French government faces a buzzkill: One million petitioners say ‘no' to bee killer pesticide
The so-called 'Duplomb law' has stirred public anger for permitting a return of acetamiprid — a chemical known to be toxic to pollinators such as bees and to ecosystems. It was adopted on July 8 but has not yet come into effect.
A 23-year-old master's student launched the petition against the law on July 10, with support quickly snowballing with the backing of many including actors and several left-wing lawmakers. More than 500,000 people signed it in 24 hours from Saturday and Sunday alone.
The law's proponents however argue farmers face too much regulation in France as is, and allowing them to use acetamiprid again would help reduce the constraints they face.
National Assembly Speaker Yael Braun-Pivet on Sunday ruled out abandoning the legislation, named after the conservative lawmaker who proposed it, as it would 'save a certain number of our farmers'.
The petition's author, Eleonore Pattery, who describes herself as 'a future environmental health professional', called the new law a 'scientific, ethical, environmental and public health aberration'.
'It represents a frontal attack on public health, biodiversity, the coherence of climate policies, food security, and common sense,' she said.
'Bee killer'
Acetamiprid has been banned in France since 2018, but remains legal within the European Union.
The insecticide is particularly sought after by beet and hazelnut growers, who say they have no alternative against pests and face unfair competition.
On the other hand, beekeepers have branded the chemical 'a bee killer'. French scientists who have studied its disorientating effects on bees confirm it is toxic to them.
Its effects on humans are also a source of concern but, in the absence of large-scale studies, its risks remain unclear.
The petition calls for the 'immediate repeal' of the law and a 'citizen-led consultation involving health, agricultural, environmental and legal stakeholders'.
Launched on July 10, two days after the Senate adopted the text, it had already passed 500,000 signatures on Saturday.
Appeal to Macron
Petitions do not in themselves trigger a review or repeal of the legislation but unprecedented public support may prompt renewed parliamentary discussion on the matter.
Under French rules, if a petition reaches 500,000 verified signatures, the National Assembly may choose to hold a public debate limited to the content of the petition itself.
Speaker Braun-Pivet told the broadcaster franceinfo on Sunday she would be in favour of such a debate, but lawmakers 'could not in any case go back on the law which has been voted through'.
President Emmanuel Macron does have the power to send the text back for deputies to re-examine it, and on Sunday Green party leader Marine Tondelier appealed to him to do just that in a video posted online.
In late June, ahead of the law's passage, several thousand demonstrators—including farmers, environmental organisations and scientists — rallied across France calling for the bill to be withdrawn. — AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
3 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Niche and needed: German SMEs weather Trump tariffs with specialist tech
FRANKFURT, Aug 7 — While Germany's big companies groan under the US tariff burden, many small and midsize firms, the backbone of Europe's top economy, are confident their highly-specialised goods will just keep selling. The hope is that, in niche areas where American customers have no obvious alternatives, buyers across the Atlantic will just have to accept paying higher prices for their high-tech machines and products. 'The customer in America pays the tariff,' said Thorsten Bauer, co-head of laser maker Xiton Photonics, based in the western city of Kaiserslautern. 'We don't notice a thing.' Bauer's firm of about 20 workers is in this respect typical of the often family-owned enterprises that make up the German 'Mittelstand', Deutsche Bank executive Jan-Philipp Gillmann said. 'German Mittelstand companies are somewhat protected since they are often very specialised, sometimes the only firm that makes a particular part,' said Gillmann, Deutsche Bank's Head of Corporate Bank Europe. 'The cost of the tariff will often be borne by the consumer.' Under a framework deal agreed in late July, EU exports are set to face across-the-board US tariffs of 15 per cent from Thursday — higher than traditional duties but much lower than Trump's threatened 30 per cent. While German corporate titans such as automaker Volkswagen have grabbed headlines by taking tariff hits measured in the billions, many of the smaller firms hope to weather the headwinds. Brian Fuerderer, head and founder of Microqore Medical, a high-end surgical equipment maker with 32 employees, agreed. 'It's not possible to just copy 'Made in Germany,'' he said. 'There's not much comparable to what we in Germany do when it comes to medical technology.' He added that US tariffs would have to rise to 30 or even 40 per cent before American customers got cold feet. 'For Volkswagen, for big business, it's hard,' he said. 'But if you have a real niche, something only certain specialists can do, demand will carry on as before.' 'No legal certainty' The Mittelstand's rugged optimism defies Trump's repeated statements that foreign companies — not American importers or consumers — will pay the tariffs. That does not mean the levies — and the past months of uncertainty around them — have left the small and medium enterprises entirely unscathed. The United States is Germany's largest trading partner and Trump's on-again, off-again tariff blitz has already had an impact. 