Yoplait gets injunction stopping Danone launching allegedly similar yoghurt product
Yoplait Ireland Ltd is suing Nutricia Ireland Ltd, the Irish subsidiary of Danone, over alleged "passing off" the product.
Advertisement
Yoplait claims that the "get up", or packaging, of the Danone Skyr "Icelandic style" yoghurt is so similar to Yoplait "Skyr" product that consumers are likely to be confused when shopping.
Yoplait claims Danone is piggybacking on the goodwill it has built up in its product to sell its product and engaging in an unfair competitive tactic in doing so.
Nutricia argued Yoplait did not meet the requirements for an injunction and failed to provide any evidence of confusion among consumers.
On Friday, Mr Justice Max Barrett said he was satisfied to grant an injunction restraining Nutricia from passing off certain Danone products as those of Yoplait by placing them on the market in Ireland with a get up that is confusingly similar to the Yoplait products.
Advertisement
At a hearing over the injunction application earlier this week, which Nutricia opposed, the court heard both products are marketed as zero fat, high protein, low or no sugar with low calorie content based on Icelandic-style yoghurt recipes.
Yoplait launched its Skyr in 2022 while there has been Danone Skyr product in France for a number of years but Yoplait says the French packaging was distinctly different from the Yoplait Skyr.
When Nutricia launched in the UK in February last, Yoplait says the Danone product was packaged in a similar style to Yoplait product using a similar distinctive blue colour and a white mountain or iceberg while the size of the tub containers was also similar.
Nutricia disputed the claims and said Yoplait failed to meet the requirements for an injunction. Yoplait also had not provided any evidence of consumer confusion, it said.
Advertisement
In his judgment, Mr Justice Barrett said as far as the established test in relation to similar products was concerned, it was the "sheer blueness (with white as the background colour) that jumps out when one looks at the Yoplait and Danone containers that are issue".
Ireland
Calls for extra gardaí to police Rathkeale after f...
Read More
Looked at side by side in a supermarket fridge, as the court had been shown in photos, this colour trait predominated, he said.
In one photo, the "blueness of the competing Yoplait/Danone products is so pronounced that it is difficult to tell them apart in a picture," he said.
He was satisfied the balance of convenience favoured maintaining the status quo until the full hearing of the action has been determined.
He was also satisfied that in the absence of an injunction, and where Yoplait wins its main action, that the awarding of damages would not be an adequate remedy for the plaintiff firm.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
What Motherwell must do with the Lennon Miller millions
Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened. And, also, for the small matter that the club have banked a record fee at the end of it all. It was one of the great debates swirling around Motherwell all summer; which would happen first, Lennon Miller being sold or the Pig Iron pub up Brandon Parade opening its doors? We should have known better. Thankfully, there are other hostelries in the town available for any Motherwell fans seeking a consolatory pint after the departure of one of the finest young talents to have come through the club, and four and a half million or so reasons why his loss from the team isn't the end of the world. It is a great shame of course that we won't get to see Miller strut his stuff in this side being built by Jens Berthel Askou, which would surely complement his skillset and allow him to shine even more than he managed previously, but whisper it – the midfield has actually coped fine without him. In fact, that triumvirate of Elliott Watt, Lukas Fadinger and Callum Slattery looks far and away the strongest part of the team, and a match for just about any other engine room in the country. (Image: SNS Group) So, whatever portion of the Miller millions is invested back into the team, replacing him won't be the top priority. What should be, though? In terms of the squad, there will be money freed up to bolster the backline and the striking position. A ball playing centre back would be high on my wishlist, as well as a striker to provide competition (and not just back-up) to Apostolos Stamatelopoulos. Read more: The Berthel Askou reign has got off to a more than encouraging start, but the manager deserves the resource to add those finishing touches, and bring a greater goal threat into the team. That being said, this is where the board should take a breath, and resist the urge to go full John Boyle. When David Turnbull was sold, we were told that the £3.25m Motherwell banked from Celtic was a 'revolutionary' amount of money for the club. Now, granted, no one could have foreseen a global pandemic, and the money that was ploughed into the pitch was certainly well spent, but the material changes to the club's infrastructure that were mooted never quite came to fruition. This time, that has to be the priority. Improvements to the training facilities, or dare I say it, even a purpose-built training ground, should be top of the agenda. Of course, the stadium itself could be doing with a little TLC. Some further improvements to the disabled facilities would be welcome. It's no secret either that the Phil O'Donnell Stand in particular is a continual drain on finances, and could actually be doing with being pulled down, but suggestions that the money be used to build a replacement may be a little fanciful. I have it on good authority that when the club explored some options for doing just that, the minimum cost was coming in at around £5-6m for a St Mirren-style Main Stand, and that's not factoring in the loss of revenue as the stand itself is being built from tickets and hospitality. So, a more modest investment on the POD Stand