Children prescribed anti-psychotic drug while in Camhs care settle High Court actions
High Court
actions for a total of €135,000.
In one of the cases, the then nine-year-old boy gained 3.5kg in weight in the six months he was on the drug, Risperidone, which the High Court heard was not appropriate and should not have been prescribed.
They had sued the HSE over the care they received at South Kerry Camhs. None of the children can be identified by order of the court. The settlements were reached after mediation.
Robert Fitzpatrick SC with Siun Leonowicz BL told the court that the first boy had been referred to the Camhs service when he was under 10 years of age and he was prescribed the antipsychotic drug Risperidone.
READ MORE
Counsel said the drug should never have been prescribed, and it was dispensed for another five months in 2019. The young boy, he said, suffered side effects including weight gain and he had gained 3.5kg over a 23-week period.
At one stage, counsel said the boy was prescribed an appetite suppressant medication which was also inappropriate. Mr Fitzpatrick said the appetite suppressant medication appeared to be given in a misplaced effort to counteract the Risperidone, which should not have been prescribed. Counsel described it as a 'case of double error.'
Approving a €60,000 settlement in the teenager's case, Mr Justice Paul Coffey said it was fair and reasonable, and he wished the boy the best for the future.
In the second case, a 16-year-old boy settled for €75,000. Mr Fitzpatrick said the boy, when he was nine years old, had been put on Risperidone and was taking it for five months in 2018. Counsel said the antipsychotic was never appropriate for the child.
Counsel said the boy had been put on an ADHD medication which he had taken before and from which he previously suffered side effects.
By putting the boy on the ADHD drug again, counsel said he had been needlessly put through side effects. Approving the settlement, Mr Justice Coffey conveyed his best wishes to the teenager.
In a third case, a 16-year-old boy was awarded €17,500 in relation to his care at South Kerry Camhs.
Mr Fitzpatrick told the court that the boy when he was six years old had been assessed by the service, diagnosed with ADHD and started on medication. Counsel said his case related to a 23-month gap in later follow up.
At one stage counsel said the boy was prescribed the antipsychotic drug Risperidone but thanks 'to the good sense of his father, he never gave him the medication.' His case solely related to lost follow up.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Chaotic, charming and full of big ideas, comedian Johnny Vegas is the very personification of ADHD
ADHD stands for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, and it could be present in about 5pc of the population. That's a lot of missed appointments, unfinished knitted jumpers and lost phones. And that's also why the diagnostic systems both here and in the UK are overwhelmed. The problem with Do You Have ADHD? was simply this: one programme wasn't enough to contain the sheer range of what is currently known as ADHD. Between the child psychiatrist and the online influencers it was jumping around and, perhaps predictably, kind of disjointed. We followed a lovely doctor, Clare Bailey Mosley – widow of the telly and radio health expert, Dr Michael Mosley – as she revealed all the classic symptoms of ADHD. Her school reports said she should pay more attention, her late husband's complaints about her timekeeping, the way she had completely forgotten about a saucepan of boiling rice in a friend's kitchen. Although burning rice could happen to anyone? We had been sitting in front of our televisions going: 'Yeah, Clare definitely has it'. But it turned out that Clare just hadn't suffered enough to be diagnosed with ADHD. Part of the diagnostic process is called 'impairment', apparently. As in, how much has having the symptoms of ADHD impaired your life? How much has it disadvantaged you? Did you have the potential to be a tech bro, for example, but ended up living in a bin? That doesn't sound very scientific to me. If cancer hasn't had a negative impact on your life – so far – does that then mean you don't have cancer? If you have coronary heart disease but are managing fine, does that mean you don't have coronary heart disease? The thing is, Clare wasn't living in a bin, but in a very nice house and wearing a lovely green suit. She has had a career in medicine, for God's sake. It was at this point that everyone who suspects that they may have ADHD – and also their parents – was leaning towards the TV shouting: 'How did Clare manage to have such a successful life?' But the programme never provided this vital information. Clare walked out of the assessment room in her lovely green suit and we were none the wiser. The following night on Johnny Vegas: Art, ADHD & Me, we meet Vegas's personal assistant, Bev. Bev knows a thing or two about ADHD because she's living with it at close quarters. Vegas, with his charm and his chaos and his big ideas, seems to be, as someone said here, the very personification of ADHD. Bev could actually be that traditional figure, the comedian's wife. She laughs at all Johnny's jokes, jollies him along and generally takes care of all the tough stuff: bookings, phone calls, deadlines. In other words, she's his personal