
India's next victory should be in its battle for narrative dominance
India's answer to the Pahalgam massacre came not as a mere retaliatory sortie, but as Operation Sindoor—a meticulously orchestrated act of calibrated coercion. It was military precision in the service of political messaging. Not since Balakot had India demonstrated such willingness to redraw the rules of engagement.
In doing so, it shattered two myths: that strategic restraint remained India's default posture and that Pakistan's threshold for escalation was immutable.
For decades, India absorbed Pakistan-sponsored terrorism with caution, hemmed in by the spectre of nuclear escalation. That has now been replaced by a posture of escalation dominance. Operation Sindoor marks a basic shift in India's doctrine: from restraint to reciprocal risk, from deterrence-by-denial to deterrence-by-punishment. India now treats major terror attacks as acts of war, responding across air, land and sea while keeping escalation in control and providing off-ramps to avoid full-scale war.
Also Read: Nitin Pai: Operation Sindoor leaves India better placed for the next round
Rawalpindi replied in a predictable cadence of reciprocal strikes. Yet, the choreography felt rehearsed, its symbolism worn. The global response, urging 'maximum restraint,' was almost ceremonial in its fatigue. Washington, quick to claim credit for brokering a ceasefire, seemed less concerned with Pakistan's recurrent use of Islamist terror (shielded by the implicit threat of its nuclear deterrent) and more desperate not to be eclipsed by Beijing's quiet encroachment of the region's diplomatic space.
What this sequence unmasked was not simply the resumption of a conflict, but the emergence of a strategic pivot. Historically, Pakistan manipulated the threat of nuclear escalation to draw international intervention and avoid consequences for its sponsorship of terrorism. But India has flipped that playbook by leveraging calibrated strategic risk to pressure the international community to contain Pakistan's reckless behaviour.
India's new doctrine has popular backing, with domestic expectations and bipartisan support having entrenched a consensus that terror will be met with force, but New Delhi's calculus extends well beyond the battlefield.
Also Read: Operation Sindoor: A doctrinal shift and an inflection point
Recognizing that perception governs legitimacy, it has launched an ambitious diplomatic counteroffensive: seven high-level delegations are being despatched to other countries. Their mission is precise: to thwart Pakistan's attempt to internationalize Kashmir. They will not argue on a premise of grievance, but of law, sovereignty and the global imperative to treat terrorism as indivisible.
These delegations are not just emissaries of the state; they are narrative architects and strategic communicators. Tasked with restoring clarity and countering Pakistan's narrative rooted in the communalism of the 'two-nation theory,' they serve a dual purpose. First, to reframe the Kashmir issue as a constitutional and internal matter rather than a bilateral dispute. Second, to emphasize that Pakistan's use of terror as statecraft is not a bilateral problem, but a global challenge to the integrity of international counterterrorism norms.
They will articulate that India no longer accepts terror exceptionalism, that Pakistan cannot perpetually shield its proxies behind a veil of nuclear blackmail, and present a doctrine of clarity: India will defend itself unilaterally, proportionally and within the bounds of international law.
Moreover, they will leverage India's democratic legitimacy and civilizational identity to project the country as a responsible global power. They will position India as a bulwark against radicalism, an upholder of pluralism and a force for stability. India's actions, they will assert, are not escalatory by choice, but corrective by necessity. And Operation Sindoor is not an aberration, but the new normal.
Also Read: Nitin Pai: Operation Sindoor sets a new normal for India's strategy
Under the pressure of Indian strikes, Pakistan sought US mediation—a move that revealed its strategic vulnerability and India's operational superiority. Islamabad's reliance on international intervention as a safety valve has been exposed as outdated, given how India has demonstrated both escalation control and narrative discipline.
Yet, therein lies the deeper risk for India—not that Pakistan may succeed, but that the world may listen. The recent face-off has become a pretext for a creeping re-hyphenation of India and Pakistan in global discourse, threatening to resurrect the dynamic that Indian diplomacy has laboured to bury since Nehru's United Nations gambit.
This peril is underscored by US President Donald Trump's assertion of having brokered the ceasefire. In a world tempted by transactional diplomacy, India faces the challenge of navigating a global environment where principles are often subordinated to deals. For a West wary of China's growing influence, Kashmir may become a theatre of symbolic contestation rather than legal and political clarity.