and elsewhere to keep Fir Park ticking along seems, sadly, more realistic. The more impactful investment would lie elsewhere. The Miller sale has done much to bolster the club's reputation as the best place in Scotland for young players to flourish, and for me, the club should look to cement that status. Through investing in the training and academy facilities, Motherwell becomes a more desirable location for first team players, yes, but also to young prospects and their parents. Hats off to the academy staff, who have done a tremendous job nurturing Miller's talent despite the limitations of what they have to work with. If they had a base where academy and first team players can train and eat together without having to carpool it from Fir Park to Dalziel Park, then who knows what they could achieve. Or how many top prospects they could attract. Things like this may seem small from the outside, but even with the club's well-earned standing as one of the best pathways for young players in the country, they can tip the scales when parents are weighing up the pros and cons of where to send their little prodigies. Developing the next Miller has to be the priority. (Image: SNS Group) As for the lad himself, I'm sure I'm not alone in wishing him all the best at Udinese. And I'm certain I'm not alone in my relief that he didn't end up at either side of the Old Firm. With the greatest of respect to both Celtic and Rangers, I didn't much enjoy watching David Turnbull ping a 25-yarder into the top bin against Motherwell at Fir Park, and had no desire to see Miller come and control the game for the opposition either. For him, I can think of no better place than Serie A, where so many Scots have flourished of late, for him to continue his journey. It's a little crazy to think that at the end of his five-year deal with Udinese he'll still only be 23, but hopefully he will show the world what he showed the Motherwell fans and he gets yet another big-money move, banking the club another tidy sum into the bargain. Maybe then the board can build a new Main Stand, or splash out 750 grand on Ronan Hale. But for now, the Lennon Miller Training Centre has a nice ring to it.
Scottish Sun
19 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
River Island to cut 110 jobs with hundreds more at risk as 33 shops to shut in huge shake-up
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) RIVER ISLAND is set to axe 110 jobs, as it continues with restructuring plans that will see 33 shops shut for good. The high street fashion retailer previously axed 100 staff members in January, meaning that its redundancies are expected to surpass 200 by the end of the year. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 River Island is set to axe 110 staff members Credit: Alamy According to reports from Drapers, River Island is currently in talks with the impacted head office employees. It is currently unclear which departments are affected. 33 stores to shut Last Friday, the High Court approved a major restructuring plan for the business, which will see at least 33 stores shut. The plan has been put in place to help write off the fast-fashion retailer's debts. Ben Lewis, CEO of River Island, said: "We are pleased that River Island's restructuring plan has been approved by the High Court. "We have a clear transformation strategy to ensure the long-term viability of the business, and this decision gives us a strong platform to deliver this. "Recent improvements in our fashion offer and shopping experience are starting to show results, and the restructuring plan will enable us to align our store estate to our customers' needs. "We are grateful to our suppliers, landlords and other stakeholders for their constructive engagement and shared confidence in River Island's future." Rent reductions River Island also asked for rent reductions at a further 71 of its stores, and although it failed to get landlord support for this, the High Court ruling means that it is still likely to take place. A leading insolvency and restructuring lawyer said the High Court's decision has been taken "over the objections of landlords". Beloved high street chain with 24 Irish locations confirms Dublin city centre store closing down in 10 days in huge blow Michelle Quinn, partner at Grosvenor Law, said: "Absent any successful appeal, the landlords will now be subject to what is called a 'cross-class cram down' meaning that the restructuring plan will be imposed on them despite their objections." The Sun understands River Island is working with the landlords to minimise the number of store closures and job losses. A spokesperson for the fashion chain said: "We regret any job losses as a result of store closures, and we will try to keep these to a minimum." The restructuring plan, put forward by PWC revealed that if the High Court had not approved it, River Island would not be able to continue trading and would go into administration. Full list of 33 River Island stores to close Beckton Bangor Bloomfield Wrexham Edinburgh Princes Street Hereford Surrey Quays Didcot Sutton Coldfield Aylesbury Burton-Upon-Trent Northwich Taunton Workington Falkirk Cumbernauld Kirkcaldy Gloucester Hartlepool Brighton Lisburn Norwich Oxford Poole Kilmarnock Hanley Barnstaple Grimsby Leeds Birstall Park Rochdale Great Yarmouth St Helens Stockton-on-Tees Perth River Island currently has more than 250 stores across the country and around 5,500 employees. The plans mean more than 140 stores and thousands of jobs are likely to be saved. New funding is also expected to be injected into River Island now the restructuring plan has been approved. The retail sector has struggled in recent years because of the rise of online shopping, lockdowns during the coronavirus pandemic and decreased customer spending. Earlier this summer, the owners of Poundland confirmed they would shut 68 stores with 82 more at risk. Both Hobbycraft and The Original Factory Shop are also shutting branches as part of restructuring efforts.
