Born in the US but not American? USCIS's plan to restrict birthright citizenship puts student families at risk
A sweeping new executive order by President
Donald Trump
aims to end automatic birthright citizenship for most children born in the United States, sparking intense debate and legal uncertainty.
The US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has now drafted an implementation plan that, if enforced, would deny automatic citizenship to babies born to non-citizen parents, including those in the US on temporary visas such as H-1B, H-4, F-1, or B-1.
For international students and families pursuing education or professional careers in the US, this change could disrupt long-term goals. With court battles ahead, those on student and work visas now face fresh anxieties, not just about their own immigration pathways, but about the future legal status of children born on American soil.
What the executive order changes
Trump's executive order, signed on January 20, directs that only children born to US citizens or lawful permanent residents (green card holders) will automatically receive American citizenship. If both parents are on temporary or non-immigrant visas—whether student, worker, tourist, or undocumented, their US-born children would not be granted citizenship at birth.
Instead, such children would inherit the immigration status of their mother, a major departure from the longstanding guarantee of birthright citizenship under the Fourteenth Amendment, in place since 1868.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
This Japanese AI invention allows you to speak 68 languages instantly. The idea? Genius.
Enence 2.0
Undo
How this affects student and professional families
International students from across the globe come to the US on F-1 visas for higher education, often followed by work opportunities through Optional Practical Training (OPT) or H-1B visas. Many hope to build careers and families while navigating a complex immigration system.
Under the proposed policy, if an international student or temporary worker gives birth in the US, the child would no longer receive citizenship by birth.
This undermines assumptions many families made when investing in US education or employment, and raises doubts about the long-term benefits of living legally in the country.
The risk of statelessness and legal battles
The new rule may create a class of US-born children who are neither citizens of the United States nor guaranteed nationality by their parents' home countries, especially in nations where citizenship is not automatically granted by descent.
These children could become effectively stateless, lacking access to basic legal protections, social services, and future mobility.
This risk disproportionately affects students and professionals from countries with complex or restrictive citizenship laws, creating deep anxiety among families planning to start a life while studying or working in the US.
Currently, courts have blocked the executive order through preliminary injunctions.
However, USCIS has laid out an implementation roadmap for if and when those injunctions are lifted. Legal scholars widely believe the order violates the Fourteenth Amendment, but recent US Supreme Court decisions have made it harder for federal judges to block nationwide enforcement.
This means the order could be implemented in some states while others continue to recognize birthright citizenship, leading to confusing outcomes where a child's rights may depend on the state in which they are born.
Impact on education, healthcare, and future rights
Without US citizenship, children born to international students or skilled workers may be ineligible for essential services, including public education, in-state tuition, financial aid, healthcare, and even the legal right to work upon reaching adulthood.
Schools, hospitals, and universities may be forced to verify parental immigration status before enrolling or treating children, effectively turning educational and healthcare institutions into enforcement zones.
This could erode trust and deter prospective international applicants from choosing the US for study or work.
Changing the meaning of the American Dream
Supporters argue the policy will reduce 'birth tourism' and discourage undocumented migration. But critics say it challenges the very foundation of the American promise, that the US is a place where anyone, regardless of origin, can build a future based on fairness and opportunity.
For thousands of law-abiding students and professionals who came to the US legally and contribute to its academic and tech ecosystems, this move could send a discouraging message: that even if you follow the rules, your children may not belong.
What happens next
The order's fate lies in the courts, but the social and psychological impact has already begun. Universities, legal advocates, and immigrant communities are calling for clarity, urging the federal government to protect the interests of international families who have invested years and resources into building futures in the US
Advisors recommend international students and workers stay informed, seek legal guidance, and consider backup options such as understanding dual citizenship laws or exploring countries with more stable immigration policies.
USCIS's plan to implement Trump's birthright citizenship order marks a major shift in US immigration policy. If enforced, it would impact thousands of student families and skilled professionals, creating legal ambiguity and raising concerns about equal rights, long-term residency, and national identity. As lawsuits proceed and policies evolve, the future of many international families in the US remains precarious.
TOI Education is on WhatsApp now. Follow us
here
.
