And department officials also had subsequent conversations. And I know some groups were able to provide some feedback. So if there's more that we can do, I'm always happy to hear their views."
He added that certain aspects of the social studies curriculum were adapted to align with that feedback, particularly relating to terminology.
For example, the word 'stories' was changed to 'narratives' when discussing First Nations histories in K-6 elementary curriculum.
'It could imply a fictional element to it so that was some of the feedback we received from one of our First Nations partners', Nicolaides said.
Successive provincial governments have been trying to modernize the curriculum for a decade, a process that has received backlash from Indigenous leaders and elders in the past.
In 2021, Lubicon Lake Chief Billy-Joe Laboucan withdrew his support of K-6 curriculum drafts, citing that he felt like a "token Indian."
Starlight said Indigenous teachings are too often pigeon-holed into cultural days or arts-based learning at school, and that they should be incorporated more holistically across subjects.
He added that when elders or Indigenous leaders are repeatedly overlooked, it feels like a continuation of colonialism.
"They gotta teach about the residential school, they gotta teach about things that affect us daily … then why is it that they're developing a curriculum that we're not involved in?"
David Scott, an associate professor with the Werklund School of Education at the University of Calgary, was invited to take notes at the summit, and plans to compile a report for the group of elders to bring forward to the Ministry of Education.
He said the government has fallen short on its commitment to involve Indigenous leaders in the education system.
"They'll say that there is inclusion, but I would say it's tokenistic," said Scott.
"If we're really getting serious about thinking about Indigenous knowledge systems and, you know, the real history of this place in this country, that's absent in the curriculum right now."
Teena Starlight is an educator with the Tsuut'ina Board of Education and the first member of that nation to earn a doctorate.
She said some areas of the curriculum in particular that could be improved are teachings on how First Nations are governed, and the details and intentions behind treaties.
She added that, in addition to improved curriculum drafts, she hopes that educators, including principals and superintendents, begin to implement the four calls to action pertaining to education by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission more often.
Right now, she said those calls are often adhered to as just another box to check, and are not as meaningfully engaged with as they could be.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Star
an hour ago
- Toronto Star
Statue of Sir John A. Macdonald outside Queen's Park uncovered after five years
After five years behind protective hoarding, the 1894 statue of Sir John A. Macdonald on the front lawn of the Ontario legislature is now uncovered. Workers have put a protective coating on the bronze figure, which gazes south down University Avenue, along with a plaque hinting at Macdonald's controversial role in creating residential schools, where thousands of Indigenous children died after being taken from their families. The statue had been boxed in after repeated acts of vandalism. 'I recognize the sensitivities surrounding the history of Canada's first prime minister and I welcome all Ontarians to express their views — peacefully,' Donna Skelly, Speaker of the legislature, said in a statement Wednesday. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Workers unveil the statue. Rob Ferguson 'Violence and acts of vandalism will not be tolerated, and the Legislative Protective Service will actively monitor the statue and grounds.' Officers kept a close eye on the statue as it was uncovered Wednesday and throughout the day. A plaque in front of the statue says in part 'though we cannot change the history we inherited, we can shape the history we wish to leave behind' and notes officials at the legislature, including a committee of MPPs, are considering how Indigenous history can be better represented in the building and on its grounds. When the decision to remove the hoarding was made by the legislature's all-party board of internal economy last month, Indigenous New Democrat MPP Sol Mamakwa (Kiiwetinoong) — who survived residential schools — made it clear he was hurt by the move and warned the statue remains a target. 'It might come down, it might get spray-painted. I don't know. But let them learn,' he told reporters. 'We are still trying to find our kids, our ancestors, in these residential schools,' he added, referring to ground radar searches for graves in former school locations across Canada. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW There has been criticism that the plaque now in place does not say more about the controversy over Macdonald. Many suggestions have been made about how to deal with the statue, such as moving it into a museum where its context can be better explored or a building a monument to residential schools nearby. Tiny shoes that had been placed in front of the boarded-up statue in tribute to residential schoolchildren have been 'carefully and respectfully removed' and stored. Some left there years ago had already been moved into the legislature and included in an exhibit of Indigenous art called the Gathering Place. Residential schools were opened in 1883 under Macdonald's government, and the last one closed in 1996. About 150,000 Indigenous children were removed from their homes and forced into a system likened to apartheid and genocide. In its 2015 report, Canada's Truth and Reconciliation Commission initially counted 3,201 deaths at the schools. The search for unmarked graves at former school sites is expected to continue for years. Politics Headlines Newsletter Get the latest news and unmatched insights in your inbox every evening Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. Please enter a valid email address. Sign Up Yes, I'd also like to receive customized content suggestions and promotional messages from the Star. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Politics Headlines Newsletter You're signed up! You'll start getting Politics Headlines in your inbox soon. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page.
