27 Sandals Reviewers Say Hold Up Year After Year

Buzz Feed

6 days ago

The classic Birkenstock Arizona sandals because these two-strap sandals are supremely supportive *and* durable. The contoured cork footbed molds to the foot for made-for-you comfort, and they'll last for seasons to come! Seriously, mine survived SEVEN years of frequent walking.
Plus, some Birkenstock Mayaris featuring the same unrivaled corkbed support only with a slightly more ~dainty~ aesthetic. These are my absolute go-to for trips to Europe, as they're a bit dressier than the Arizonas while still keeping my feet happy as I walk 15,000+ steps a day.
You already guessed it — my pair lasted a good six years of HEAVY use. Considering the fact that I wore these for multiple 7–10 day vacations where I'd be walking miles each day, I'm genuinely surprised they didn't wear out sooner.Promising review: "While comfortable and stylish. They have lasted me a few years each pair I've bought wearing them nearly daily in the later spring and summer months.Definitely will buy again" —JenGet them from Amazon for $30+ (available in sizes 4–13 and lots of colors).
Or, a pair of these trendy two-strap sandals if you want the look and feel of the Mayaris, minus the expensive price tag. Some reviewers even think these ones are softer and comfier than the name brand — and with nearly 60,000 5-star ratings, you can be sure these won't disappoint.
An iconic Teva sandal so you can take on all those warm-weather adventures in fun, colorful style and with comfy support. After all, there's a reason everyone loves their signature strappy design.
A cushy pair of slide-on slippers that, according to reviewers, feel like walking on a big fluffy cloud or a soft, pillowy marshmallow. Either way, sign me up!
Aerothotic flip-flops because these ones actually have adequate arch support — so much arch support that reviewers with plantar fasciitis swear by these shoes. See? Dreams really do come true!
Or Vionic orthotic sandals for footwear that's as comfy as it is cute. Beneath those adorable little bows, you'll find three-zone comfort features, including deep heel cups, arch support, and ample cushioning.
A pair of darling Skechers wedges so you can stroll about all sweet and flirty on any and all summer excursions — be it a picnic in the park, outdoor wedding, or weekend getaway. Hard to say what you'll love more: their adorable aesthetic or the foam-cushioned contoured footbed!
Promising review: "Stand the test of time! I bought this exact size (9.5) in black in 2021. Yes they lasted that long and I wore them as soon as the weather warmed each year! Literally my go-to sandals! I'm very pleased that the white fits perfectly in the same size and style! Best sandals for comfort, style, and cost!" —DeresaGet it from Amazon for $38.93+ (available in sizes 5–13, wide sizes, and seven colors).
A Keen sandal that has been one of my favorite summertime shoes for years. Why, you ask? Well, it's just so darn adorable while also being unbelievably comfy. I walked for hundreds of miles in my first pair (everything from city streets to nature trails) before I eventually had to order a new pair...and I still love them just as much the second time around.
Promising review: "This is my second pair of these; the last ones I wore for six years, decided it was time to retire them. :) Super comfortable and good support for leisurely walking. Love these. I purchased these in navy; good color, truly navy." —SchnauzerMomGet it from Amazon for $62.20+ (available in sizes 5–12 and 16 colors).
Faux leather strappy sandals for days when you want the lightweight and breezy feel of flip flops but a slightly more elevated look. Not to mention, they're available in all kinds of colors and for less than $15 per pair!
Espadrille flatforms that promise to add some ~oomph~ to your spring and summertime vacay 'fits year after year. Pair 'em with jeans, dresses, rompers, really anything, it doesn't matter! What *does* matter is the fact that they're cute, comfy, and durable af!
Elastic strap sandals since the twisted strap is not only super cute but also super stretchy, which means the sandal conforms perfectly to your foot for a secure, comfy fit.
A slip-on beaded strap sandal here to make your dreams of becoming a boho summer princess come true. All that's missing is a flowy peasant dress and some flowers in your hair.
Promising review: "I bought a pair in black 4 years ago and they still look and feel great. I bought this pair in white. So beautiful, so comfortable, the arch support is wonderful. I receive compliments every time I wear them. I wear them often because they are so comfortable. I was a bit hesitant about the wraparound big toe, but no worries, they feel great. Highly recommend. The butterfly charms even slide!" —KellyDGet it from Amazon for $26.02+ (available in sizes 5–10.5 and seven styles).
A pair of sporty hiking sandals that might not have a brand name logo but have literally everything else you could want: high arch support, cushioned midsoles, adjustable ankle straps, and a rubber outsole with great traction. Spring and summer adventures, here you come!
Surprisingly cute Skechers sport sandals because their contoured footbeds will keep your feet happy even on your longest treks.
A pair of Dr. Martens vegan leather sandals, AKA the summertime equivalent of your fave ~spunky~ chunky platform boots. Thanks to these, there's no reason the punk-rock fashion vibes have to end when the weather gets warm and you swap the leggings for skirts and dresses.
A Reef platform slide sandal that manages to be equal parts classic, trendy, and super comfy. I don't quite understand it either, but I *do* understand that you'll look like a chic summer baddie strutting around wearing nothing but these shoes and a simple T-shirt dress. Talk about easy fashion!
