Kerala Nuns' Arrest: Chhattisgarh Woman Now Says ‘Was Coerced to Give Adverse Statement'
Congress MPs Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, KC Venugopal and Hibi Eden with others stage a protest over the arrest of two Catholic nuns. Photo: PTI
New Delhi: In a fresh twist to the arrest of two nuns from Kerala in Chhattisgarh, one of the women who they attempted to convert to Christianity and thereafter traffic, has told The Indian Express that she was 'coerced to give an adverse statement against them.'
The arrest of the two Malayali nuns – Preeti Marry and Vandana Francis – along with another person, Sukhman Mandavi, by police at Durg railway station on July 24, based on the complaint of a local Bajrang Dal worker that they were forcibly converting three women from Narayanpur and were attempting to traffic them, has created a nationwide uproar, and also caused an attack on minority communities.
The Indian Express report said that one the three persons, a 21-one year old tribal woman, told the newspaper that she was 'threatened and assaulted by Jyoti Sharma, a woman associated with a right-wing outfit, to change her statement, and the police based their FIR (First Information Report) on what members of the Bajrang Dal told them'.
The woman, who had returned to her home in Narayanpur on July 30 after spending five days at a shelter home in Durg, told the daily on phone, 'Please release all three (the arrested accused), they are innocent.'
Recounting the sequence of events on July 24 that led to the arrest of the nuns at the Durg railway station, the woman said she had gone to the station to travel 'with the nuns of her own will' and with her 'parents' consent.'
She alleged that 'Sharma assaulted her', and the Government Railway Police (GRP) in Durg 'did not record her statement'.
Instead, she alleged, the police based the FIR on a statement given by Bajrang Dal members.
The woman from Narayanpur said she, along with the other two women from Orcha in Narayanpur, had reached the railway station around 6 AM. According to the report, 'They were accompanied by Mandavi. Around 9 am, the nuns, whom she had never met, arrived. Shortly after, a Bajrang Dal worker and the GRP reached the scene and started questioning them.'
She related over phone, 'They took us to the railway police station. We were scolded a lot, and Jyoti Sharma hit me twice on the face.'
The woman alleged that Sharma told her 'if you do not follow what we say, we will put your siblings in jail and assault them. They wanted us to say that we were brought here forcibly. I told Sharma that I have come of my own will and have the consent of my parents. I said this inside the police station in the presence of two to three policemen.'
'I had met the nuns for the first time. When we were being assaulted, one of the nuns said, 'do not worry, I am here with you.' She told the person beating us, 'hit us, but not them',' the woman said.
Jyoti Sharma, when contacted by Express, said, 'I did not touch any one of them. When I reached, they were already inside the police station. Will the police allow me to touch them? I am hearing this allegation for the first time; earlier, they were saying I beat a nun, which is false.'
Meanwhile, Rishi Mishra, the Bajrang Dal's state coordinator, told the daily, 'A rickshaw driver associated with the Bajrang Dal overheard the conversation between the nuns and the women and suspected they were being trafficked, after which our workers reached the spot and gave a complaint to the GRP.'
Misha told the newspaper that Sharma 'is not from the Bajrang Dal but from the Durga Vahini Matrushakti.' On being asked, she identified herself as 'a Hindutvawadi who turns up wherever Hindutva needs saving.'
Chhattisgarh DGP Arun Kumar Gautam declined to comment on the Narayanpur woman's allegations, saying, 'Matter is sub-judice,' the report added.
The nuns were refused bail by a local court in Durg on July 30, stating that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the plea as the charges involved serious offences, including human trafficking, which comes under the ambit of the National Investigating Agency (NIA).
'The judge directed that the matter be taken up with the special NIA court in Bilaspur,' as per a Matrubhumi report. It said the advocates of the nuns are preparing to move a fresh bail plea in the Chhattisgarh high court.
'Meanwhile, the court move triggered celebrations by Bajrang Dal activists who had gathered outside the court in large numbers,' said the report.
The issue has been raised in the ongoing parliament session, with MPs from Kerala demanding immediate release of the nuns. Three MPs from the southern state who visited the nuns in Durg jail, also met Union home minister Amit Shah on July 30 on the matter.
