‘Too lazy': Labor blasted over ‘rigged' system
Aussies keen to see their student loan debts cut by 20 per cent as promised by Labor in the federal election may not be so happy when they check their accounts.
Since Sunday, students with HELP or HECS loans would have seen their debts increase by 3.2 per cent as indexation kicked in.
Indexation serves to adjust student loans according to inflation – but the timing at which they are applied has been heavily criticised for years.
'HELP debts aren't actually very helpful,' independent Tasmanian senator Tammy Tyrell said.
'Today, students are watching their debts go up, with the money they've paid through the year nowhere in sight. Senator Tammy Tyrrell has called for the government to address HECS/HELP indexation. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia
'Banks reduce your loan before charging interest. Credit unions do too. Just not the government who pretend someone's repayments don't exist. It's costing students thousands of dollars all because Labor is too lazy to fix its accounting.
'Labor's HELP debt changes are one-off sugar hits. If they're genuine about making a difference for students, they could fix this rigged system when parliament returns. Just count someone's payments before interest is charged.
'It doesn't make sense to me that someone's debt is indexed before taking into account the thousands of dollars they've paid throughout the year,' she said. It does not take into account debt that has been paid off throughout the year, Senator Tyrrell said. NCA NewsWire /Brendan Beckett Credit: News Corp Australia
'Imagine if banks did that with your home loan – took your money, charged you interest but the repayments don't come off the outstanding balance. I reckon people would be pretty upset about that, so why do we expect students to put up with it?
'A student's HECS-HELP debt should be indexed after the yearly repayments are taken off.
'No matter what the indexation rate is, it's not a fair system when you're indexing badly. We need to change the timing, not the rate.'
Education Minister Jason Clare said Labor's policy to reduce HECS debts by 20 per cent would be backdated to June 1 before indexation was applied. Education Minister Jason Clare says legislation will be backdated so debt is actually cut by the promised 20 per cent. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia
'It will be the first Bill that we introduce into the parliament when parliament sits for the first time in the last week of July,' Mr Clare told ABC radio.
'What that legislation will do is cut everyone's debt by 20 per cent and backdate that cut. And that's important because every 1st of June in every year HECS debts or student debts get indexed.
'That 20 per cent cut will come into effect before that indexation effectively happens to make sure that we honour the promise we made and we cut everyone's debt by 20 per cent.
The Australian Universities Accord Final Report 2024 determined that the indexation should be applied later in the year after compulsory repayments made during the previous financial year were deducted from a student's balance.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
44 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Erin Patterson trial: Mushroom cook set to return to witness box for third day of giving evidence
The Victorian mother accused of murdering three of her in-laws with a poisoned beef Wellington dish is poised to continue giving evidence when her trial resumes on Wednesday, after new details on the fatal lunch were revealed. For the last two days, Erin Patterson, 50, has been giving her own version of events as to what happened on July 29, 2023, telling the court on Tuesday she accepted there had to have been poisonous mushrooms in the beef wellington she served, and that dried mushrooms used in its creation had sat in her pantry for months due to their 'pungent' aroma. Ms Patterson has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder relating to the lunch with her estranged husband's family. Simon Patterson's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, and aunt, Heather Wilkinson, died in the week after the lunch due to death cap mushroom poisoning while Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, survived. Camera Icon Ms Patterson will return to the witness box on Wednesday. Brooke Grebert-Craig. Credit: Supplied Prosecutors allege Ms Patterson deliberately spiked the meal while her defence argues the case is a tragic accident. After prosecutors concluded their case earlier this week, defence barrister Colin Mandy SC called his client as a witness and Ms Patterson began giving evidence. Over two days she answered extensive questions about her relationships with Simon Patterson and his family, health concerns, financial situation and her love of mushrooms. Shortly before the jury was sent home on Tuesday, Ms Patterson agreed that her lunch 'must' have contained the poisonous mushrooms. She told the court when preparing the dish, she used fresh mushrooms purchased from the local Leongatha Woolworths and dried mushrooms purchased months earlier in April from an Asian grocer in Melbourne. Camera Icon The trial is being held in the country Victorian town of Morwell. NewsWire / Josie Hayden Credit: News Corp Australia Ms Patterson said the dried mushrooms had been initially bought for a pasta dish but she did not use them at the time because they has a 'very pungent' aroma. Instead, she told the jury, she brought them home and stored them in a Tupperware container in the pantry. She also confirmed she'd begun foraging for wild mushrooms in 2020 and had purchased a dehydrator to preserve mushrooms in early 2023. 'I liked eating wild mushrooms, but it's a very small season and you can't keep them in the fridge,' she said. Ms Patterson told the jury she would store dried mushrooms in her pantry. 'Generally, I would put them into a container that I already sort of had going with Woolies mushrooms and whatnot in there,' she said. The final question Ms Patterson was asked of the day was if she had a memory of putting wild mushrooms in May or June 2023 into a container that already contained mushrooms 'Yes, I did do that,' she said. The trial continues.