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Province adds $5M to Research Manitoba funding
Research Manitoba is getting $5 million more annually to create 'an intellectual property collective' and support scholars who specifically study artificial intelligence, information technology and data. A total of $18.9 million has been earmarked for the grant-collection agency in 2025-2026, the province announced in a news release Wednesday. A provincial spokesperson confirmed a portion of that funding will be designated to establish a collective that ensures Manitoba researchers can retain intellectual property related to major scientific breakthroughs. MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES Innovation and New Technology Minister Mike Moroz said a $5-million top-up for Research Manitoba is necessary 'to rebuild' capacity for scientific breakthroughs. MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS Mike Moroz (River Heights), is sworn in as minister of innovation and new technology. Premier Wab Kinew expanded and shuffled his cabinet after a year in office during a ceremony Wednesday morning at the Manitoba Legislative Building. Mike Moroz, the MLA for River Heights, will lead the department of innovation and new technology, an entirely new division. The other two new members of cabinet are Mintu Sandhu (the Maples), who is now minister of the delivery of public services, and Nellie Kennedy (Assiniboia), who is now minister of sport, culture, heritage and tourism. Jamie Moses (St. Vital) is now minister of business, mining, trade and job creation. lan Bushie (Keewatinook) is now minister of natural resources. He remains the minister of Indigenous economic development. Glen Simard (Brandon East) is now minister of municipal and northern relations. Lisa Naylor (Wolseley) remains minister of transportation and infrastructure but is no longer minister of consumer protection and government services, the news release stated. Including the premier, there are now 19 cabinet members. Reporter: Carol Sanders 241113 - Wednesday, November 13, 2024. Jennifer Cleary, chief executive officer of the agency, called the changes 'a turning point for research in Manitoba.' 'It strengthens our foundation, accelerates innovation and ensures that Manitoba's brightest minds have the support they need to thrive right here at home. We are not just keeping pace — we are setting the pace,' Cleary said in a news release. Research Manitoba had lost significant spending power over the last decade. In 2015-2016, it received $17 million to support local research projects. The agency's annual allotment was $13.6 million when the NDP was elected in 2023. Local researchers have been calling on the Kinew government to reinstate Research Manitoba's funding in recent months as their colleagues in the United States grapple with budget cuts and political interference. Premier Wab Kinew invited disgruntled U.S. scientists to relocate north during a scrum with reporters at the legislature on March 28. Multiple petitions were launched in response to his comments. Hundreds of signatories urged the government to address status-quo research funding and local workforce challenges before recruiting international scholars. 'Research is not a luxury, but a vital investment in economic growth, resilience, and opportunities for all Manitobans,' said Robert Beattie, an assistant professor of biochemistry and medical genetics at the University of Manitoba. Beattie said he was 'thrilled' to learn the developments Wednesday. Innovation and New Technology Minister Mike Moroz said a $5-million top-up for Research Manitoba is necessary 'to rebuild' capacity for scientific breakthroughs. Moroz said additional investments in research chair positions will encourage high-calibre researchers to stay put and attract an influx of experts from the U.S. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. Research Manitoba, previously housed under the department of advanced education and training, has been moved to his department. The shift is being touted as a way to position the province as a leader in 21st-century digital governance and expand research into cloud computing and data analytics, among related areas. Every dollar spent on research in Manitoba is estimated to yield upwards of $4 in economic benefits. Based on a review of its grants between 2010 and 2015, Research Manitoba has pegged the return on the dollar at $4.77. Maggie MacintoshEducation reporter Maggie Macintosh reports on education for the Free Press. Originally from Hamilton, Ont., she first reported for the Free Press in 2017. Read more about Maggie. Funding for the Free Press education reporter comes from the Government of Canada through the Local Journalism Initiative. Every piece of reporting Maggie produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
First Nations opposition continues after passing of Ontario's Bill 5
Many First Nations people in Ontario are continuing protests following the passing of Bill 5 in Ontario last week. Bill 5, the Protecting Ontario by Unleashing Our Economy Act, allows the province to create special economic zones, where companies or projects can be exempted from having to comply with a provincial law, provincial regulation or municipal bylaw. Shem Mattinas, from Moose Cree First Nation on James Bay, was one of the organizers of a protest in Timmins, Ont., last Friday. "This will affect all of us; it threatens our land, our water, and our democratic rights," he said. "This isn't only a First Nations issue; it's an Ontario issue." The premier has said one of those special economic zones will be the mineral-rich Ring of Fire region on Treaty 9 territory in northwestern Ontario. "Attawapiskat River is right in the middle of the Ring of Fire. The First Nations along that river will be deeply affected by poisons and chemicals if this kind of development goes forward unchecked," Mattinas said. Mattinas said it was important for him to organize a protest because he's always heard "when youth speak, that's when people listen." The province has said the law is aimed at speeding up major infrastructure and resource projects. Ontario Premier Doug Ford said Friday he intends to designate the Ring of Fire as a special economic zone "as quickly as possible." He added he and several ministers will consult all summer with First Nations about the new law before making the designation. People also continue to rally at the provincial legislature at Queen's Park in Toronto. Myka Burning from Six Nations of the Grand River said she will be one of the people maintaining a presence there. She said those gathered are calling on Indigenous nations across the country to support them, not just Ontario, because of the law's widespread environmental implications but also because she believes it sets a precedent. "I feel like there has been consistent voicing of opposition as it's been coming down like the pipes and that's just not being respected," she said. Concern for caribou Bill 5 also scraps Ontario's Endangered Species Act and replaces it with a new law called the Species Conservation Act, which critics say waters down protections. Jennifer Franks, the director of Indigenous Relations at the Toronto Zoo, said there was "resounding disappointment" around the passing of Bill 5 with the zoo's Indigenous advisory circle. Franks, who is Red River Métis from Birch Hills, Sask., said the zoo's mission is to "connect people, animals, traditional knowledge and conservation science to fight extinction," like the zoo's caribou biobanking project in the Hudson Bay region, where they help collect samples from hunted caribou for genetic preservation. Caribou are traditionally hunted by the Cree and Anishinaabe who live in the Ring of Fire area. In Ontario, caribou is listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act. Habitat loss and human activities are among the threats to the province's caribou. Toronto Zoo CEO Dolf Dejong, who spoke out against the bill at a committee hearing at Queens Park in May, said he wasn't surprised the bill passed despite opposition and said he's concerned special economic zones could be designated anywhere, effectively undoing decades of work in conservation. "They've been very clear that they intended to move quickly," he said.
