RUC investigation into 1991 Belfast murder was 'ineffective', ombudsman finds
The RUC investigation into the murder of a man by loyalists in Belfast in 1991 was "ineffective" and not capable of bringing perpetrators to justice, Northern Ireland's Police Ombudsman has said.
Marie Anderson said that complaints from the family of John O'Hara about the inquiry were "legitimate and justified".
The 41-year-old father of five was working as a taxi driver when he was attacked by gunmen in Dunluce Avenue, south Belfast, on 17 April 1991.
He had arrived to pick up a fare when a number of men emerged from an alleyway and fired shots through the side window of his vehicle.
The Ulster Freedom Fighters (UFF), a loyalist paramilitary group aligned with the Ulster Defence Association (UDA), admitted the murder the following day.
Police said that Mr O'Hara had no connection to any political or paramilitary organisation.
Publishing her report, Ms Anderson said while the original RUC response was of a good standard, the subsequent murder inquiry was "not capable of bringing those responsible to justice".
She said the "inadequacy" of the investigation meant it failed to meet the legal obligation under the European Convention on Human Rights.
Ms Anderson said that police investigating the murder did not effectively pursue relevant suspects, including failing to arrest a significant number of individuals implicated by intelligence reports and other information as having been involved.
Her report also said the murder weapons can no longer be located for analysis using modern forensic techniques, and identified failures to test suspect alibis, to seize a car suspected of being used by the killers, and to conduct adequate forensic inquiries.
However, the ombudsman said that she had found nothing to suggest police had information that would have allowed them to prevent the murder.
RUC actions surrounding Mr O'Hara's murder were initially looked at as part of a larger ombudsman investigation which focused on the activities of the UDA in south Belfast between 1993 and 1998.
Mr O'Hara's killing was not included in the report on the broader investigation, published in 2022, due to the pending prosecution of a man charged in connection to the murder.
The trial was halted in December 2023 when the suspect died.
Ms Anderson said: "I am mindful that intelligence is not evidence but all investigative agencies rely on intelligence to assist in the investigation of crime.
"Intelligence can provide investigators with new lines of inquiry which may result in subsequent arrests and other investigative opportunities.
"My investigators have viewed intelligence and information that was provided to the murder investigation team that would have enabled them to identify a number of potential suspects to the murder.
"However, no arrests of these individuals followed."
She said that one potential suspect was not arrested despite being connected to the murder by witness evidence and four separate pieces of intelligence received between April and September 1991 - one of which suggested he had been one of the gunmen.
Ms Anderson also referred to intelligence received by police in late April 1991, which indicated that eight people had been involved in the murder.
"This intelligence provided a significant amount of information about the murder, which I have concluded ought to have been actioned by police.
"However, only three of those people were arrested," she said.
Her report added that another of those named in the intelligence was identified by RUC Special Branch as a possible likeness to a photofit created by witnesses who described a gunman running down the street telling people to stay indoors.
Despite having been identified on the basis of intelligence and witness evidence, he was not arrested, although his home was searched.
The search found nothing to assist the investigation of Mr O'Hara's murder.
'Concern' that suspect wasn't arrested
Police also raised an investigative action to trace and interview another of the potential suspects, rather than arrest him, the ombudsman's report said.
"I find it concerning that police had separate pieces of information suggesting that this man may have been linked to Mr O'Hara's murder yet he was not arrested.
"He was interviewed only as a witness rather than a suspect."
The ombudsman investigators found no evidence that the alibis provided by three suspects arrested in connection with Mr O'Hara's murder had been tested by police.
One was interviewed 21 times over three days in April 1991. Ms Anderson said there were only two brief mentions of the murder during the questioning.
The report said the suspect stated that he had been at his brother's house at the time of the murder.
Ms Anderson said there was no evidence that police had conducted inquiries to test this alibi.
The complaint to the ombusdman by Mr O'Hara's widow included an allegation that she had not been kept updated about the progress of the original police investigation.
As a result, she suspected there had been collusion between the RUC and those involved in the murder.
Ms Anderson said her investigators had identified and spoken to the officer who had liaising with the family during the inquiry.
He said that his point of contact with the family had been Mrs O'Hara's brother-in-law.
The ombudsman said: "The officer agreed that, because of the pressure of work at that time, together with security concerns regarding the releasing of information, there was insufficient contact with all families who found themselves in similar circumstances during this time period.
"This is a systemic issue that I have identified in other similar cases."