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Pay increase for Tasmanian politicians determined by industrial commission
Tasmanian politicians will receive a $30,000 increase in their base salary following a long-awaited determination by Tasmania's Industrial Commission. The 22.36 per cent increase takes the base pay from $140,185 — where it had been frozen since 2018 — to $171,527, with the pay rise to take effect from July 1. It also includes increases in motor vehicle and electorate allowances. The determination still leaves Tasmanian MPs with the lowest base pay of any politicians in the nation, but only slightly behind New South Wales ($172,576), Western Australia ($173,393) and the Northern Territory ($175,000). Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff's pay will increase to almost $369,000, a rise of almost $68,000, while ministers will receive a base salary of $291,597. In its report, the industrial commission acknowledged the increases "may seem large". "However, they are based on the Wage Price Index or the Consumer Price Index, which track inflation and real movements in salary," the commission said in its determination. "The recommended increase for members of parliament is comparable, though slightly more than, increases in the public sector wages agreements for a similar period. The determination does not recommend back pay be given to politicians who were in state parliament between 2018 and present. The pay rise will automatically take place from July 1, unless it is disallowed by both houses of parliament. Mr Rockliff said the report from the industrial commission was seven years coming. "The recommended increase is out of step with community expectations and we will not be accepting it," he said. The commission's report found politicians in Tasmania's lower house would sit in parliament for 45 days this year, up from a national average of 43.25, while upper house MPs would also sit for 45 days, down from a national average of 49 sitting days.
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Labor's freedom in numbers is a double-edged sword on Gaza and Israel
In politics, it's not always those who sit opposite that you need to worry about. It's also those who sit behind you. As the Albanese government prepares to return to Parliament next month, it will sit across from a demoralised Coalition, which has spent the past couple of weeks breaking up and making up with all the drama of a high school couple. But perhaps posing more of a problem for Labor is a politician scorned. Dumped cabinet minister Ed Husic blamed Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles for his removal from cabinet, calling him a "factional assassin". But assassins are paid to kill and Husic's still kicking. The long-serving Labor MP wasted no time in saying the way power was wielded would repel people from the party, declaring former attorney-general Mark Dreyfus — a fellow victim of factional fighting — was denied dignity in the process. In dumping Husic from the ministry, the party has also liberated him from the shackles of cabinet solidarity that have seen him tread more carefully when speaking about the war in Gaza. No longer. Husic has been highly critical of the government for not doing enough to condemn Israel for withholding aid from Gaza. He said Australia "can and should be doing more" — from calling in the Israeli ambassador, to ramping up its contribution to the international humanitarian effort and imposing sanctions on Israel, beyond what's already been imposed on settlers in the West Bank. And while he noted Australia had signed a statement alongside several countries calling for the reinstatement of aid, he questioned why the government didn't "proudly" join the UK, Canada and France, saying they would take concrete actions if Israel didn't cease its renewed military offensive and lift its restrictions on humanitarian aid. There is also pressure within Labor's grassroots membership for the government to impose sanctions on Israeli individuals and groups, while former foreign ministers Gareth Evans and Bob Carr have also endorsed sanctions. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has previously said Australia is not a major player in the Middle East. But the impact of the war in Gaza is being felt acutely by people in Australia. Incidents of antisemitism and Islamophobia have risen, and Australians have also watched in horror as family members have been displaced or killed in the conflict. In trying to hold the middle ground on the Middle East, the government has often found itself disappointing all sides at home - those in support of Israel and those with anti-Zionist views, who feel let down by the government. And while Labor had a sweeping election victory, if you look under the hood of the results in western Sydney seats like Blaxland and Watson — where there are high concentrations of Arab-Australians — Labor's primary vote was down. Free from the constraints of an election campaign — and as images of burned, maimed and starving children, some crying and some simply too weak to — continue to be broadcast on people's screens, Albanese has toughened his rhetoric. Trying to allay the concerns of international allies, Israel has argued it would let a "basic amount of food" in for the Palestinian population. But Albanese said it was "outrageous" Israel was blocking food and supplies to people in need, while shrugging off calls for sanctions, saying the government would follow its own path. Australia will attend a United Nations-backed summit in New York this month, although at this stage it hasn't landed on who will go. The federal government's prevailing narrative is that Australia no longer sees recognition of a Palestinian state as occurring at the end of negotiations — but rather as a way of building momentum in the peace process. However, Labor has also been adamant there can be no role for Hamas in a future Palestinian state. Until the party lands on its next moves, they will have people within pushing for more to be done. As the prime minister fends off criticism from those now sitting much further back on the benches, the Greens have also had a blow from within. Having lost three seats in the lower house at the last election — including that of former leader Adam Bandt — it's now also lost a Senate seat. But this time, it had nothing to do with the voting public. Greens senator Dorinda Cox has defected to sit with the Labor party, saying her values align more closely with them. It's a curious statement, given just days ago she criticised Labor's approval of Woodside's expansion of the North West Shelf gas project out to 2070. But the senator had run unsuccessfully for the Greens deputy leadership in the wake of the election, and was facing the prospect of losing the number one spot on the Greens' WA senate ticket. Like many relationship break-ups, this split comes with baggage. Labor is taking on a senator who has also been accused of bullying a number of office staff, allegations she has denied and criticised as "missing context". But in turn the party gains a senator and punishes a party which the prime minister has declared has "lost their way." The last parliament saw numerous defections: Liberals and Nationals quit to sit as independents. Lidia Thorpe quit the Greens over the Voice, and Fatima Payman resigned from the Labor party over the party's position on the Gaza conflict. When Payman quit the party to sit as an independent, the prime minister suggested she should end her six-year term — "gifted" under Labor — and recontest the next federal election as an independent. However, presented with the opportunity to gain a number rather than lose one, Anthony Albanese said Cox would serve out the remainder of her term with Labor, noting she will have to be pre-selected through ALP processes to run for the next election. Nationals Senator Matt Canavan has described the Senate as a "political merry-go-round". And especially given the election was mere weeks ago — it begs the question: is it democratic for politicians, having been elected as a member of one party, to leave for another? There's currently no federal legislation in Australia that specifically addresses defections — only deaths and resignations — and experts have suggested punishing defectors could raise constitutional issues, and reduce stability and accountability in the Parliament. So while defections frustrate the public, they're a feature of the Australian parliament that isn't likely to go away. With an additional number in their ranks, the change is undoubtedly a morale boost for Labor, but practically it doesn't change the composition of the upper house dramatically. Labor still needs the Greens or the Coalition to pass legislation there, although this shift means that if the pair want to join forces to block government legislation, they'll need another number from the crossbench. Albanese will enter the first parliamentary sitting of the new government with calls to use his increased majority in the House to tackle more ambitious agenda items. Before the election, most in Labor were willing to swallow their concerns because of fears disunity would mean political death. But in the wake of a victory few saw coming, the enormous majority also comes with a downside for the PM. It means there are now more backbenchers to get on board, and more Labor MPs who could speak out if Albanese isn't able to land on a position everyone in the backbench is satisfied with.