Ready to navigate global policies? Secure your overseas future. Get expert guidance now!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
2 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Russia kills 21 civilians in Ukraine as the Kremlin remains defiant over Trump threats
Russian glide bombs and missiles struck a Ukrainian prison and a medical facility overnight, killing at least 21 people, officials said Tuesday, as Russia kept up its bombardment of civilian areas despite U.S. President Donald Trump's threat to soon punish Russia with sanctions and tariffs unless it stops. A Russian airstrike on a prison in Ukraine's southeastern Zaporizhzhia region killed at least 17 inmates and wounded more than 80 others, officials said. In the Dnipro region, authorities reported at least four people were killed and eight injured. Trump said Monday he is giving Russian President Vladimir Putin 10 to 12 days to stop the killing in Ukraine after three years of war, moving up a 50-day deadline he had given the Russian leader two weeks ago. The move meant Trump wants peace efforts to make progress by Aug. 7-9. Trump has repeatedly rebuked Putin for talking about ending the war but continuing to bombard Ukrainian civilians. But the Kremlin hasn't changed its tactics. 'I'm disappointed in President Putin,' Trump said during a visit to Scotland. The Kremlin pushed back, however, with a top Putin lieutenant warned Trump against 'playing the ultimatum game with Russia.' 'Russia isn't Israel or even Iran,' former president Dmitry Medvedev, who is deputy head of the country's Security Council, wrote on social platform X.'Each new ultimatum is a threat and a step towards war. Not between Russia and Ukraine, but with his own country,' Medvedev said. Since Russia's full-scale invasion of its neighbour, the Kremlin has warned Kyiv's Western backers that their involvement could end up broadening the war to NATO countries. 'Kremlin officials continue to frame Russia as in direct geopolitical confrontation with the West in order to generate domestic support for the war in Ukraine and future Russian aggression against NATO,' the Institute for the Study of War, a Washington think tank, said late Monday. The Ukrainian air force said Russia launched two Iskander-M ballistic missiles along with 37 Shahed-type strike drones and decoys at Ukraine overnight. They say 32 Shahed drones were intercepted or neutralised by Ukrainian air defences. The Russian attack close to midnight Monday hit the Bilenkivska Correctional Facility with four guided aerial bombs, according to the State Criminal Executive Service of Ukraine. At least 42 inmates were hospitalised with serious injuries, while another 40 people, including one staff member, sustained various injuries. The strike destroyed the prison's dining hall, damaged administrative and quarantine buildings, but the perimeter fence held and no escapes were reported, authorities said. Ukrainian officials condemned the attack, saying that targeting civilian infrastructure, such as prisons, is a war crime under international conventions. In Dnipro, missiles hit the city of Kamianske, partially destroying a three-story building and damaging nearby medical facilities including a maternity hospital and a city hospital ward. Two people were killed and five were wounded, including a pregnant woman who is now in a serious condition, according to regional head Serhii Lysak. Further Russian attacks hit communities in Synelnykivskyi district with FPV drones and aerial bombs, killing at least one person and injuring two others. According to Lysak, Russian forces also targeted the community of Velykomykhailivska, killing a 75-year-old woman and injuring a 68-year-old man.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
4 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Kremlin silent as Trump cuts new deadline for Putin to halt Ukraine war
Donald Trump's decision to sharply curtail a deadline for Vladimir Putin to halt his war in Ukraine is being met by silence in the Kremlin so far, though analysts say it won't pressure the Russian president into changing course. The US president threatened Monday to impose sanctions within 10-12 days on countries buying Russian exports including energy unless Putin accepts a ceasefire, instead of the 50 days he announced earlier this month. 'There's no reason to wait. If you know what the answer is,' Trump said, voicing frustration at Putin's repeated rejection of his calls for a truce. 'Russia will respond very diplomatically' and point out that 'setting specific deadlines does not, by itself, encourage the negotiation process,' Sergei Markov, a Moscow-based political consultant close to the Kremlin, said on Telegram. 