The ombudsman's investigation found no collusion in relation to the allegation of failures by police to update Mrs O'Hara about her husband's murder.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
3 days ago
- Sunday World
Driller killer dentist Colin Howell plans to set up evangelical church in jail
Double-murderer dentist wants to set up a new religious group behind bars The 66-year-old, who murdered his wife and his lover's husband in 1991 then staged the deaths as a double suicide, spent his initial years locked up trying to persuade the authorities to make him the on-site dentist. But as a convicted double killer he lost his licence to practise and his charm offensive failed as he was repeatedly reminded by prison staff that he was no longer eligible for the role. Hazel Stewart Today, 15 years into his 21-year-minimum jail term for the murders of his wife Lesley and police officer Trevor Buchanan, sources say he is working on a plan to become a religious leader inside HMP Maghaberry with 'renewed energy'. One said: 'Around three years ago Howell started trying to convince prison allies and the authorities that he should be permitted to set up a new evangelical church. 'He felt the religious arrangements in Maghaberry were not up to his standards and that he could do a much better job on the inside. ' Howell is always looking for a role, to be someone special, to be admired and he does it all with this sort of humble charm. He's a well behaved prisoner but he's always got a plan in mind. The plan for the new church came to nothing but now the plan appears to be underway again.' Howell is a convicted killer, repeat sex offender and a self-confessed cheat. While having an affair with a Sunday school teacher, Hazel Stewart, he murdered his wife, nurse Lesley Howell, 31, the mother of their four children by gassing her as she lay sleeping on the sofa in their sitting room in Coleraine. It was May 18, 1991, the day their son Matthew turned two. Murder victim Lesley Howell, above, and Trevor Buchanan, below . He suffocated Lesley using a garden hose attached by the rubber seal on the child's baby bottle to the car exhaust and then trailed the hose into the house directing deadly carbon monoxide to Lesley's nose and mouth as she rested following the toddler's birthday party. Once Lesley was dead Howell dumped her body in the boot of the family car, covered her with a sheet and placed a bicycle on top of her before calling Hazel Stewart to say: 'I've finished with Lesley.' He grabbed photos of his wife and a CD player to place beside his dead wife in the car in a bid to make police think she had killed herself with Trevor Buchanan. Colin Howell and Hazel Stewart murdered Lesley Howell and Trevor Buchanan before trying to make it look like a double suicide News in 90 Seconds - 09 June 2025 With Hazel in the boot, Howell drove to the home of his lover Hazel Stewart – then called Hazel Buchanan – and as she stood in the hallway of the family home, Howell subjected her husband and dad-of-two, RUC constable Trevor Buchanan, 32, to the same brutal treatment. Hazel had drugged her husband and prepared a set of clothes for Howell to dress him in after he was dead, then she took the family car out of the garage to make room for Howell's car. As Howell drove up to Hazel's house, she opened the garage door and let the killer in. Inside, Howell got down to his deadly work, having already measured enough hose pipe to drag through the Buchanan home to the bedroom. After overwhelming Trevor who was in the bed, Howell suffocated the young police officer with carbon monoxide from his running car engine. He stuffed Trevor's body into the boot beside Hazel, covered them both with the sheet and put the bike on top. The floor plans drawn by Colin Howell for police Then he drove the victims to a garage that belonged to his dead wife's late father and rearranged their bodies in a bid to make the scene look like a double suicide. He set the photos beside Lesley and placed earphones on Lesley and set a CD to play religious music. And he crammed Trevor into the front seat, forgetting to pull the seat forward to allow enough space for the 6ft-plus police officer. Howell cycled back to his house and tidied as Hazel did the same in her home, burning the hose pipe in the hearth and opening the windows to air the house, before they separately alerted friends to say Lesley and Trevor were missing. The victims were found together by police after a series of searches and following a botched investigation, their deaths were recorded as suicides. It was wrongly assumed by many that Lesley and Trevor had an affair. Howell and Hazel continued their relationship for a while, but later split up and found other spouses, leaving their murderous past behind. But in 2009, 17 years, eight months and 15 days after the murders, Howell came under pressure from his then wife to reveal all and confessed to fellows in a Coleraine church. Two days later on January 28, 2009 he gave a full and detailed interview to police in Coleraine, even sketching out the floor plans of the homes he had killed in. He told the police: 'I know I lived in a world, of believing I could do anything, like a fantasy world where I could do anything and so I probably believed I could get away with it.' In rough sketches for the police, he drew: • The floor plans of both homes; • The direction he took the hose from the car exhaust to the victims, Lesley in the sitting room and Trevor in the bedroom; • Fireplace used by Hazel to burn the hose after Howell left the house. The following year, in 2010, he pleaded guilty in court to the murders and was handed a 21-year sentence before turning evidence on Stewart. At his trial, he told the jury: 'I may have been the lead partner in the waltz but Hazel was dancing in co-operation.' Three days after Howell's police statements, Hazel Stewart was arrested and questioned by PSNI Detective Sergeant Ferris. A recording of the interview revealed the DS said: 'You were part of a plan Hazel, which was to murder two people. 