'When all the tariffs started, I made no US sales for three months,' Bauer said. 'You don't spend money if you don't know how things will look in the next six months.' He hopes the latest agreement fixing duties at 15 per cent, up from a provisional 10 per cent in the lead-up to an August 1 deadline, will at least give American companies the confidence to place orders again. But he is not entirely sure, pointing to Trump's highly changeable tariff policies. 'There's no legal certainty, basically,' Bauer said. 'I am trying to push up sales in Europe with discounts and things like that, to be less dependent on the international market.' 'Regulating ourselves to death' About a quarter of Xiton Photonic's sales are exports to the United States and it would be hard to diversify, Bauer said, since his high-tech customers are more often found in Japan, China or America than in Europe. Wider geopolitical tensions mean there is no easy answer. 'China could equally turn around tomorrow and say: 'We are not importing anything from the EU,'' said Bauer. 'In that case I'd be just another leaf blown about by the wind.' Fuerderer, whose company makes half its sales in the United States, said that relocating production there could make sense for some firms in the sector over the long term, particularly given high energy costs and burdensome bureaucracy at home. 'The US government wants companies to manufacture in the United States and they have tax breaks, grants and subsidies to make it happen,' he said. In Europe, by contrast, Fuerderer said 'we are regulating ourselves to death. People are afraid to put money on the table and try something new.' — AFP
Free Malaysia Today
4 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
French scouts chief quits after backlash over sexuality
The SGDF is France's leading scouting association with more than 100,000 members. (AFP pic) PARIS : The chief of France's biggest scouts movement, which has its roots in Catholicism, has said she is stepping down after less than two months following online attacks over her sexuality. Marine Rosset, who is in a same-sex relationship and is the mother of a child, made the announcement in an interview published today by the Catholic newspaper, La Croix. 'I have chosen to step down as president of the Scouts and Guides of France (SGDF),' said Rosset, who is an elected councillor with the Socialist Party (PS) and supports the right to abortion. 'The situation had become untenable and my goal is to protect the movement,' Rosset told the newspaper. She accused people outside the scouting movement 'political, PR, and even financial forces' of having attacked her. They had created a false image of the movement 'because a number of my positions were associated with those of the movement', she said. Rosset was chosen in mid-June as the head of the movement at the age of just 39. A Socialist councillor in the fifth arrondissement of Paris, she notably supports the right to abortion. Her appointment got angry reactions from several far-right sites and prompted wary reactions within the church. Rosset said she had not expected 'the violence of criticism' following her support for the right to abortion and her family situation. 'I'm angry, especially because my faith has sometimes been questioned because of my homosexuality. It's hurtful,' she told La Croix. In a statement, the SGDF said Rosset's decision to step down 'allows us to preserve the non-partisan nature' of the organisation. But it also 'firmly denounces the violent, discriminatory, and dehumanising remarks that have been expressed in recent weeks' against her. It said it was backing a legal complaint Rosset has filed over the attacks on her and had not ruled out taking legal action itself. With more than 100,000 members, the SGDF is France's leading scouting association, with far greater members than the more conservative Scouts Unitaires de France and Scouts d'Europe.
Malay Mail
4 hours ago
- Malay Mail
King test drives Russian-made Aurus luxury car during visit to top auto institute in Moscow
MOSCOW, Aug 7 — His Majesty Sultan Ibrahim, King of Malaysia, today visited the Central Scientific Research Automobile and Automotive Engines Institute (NAMI) here to observe advancements in Russian automotive technology. Upon arrival, His Majesty was received by NAMI chief executive officer Fedor Nazarov. Also present were Defence Minister Datuk Seri Mohamed Khaled Nordin, who is also the Minister-in-Attendance, Foreign Ministry secretary-general Datuk Seri Amran Mohamed Zin, and Malaysian Ambassador to Russia Datuk Cheong Loon Lai. The visit began with a briefing by Nazarov and a video presentation on NAMI, a premier Russian scientific and engineering institute established in 1918 as the country's first automobile research laboratory. Today, NAMI is among Europe's largest automotive testing centres, with laboratory facilities, test tracks, and a special zone for autonomous vehicles. Among its key projects is the development of the AURUS luxury vehicle range, designed and manufactured at NAMI facilities. His Majesty showed keen interest in the institute's operations, vehicle models and production processes, posing various questions throughout the visit. Sultan Ibrahim later toured the showroom with Russian Deputy Minister of Industry and Trade Albert Karimov, before visiting the assembly plant. Before concluding the visit, His Majesty took the wheel of an AURUS vehicle for a brief test drive. Sultan Ibrahim is currently in Moscow for a state visit to Russia at the invitation of President Vladimir Putin. — Bernama
