Officer's Taser push on mother's face justified
PC Zachary Marsden admitted pushing his Taser in her face as she leant over Muhammad Amaad's prone body but denied 'losing control' in the alleged assault on July 23 last year.
Mohammed Fahir Amaaz, 20, and Amaad, 26, are said to have struck out after police were called to a reported assault at the Starbucks cafe in Terminal 2 arrivals, when Mr Amaaz is said to have headbutted a customer.
On Wednesday, jurors at Liverpool Crown Court were shown a photograph of injuries to the face of the defendants' mother, said to have been sustained as PC Zachary Marsden attempted to arrest Mr Amaaz at the T2 car park paystation area.
CCTV footage played to the jury showed Mrs Akhtar knelt near to her son on the floor after a Taser discharge felled him.
Cross-examining PC Marsden, Imran Khan KC, defending Mr Amaaz, said: 'Did you cause the injury as a result of your conduct on July 23?'
The Greater Manchester Police firearms officer said: 'I believe it is unclear whether or not it was my actions that caused those injuries. I believe I was not the only person who made contact with Mrs Akhtar.'
Mr Khan said: 'I am suggesting that it was you who caused that injury by hitting her with a Taser?'
PC Marsden said: 'I firmly believe that you can't wholly attribute my actions to those injuries.'
The officer said he believed Mr Amaad had struck his own mother during the disturbance.
Mr Khan said: 'Did you push the Taser you were holding into Mrs Akhtar at the time she was tending to Mr Amaaz?'
PC Marsden said: 'I did, yes.'
Mr Khan said: 'Did you think that was justified?'
PC Marsden said: 'In the circumstances, yes, I did.
'She grabbed my left leg. Using my left hand, I have taken hold of her grip to remove it. She clamped on to my left hand pulling me forward.
'I was being pulled over Mr Amaaz and at risk of falling on top of him and being vulnerable.'
Mr Khan said: 'I am going to suggest to you that was unnecessary. This was a hard push by your Taser on Mrs Akhtar's face?'
PC Marsden said: 'I disagree.'
Mr Khan said: 'She was concerned for Mr Amaaz. She was not a threat. She was not interfering with anything you were doing and this was conduct, I suggest, where you have lost control.'
PC Marsden said: 'I would deny that.'
Mobile phone footage was also played to the jury of PC Marsden later using Pava incapacitant spray on a bystander who he said was effectively 'shielding' another man who officers wanted to detain for obstructing their duties.
PC Marsden told the court he deployed the tactic because events were 'beyond verbal reasoning'.
The officer was then seen to grab the man around the neck and pull him to the floor, Mr Khan said.
Mr Khan said: 'How do you justify putting your hands around a man's neck?'
PC Marsden said: 'Immediately prior, I had been subjected to the most violent assault of my life.
'I was now terrified that we are on the tipping point of another volatile situation. They were complicit in watching us being violently assaulted.
'I used pre-emptive force. I was in pain, exhausted and wanted to try the best I could to effect an arrest.'
Mr Khan said: 'Was he doing anything that required Pava spray in the face?'
PC Marsden said: 'My fear was that he would be combative and we would end up with another hostile fight that I didn't want to happen.'
Cross-examining PC Marsden, Chloe Gardner, defending Mr Amaad, said: 'I suggest that you and your colleagues were the aggressors.'
PC Marsden said: 'I can only account for my actions. I deny what you allege.'
He also denied her suggestions that he failed to exercise any self-control and did not act with integrity.
PC Marsden 'strongly disagreed' with another suggestion that he had not been honest with the jury.
Mr Amaaz is alleged to have assaulted PC Marsden and PC Lydia Ward, causing them actual bodily harm.
He is also accused of the assault of PC Ellie Cook and the earlier Starbucks assault of Abdulkareem Ismaeil.
Mr Amaad is alleged to have assaulted PC Marsden, causing actual bodily harm.
Both men, from Rochdale, Greater Manchester, deny the allegations.
The trial continues.