'The plan was carried out and it was near the perfect murder. You got close, very close but it doesn't always work out like that and it has came to a head this week. 'It was vicious in relation to what you did, both of you. You showed no regard for your partners, you showed no regard for their families and you certainly showed no regard for your own children. 'And you made that decision that you could live with your two children who were only nine and 10 years of age and you agreed to a plan that resulted in the father of your two children being murdered in the very house where they lay sleeping. Can it get any more cold, colder than that Hazel?' She replied: 'No, no.' DS Ferris continued: 'Colin Howell could not have done this on his own and you could not have done it on your own Hazel, this had to be a joint enterprise between the two of you, the two of you had to work together to make this plan come to fruition, do you accept that?' She replied: 'Yes.' Hazel Stewart was jailed for a minimum of 18 years in 2011 and remains in prison. Last month, on May 25, 2025, she launched her third appeal against her conviction on the basis of 'coercive control' of her co-conspirator, Colin Howell. In addition to the double murders, Howell, was also later convicted of the indecent assault of five women. Each had been drugged and abused while they were patients at his dental surgery. He said in police interviews that he had drugged his lover for sex sessions but insisted it had been consensual. Today, 15 years into his 21-year-minimum jail term for the double murder of Lesley and Trevor, he remains in prison and has floated the idea again of setting up an evangelical church inside HMP Maghaberry, outside Lisburn, Co Antrim. Prison sources, who describe Howell as an 'exemplary prisoner', believe he is bored with the religious offerings available inside the jail and says he claims he 'is desperate to help others'. One said: 'Howell has deeply- held religious views, he's always praying for people and counselling them about God and he's free to do that as long as they're happy to tolerate it. But he's still going on about setting up services that are more evangelical, more happy clappy with him at the head of it no doubt. 'He has spoken to a number of people about the possibility of a new church and he'd be happy to lead it and act as pastor. He still has people on the outside who support him and pray for him and he seems to think he'd make a great spiritual leader inside jail because he says he has atoned for his sins.' But leading criminologist, Professor David Wilson believes Howell's interest to set up a new church is less about boredom or a desire to help others than to bolster his own ego. Describing him as a narcissist, Prof Wilson, an authority on understanding the criminal mind, told the Sunday World : 'Colin Howell's element of his personality is narcissism, which means he need to be the centre of attention, the need to have a sense of self which is validated not by himself, by other people. 'So how does he get that sense of self validated within an institution such as Maghaberry Prison? Well Maghaberry like all prisons, has its own subcultures with people at the top, people at the bottom, and people somewhere in the middle. And of course especially if you're serving a sentence of the length that he's serving, he will want to get as far to the top as he possibly can go. 'Having failed to use his profession as a dentist, he has to find some other way to narcissistically fulfil the need for his identity to be validated, and the way that he can do that is to say he's the pastor of a new religion or church. 'Of course, these things involve no effort. It's like the kids who turn up on talent shows having never actually sung but they think they're the next pop sensation. You actually have to work at these things. You have to train as a priest, as a chaplain, as a lay preacher. 'A charismatic religion that he wants to set up would be the whole basis in which he could move from zero to 100 miles an hour. 'That's where you see the narcissism in operation but of course, that narcissism is an elevated sense of self.' And Prof Wilson says if Howell was given the authority of flexing his evangelical muscles, he would be likely to abuse the authority. He explained: 'I would expect it to be consistent in terms of how he behaved in the community and how he behaves whilst behind bars. Now remember, prisoners pose problems in maximum on security prisons either because they're likely to be violent, or because they're likely to be psychologically manipulative and prison officers are actually very good at managing those threats, that either the violent prisoner will pose or the threats posed by somebody who's psychologically manipulative. 'You don't want to give a psychologically manipulate prisoner, a narcissistic prisoner a means by which he could use a position of authority over other people, because that's not going to have a good conclusion. 'There is an importationist element to prisons. Prisoners import who they were in the community into the jail. So that's really what's happening. 'He was charismatic in the community and that charisma doesn't disappear simply because he's behind bars, it merely finds a different outlet behind bars, but effectively, he's importing his personality and the culture in which he would get his personality to succeed.' A spokesperson for the Northern Ireland Prison Service said they do not comment on individual prisoners, and added: 'Pastoral care, religious or otherwise, within the prison setting is the primary responsibility of the Prison Chaplaincy Team. 'Chaplaincy provision is delivered by the five main Christian Churches; Roman Catholic, Presbyterian, Church of Ireland, Methodist and Free Presbyterian as well as the Muslim Faith. Also, a number of voluntary organisations offer pastoral support within prisons such as Quakers, Prison Fellowship and Saint Vincent de Paul.'