assistant. Johnny was just full of love for his hometown of St Helen's, where he wanted to create a public art project as a way of saying thank you to the population. Vegas is a funny person. But here he was frequently emotional and often close to tears. His personal crisis looked like much more than ADHD. And the art looked terrible, Johnny seemed to get a lot of hugs from women, and to tell them he loved them. Needy doesn't begin to cover it, and this is a brilliant man. The most telling scene came when Johnny met three men he went to art college with. These guys actually were artists: thin, hard-headed and terrifyingly practical. They didn't give much for Johnny's chances of finishing the public art project – or indeed of starting it. With three months to go before his first one-man exhibition, Johnny went out and bought a dodgem car. When he and Bev went out to look for possible sites for the public art project, it was Bev who took the photos. There didn't seem to be much work going on – at least work by Johnny. 'I'm like God, and I've just come up with the tadpole and I'm knackered,' he said. If he can come out with lines like this you wonder why he's bothering with public art projects. But backstage at a comedy gig, Johnny said: 'I'm not funny, I just crave acceptance.' Shortly after that Bev had to ring everybody to tell them that Johnny was taking a year off. In the second programme, Johnny had his new diagnosis of ADHD. Bev had known he had it all along. The new public art project is an iron frame, which looks like a giant Dalek, holding 72 tiles, painted by Johnny, showing aspects of his beloved St Helens. But only 20 of the 72 tiles actually fit into the Dalek frame. Johnny has been trimming tiles for 48 hours. 'Measure once, cut nine times, that's what I say,' he said. Then the Dalek frame is too big to get out of the workshop. It all ended in happy tears. 'Thank God it's over,' said Bev.
Irish Times
4 days ago
- Irish Times
Do You Have ADHD? ‘It feels like there's always a swarm of bees in my brain'
There has been a surge in cases of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, or ADHD , with much of the awareness about the condition driven by influencers on TikTok and Instagram. But has incidence of ADHD truly increased, or are we simply more alert to the symptoms than we used to be? That question is considered, though never satisfactorily answered, by Dr Karan Rajan, a British surgeon, in his enjoyable Do You Have ADHD? (Channel 4, Tuesday, 8pm). Rajan doesn't pretend to be a definitive expert on the subject, and he's upfront that the documentary is an introduction rather than a deep dive. He goes out on the street to talk to people with ADHD about their experiences. 'My brain feels as if there are all these particles firing,' one of them, Ellie, says. 'It feels like there is always a swarm of bees in my brain trying to fight each other,' another, Milly, explains. There is also a guinea pig of sorts in Dr Clare Bailey Mosley, widow of Dr Michael Mosley (a relatively obscure figure in Ireland but a national treasure in Britain), who believes that both she and her late husband had undiagnosed ADHD. READ MORE She puts that theory to the test by going for a professional diagnosis; Rajan advises those in a similar situation to first complete an ADHD screening questionnaire devised by the World Health Organisation. He is at pains to point out that the questionnaire is not itself a diagnostic tool. Still, it could indicate whether it might be helpful to seek a professional assessment. That's sufficient for Bailey Mosley, who answers 'yes' to a question about having trouble wrapping up the final details of a project. 'I do kind of fade towards the end,' she says. Is a diagnosis recommended in every case? It depends, according to the ADHD researcher Val Harpin. For children, the answer is always yes: 'There are no downsides.' For adults, the question can be more nuanced. 'Older people have different responses. The biggest is relief,' she says – ''Yeah, that explains it'' – but 'sometimes it makes them feel resentful: 'My life could have been different if I'd known.'' Rajan acknowledges that there's an element of faddishness to some of the online conversation about ADHD. He points to TikTokers who diagnose 'T-rex arm' – which is to say holding your arms close to your body, with your wrists limp – as a trait. 'Be mindful,' he warns, 'of internet diagnosis.' That said, ADHD is not at all uncommon. It seems to affect about 5 per cent of people – more than epilepsy or autism, at 1 per cent each – according to Prof Stephen Scott. But experiencing symptoms doesn't mean you need professional assistance, as Bailey Mosley discovers. She goes for an assessment but 'falls' at the final hurdle after it's concluded that she doesn't experience any 'impairment' in her day-to-day life. She sounds relieved rather than disappointed – though others believe ADHD is, in the round, a benefit. A journalist with the Ladbible website says the condition has given him the ability to 'hyperfocus' at work. The point is taken up by the daredevil George King, who was jailed after scaling the Shard skyscraper in London. He says his ADHD played a huge part in his climb. 'When I have something that means something to me, all those [out of control] thoughts get compressed,' he says. 'The universe gets out of the way.'