The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India Today
9 minutes ago
- India Today
Chhattisgarh principal arrested for assaulting student over 'Radhe Radhe' greeting
A school principal in Chhattisgarh's Durg district was arrested for allegedly assaulting a nursery student and taping her mouth shut after the child greeted her with 'Radhe Radhe', a traditional Hindu salutation, police said.A 3.5-year-old girl was allegedly subjected to physical punishment by the principal of a private school for greeting her with 'Radhe-Radhe'.The incident occurred at Mother Teresa English Medium School in Bagdumar village, under the jurisdiction of Nandini police station. The accused principal, identified as Ela Even Kaulveen, was arrested following a formal complaint and a preliminary According to the child's family, the incident took place on Wednesday morning around 7:30 am. The girl reportedly greeted the principal with 'Radhe-Radhe' prompting an allegedly aggressive principal is accused of slapping the child, taping her mouth shut for nearly 15 minutes and subjecting her to further physical girl narrated the incident to her parents after returning home in a distressed state. Her father, Praveen Yadav, immediately approached the Nandini Police Station to lodge a marks of injury on the child's body reportedly corroborated the allegations of physical Padmashree Tanwar said that the principal punished the child for not responding to a question. However, the actions taken were excessive and unjustified.'The child's mouth was taped shut for almost 15 minutes, and she was beaten. We have arrested the principal and registered a case under relevant sections of the Indian Penal Code,' ASP Tanwar incident has sparked strong reactions across the district. Members of the Bajrang Dal reached the police station shortly after the complaint was filed, demanding strict action against the school administration and accusing it of promoting religious discrimination under the guise of also alleged that such incidents reflect a deeper intolerance within some educational institutions and called for a broader enquiry into the school's functioning.A case has been registered under applicable sections of the Indian Penal Code, including those pertaining to child abuse and causing hurt. Authorities have confirmed that a detailed investigation is underway to establish the facts and determine the Education Department is expected to initiate an independent enquiry, which may result in administrative action against the school or its management based on the findings.- Ends


The Print
9 minutes ago
- The Print
Malegaon blast probe politics will simmer till Maharashtra polls
A trial court in Mumbai gave its judgment on the case Thursday, acquitting all seven accused, including former Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MP Pragya Singh Thakur, saying there was strong suspicion, but not enough evidence to convict them. And, the most unfortunate part is that nobody seems to be interested in finding out, least of all the government. An explosive went off during the holy month of Ramadan in Maharashtra's Malegaon in 2008. Six people died. Almost a hundred others were injured. It's been 17 years, but in the eyes of the judiciary, there are still no answers as to who was responsible for the attack. The court ordered compensation of Rs 2 lakh to the families of those who died in the attack, and Rs 50,000 for the families of those injured. But it is too little, too late. The Malegaon blast case has, after all, been a victim of politics, and justice or closure has been the biggest casualty. For this reason, the Malegaon blast verdict is ThePrint's 'Newsmaker of the Week.' 'Saffron terror' politics The Malegaon case has been in the public discourse for 17 years, more for the politics surrounding it than for any significant details regarding the investigation process. The probe in the immediate aftermath of the blasts, under the Maharashtra Anti Terrorism Squad (ATS) and its former chief Hemant Karkare, had led to the arrests of a bunch of Hindutva activists, including Pragya Singh Thakur, as well as Lt Colonel Prasad Purohit, an Army officer. The accused were said to be linked to a Hindu fundamentalist group, Abhinav Bharat. India had seen a fair number of terror attacks across the country in 2008, raising questions on the efficiency of the home ministry under the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government. The initial revelations in the Malegaon probe gave a political opportunity to the Congress to turn the narrative. The party raised red flags on terrorism allegedly sponsored by Hindutva organisations, with some senior leaders such as P Chidambaram, Digvijaya Singh, and Sushilkumar Shinde using the word 'saffron terror'. They blamed the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) for allegedly encouraging such fringe Hindutva groups. These strong statements had at the time sparked a debate on how the term 'saffron terror' defames the entire Hindu religion and how terror should not be seen through the lens of any religious colour. The BJP and RSS, meanwhile, slammed the Congress for allegedly trying to appease the minorities. Karkare was killed in the 2008 Mumbai attacks. His death too became politically controversial as the Union Minority Affairs Minister AR Antulay, a Congressman from Maharashtra, suggested that there could be a larger controversy behind the IPS officer's death. Thursday's verdict