MORE: Five Manchester United stewards removed from work at club over alleged assault
MORE: Ex-Asda manager jailed after smuggling 30kg of cannabis into Manchester Airport
MORE: EasyJet flight to Turkey diverted back to UK airport after 'passenger issue'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
a day ago
- STV News
Police officer 'feared for his life' after man struck him with his baton and bit ear
A man battered a police officer with his own baton and bit his ear leaving the constable fearing he was going to be killed. Darren Davies turned on the PC in darkened woods in Leslie, Fife last September 10. The 34-year-old launched the brutal attack despite a police dog biting Davies. The assault only ended when the badly wounded officer was able discharge incapacitant spray into his eyes – although Davies later went on to kick another officer. He admitted his guilt during a hearing at the High Court in Glasgow. Davies had fled a house after an argument with a woman there had led to police being called. The trained dog handler went on to find Davies in a desolate area of nearby woods that night. Davies yelled at him: 'You are not going to arrest me.' He continued to be aggressive as the officer tried to calm him. The officer shouted: 'Police with a dog. Stay where you are or I will send the dog.' But, instead, Davies ran at the constable, wildly swinging punches while shouting: 'Let it bite me.' The dog repeatedly got hold of Davies, but he still lashed out hitting the PC. The officer tried to sweep his legs away and pin him to the ground. He called for back-up before Davies grabbed his body armour and was on top of him. Prosecutor Stewart Ronnie: '[The police officer] struggled to escape. They both rolled down a hill and the officer ended up in a seated position. 'Davies stood behind and began to strike blows on top of his head. 'The officer noticed these were significantly stronger than ones earlier. 'When each landed, he saw stars and felt significant sharp pain on his head. [The officer] was now in fear of his life.' The constable was stricken on the ground as Davies then bit through the top of his ear. He was unable to defend himself, but eventually managed to free himself. It was then he was able to push Davies away and discharge his incapacitant PAVA spray into his eyes. Two other officers then turned up to help their bleeding colleague. The court heard, after Davies was arrested, the officer 'collapsed to his knees, dizzy, exhausted and in severe pain'. He was then taken to hospital. It emerged he had been repeatedly struck with his police baton. The officer luckily suffered no fractures, but has been left scarred for life from the injuries. He was off work for four weeks and continues to receive trauma counselling. The officer remains conscious of his scars. The court heard that, after Davies was held, he kicked another officer while in the police van. Davies – who already had convictions for violence – pled guilty to assaulting the officer to his severe injury and permanent disfigurement. He had initially faced an attempted murder allegation. Mark Stewart KC, defending, said Davies realised he should have stopped when faced by police, but that 'one thing led to another and matters got out of hand' that night. Lord Mullholland remanded Davies in custody as sentencing was deferred for reports. The judge told him he would have been looking at a jail-term 'well into double figures' had he been convicted of the original charge, but that he was still facing a 'significant sentence'. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
North Wales Live
2 days ago
- North Wales Live
New ANPR parking to tackle 'lawlessness' at iconic Welsh beach and forest
A new barrierless parking system is to be introduced at a famous Anglesey beach to curb soaring levels of illegal camping. A forest behind Traeth Llanddwyn is said to be at 'significant' risk from camp fires and illicit barbecues. Wardens patrolling the area do their best to move on groups of wild campers despite 'abuse and threats'. BBQs are banned in the area but a fire broke out in Newborough forest last week when campers set light to bone-dry pine needles. The 2,500-acre forest is part of a National Reserve and there are concerns a major fire would devastate local wildlife, including red squirrels. Residents in the nearby village of Newborough claim the forest has become 'lawless' and and worry a runaway blaze would threaten nearby homes. In May, brutal new parking charges were introduced at the reserve, popularised on social media after gaining fame from the TV series House of the Dragon. This was designed to curb visitor numbers and so bring relief to a village often brought to a standstill by vehicles queuing to reach the sandy beach and its iconic island. Now site manager Natural Resources Wales (NRW) is planning to install a new Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) parking system later this year. It will operate in a similar fashion to the pay-later barrierless arrangements at Mersey Gateway Bridge and Manchester Airport. This way, NRW will be able to identify vehicles parking up overnight and so allow the environment body to clamp down on wild camping. A barrier will be retained along the exit road – not for payments but to control traffic flows through the village. A spokesperson said: 'The new system will provide CCTV which will assist with reporting and investigating anti-social behaviour. It will allow us to monitor and issue fines for those parking overnight in our car parks. 'Overnight camping remains prohibited and during this summer we have increased patrols and responded to a number of call-outs from the public to deal with illegal camping.' Local people have been flagging Llanddwyn's 'selfish and incredibly dangerous' campers for some time, calling for more warden patrols and large on-the-spot fines. Some visitors camp on the beach or in the car park, many string up tents between trees in the forest itself. Last year's out-of-control fire wasn't the first this summer. 