Further complications arise from the intractability of global crises, be it Russia's war in Ukraine, the Israel-Hamas conflict or nuclear tensions with Iran. These ongoing flashpoints dilute diplomatic bandwidth and allow malign actors like Pakistan to exploit moments of global distraction to resurface their narratives.
Thus emerges a dual mandate for India. First, to maintain its strategic initiative without risking adventurism. Second, more critically, to preserve its narrative dominance on Kashmir. India's campaign has two fronts: deterrence and discourse. Its actions must be demonstrative but deliberate; its diplomacy, assertive yet unsentimental.
Also Read: The IMF's Pakistan loan spotlights the case for voting power reform
India must seize not only the high ground, but the defining voice. It must portray Operation Sindoor as an overdue recognition that past limited responses in 2016 and 2019 failed to alter Pakistan's terror calculus. It must articulate that the essence of deterrence lies not only in firepower, but in clarity of intent. And it must reject the premise that Kashmir is open to third-party adjudication.
This is not, at its core, a contest over boundaries. It is a struggle over narrative dominance and temporal trajectory. Pakistan clings to grievance as both a shield and weapon, and its backward gaze affirms its inability to pivot forward, even as India charts its future with the balance of force and foresight. New Delhi's assertion of its sovereign prerogative and refusal to outsource its security calculus is a mark of strategic maturity. The global order respects clarity more than compromise, particularly when the stakes are cloaked in moral ambivalence and strategic ambiguity.
In the coming days, the contest will unfold in minds, not maps. And narrative clarity will determine not only who commands the present, but who inherits the future. India's challenge is not just to win battles, but to own the story. In geopolitics, as in battle strategy, the side that frames the question often controls the answer.
The authors are, respectively, professor of international relations, King's College London, and assistant professor, international affairs and security studies, Sardar Patel University of Police, Security & Criminal Justice.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Delegations took India's stand to the world: Modi
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday met all seven multi-party delegations that visited 33 countries over the past two weeks to present India's stand on cross-border terrorism and Operation Sindoor, and said everyone was proud of how the teams put forth India's voice. Modi told the delegations, comprising 59 lawmakers and several former ambassadors, that such platforms for amplifying the country's voice should continue to be utilised, said people aware of the details. He also said that the exercise conveyed the message that India remained united against terror, the people said. 'Met members of the various delegations who represented India in different countries and elaborated on India's commitment to peace and the need to eradicate the menace of terrorism. We are all proud of the manner in which they put forward India's voice,' Modi posted on X. The meeting lasted over an hour at the PM's official residence at 7, Lok Kalyan Marg. 'The delegation members talked about their meetings in different countries and gave feedback about what was conveyed to them. In an informal set up, the PM met all seven delegations and heard the also made a few comments as well,' said a person privy to the details. On May 17, the government announced that lawmakers from across the political spectrum will be part of seven delegations that will also include former diplomats and some eminent persons to talk about India's response to terrorism in the wake of the April 22 attack in Pahalgam. 'We are all grateful for the opportunity to be of service to the nation, Pradhan Mantriji @narendramodi! Jai Hind,' said Congress leader Shashi Thaoor, who led the delegation to the US, Guyana, Colombia, Panama and Brazil. Four of the delegations were led by National Democratic Alliance leaders, and three by Opposition lawmakers. 'The PM thanked all the delegates and said the work they had done for the nation was commendable. When some delegates pointed out that the composition of the groups came as a surprise to many, as they could not understand how political rivals could come together, the PM said he had also learnt of this. He said some people abroad were astonished that leaders of the opposition and the ruling side were part of the same initiative,' said a second person aware of the details. Thesecondperson said the PM was apprised of the sentiments and views of world leaders, particularly about India's new diplomatic doctrine. 'In many countries, including those which are part of the OIC (Organisation of Islamic Cooperation) the doctrine underlined by the PM – blood and water cannot flow together and that all acts of terror will be considered an act of war – were discussed at length. The PM was told of the support that India's anti-terror policy has received,' the second person said. In his address to the nation after Operation Sindoor, the PM had emphasised that 'talks and terror' cannot go together and justified India's decision to put the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty, a water sharing agreement between India and Pakistan, in abeyance. India underlined that Pakistan's support to acts of terror on Indian soil was the reason for its decision. 