'But Russia's actual response to Trump's ultimatum will be the same as it has been to all ultimatums for the past 500 years: Get lost! Go to hell!' While maintaining relations with Trump is important for Putin, the Russian leader 'has no desire to stop, and even more so under pressure,' said Moscow-based political analyst Andrei Kolesnikov. Former Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, who's now deputy chairman of the county's security council, said Trump was 'playing the ultimatum game' and warned it was 'a step towards war' between Russia and the US. Markets responded more nervously. The ruble continued to weaken on Tuesday, passing 82 per dollar in early trading, after it declined by nearly 3 per cent in the wake of Trump's remarks to the lowest since mid-May. Oil prices climbed, amid concerns over potential disruptions in Russian oil supplies or increased costs from rerouted flows. The Brent benchmark was trading near $70 a barrel after closing 2.3 per cent higher in the previous session, the biggest increase in two weeks. Russia is a top-three global oil producer after the US and Saudi Arabia, exporting more than 3 million barrels a day by sea alone, and supplies crude to such major consumers as India and China. Any significant disruptions in Russian flows in the near future would require a ramp-up in supplies from other major producers and rerouting of existing barrels, just as the global market remains tight amid robust summer demand. Trump returned to the White House in January after campaigning on a pledge to bring a swift end to the war that's now in its fourth year. His frustration mounted, however, after six publicly announced phone calls with Putin produced no progress on a ceasefire. Russia also intensified missile and drone attacks on Ukraine in recent weeks, adding to US perceptions that Putin was intent on continuing the war. Trump said Monday that 'I'm not so interested in talking any more' to Putin. 'We have such nice conversations, such respectful and nice conversations, and then people die the following night,' he told reporters during a visit to Scotland. Russian officials viewed the original 50-day deadline as another postponement that allowed Moscow's forces a window to intensify fighting on the battlefield and seize more territory in Ukraine at the height of the summer fighting season. 'For some reason, Trump believes that's he's an arbitrator and can issue ultimatums,' senior Russian lawmaker Vladimir Dzhabarov told the Izvestia newspaper. 'But ultimatums are usually issued to the losing side, which Russia isn't.'
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
4 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Russia kills 21 civilians in Ukraine, remains defiant over Trump's threats
Russian glide bombs and missiles struck a Ukrainian prison and a medical facility overnight, killing at least 21 people, officials said Tuesday, as Russia kept up its bombardment of civilian areas despite US President Donald Trump's threat to soon punish it with sanctions and tariffs unless it stops. A Russian airstrike on a prison in Ukraine's southeastern Zaporizhzhia region killed at least 17 inmates and wounded more than 80 others, officials said. In the Dnipro region, authorities reported at least four people were killed and eight injured. Trump said Monday he is giving Russian President Vladimir Putin 10 to 12 days to stop the killing in Ukraine after three years of war, moving up a 50-day deadline he had given the Russian leader two weeks ago. The move meant Trump wants peace efforts to make progress by Aug 7-9. Trump has repeatedly rebuked Putin for talking about ending the war but continuing to bombard Ukrainian civilians. But the Kremlin hasn't changed its tactics. I'm disappointed in President Putin, Trump said during a visit to Scotland. The Kremlin pushed back, however, with a top Putin lieutenant warned Trump against playing the ultimatum game with Russia. Russia isn't Israel or even Iran, former president Dmitry Medvedev, who is deputy head of the country's Security Council, wrote on social platform X. Each new ultimatum is a threat and a step towards war. Not between Russia and Ukraine, but with his own country, Medvedev said. Since Russia's full-scale invasion of its neighbour, the Kremlin has warned Kyiv's Western backers that their involvement could end up broadening the war to Nato countries. Kremlin officials continue to frame Russia as in direct geopolitical confrontation with the West in order to generate domestic support for the war in Ukraine and future Russian aggression against Nato, the Institute for the Study of War, a Washington think tank, said late Monday. The Ukrainian air force said Russia launched two Iskander-M ballistic missiles along with 37 Shahed-type strike drones and decoys at Ukraine overnight. They say 32 Shahed drones were intercepted or neutralized by Ukrainian air defenses. The Russian attack close to midnight Monday hit the Bilenkivska Correctional Facility with four guided aerial bombs, according to the State Criminal Executive Service of Ukraine. At least 42 inmates were hospitalised with serious injuries, while another 40 people, including one staff member, sustained various injuries. The strike destroyed the prison's dining hall, damaged administrative and quarantine buildings, but the perimeter fence held and no escapes were reported, authorities said. Ukrainian officials condemned the attack, saying that targeting civilian infrastructure, such as prisons, is a war crime under international conventions. In Dnipro, missiles hit the city of Kamianske, partially destroying a three-story building and damaging nearby medical facilities including a maternity hospital and a city hospital ward. Two people were killed and five were wounded, including a pregnant woman who is now in a serious condition, according to regional head Serhii Lysak. Further Russian attacks hit communities in Synelnykivskyi district with FPV drones and aerial bombs, killing at least one person and injuring two others. According to Lysak, Russian forces also targeted the community of Velykomykhailivska, killing a 75-year-old woman and injuring a 68-year-old man. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
