Walters: New California school data project fulfills campaign promise Newsom made
When reminded of them after becoming governor, he dismissed them as 'aspirational,' a caveat he neglected to attach to his original pledges.
Nevertheless, credit is due when one of his promises becomes reality, as it did this week when the state launched the beginnings of a long-needed system of tracking how the state's public school students fare in classrooms and later in life.
The Cradle-to-Career project released its first batch of numbers, along with video tutorials on how to access the data.
'With the C2C Student Pathways Dashboard now live, Californians can visualize their futures by seeing disconnected data from across sectors and previously unavailable insights, all in one place,' Newsom said in a statement. 'The Golden State is once again leading the way in innovation, connecting our education system to the workforce to ensure everyone has the freedom to succeed.'
However, not everyone in the rarified ranks of education researchers and reformers echoed Newsom's boasts.
Alex Barrios, president of the Educational Results Partnership, a business-backed education policy coalition, complained that 'the dashboard fails to do what it promised. It doesn't represent the journeys of all students and how they navigate to and through careers.
'By following the career trajectories of only college graduates, it assumes the only path to success for students is through a four-year college degree,' Barrio alleges.
The new data system should include all of the factors that Barrio's organization lists, but its criticism may be premature, since officials say they intend to expand the project's scope as rapidly as it can obtain data.
Assuming that the project does widen its reach, C2C, as it's dubbed, not only will be a lasting accomplishment for Newsom, but it will fill a void that's existed far too long. Without reliable data on outcomes, the nation's largest school system operates in an accountability vacuum, which the education establishment seems to prefer.
The state Department of Education has a 'dashboard' that purports to give parents, taxpayers and voters a picture of how well schools are doing their job. However, the current system is a mishmash of educational jargon that is difficult to decipher. It also skews the ratings in ways that minimize actual academic achievement, such as in reading, writing and mathematics, and elevates peripheral factors it calls 'multiple measures.'
Thus, it downplays the fact that California's students fare very poorly vis-a-vis those in other states and the 'achievement gap' still broadly separates low-income and English-learner students from those with more privileged circumstances.
Education reformers have long pushed for obtaining and publishing more objective and complete data, especially after former Gov. Jerry Brown and the Legislature overhauled school finance a decade ago to provide more funds to schools with substantial numbers of what were called 'at-risk' students.
Better numbers would, the reformers said, provide a clearer understanding of whether Brown's Local Control Funding Formula was working.
Brown, however, backed the education establishment's preference for getting the money without strict accountability for how it was spent and whether it was having a positive effect. He said he trusted that local school officials would spend the extra money wisely, calling it 'subsidiarity,' a secular version of an obscure religious principle.
After Newsom succeeded Brown he quickly reversed that position and called for a comprehensive data system to track how students were faring during and after their journeys through the school system. The Legislature responded by authorizing the C2C system.
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California's state Capitol works and why it matters.
