Who did it better in Yankees-Dodgers: Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani?
LOS ANGELES — In one of the most anticipated series of the 2025 MLB season, Dodgers-Yankees made a regular-season clash at the end of May feel important. The three games counted the same as the others in the annual 162-game marathon, but in the first meeting between New York and Los Angeles since the Dodgers hoisted the World Series trophy at Yankee Stadium in November, it felt meaningful.
Add in three nationally-televised games, multiple All-Stars and league MVPs, we had the makings of a series filled with intrigue.
Advertisement
Here are three takeaways from the World Series rematch.
Aaron Judge continues to terrorize pitchers
The reigning AL MVP did not disappoint against the Dodgers and looks as locked in as he's ever been in 10 seasons. Judge went 5-for-13 in the three-game series with three homers in L.A. He continues to play at a level not seen in baseball in some time.
Judge, who's now hitting .391 on the season, is in rarified air and as June begins, it makes his chase of .400 so impressive and even more real. Hitting with that high of a batting average combined with Judge's prodigious power is unheard of in today's baseball and more closely reminiscent of the days of Tony Gwynn or Ted Williams, who was the last player to hit .400 in 1941.
Advertisement
The highest batting average in a full season since Gwynn hit .394 in the strike-shortened 1994 season (110 games) was Larry Walker, who hit .379 for the Colorado Rockies in 2000. Judge hit a career-high .322 with 58 homers in 158 games last season.
Battle of MVPs: Shohei Ohtani vs. Aaron Judge
There was theater and fireworks in this series. Judge and Shohei Ohtani, the game's two biggest stars and reigning AL and NL MVPs, did not disappoint the baseball world.
It's almost like Judge and Ohtani met before the series opener and agreed to give the people what they wanted. Once Judge kicked the festivities off with a homer in his first at-bat Friday, Ohtani matched him with a homer in his first AB. It almost felt scripted. The three-time MVP got the last laugh with a two-homer game in Friday's 8-5 win for the Dodgers.
Advertisement
It was the first time in MLB history two reigning MVPs homered in the first inning of the same game.
'I feel like he was copying me, I started it off,' Judge said jokingly Friday. 'He's impressive. One of the best players in the game for a reason.'
Shohei Ohtani tallied four hits in a three-game series against the Yankees, two of them homers. (Photo by Keith Birmingham/MediaNews Group/Pasadena Star-News via Getty Images)
(MediaNews Group/Pasadena Star-News via Getty Images via Getty Images)
Judge, not to be outdone, followed up with a two-homer game of his own in the Yankees' 18-2 loss to the Dodgers on Saturday. It gave him the 3-2 advantage over Ohtani in the series, but the Dodgers took two of three from the Bronx Bombers.
Baseball has been dying for a superstar to carry it for some time and after years of searching, it has two. And what this weekend's three-game series showed exactly why.
Advertisement
Dodgers show up against above .500 team
If you want to be the best, you have to beat the best and going into this series against the Yankees, that wasn't something the Dodgers had been doing very much, going 10-9 against teams above .500. With series victories over the Cleveland Guardians and Yankees, it's the first time L.A. has taken a series from a .500 or better club since their sweep of the Detroit Tigers to open the season stateside.
While the Dodgers hold the fourth-best record in MLB, they haven't been setting the world on fire in May, going 13-12 heading into the series vs. the Yankees.
Advertisement
This current stretch of games against October contenders, including the New York Mets who come into L.A. starting Monday for a four-game series, serves as a measuring stick for where they are.
'I wouldn't say it's a statement. That's a good club, good club over there,' Dodgers manager Dave Roberts said about the Yankees. 'So I'm just happy with the process and how we're taking the field and going about playing baseball."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
14 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
The Knicks Just Fired Their Best Coach in Decades. Are They Back to Being the Knicks?
