Homeowner vows to fight council order to tear down fence protecting her garden
A Livingston woman has vowed to fight on against an order by councillors to tear down a fence she put up to protect her garden.
Dawn Gardner accused West Lothian Council's development management committee of 'bullying' behaviour and of ignoring a decision by Scottish ministers, which agreed the land belonged to her.
Mrs Gardner partially won an appeal to the Scottish Government last year and had to retrospectively apply for new permission to keep the fence.
She told the Local Democracy Reporting Service that the fence had been put up to stop persistent dog fouling and littering over the area of land beside her home.
The corner site is in her title deeds, and she has to maintain it, as did the previous owner of the house in Waverley Crescent.
Before the fence was put up, the land was frequently used as a shortcut by some, and the last straw for Mrs Gardner was seeing drunks urinating against a garden wall just feet from her back door.
Mrs Gardner paid thousands of pounds to have the area fenced off to create more privacy around her home. While most of the fence is low enough to be allowed as permitted development, one section is just a few inches above the height permitted.
Council planning officers told a meeting of the DMC that, while they did not fully agree with the Scottish Government's Reporter's partial upholding of the appeal, they did recommend retrospective planning permission for the fence along with planning permission to build a double garage within the garden of the house be approved.
Eliburn Community Council complained last year about the enclosure of open space and it reiterated that when Steve Egan appeared before the committee.
He said: 'The community council's objection was to the loss of open space. Why have stated policies and not followed them? The officer's report is wholly silent on this.'
An agent for Mrs Gardner said Mr Egan had an 'unhealthy obsession' with the issue of open space around Mrs Gardner's home, adding she had fenced in land she owned to protect her home against criminal behaviour.
However, councillors did not like the fence.
Councillor George Paul said, 'The quality of finish is very poor. I don't think it's very aesthetic to the area.'
Councillor Pauline Stafford said: 'It appears that the fence is in breach of planning legislation; the height of the fence detracts from the streetscape, which most other properties have quite an open aspect.'
Chairing the meeting, Councillor Tony Boyle said the fence was 'really intrusive'.
He added: 'I note there are no objections from neighbouring householders, but that's beside the point.'
Having sought clarification from planning and legal officers, the DMC agreed to grant permission for the garage but refused permission for the fence.
After the meeting, a furious Mrs Gardner told the LDRS: ' A new appeal goes in tomorrow.'
She added: 'The councillors took no notice of what the Scottish ministers said. They didn't even listen to the planning officer.'
Referring to the councillors, she said: 'They were making really personal remarks. Some of the comments were very personal. There's nothing wrong with the fence.
'I thought it was bullying. There was not one decision based on fact; it was all personal opinion, and they didn't even look at what the ministers said.
Mrs Gardner said she had the support of surrounding neighbours who have told her the fence is better than the unkempt open ground there previously.
As for the objection: 'Eliburn Community council didn't even discuss it, it was never on their agenda,' she added.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
Police issue urgent appeal to trace missing Ayrshire man who vanished
Frazer John Duncan, 35, was last seen in the Kilwinning Road area of Irvine yesterday afternoon, Sunday, June 8. Police are appealing for information in bid to find a missing Ayrshire man. Frazer John Duncan, 35, was reported missing from his home in Irvine yesterday, Sunday, June 8. He was last seen in the Kilwinning Road area of the town at around 4pm yesterday. Enquiries so far by police have revealed that he is known to frequent the Irvine town centre area. Frazer is described as white Scottish, six feet tall with short, brown hair. He was last seen wearing a grey hoodie over a red Rangers football top, blue tracksuit bottoms and blue trainers. Police are now appealing for information as they seek to trace his whereabouts. A spokesperson for Police Scotland said: "Officers from Ayrshire are seeking the assistance of the public to trace a 35-year-old male missing from Irvine in North Ayrshire. "Frazer John Duncan was last seen near to Kilwinning Road, Irvine about 4pm on Sunday, June 8. "He is described as white Scottish, 6'0', short brown hair and was last seen wearing a grey hoodie over a red Rangers football top, blue tracksuit bottoms and blue trainers. "Extensive enquiries are underway which have so far revealed that Frazer is known to frequent the Irvine town centre area. "Anyone with information is asked to call officers at Irvine Police office on the police non-emergency number, 101, quoting incident 2095 of June 8."
Glasgow Times
4 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Urgent search launched for missing man Christopher Bennett
Christopher Bennett was last spotted on Kilwinning Road in Irvine around 1.30pm on Saturday, June 7. The 40-year-old is described as white Scottish, approximately 5ft 8in tall, with shaven black hair. At the time of his disappearance, he was wearing a black hoodie featuring a 'CK' logo on the front, blue jeans, and white trainers. READ MORE: Man wearing Rangers top vanishes as police launch urgent search READ MORE: 'We never gave up': Family's heartbreaking tribute as body of missing teen found He may also be carrying black sunglasses and a mobile phone, and is known to be a smoker. Search teams have highlighted Mr Bennett's familiarity with the Three Towns area, as well as Dumfries and Galloway. He is also known to frequent Troon Beach. Police have confirmed that extensive enquiries are ongoing, and anyone with information is asked to call officers at the Irvine Police office on the police non-emergency number, 101.