This article originally appeared on Ventura County Star: Walters: New California school data site fulfills a Newsom promise made
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
29 minutes ago
- The Hill
Newsom requests DHS records on Border Patrol activity outside press event
California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) is seeking information from the Trump administration about why federal agents were present at an event he held with other Democrats to discuss redistricting efforts last week. The governor, who is a frequent critic of President Trump, filed a formal records request Sunday with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) seeking 'all documents and records, including but not limited to text messages, Microsoft Teams messages, phone logs, risk assessments and memoranda' related to the presence of Border Patrol officers at his downtown Los Angeles press conference on Thursday. 'Trump's use of the military and federal law enforcement to try to intimidate his political opponents is yet another dangerous step towards authoritarianism,' Newsom said in a statement. 'Trump is attempting to advance a playbook from the despots he admires in Russia and North Korea.' 'We will not back down in our defense of democratic freedom, and the Trump administration should answer for this pathetic and cowardly behavior,' he added. DHS didn't immediately respond to The Hill's request for comment on Newsom's allegations or his pursuit of federal records. Newsom has emerged as a key figure in the ongoing tit-for-tat between red and blue states over drawing new Congressional maps to be more favorable to their respective parties in the upcoming midterm House elections. During the L.A. news conference, Newsom announced plans for a ballot measure to temporarily bypass the state's independent redistricting commission in favor of a map favorable to Democrats that would counter the GOP's redistricting push in Texas.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Schwarzenegger teases a fight against Newsom over redistricting
Former California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger (R) teased a fight with Gov. Gavin Newsom's (D) redistricting push in a post on social media Friday as Democrats in the state look to redraw their maps in response to similar moves in Texas. 'I'm getting ready for the gerrymandering battle,' Schwarzenegger wrote, including a photo of him lifting weights. He also wore a shirt that read 'F‑‑‑ the politicians' and 'terminate gerrymandering.' California is moving forward with its own plans to redraw the state's map as it looks to neutralize a proposed House map in Texas that would net the Republicans five seats in the midterms. 'We're putting maps on the ballot, and we're giving the power to the people,' Newsom said at a rally Thursday. 'This will be the first redistricting that's ever done that. That's the difference.' California is expected to see a special election over the mid-decade redistricting in November; Newsom has noted the state is not looking to eliminate its independent redistricting commission. But the move has received some criticism, including from those around Schwarzenegger's team. Schwarzenegger helped championed California's independent redistricting commission, which draws the legislative and congressional maps in the state and is seen as a gold standard in fair, redistricting efforts. 'Governor Schwarzenegger has a 20 year history of battling gerrymandering, taking power from the politicians and returning it to the people where it belongs, and he believes gerrymandering is evil no matter who does it. He still stands by the rule we learn in pre-school: two wrongs don't make a right,' Daniel Ketchell, a spokesperson for the former governor, said in a statement earlier this year. 'He will continue to be on the side of the people and not politicians – from either party – on this issue,' he added. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Solve the daily Crossword
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
Trump releases new rules to limit a major student-loan forgiveness program for public servants
President Donald Trump's administration published its new rules to narrow eligibility for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program on Monday. The public comment period — during which anyone can submit comments on the new regulations to the administration — is officially open through September 17. PSLF, which is intended to forgive student debt for government and nonprofit workers after 10 years of qualifying payments, has allowed for the discharge of over a billion dollars in student debt for public servants. Trump is seeking to alter the program — he signed an executive order in March asking the education secretary to redefine what "public service" means to remove PSLF eligibility for employers engaging in "anti-American" activities. The proposed rule to limit PSLF, published in the Federal Register, said that "in cases where an employer is deemed to have engaged in activities that breach federal or state law or established public policy, affected borrowers would no longer receive credit toward loan forgiveness for months worked after the effective date of ineligibility." "While this may delay or prevent forgiveness for a subset of borrowers, the overall design of the regulations—including advance notice, transparency around determinations, and employer recertification pathways—helps mitigate unexpected harm," the rule said. Compromising behavior by an employer, according to the rule, could include violation of the federal disabilities act; violation of federal immigration law; what the department characterizes as "chemical castration or mutilation," like the use of puberty blockers or hormones to help a transgender person transition; and acts of terrorism. The Department of Education held negotiation sessions with stakeholders in early July, and some members of the committee expressed concerns with the department's intent to limit the program. "The intent of Congress was not to narrow the eligibility," Betsy Mayotte, the president of The Institute of Student Loan Advisors and arepresentative of student-loan borrowers, said during a session. "It was to make it as expansive as possible under the statute that they wrote." Representatives of the administration argued that the education secretary has the authority to interpret regulations and statutes and can legally refine PSLF. Student-loan borrowers enrolled in PSLF previously told Business Insider that Trump's plans to change a program they rely on for debt relief are a major concern. "I'm so close to the finish line," Jeff Hughes, a government employee with student debt, said. "I really hope that the program continues as is because we need some more good people out there doing good work." Undersecretary of Education Nicholas Kent said in a statement that "the federal government has a vital interest in deterring unlawful conduct, and we're moving quickly to ensure employers don't benefit while breaking the law."
