‘Up yours to the fans': Slater, QRL boss under fire over controversial Mam Origin selection
Queensland's selection of Ezra Mam has created a stir given the Broncos five-eighth missed nine games of the season due to a serious off-field incident.
Maroons coach Billy Slater dropped a couple of bombshells when naming his team for the must-win game two in Perth including naming Mam in the extended squad after playing just three games this season.
Mam missed the first chunk of the season after he was handed a nine-game suspension and a total of $120,000 in fines from the Broncos and NRL combined following a car crash while he was driving with drugs in his system and without a current licence.
FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer >
Slater told reported on Monday that the 22-year-old is 'the right person for that position right now' and 'we feel the squad will benefit from him being there.'
But not everyone is on board with the controversial selection with veteran journalist Phil Rothfield declaring the selection is an insult to NRL fans.
'Ben Ikin, the CEO of the Queensland Rugby League and Billy Slater have not read the room under these circumstances,'' Rothfield said on NRL 360.
'You saw Mam run onto Brookvale Oval and the entire crowd booed him. He is very, very lucky to be playing NRL football this year. I'm not going to go through the crime again.
'I think we've had to wear him coming back to play NRL this year. The NRL made the mistake there and so did the Broncos.
'But to put him on the highest stage of our game — extended bench or not — is going to the fans 'up yours'.'
Proud Queenslander and Maroons legend Gorden Tallis defended the decision by saying Mam 'has served his punishment' and that it was the NRL's fault that he was back playing and free to be selected.
'Don't blame Queensland for picking him. He's playing the game, he should be allowed to be chosen,' he declared.
But Rothfield went as far as suggesting Mam shouldn't have been allowed to play again this year.
'This was the most serious off-field indiscretion for a very long period of time, driving with drugs and drink in his system and putting a little girl into hospital,' he said.
'He does not deserve to be any part of Origin this year.
'In this situation I think he was entitled to a greater punishment. I would've been happy if he didn't play again this year.
'I'm just surprised Ben Ikin of all people, so smart, so clever, has not read the fans on this occasion.'
Tallis continued to argue that it's not Mam's fault that he was selected, to which the panel agreed. But News Corp journalist Brent Read also backed up Tallis on his belief that it's also not the QRL's fault that Mam was free to be picked.
'Once the NRL gave him the sanction and he was cleared for Origin, I don't think you can blame the QRL,' he said.
However Rothfield doubled down on saying the selection offends fans.
'Do you think the QRL understand the fan outrage that he's even playing footy this year? They've gone to the fans 'up yours',' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
What the Socceroos need against Saudi Arabia to qualify for the World Cup
The Socceroos are so close they can almost taste it. Automatic qualification for the 2026 FIFA World Cup is just 90 minutes away following the Socceroos' dramatic 1-0 victory over Japan in Perth. However, the Socceroos first face the task of Saudi Arabia on Wednesday morning before they can book their spot on the plane. Saudi Arabia is still in with a chance of upsetting Australia's hopes and stealing the final automatic qualification spot. Here's what needs to happen for Australia to progress to their sixth-straight World Cup finals. Simply put, a draw or a victory over Saudi Arabia in Jeddah will confirm the Socceroos' spot on the plane to North America. The Green Eagles, in third spot, are three competition points behind second-placed Australia in Group C of this phase of qualifying. With two teams from each of the three six-team groups progressing to North America next year, the Socceroos only have to equal Saudi Arabia to join group winners Japan at the showpiece 32-team tournament. The Socceroos can still progress even if Saudi Arabia wins. Due to the Socceroos' far superior goal difference, Saudi Arabia will need to win by a whopping five clear goals to leap-frog Australia to second spot. Saudi Arabia has not beaten a team by this margin since they beat Palestine 5-0 in March 2021 and have not scored more than that since a 7-2 victory over Cambodia in January 2017. Saudi Arabia has scored just six goals in this phase of qualifying, with only Bahrain (5) scoring fewer across all the teams in Asia in this phase of qualifying. Things get mighty complicated if Australia can't hang on to second spot in the group. The Socceroos cannot finish any lower than third or fourth, which will put them in the fourth phase of qualifying. That means the Socceroos would be placed into a round-robin tournament in October, played at a centralised venue within the Asian Football Confederation (AFC) and featuring the other third- and fourth-placed teams from across the AFC in two groups of three. That is likely to be the UAE and Qatar from Group A; and Oman, Iraq or Palestine from Group B — although those groups are still in flux. The two group winners from each three-team group will progress to the 2026 World Cup. If the Socceroos finish second in that group, there is still another chance to qualify through the intercontinental play-offs, but first they'd have to beat the other second-placed finisher from the other group in another two-legged match. Then they'd need to finish in the top two of a six-team inter-confederation play-off tournament in the USA. Last time around the Socceroos drew 0-0 with Saudi Arabia in Melbourne all the way back in November. Incredibly, the Saudis had a last-gasp winner (correctly) ruled out for a narrow offside decision. Saudi Arabia vs the Socceroos kicks off at 4:15am (AEST) on Wednesday morning in New South Wales, Queensland, the ACT, Victoria and Tasmania. That's 2:15am in Western Australia and 3:45am in South Australia and the Northern Territory. This game is exclusive to Paramount+. However, you can follow all the action as it unfolds in the ABC Sport live blog.
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Munster postive QLD can level the series
State of Origin: Newly crowned QLD Maroons captain Cameron Munster is backing his team to level the series for Game 2 in Perth.
Sydney Morning Herald
an hour ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
The ghost of Holger Osieck is the only thing that can stop the Socceroos
The last time the Socceroos lost a match by five goals, it launched the careers of both Ange Postecoglou and Maty Ryan. It was 2013, and Australia had just sealed a spot at the World Cup in Brazil. Josh Kennedy was the saviour, thanks to his iconic late header against Iraq in front of 80,000 people in Sydney. But there was no saving the unpopular Holger Osieck, who was sacked three months later, despite delivering Australia's third successive qualification. The Socceroos were a bit on the nose with the public. Osieck had allowed the ageing 'Golden Generation' to hang on for too long, and his style of football was hardly inspiring. Later that year, in their wisdom, Football Federation Australia scheduled back-to-back friendlies, both away, against Brazil and France. Rare chances for them to measure up against true global yardsticks. 6-0, 6-0. Critics accused the Socceroos of making the Australian game look like a 'joke' on the world stage with their 'spineless' performances, and several players of outstaying their welcome in the team. As soon as he returned to the team hotel after game two in Paris, Osieck was dismissed, and moves were immediately afoot to get the federation's No.1 coaching target, Ange Postecoglou, out of his contract at Melbourne Victory, thus setting in train a series of events that would soon lead to Postecoglou taking over and regenerating the squad, Mark Schwarzer's retirement, and the handing over of the gloves to Ryan, who will win his 100th cap on Wednesday morning (AEST) by hopefully contributing to what would be one of the best moments of his career. For that not to happen, the Socceroos would need to turn in a stinker the likes of which they have not had in 12 years. Not since that day in Paris. Or that other day in Brasília. That is how bad they would have to be to miss out on the 2026 World Cup from here. That is how long ago they last lost by five goals or more. That is the sort of heist Saudi Arabia has to pull off in Jeddah. It is an unfathomable thought on multiple levels. So far in this qualifying phase, the Saudis have scored only six goals in nine games – so to do it, they'd essentially need to reproduce that whole output in one match. Only twice before have the Socceroos ever lost a competitive match (not friendlies) by 5-0 or worse, and not since 1997.