The Irish Sun
5 days ago
- The Irish Sun
Killer, 34, murdered and dismembered student, 19, on first date after ‘watching Netflix series showing mutilation'
A 34-YEAR-OLD man murdered and dismembered a college student, 19, on the first date after allegedly watching a Netflix series showing mutilation. Maxwell Anderson was convicted of homicide and dismembering a corpse on Friday for the heinous murder of Sade Robinson last year. 10 Sade was brutally murdered Credit: FB/Sade Robinson 10 Sade was on a first date with Anderson Credit: FB/sade robinson 10 Maxwell Anderson is led into the courtroom for his initial appearance in April 2024 Credit: AP The two had met at a bar and spent the rest of their evening getting dinner and drinks at the Twisted Fisherman in Milwaukee. Teen Sade then went back to Anderson's apartment where, at one point in the night, the alleged killer put on Netflix show Love, Death & Robots . One episode of the series called "The Drowned Giant" portrays the horrific mutilation of a human body on the beach. In a chilling similarity, prosecutors have claimed that monster Anderson dismembered Sade's body on a beach in Wisconsin overlooking Lake Michigan. Juror Melissa Blascoe told the "I physically felt like I was gonna throw up at that point. I know a lot of people were shaking and crying." Anderson was also charged with arson and hiding a corpse in connection with Sade's death. He was found guilty on all counts. Most read in The US Sun Cops said it's believed Anderson spread the 19-year-old's remains across Milwaukee County and burned her car in an attempt to hide key evidence. Surveillance footage showed Sade's car leaving Anderson's apartment in the early hours of April 2. Eerie new video shows 'killer' dad Travis Decker as cops fear 'expert' soldier won't be caught for MONTHS after murders It then arrived at the beach along the shores of Lake Michigan. When Sade didn't turn up for work the next day, concern was sparked on her whereabouts. The student's manager Justin Romano told CNN that she was "very outgoing, she would talk to everybody here." He added: "She was always there to lighten the mood." After Sade hadn't showed up for her shift - which "wasn't like her at all" - Justin added: "We kind of knew something was up. "We had been calling her all day." Anderson is thought to have dismembered Sade and set her car alight behind an abandoned building. He then took a bus back to is apartment. 10 Maxwell Anderson, right, with his defense attorney Anthony Cotton, left Credit: AP 10 The booking photo of Maxwell Anderson is seen as part of state exhibit in the trial of Anderson, center Credit: AP 10 A photo of the studio apartment of Sade Robinson was presented as part of the state's exhibit in the trial of Maxwell Anderson Credit: AP 10 Sade's grieving mom Sheena Scarbrough Credit: WISN 12 ABC Despite "extreme fire damage" to Sade's car, cops where able to identify the outfit the 19-year-old had been wearing on the night of the date alongside part of an iPhone consistent with hers, CNN reports. Cops had been called to Warnimont Park after a human leg was horrifically discovered, which was later identified as belonging to Sade. Anderson had planned to kill the student weeks before her death, a "confidential informant" claimed, Anderson's attorney Tony Cotton argued that the prosecution showed no evidence of his intention to kill Sade. The attorney also raised how Anderson didn't try to hide his identity as he travelled on public transport home and was also in clean clothes despite having allegedly dismembered Sade's body in a muddy location. Jurors reached their verdict in one hour on the ninth day of trial. Milwaukee County Assistant District Attorney Ian Vance-Curzan said: "While we are satisfied with this verdict, our hearts go out to the family of Sade Robinson." And Milwaukee County Sheriff's Det. JoAnn Donner - who had spent months working on the heartbreaking case - said: "My heart goes out to the family and [Sade's] friends and really, the community at large. "It's everyone's come together, and it's really hard to take that step back as a law enforcement officer and not get that really emotionally involved during the case. "I will admit that I did go back to my office after the verdict, and I had a good cry because I finally got to have that emotion. It does affect us too." Read more on the Irish Sun And Sade's grieving mom Sheena Scarbrough said in a GoFundMe set up for her daughter's memorial service that she was a "loving daughter, a cherished sister, and a dear friend to many". Anderson is to be sentenced on August 15, where he faces a mandatory life sentence in prison. 10 Prosecutor Ian Vance-Curzan holds up a jacket that had DNA in sections of the jacket from Maxwell Anderson and Sade Robinson while questioning state witness Sharon Polakowski Credit: AP 10 Sharon Polakowski, forensic scientist, senior DNA Analysis Unit from the Wisconsin State Crime Laboratory Milwaukee, testifies for the state on DNA found on clothing of Maxwell Anderson Credit: AP 10 Maxwell Anderson, center, responds to questions from Circuit Court Judge Laura Crivello after the state and defense both rest during his trial Credit: AP