The Herald Scotland
4 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Fair Work is still a distant dream for some of Scotland's arts sector
That's a lot. More than people realise and it is high time they were treated fairly. Our latest STUC report, Freelance and Forgotten, crashes open the stage door and draws back the curtain on Scotland's arts & culture sector. It paints a very different picture that the reality we dare to dream whilst getting lost in the dazzling performances of our favourite artists. It's a sector of exploitation, insecurity and systemic neglect. The voices of over 800 workers from across the sector were unequivocal: Fair Work is still a distant dream for most creative freelancers in Scotland. Read More It's cheap of Labour to pin the blame on migrants in dinghies It's time to offer hope - but we can't do it alone This is not a just war, it's terrorism and psychological warfare We have power to nationalise Scotland's bus services - so let's use it Fair Work is capitalised for a reason. I refer to the Scottish Government's Fair Work agenda whereby they – and unions too – hoped Scotland would become a leading Fair Work nation by 2025. Needless to say, we haven't. Not through lack of trying. Trade unions, including our creative unions like Equity, BECTU, the Musicians' Union and others, wholeheartedly support the Fair Work agenda. We want what every worker deserves: decent pay, secure contracts, safe workplaces and a voice on the job. But in the arts sector, this vision is being undermined by structural exploitation and a culture that too often ignores the basic rights and dignity of workers. Let's be clear: the creative industries in Scotland are not short of talent or value; they're just short of fairness. Our report reveals that 69% of freelance creatives have faced late payments with one third not being paid at all for work already completed. One respondent described waiting 10 months to be paid by a 'prestigious' university. Others described stolen artwork, ghosting by clients who don't respond to their requests for payment, and having to fight tooth and nail for basic compensation. In any other industry, this would be deemed unacceptable and the culprits named and shamed. In the arts, where word of mouth is often the best way to get your next gig, it's a by-product of a sector that's allowed exploitation to run rampant. It doesn't stop at pay. Oh no – this sorry chapter has many acts. Nearly 75% of freelance creatives told us they rarely or never have access to a clear and accessible complaints process. More than 50% have experienced bullying, harassment or sexual harassment. Shockingly, 46% reported losing work or income due to illness, bereavement, or maternity leave. Further, more shockingly, we've seen testimony of workers being offered work in exchange for sexual favours or being throttled and yelled at. This is the reality for many workers in our creative industries. Yet these conditions are a direct contradiction of the Scottish Government's commitment to Fair Work. The principle that everyone should have access to work that is secure, respectful and pays fairly is being flouted in a sector largely supported by public funding. The Scottish Government supports culture and the arts to the tune of £280m a year. Creative Scotland, our national funding body, disperses tens of millions of pounds each year. Yet our report makes clear that the oversight, monitoring and enforcement of Fair Work standards is virtually non-existent for freelance workers. Too often, freelancers are treated as disposable and expected to deliver world-class work under poverty conditions, without contracts, sick pay, or any of the employment rights unions fight for day in and day out. These are skilled professionals, not cheap labour. They are lighting designers, playwrights, actors, musicians, choreographers, technicians and more. Without them, the spotlights will dim, the orchestra will fall silent and, despite the adage, the show literally cannot go on. So let's raise the standards as we raise the curtain. We need funding conditions that are tied explicitly to Fair Work standards for freelancers. This means organisations receiving public money must adopt the STUC's Fair Work for Freelancers Checklist, recognise unions as the legitimate voice of workers and work with unions to create binding Fair Work Agreements. Our report also calls for Creative Scotland to be given a specific remit to support workers and monitor fair practice within funded organisations. We need to end the culture of silence and fear. A third of workers surveyed had signed non-disclosure agreements that silenced them about their work. One respondent described being forced to sign a non-disclosure agreement just to be paid, only to discover the contract banned them from even showing their work in their portfolio. Another told us of being harassed while an entire crew looked on and said nothing. In any other industry, there would be uproar. In the arts, too many are afraid to speak out for fear of being blacklisted. That is the personification of a power imbalance. Powerful producers, directors, showrunners and more keep workers in a state of silence and fear for worrying about where they may get their next gig. That must end. As should the awful, derisory levels of pay. More than 80% of respondents reported a real terms fall in earnings, with many struggling to earn even £10,000 a year despite years of experience. Equal pay remains a fiction, with women and marginalised groups consistently paid less than male counterparts for the same work. These issues don't only impact on the workers themselves. They impact on what we see on our screens, on the stage and in our galleries. Working class artists are being driven out of the industry. If Scotland's art and culture is left to those with income and wealth to fall back on, then it won't reflect who we are as a nation. As we turn up the lights on this sorry saga of exploitation, let's do so in the hope that our freelancers and our creatives can secure decent levels of funding to support their aspirations and realise their creative vision. Fair pay is central to that and the Scottish Government has rightly set high expectations around Fair Work. Now is the time to deliver on those promises. Roz Foyer is general secretary of the STUC