Promising review: "This is the second pair of REEF Higher Sandals I have purchased. The last pair lasted me over two years of heavy wear. They are the most comfortable and supportive sandals I have ever owned. The style is cute with jeans, shorts, dresses--literally everything I put with them. I have walked all day in them and my feet and legs do not get fatigued. I have other styles of REEF that are great also. Wonderful products and great customer service." —Meghan Norton"I bought two black pair two years ago that I still wear heavily/basically daily.. although they look a little worn down, they are my absolute fav sandal. They are so comfortable!" —LaurenGet it from Amazon for $55.95+ (available in sizes 5–11 and 16 colors).
A Crocs wedge sandal with adjustable ankle straps, since there's just no reason you need to sacrifice comfort for style. These beauties seem wayyy too cute to be Crocs — but once you feel how comfy they are, you just might believe it.
Promising reviews: "It's very. Comfortable and last for years, I already have one without a back strap and I love it (actually I looked for that one but couldn't find)." —Ado"I've had these sandals for two years and they're still going strong! I bought them for a Disney trip in 2022 and wore them to three parks. They're comfortable and casual enough to wear with most outfits, but they're cute enough to wear with a nice, flowy summer dress. They're pretty sturdy, too. Highly recommend!" —Renz de GulaGet it from Amazon for $50+ (available in sizes 3–11 and 13 colors — not all sizes available in all colors).
Skechers rhinestone slingbacks to glam up even your most basic and plain outfits with a bit of *sparkly* fun. Plus, your feet will feel like absolute royalty, thanks to the yoga foam sole.
A pair of Clarks flip-flops for a pair of easy-on summer sandals that won't break your back (or your budget). Don't be fooled by their appearance — they're built with a cushiony, supportive orthopedic footbed!
Promising review: "These are so great ! My 1st pair lasted about three years , I still wear them at home . Just got the same pair as a replacement . Most comfortable flip- flops I ever had . Esp good for us older gals , and they look nice." —K. AdamsGet it from Amazon for $27.50+ (available in sizes 5–12 and dozens of colors).
Braided Plaka sandals that combine functionality with a breezy boho aesthetic, aka the perfect combo for oceanside strolls. The straps fit snugly around the foot without rubbing or pinching while the rubber soles are durable enough for sand, beach rocks, and other rough terrain.
An adjustable cloud-like sandal here to put an end to your search for the most comfortable shoe ever. With a contoured footbed that molds to your feet, these feel like walking on a soft, fluffy pillow (so don't be surprised when you're wearing them 24/7). 😍
Promising review: "I have a bad back and knees. This is my second pair and I love these shoes. I feel like I am walking on a cloud! I have had my first pair for 2 years and I wear them quite often. The durability and quality has stayed looking good as well." —megan rech"I bought these for beach sandals, and they were not just affordable but so comfortable I bought five more pairs! I'm not a person concerned with style, so if you are I'm sure this isn't for you, but if you want comfort, these are your perfect match! Lots of color options and after two years, I can assure you they're durable too." —Alexandra Z.Get them from Amazon for $22.99+ (available in sizes 5.5–16W, 3.5–15M, and 18 colors).
A pair of Ecco sports sandals you'll turn to again and again for beach walks, sports games, hiking, sightseeing excursions, and other adventures in the years ahead. Reviewers rave about their comfort, support, and durability.
Promising reviews: "I love these sandals. Bought in a different color about four years ago. I'm still wearing them. They are pretty, well-made, and sturdy. On this new pair, there is a 'gold' covering on part of the straps and sides. Pretty, but not my taste. However, they're not prominent, so I'll keep them. Definitely recommend!" —Cecil"I love these sandals! They are my second pair. I have had my first pair for about five years. I use them to hike and for everyday use. I bought a new pair because my others were dirty due to hiking and working in the yard, but not worn out. Great arch support and a great walking shoe. My new ones will be fit for going out!" —LynGet them from Amazon for $91.08+ (available in sizes 4–12.5 and 35 colors).
Crocs flip-flops that don't look like the typical Crocs, but offer a similar feel in terms of comfort. We're talking lightweight and flexible support that makes these bbs perfect for poolside lounging and casual strolls alike — and just like the OG Crocs, they'll last you for many MANY moons!
Or these strappy Crocs sandals if you want the same comfort, convenience, and reliability the brand is known for, only a more aesthetic design than the classic clogs or flip-flops. Whether you're a die-hard Crocs lover or new to the cult, you're gonna want these cuties in your collection.
A water-resistant strappy sandal because it's designed with a sturdy sole that'll help stabilize and support your arches and relieve pressure on your joints, meaning you'll actually *want* to wear them year after year.
A pair of minimalistic sandals to complete your laid-back boho summer aesthetic — just pair 'em with a flowy romper or peasant dress and you're set!
Promising review: "These are my absolute favorite shoes; I have them in black. They go with everything, and they are the most comfortable shoes I have. They are well-made, and even though I have had them for a couple of years, they have shown no wear. I love them so much, I just bought a pair for my DIL for Christmas! She was thrilled." —UK76girlGet them from Amazon for $109.95+ (available in sizes 6–11 and six colors).