Irish Examiner
5 days ago
- Irish Examiner
CervicalCheck diagnosed and treated 162 women for cervical cancer in a year
Over the course of one year alone 162 women were diagnosed and treated for cervical cancer through CervicalCheck, a new report shows. The report, covering April 2022-March 2023, also shows that among 269,550 women screened some 11% had HPV - the virus responsible for almost all cervical cancer. These women are monitored so if cancer develops it can be treated early. The report found that 75% of eligible women were tested, while the target is 80% and CervicalCheck clinical director Dr Noirin Russell is keen to see this 80% figure reached. She has raised concerns about 'women who are on the fence' about testing, saying they may not be aware of the benefits of regular testing. "If a woman is diagnosed with cancer after attending for screening, there's an 80% chance she will be diagnosed with stage 1," she said. This early stage can be more treatable. 'In Ireland today your chance of being diagnosed with a late stage cancer, so Stage 2 or above, if you get screened is one in 10,000. If you don't get screened, it's 10 times higher,' she said. This is because screening can help identify early signs of cancer. 'The incidence (of cervical cancer) has gone from 15 per 100,000 down to 10 per 100,000, that's the proof the programme works,' she said. She acknowledged 'this terrible outcome that we see in the newspapers and we really all want to avoid - it's one in 10,000 so that means it is someone'. Dr Russell said she could not comment on individual cases. Concerns around cervical cancer testing were back in the spotlight in June when Cork woman Leona Macken received an apology for failings in her care at the High Court. Ms Macken, who has cervical cancer, sued over two tests, conducted in 2016 and 2020, which it was claimed were incorrectly reported as negative. Sample checking is currently shared between Quest Diagnostics in America and the national laboratory in Dublin. Dr Russell said she is aware of calls to conduct checks only in Ireland. Leona Macken (centre) and her husband Alan (right) settled their legal action against the HSE arising from what they said were failures in the CervicalCheck screening programme in 2016 and 2020. File photo: Collins Courts '(the Irish laboratory) never did more than 10% until this year, and they are on target to get up to approximately 20% of the programme work,' she said. However, she said that interval cancers – cervical cancer found between screening tests – and false negative results can happen in all systems. 'That is not limited to a particular laboratory, that is going to be what we find in cancer cases,' she said. She has worked with advocacy group 221 plus on reforms, saying: 'They felt the programme didn't really explain false negatives and that this is a possible outcome.' She urged: 'It's really important that anyone with symptoms, even if they've had a normal screening test, have those symptoms investigated.' Dr Russell has visited Quest Diagnostics, saying: 'It's done in a particular quarter of the laboratory, so it's a completely different pathway of care. And they follow the Irish standards.' The scientists also do regular skills-tests where they check already-analysed samples and must match the results in 95% of cases. This is assessed by Quest and in Limerick by the National Cervical Screening Programme. Dr Russell said: 'There is an understanding in the cyto-screening community that you can't ask your screeners to get 100% in the proficiency test. If they are getting 95% they are working at the most achievable human level there is but then there will be abnormalities that are missed.'