'If it carries on, we won't have a forest,' said a worried local online. Another added: 'I hate going down first thing in the morning because you see are the entitled campers and I get so angry.' He's not the only one. 'Car park rammed with over-nighters again!' sighed a local this week. 'Lawless Llanddwyn!' Half in jest, some residents have talked of taking action themselves – one idea involved broadcasting loud music in the forest through the night to deter campers. NRW wardens – often locals themselves – risk patrolling the forest at night. It can be hazardous. A resident who spoke to them said: 'I'm sure the rangers would prefer to be at home with their families rather than spending the night in the forest worrying about the forest getting burned down and risking abuse or being assaulted. "Would you want to confront a bunch of pi**ed-up idiots late at night?' Get the best island stories from our Anglesey newsletter - sent every Friday After parking in one of three car parks in the forest, visitors currently pay up to £15 per day at exit barriers at the edge of the reserve. Not only does this system fail to identify overnight stayers, the barrier can malfunction. Occasionally, height barriers designed to deter motorhomes are wrecked by drivers, usually due to complacency rather than malice. NRW is reportedly waiting until the busy summer season is over before installing its new cameras in case of teething problems. Not everyone is convinced they'll make a difference. A resident said not all campers park in the reserve itself, instead picking spots in and around the village itself. Last weekend he said: 'On Saturday evening we saw people walking (into the forest) with camping gear.' It is quite a haul, however. For years the main beach car park at Llanddwyn had a designated BBQ area. This summer the facility was closed down and replaced with a picnic area, in line with a wider BBQ ban in the reserve. Local people suspect it's made matters worse, encouraging campers to light BBQs on the beach and in the forest instead. On Thursday (August 14) NRW was forced to issue the latest in a long line of safety messages on social media. These reminded visitors there is now a 'full ban in place for all barbecues and fires following a rise in fire-related incidents'. NRW has yet to set of a date for the barrierless APNR cameras. A spokesperson said: 'The new system will enable users to manage car park payments via an app, as well as handle season tickets and registration for local users. 'Barrierless entry systems provide easier access for emergency vehicles and help reduce the technical issues we have experienced with our current system. 'There will be an exit barrier to help manage traffic flow back into the village. We will monitor any changes resulting from the new system and assess how it impacts traffic in the village.'
The Herald Scotland
2 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
Officer 'feared he would be killed' after being attacked by own baton
The 34 year-old launched the brutal attack despite a police dog sinking its teeth into Davies. The assault only ended when a badly wounded PC O'Donnell was able discharge incapacitant spray into his eyes - although Davies still later went on to kick another officer. He is now behind bars after he admitted his guilt during a hearing at the High Court in Glasgow. Davies had fled a house after an argument with a woman there had led to police being called. PC O'Donnell - a trained dog handler - went on to find Davies in a desolate area of nearby woods that night. The tattooed thug yelled at him: "You are not going to arrest me." He continued to be aggressive as the officer tried to calm him. PC O'Donnell shouted: "Police with a dog. Stay where you are or I will send the dog." But, instead, Davies ran at the constable, wildly swinging punches while screaming: "Let it bite me." The dog repeatedly got hold of Davies, but the thug still lashed out hitting PC O'Donnell. The officer tried to sweep his legs away and pin him to the ground. Read More PC O'Donnell called for back-up before Davies grabbed his body armour and was on top of him. Prosecutor Stewart Ronnie: "PC O'Donnell struggled to escape. They both rolled down a hill and the officer ended up in a seated position. "Davies stood behind and began to strike blows on top of his head. "The officer noticed these were significantly stronger than ones earlier. "When each landed, he saw stars and felt significant sharp pain on his head. PC O'Donnell was now in fear of his life." The constable was stricken on the ground as crazed Davies then bit through the top of his ear. He was unable to defend himself, but eventually managed to wriggle free. It was then PC O'Donnell was able to push Davies away and discharge his incapacitant PAVA spray into his eyes. Two other officers then turned up to help their bleeding colleague. The court heard, after Davies was arrested, PC O'Donnell "collapsed to his knees, dizzy, exhausted and in severe pain". He was then taken to hospital. It emerged he had been repeatedly whacked with his police baton. PC O'Donnell luckily suffered no fractures, but has been left scarred for life from the injuries. He was off work for four weeks and continues to receive trauma counselling. The officer remains conscious of his scars. The court heard that, after Davies was held, he booted another officer while in the police van. Davies - who already had convictions for violence - pled guilty to assaulting PC O'Donnell to his severe injury and permanent disfigurement. He had initially faced an attempted murder allegation. Mark Stewart KC, defending, said Davies realised he should have stopped when faced by police, but that "one thing led to another and matters got out of hand" that night. Lord Mullholland remanded Davies in custody as sentencing was deferred for reports. The judge told him he would have been looking at a jail-term "well into double figures" had he been convicted of the original charge, but that he was still facing a "significant sentence".