Tom Thibodeau has been sacked as head coach of the New York Knicks following a season in which he led this comically forlorn franchise to the edge of the NBA Finals for the first time in a quarter-century. I used to feel happiness for whomever got fired as a Knicks coach—finally, they are free from this cave! Fly away! This time, it's hard not to feel bad for Thibs, a grinding lifer who transformed one of the most thankless jobs in sports. You can look at the team's decision a couple of ways. I'll do the optimistic rendering, naturally followed by the irritated, pessimistic one. This Shows the Knicks are Serious. An optimist may choose to see Thibodeau's ouster as a signal that New York's front office believes the team is close to a championship, and only a few key changes are needed to get them over the hump. Under this theory, relieving Thibodeau—a former head coach in Chicago and Minnesota who was hired by the Knicks for the 2020-21 campaign—is a painful but necessary move. It's painful because Thibodeau was undeniably successful: He built the Knicks into an overachieving unit that finished in third place in the Eastern Conference, and knocked off both Detroit and defending champion Boston in the playoffs. He wrung the best out of imperfect lineups and gave the freedom to Jalen Brunson to become a generational New York superstar. He carved Josh Hart and OG Anunoby into warriors. Thibodeau also coached Karl-Anthony Towns for 18 playoff games without opening a bottle of bourbon on the sideline. Thibodeau isn't for everyone. He's a no-nonsense obsessive who always looks like he can't find his rental car. He isn't going to get a job hosting the 'Today' show, although I would totally watch that. Instead he gave the Knicks an identity to match their city: tough, resilient, hard to kill. His team, Brunson especially, is beloved. Thibs's resistance to change could be maddening, but Madison Square Garden rocked in a way it hadn't since the Ewing/Starks days. As for why his firing is necessary…well, the Knicks must feel they are ready to go up a level, and didn't think Thibodeau was the guy to get them to take the leap. Maybe they've been ready to do it for a while, and then this playoff run made the optics weird. Much has been said about Thibodeau's stubbornness about using rookies and bench players, which led to him milking a ton of minutes from his starters. This led to injury worries, plus some frustrating moments in the playoffs, especially when Thibodeau needed to dust off his bench versus the frantic Indiana Pacers. Moving on from Thibodeau signals a change in approach, which presumably means utilizing the bench more and keeping the team fresher into May and June. But still! They just won 51 regular-season games and went deeper in the playoffs than any Knicks team in eons! They reached the postseason in four of Thibodeau's five seasons! Do you realize how sad this team was not long ago? Do you remember the soul-crushed atmosphere in the Garden, the easy punchlines about ownership and ineptitude? Do you think Kylie Jenner was going out on a date to watch THAT? Absolutely not. Under Thibs, New York found hope again. Do you see how old those Clyde Frazier and Earl Monroe championship banners are in the rafters? They're old enough to still be reading a sports column in a newspaper. Which leads to this natural but nagging worry: This Shows the Knicks are Still the Knicks. This is the fear: that maybe the Knicks maxed it out this season, shocked a Boston team that didn't take them seriously, and might not be as close to a title as they appear. The Celtics aren't looking like a huge threat as long as injured Jayson Tatum is out, but Indiana's clearly arrived, the Cavs should be solid, Detroit's rising, and Orlando might be ready to get serious. (I'm choosing to completely ignore the Western Conference and the loaded Oklahoma City Thunder, which might fire Indiana into the sun when the Finals begin on Thursday.) Maybe the Knicks are being irrational here, dismissing a coach who knew how to win basketball games, and will now do what irrational teams do, which is to find a shiny new replacement who will struggle to match the prior coach's success. The Knicks have historically craved big names, and you can expect some to surface soon. Whoever's hired will say the right things, and hit the right notes, but it doesn't mean anything until next year, when you find out if they can find a way to stop Tyrese Haliburton and Pascal Siakam. Here's the panic: Maybe this spring was as good as it got. Maybe the Knicks are heading backward, moving fast and breaking up a good thing. There will be intense pressure on who comes next—not just as coach, but to supplement Brunson, Towns and the overworked starters. There will be agony if it doesn't work. New York City, a hard-to-please town, got used to losing a lot of basketball games. Tom Thibodeau taught it how to win again. Write to Jason Gay at
Associated Press
14 minutes ago
- Associated Press
AP PHOTOS: Tiger's son, Charlie Woods, in the spotlight
Charlie Woods made his TV debut at age 11 in the PNC Championship, the tournament that pairs major champions with a family member. He has grown and matured since then. He won his first big golf tournament last week and the 16-year-old son of Tiger Woods is getting plenty of attention. ___ This is a photo gallery curated by AP photo editors. ___ AP golf:
CBS News
15 minutes ago
- CBS News
New Penn Med center in Philadelphia aims to help people with Williams syndrome, develop better treatments
A new specialty center opened Tuesday at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. It's one of the first in the country to help children and adults with Williams syndrome, a rare condition that makes them extra friendly. "This center is going to be life-changing for families," said Jocelyn Krebs, director of the Armellino Center of Excellence for Williams Syndrome. For Krebs, this work is personal. She researched the disorder for decades and then had a child born with the condition, which she calls "an insane coincidence." "Suddenly I went from a scientist who understood Williams syndrome very deeply in one way to a mom trying to figure out, what do you do with a kid that has these various challenges?" Krebs said. The center includes a sensory room with different lights and playful distractions to ease anxiety, which is common for people with Williams syndrome. Krebs' son Rhys has intellectual disabilities, a primary symptom of Williams syndrome. In collaboration with Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, the center will provide comprehensive care and research for adults and children with Williams syndrome, which often comes with severe heart problems and social challenges. "A behavior that is very characteristic of Williams syndrome, sometimes called the cocktail party syndrome because of it … is this incredible friendliness, hypersociability," Krebs said. "And what it really is is just a completely uninhibited social approach." With the right kinds of early intervention, people with Williams are able to thrive. This center will help assure that can happen and look for better treatments and new hope for brighter futures. An estimated 20,000 to 30,000 people in the United States have Williams syndrome, which is diagnosed with genetic testing. Learn more about the center on Penn Medicine's website.