Scottish Sun
a day ago
- Scottish Sun
Trump's ‘bombshell offer to Putin for peace' revealed…but he warns of ‘severe consequences' if despot keeps up onslaught
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DONALD Trump is reportedly planning to make a bombshell offer to Vladimir Putin to crack a ceasefire deal and end the bloody war in Ukraine. But the US prez warned that the Russians risk facing "very severe consequences" if they continue to bomb Ukraine and kill innocent civilians. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 15 Trump is reportedly planning to make a bombshell offer to Vladimir Putin to crack a ceasefire deal Credit: Reuters 15 An explosion of a drone lights up the sky over the city during a Russian drone strike, amid Russia's attack on Ukraine, in Kyiv Credit: Reuters 15 Don, who hails himself as a great dealmaker, is said to be planning to present a money-making deal to lure sanctions-hit Putin into peace-making. The deal will include opening up Alaska's natural resources to Moscow and lifting some of the American sanctions on Russia's aviation industry, The Telegraph revealed. Proposals also include giving Putin access to the rare earth minerals in the Ukrainian territories currently occupied by Russia. Trump is seemingly betting on Russia's current economy, which has been hit hard by global sanctions since he launched his illegal invasion of Ukraine. It comes as Moscow and Washington are reportedly considering a West Bank-style occupation of Ukraine to secure a truce. Under the sketched plans, Russia would have military and economic control of the occupied parts of Ukraine through a dedicated governing body, reports The Times. Ukraine's official borders wouldn't budge, but the Kremlin would pull the strings in the regions it has swiped. Witkoff apparently supported the plan, which the Americans believe offers a solution to the Ukrainian law which bans giving up land without a national referendum. Trump yesterday warned there would be 'very severe consequences' if Putin does not agree to a ceasefire. Yesterday, he spoke out after a video call with European leaders, including Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer. Trump & Putin's 1-on-1 meeting is a 'listening exercise', WH says as 'Vlad wants Ukraine to withdraw for ceasefire' Zelensky said on August 12 that Putin may deploy thousands more troops to continue attacking Ukraine and grab more land. Major General Vadym Skibitskyi, deputy chief of Ukrainian intelligence (GUR), said that Russia plans to continue its onslaught He said that Russia is ramping up long-range drone production to carry out future strikes deep inside Ukraine Europe's political chiefs also vowed to hit tyrant Putin with more sanctions if talks fail. 15 It all comes as Russia appears to be preparing to test its new nuclear-armed, nuclear-powered cruise missile, according to US researchers and a Western security source. Satellite imagery shows an increase in personnel, military equipment, ships, as well as aircraft associated with earlier tests of the 9M730 Burevestnik. Jeffrey Lewis of the California-based Middlebury Institute of International Studies and Decker Eveleth of the CNA research and analysis organisation carried out the research. They said that new satellite images show extensive preparations at the Pankovo test site on Novaya Zemlya, a remote archipelago in the Barents Sea. A Western security source confirmed that Russia is preparing a Burevestnik test. Experts say the test could happen as soon as this week, which could overshadow the scheduled meeting between Trump and Putin. Though they believe the test would have been scheduled long before the summit was announced. 15 A satellite view shows equipment at the Pankovo test site in Yuzhny Island, on the Barents Sea archipelago of Novaya Zemlya, Russia Credit: Reuters 15 Satellite imagery shows an increase in personnel, military equipment, ships, as well as aircraft associated with earlier tests of the 9M730 Burevestnik Credit: Reuters Sir Keir Starmer today welcomed Zelensky to Downing Street as Europe braces for Trump's face-to-face discussions with Putin. The meeting comes aftr Sir Keir said Britain stands ready to "increase pressure" on Russia if necessary. Yesterday, European leaders and Zelensky had a "constructive" chat with Trump, said German Chancellor Friedrich Merz. Zelensky said he pushed again for a meeting between all three leaders of Ukraine, Russia and the US after he was snubbed from Trump and Putin's head-to-head on Friday. He said he hopes a ceasefire will be the main topic of discussion in Alaska - and Merz reassured that it would be. The Ukrainian leader also slipped Trump a warning about his cunning Russian counterpart - and confirmed he would receive a call from the President after he bids Putin farewell. 