'We apprised the Prime Minister of the overwhelming support extended by these friendly nations for India's resolute fight against terrorism and our unwavering commitment to global peace,' Shiv Sena's Shrikant Shinde said in a post on X. Shinde had led the delegation to the United Arab Emirates, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Sierra Leone, and Liberia. Some delegates told the PM that his 'personal ties and equations' with world leaders, including the Saudi Arabian leadership, contributed to the 'positive' response that India's operation had elicited. 'After a few members spoke about the impact of the all-party delegations in taking India's voice afar, the PM said there is a need to encourage such initiatives and parliamentary friendship groups should be leveraged as means of soft diplomacy to further the country's interests on the global stage,' said the first person quoted above. On the concerns in some countries about India's image as an investment destination in the wake of turmoil in the region, the PM is learnt to have said that such issues need to be addressed. He shared an anecdote about how during his visit to Japan in 2012, when he was the chief minister of Gujarat, there was a lot of curiosity about the violence in the Maruti Suzuki car manufacturing plant in Haryana's Manesar, said a third person. Among the leaders present for the meeting were the Bharatiya Janata Party's Ravi Shankar Prasad, Baijayant 'Jay' Panda, SS Ahluwalia and Anurag Thakur. Janata Dal (United)'s Sanjay Jha; All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam's Thambidurai; Shinde and former Congressman Ghulam Nabi Azad were present as well. The Opposition leaders present included Tharoor, Congress leaders Manish Tewari and Salman Khurshid; Biju Janata Dal's Sasmit Patra; Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam's Kanimozhi and Shiv Sena (UBT)'s Priyanka Chaturvedi; and NCP (SP)'s Supriya Sule. Earlier in the day, Ravi Shankar Prasad addressed a press conference and said his delegation during its meetings with European leaders showed evidence of Pakistan's links to terror attacks in India and other parts of the world. 'We clarified (to them) that we are not against the people of Pakistan. The problem is Pakistan's generals (Army) with whom Pakistan's people are also fed up,' he said. He added: 'No matter which government has been in power, they all have tried to have good relations [with Pakistan]. PM Narendra Modi invited Nawaz Sharief to his swearing in ceremony (in 2014), he attended the wedding of his grandson, yet Uri and Pulwama attacks happened ,' he said.


Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
11 yrs of Modi govt reshaped India's global image: Yogi
Lauding 11 years of the Modi government at the Centre, Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath on Tuesday described the period as a 'golden era' that not only gave India a global recognition but also replaced a legacy of political instability, corruption, appeasement and dynastic politics with a decisive, transparent and accountable model of governance. Addressing a press conference at the BJP headquarters here after inaugurating an exhibition showcasing the Centre's achievements, Yogi said the Modi years reshaped India's global image, brought clarity to policy and redefined the relationship between government and citizens. The CM asserted that India no longer responded to threats with silence but with strength. 'This is no longer a country that chants peace without resolve. If war is forced upon us, the response will be a surgical strike, an airstrike or Operation Sindoor,' he said. 'India is now tested in Pakistan and trusted by the world,' Yogi added. He credited the Modi government with restoring people's faith in democracy, dented under previous unstable regimes, and said India had achieved a new balance of cultural pride and economic growth. 'For the first time, schemes are reaching people based on need, not face,' he said, adding that the years under Modi had given the country a new governance identity rooted in clarity, transparency and public accountability. Yogi said the government had laid out a 25-year roadmap to a developed and self-reliant India, backed by inclusive growth and major strides in infrastructure, technology, and welfare. He said that the last 11 years had seen the country rise from being the 11th largest economy to the fourth, overtaking Britain and doubling its per capita income. The nation's exports had grown significantly and, at the current pace, India was poised to become the world's third-largest economy by 2027, he added. The CM highlighted how initiatives like the Prime Minister Awas Yojana, Ayushman Bharat, Jan Dhan Yojana, Ujjwala Yojana, and PM SVANidhi had brought tangible changes in the lives of the poor, making governance more result-oriented. He also praised the increased representation of women in leadership and the government's firm stance on safeguarding social justice and reservation. Emphasising the link between heritage and progress, Yogi pointed to the construction of the Ram temple in Ayodhya after 500 years, the grand statues of Sardar Patel and Subhas Chandra Bose and the overall transformation of pilgrimage towns. 'The Modi government has integrated India's civilisational legacy with its development goals,' he said. To mark the occasion, BJP leaders also announced a series of events across Uttar Pradesh, including exhibitions at district headquarters, digital contests on the changing face of India, yoga camps and outreach events focused on enrolling senior citizens under the Ayushman Bharat scheme. Central ministers, MPs, MLAs and party functionaries from booth to national level are expected to participate in these events.