came as vindication for the BJP's political narrative, with party leaders blaming the Congress for allegedly casting Hindus in a bad light, asking for an apology. It was ironic. The government's law enforcement agency had lost a case. It had failed to show sufficient evidence to get a conviction, despite having 17 years, over ten of which were under a BJP-led government at the Centre. And yet, those in power were celebrating. Also read: Fauja Singh's death shows Indian roads remain a national emergency—474 lives lost every day Opposition busy trying to get script right After the verdict, several Congress leaders asked if Pragya Singh Thakur and others are now acquitted, then who was behind the blast? However, the question was blunted by their more emphatic attempts at distancing the Congress from the term 'saffron terror'. Talking about 'saffron terror' in a Hindu-majority democracy had hurt the Congress even back then. In today's scenario, where the BJP has been working with every small spiritual and religious outfit on the ground to consolidate the Hindutva voter base, the consequences could be even worse. So, one after the other, leaders of the Congress tried to make all the right noises, loudly speaking about how they had never coined the term 'saffron terror,' how terror has no religion, and how Congress condemns all acts of terror. The question that should have been the loudest of all—who committed the crime—came out barely as a whimper. The Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray) questioned the failure of the government's law enforcement agencies with two back-to-back acquittals in terror cases—first the 2006 Mumbai train blasts and now the 2008 Malegaon blast. However, it stopped short of asking or even suggesting that the National Investigation Agency (NIA) should appeal against the trial court's decision in a higher court. After all, back in 2008, when the Shiv Sena was still undivided under Bal Thackeray's leadership and was a BJP ally, it had openly supported the Malegaon blast accused. On one occasion, party workers had even showered flower petals over the accused outside a Nashik courtroom. Last month, after the Bombay High Court tore into the Maharashtra ATS over the 2006 Mumbai train blasts probe and acquitted all 12 accused, all of whom were Muslims, the Maharashtra government promptly appealed in the Supreme Court. Now that an NIA trial court has done the same in the Malegaon blast case, neither the government nor the agency has shown any urgency in appealing to a higher court. The NIA has said it will decide whether to appeal after studying the order. The political pandemonium will continue as Maharashtra gears up for urban and rural local body polls sometime next year. For the victims and their families, any closure still seems to be a long way off. (Edited by Ratan Priya)


Hans India
9 minutes ago
- Hans India
Media facing credibility crisis, rues CM Revanth
Hyderabad: Chief Minister A Revanth Reddy expressed serious concern over journalism losing its credibility. In the same tone, he cautioned that the country's security will be in danger if the media credibility is not restored in the future. Participating in the anniversary celebrations of a Telugu daily here on Friday, the Chief Minister said that only a handful of media and press organisations were maintaining journalism ethics and standing by the people. These days, some media organisations established by political parties have put the profession at risk, he noted, while rueing that such media houses were exploiting the journalistic power to protect the management's political interests and their income generating sources through illegal means. Revanth Reddy said that earlier, political leaders acquired knowledge and were updated about important information from scribes during press conferences. Now the situation is reversed, which is a worrisome development. Some political parties with their ulterior motives were ruining the noble profession, he said. The Chief Minister recalled how the press had played a crucial role in uniting people during the freedom struggle. Newspapers run by the Communist parties also played an important role in creating awareness among the people on social menaces and during the farmers' armed struggle in Telangana. He praised Nava Telangana newspaper for continuing the legacy. Expressing concern that some media houses were 'crossing their limits', he said, "In the past, political parties ran newspapers to explain their ideology to the people. These days, dailies run by political parties are behaving in a strange manner as they are keen to protect their financial interests and follies'. Appealing to people to closely monitor the hidden agenda of newspapers owned by political parties, the Chief Minister said that another big worrying factor was the gross exploitation of social media by people who are unaware of the basics of journalism. These unscrupulous elements are conspiring to destabilize the system also, he charged. Like political parties, even journalists are losing their integrity, he said, while calling for a 'Lakshman Rekha' in the practice of journalism with trustworthiness. Revanth Reddy said that the Communist parties were always supporting Congress to come to power earlier and even in the 2023 State Assembly elections. The friendly relations between Congress and Left parties will continue, he said, as the two would strive for development of the state and people's welfare.