15 Keir Starmer and President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky today Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 15 Starmer talks with Zelensky in the garden of 10 Downing Street Credit: AFP 15 EU leaders together during a summit Credit: PA Drawing lines Top diplomats from the US and Russia are currently working on an agreement to finalise post-war territories - but it may not be all good news for Kyiv. Putin, who has consistently rejected calls for a ceasefire, said that he wants peace but that his demands for ending his invasion were "unchanged". One major sticking point for Moscow is the annexation of more Ukrainian territory - one of Putin's long-term demands. These are some of the possible outcomes of a Ukraine ceasefire deal. What Europe wants Zelensky and European leaders are likely to reject any settlement proposals by the US that demand Ukraine give up further land. They want to freeze the current frontline as it is - giving away the territory already being held by the Russians. Zelensky has reiterated that Ukraine will not cede any further territory to Russia. 15 Putins price Luhansk and Donetsk collectively make up the region of Donbas Zelensky said that Putin wants Ukraine to withdraw from the remaining 30 per cent of the Donetsk region that it controls as part of a ceasefire deal. That's almost 3,500 square miles of land still under Kyiv's control. And losing it will hand Putin almost the entirety of the Donbas - a region comprising Ukraine's eastern industrial heartland that Putin has long coveted. 15 Kyiv cedes When the war began in 2022, Putin signed declarations annexing the entirety of Luhansk, Donetsk, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson oblasts. His troops never controlled Zaporizhzhia and were pushed out of Kherson by the Ukrainians in a daring counteroffensive. Slave to one's habits, Putin may demand further territorial concessions from Ukraine and grab more land that it already occupies. 15 Don's proposal Trump said that the only way to resolve the issues is for both sides to accept losses of land. But he added that he would try to return the territory to Ukraine. 15 The Trump administration has said that it will not engage in any agreement on a final peace deal without Ukraine's formal involvement in the negotiations. After Trump held a call with the European leaders yesterday, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz confirmed that Trump reaffirmed that Trump would not negotiate territorial issues with Putin. Meanwhile, French President Emmanuel Macron will not be engaging in any "schemes for territory swaps" during the summit. On the offensive Russian forces launched a last-minute ground attack to grab as much Ukrainian territory as possible ahead of the peace talks with Donald Trump. The lightning speed offensive saw Russian troops breaching through defence lines in eastern Ukraine in a dramatic two-pronged attack. And it could give Putin an upper hand when he meets the US President for the historic peace summit on Friday. But in the last few days, Russian sabotage and reconnaissance units pushed some six to 15 miles deep into Ukrainian territory near the town of Dobropillia in Donetsk. The catastrophic breakthrough is set to help Moscow, which currently controls over 70 per cent of the highly-contested Donetsk region. The catastrophic breakthrough is set to help Moscow, which currently controls over 70 per cent of the highly-contested Donetsk region. 15 15 Russian soldier raising a flag, reportedly following the capture of Yablunivka in Ukraine on August 12 Credit: Reuters Russian forces surged towards three villages on a section of the frontline near Kostyantynivka and Pokrovsk, the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine reported. The location of the land grab near Dobropillia is of immense strategic importance to both Moscow and Kyiv. If the Russian forces can defend the captured land and establish a secure foothold, they would be able to cut the city of Kramatorsk off from the Donbas region. Kramatorsk is the most important fortress city in Donbas that is still under Kyiv's control. And if it falls, it will hand Putin almost the entirety of the Donbas - a region comprising Ukraine's eastern industrial heartland that Putin has long coveted.