India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
India's Strike Turns JeM's Terror Nursery Into a Ghost Campus – Even Google Gave Up
New Delhi: The so-called 'religious campus' once loudly proclaimed as Jamia Masjid Markaz Subhan Allah in Bahawalpur has quietly vanished from digital maps because the buildings behind the name no longer exist. Once a breeding ground for Jaish-e-Mohammed's (JeM) terror ecosystem, the 18-acre complex now sits in eerie silence. Google Maps, known for trailing behind real-world events, has marked the site 'Permanently Closed', India Today reported. Even algorithms seem to acknowledge what Islamabad will not – the terror camp is gone. And it was India that erased it. This wasn't just a symbolic pin on the map. It was a direct hit. The location, barely 100 kilometers from the India-Pakistan border, was believed to be JeM's core indoctrination centre where sermons met submachine guns and theology got rewritten with bullets. Operating under the Al-Rahmat Trust, the group's charitable front, the campus doubled as a training ground, a fund collection point and a launchpad for cross-border terror. But after the gruesome Pahalgam attack in May, India launched Operation Sindoor, a precision military retaliation that went far beyond border skirmishes. Among the nine major targets hit deep inside Pakistani territory, Markaz Subhan Allah took a direct blow. Ten members of JeM founder Masood Azhar's family reportedly perished in the airstrikes – something the group reluctantly confirmed later. As for Azhar himself, his whereabouts remain a mystery. Western agencies had picked up whispers before the strike. A Reuters report dated May 9 suggested the campus had been 'emptied of students in recent days'. It seems even Pakistan's deep state realised what was coming. What they did not expect was India's resolve. Masood Azhar and his inner circle had stayed behind, either too arrogant or too convinced of their impunity. Operation Sindoor proved both assumptions fatal. What Pakistan sold to the world as a mosque was in fact a militant mini-city. Locals referred to it as the Usman-o-Ali Campus, a code name with multiple entrances and layered perimeters. Inside were combat training zones, lecture halls for radicalization and stockpiles of weapons. Since 2012, it had grown from a humble seminary into a well-oiled machine of jihadist export. But Islamabad still insists this was all 'religious education'. If so, the curriculum included grenade drills and martyrdom manifestos. Some education system. When Google Maps Tells the Truth Pakistan Won't Normally, it takes years for places to be updated on Google Maps, especially in countries with minimal transparency. But when local Pakistani users began reporting the site as closed, Google had enough data to update the status. No reopening. No disclaimer. Just 'Permanently Closed'. Think about it – a terror training camp so synonymous with jihad that even a billion-dollar tech company finally said, 'Yup, this one is done.' In addition punishing those who carried out the deadly terrorist attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam on April 22, killing 26 innocent tourists, the aim of Operation Sindoor was sending out a message that you can rebrand terror as faith, you can use charities as camouflage, if your soil hosts murderers, it will be turned into a graveyard. India's latest doctrine is surgical, strategic and unapologetic. There is no 'plausible deniability' when an 18-acre complex disappears overnight. As always, Pakistan's official reaction was denial. No acknowledgment of the strike. No confirmation of deaths. Just the same old press briefings blaming 'external forces'. But the closed sign on Google and the charred remains of Markaz Subhan Allah say otherwise. While the Pakistani government blames Indian 'aggression', citizens are left to guess why one of their most prominent 'mosques' now looks like a crater. And why no one is showing up for Friday prayers anymore. One of the most dangerous terror launchpads in South Asia didn't just vanish. It was shut down mid-sentence. By force. By proof. And now, by Google.