Sunday World
6 days ago
- Sunday World
Loyalist prisoners issued ‘hands-off' order as UVF gun runner begins sentence
Winston 'Winkie' Irvine is over two weeks into a 30-month sentence after being convicted of a raft of arms charges. The UVF has issued a 'hands-off' order as gunrunner Winston 'Winkie' Irvine goes onto the loyalist wing in Maghaberry. The one-time UVF commander is two weeks into a 30-month sentence after being convicted of a raft of arms charges. After a short time on the committal wing he has now moved to the loyalist wing, which houses 13 UDA and UVF prisoners including those recently convicted of the murder of Ian Ogle in 2019. It is understood he will be joined by Robin Workman, who was convicted alongside him but who was handed a five-year term despite being the lesser participant in the incident, which saw police discover a bagful of guns and ammunition in the boot of Irvine's car. There are obvious tensions surrounding his conviction and many questions remain unanswered as to what was he doing driving through Belfast with a carload of weaponry. Winston 'Winkie' Irvine News in 90 Seconds - 6th June 2025 Irvine is a deeply divisive figure, distrusted by UVF members but backed by the terror group's leadership. Now the Sunday World understands chief of staff John 'Bunter' Graham has issued a decree that Irvine is not to be touched while serving his sentence. UVF members are convinced Irvine, former commander of UVF B Company in the Woodvale area of the Shankill, has compromised many volunteers down the years. He is also distrusted over his roles in attempting to resolved parades dispute, in particular the three-year stand off at Twaddell Avenue which saw the Orange Order admit defeat in their attempts to complete their Twelfth return parade to Ligoniel, which would have taken them past the Ardoyne shops flashpoint. Irvine has told friends he intends to take up where he left off when he gets out — which is likely to be within a year with time served and half his sentence on probation. And he is counting on the continued support of Graham and his trusted sidekick 'Harmless' Harry Stockman. John 'Bunter' Graham Despite deep suspicion surrounding Irvine, the pair have stood firm with him. His extensive contacts with both the British and Irish governments guaranteed a flow of grant aid and funding for community and ex-prisoner projects in loyalist areas. Irvine himself secured a stream of publicly funded jobs. At various intervals Irvine has been on the payroll at the Woodvale and Shankill Community Association, Intercomm, a conflict resolution organization which also employed a number of Sinn Féin members, the Duncairn Community Partnership, WGS Residential, WGS Green Energy, North Belfast Policing and Community Partnership and Building Cultural Networks. He is also the organiser of an annual parade on the Shankill in memory of UVF man Brian Robinson, who was shot dead by an undercover army unit in 1989. Despite pleas from the family — who did not support such an event — he went ahead, securing grant aid and charging traders for food stalls. He was also behind the Woodvale Festival, which is understood to receive funding from Belfast City Council. Robin Workman In references handed to court during his criminal proceedings, Irvine's work in trying to help broker a peace settlement in Afghanistan was praised. There is no threat against Irvine and as long as he has the backing of the leadership he will be left alone, but his time behind bars is sure to be uncomfortable. He had confided in friends that he was dreading his stint in the clink because, despite a long paramilitary career, he has no convictions. Until his guns rap, Irvine never faced criminal charges despite being identified as the masked man reading a statement on behalf of the UVF, and pictured in the Sunday World in 2005 rioting in north Belfast, which earned him the nickname 'Winkie The Crate'. He is also suspected of abandoning a cache of weapons recovered by police during the loyalist feud of 2000. 'The leadership has been discredited and embarrassed about what happened with Winkie,' said our source. There has yet to be an explanation as to what Irvine was doing with a bag of guns and ammo when intercepted by police in June 2022. Promises from his legal team of a 'significant announcement'' that would explain his actions have never materialized. His 30-month sentence — half behind bars, half on licence — also raised eyebrows, as his co-accused Robin Workman was handed a five-year tariff. It is understood PSNI forensic tests on the weapons did not uncover any evidence that they had been previously used in terrorist activity.
