Councillors agreed with Dippie's email insults
Allan Dippie's views about councillors were contained in an email exchange when he butted heads with mayoral candidate and fellow businessman Andrew Simms over the planned $100 million Smooth Hill landfill south of Brighton.
Mr Dippie yesterday said he had had an "unusual response from the councillors in terms of them telling me that they weren't offended".
Instead, they backed his support for the Smooth Hill landfill, he said.
The commentary in the emails, which both businessmen have now shared with the Otago Daily Times , "was kind of a bit of private banter", Mr Dippie said.
"I did have the graciousness to apologise.
"I apologised to the councillors, and then I got a whole lot of councillors backing me.
Mr Dippie shared texts and emails he had received from councillors in response to his apology , which included:
"I totally agree with your weird and woke comment, no apology needed from me ... "
And: "Thanks for your email. No offence taken. Your submission was so refreshing thank you. It was great."
Cr Steve Walker said: "I'm hard to offend Allan, so no issue from me. To be honest, I've begun taking it as a compliment being referred to as woke!"
Mr Dippie's emails — in which he said Mr Simms had been "hijacked by both the existing landfill operators and some alarmist Nimbys" — questioned both the quality of the Future Dunedin ticket that Mr Simms assembled for the October election as well as the present crop of councillors.
"Just look at the lack of talent and the general weirdness and wokeness of some of the present councillors, probably the best money they have ever been on and ever will be," Mr Dippie wrote.
"The scary thing is these individuals are sometimes in charge of decisions way beyond their capability.
"It's probably cruel."
The email exchange included Mr Dippie's brother Martin Dippie and council chief executive Sandy Graham copied in.
Mr Dippie said yesterday he copied in the chief executive as a courtesy.
Mr Simms said yesterday the fact Ms Graham was copied into the emails was why they were now public.
However, he "immediately pushed back" on Mr Dippie's characterisation of both prospective councillors and sitting councillors because it was "really unfair".
"I think the 'private banter' argument kind of disappears when you start copying the chief executive of the DCC into emails."
Mr Simms said he wanted a discussion of the merits of building a landfill at Smooth Hill compared with transporting waste to AB Lime's landfill at Winton, but Mr Dippie had made his criticism of this through an "attack" calling Mr Simms' position "populist electioneering" and claiming he had been captured by those with a vested interest.
"The affordability of rates is going to be a big issue this election, as is the mounting core council debt," Mr Simms said.
"And both of those things are contributed to significantly by a decision to spend $100 million on a landfill when there is an option that doesn't seem to have received sufficient consideration."
Ms Graham did not respond to ODT questions yesterday. A council spokesman said "it was not a staff matter".
However, Cr Mandy Mayhem said there were "some great minds" around the council table.
"I am sure Mr Dippie is embarrassed about his remarks."
Cr Carmen Houlahan said she appreciated Mr Dippie's comments about Smooth Hill at the hearings.
"His comments are unacceptable but need to be taken in context that they were private communication between him and Andrew Simms," she said.
It did a disservice to the community when a project was being "slammed for the purpose of electioneering", Cr Bill Acklin said.
"I think the greater concern for the community is expensive advertisements containing individuals' opinions being delivered as if they were facts."
Cr Sophie Barker said she was pleased to receive "and accept" Mr Dippie's apology, which celebrated councillors' diversity.
Cr Andrew Whiley said he did not believe Mr Dippie owed councillors an apology.
Cr Brent Weatherall said everyone was entitled to an opinion and it was "sad" Mr Dippie felt the need to apologise..
hamish.maclean@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
44 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
Engine issues continue to affect Dunedin flights
Global engine maintenance issues affecting Air New Zealand's fleet and Dunedin travellers are not expected to be resolved until 2028, the Otago Daily Times can reveal. Air New Zealand chief executive Greg Foran told the ODT yesterday it was "still about two plus years away" from "getting on top" of the engine issues. He shared the news after speaking with the chief executive of international aerospace manufacturer Pratt & Whitney earlier in the day. "It's unfortunate because we've already had about two years of it, but it's a tough problem to solve and there are many factors that are involved in it." In July 2023, Pratt & Whitney disclosed a condition affecting the maintenance plan for the geared turbofan jet engine fleet. Mr Foran previously said that, while the maintenance issue did not pose a safety issue, this had caused the airline to revise its flight schedule. Since late February, it has been using a 68-seat ATR-72 turboprop plane instead of the roomier 171-seat Airbus A320 on its morning and evening flights between Dunedin and Wellington — meaning the first flight of the day arrives in Wellington 50 minutes later than it did before. Mr Foran yesterday said the engines on about half of its Airbus fleet were bought during a period where a batch of "contaminated metal" was used. About 1200 engines were queued up waiting to be checked, which had created a backlog. "We're a bit unlucky. We just happened to purchase engines during this period. "It'll work its way through. They're safe but they need to be checked and hopefully by about 2028 we think we should be through." When asked if there could be further changes to domestic flight schedules and capacity, Mr Foran said there "probably will, but hopefully not as much as it has been as we work through these issues". He empathised with Air New Zealand's customers and the impact on them. "We're over half way. I wish it was going to be fixed by Christmas. It won't, but it will get fixed. "And as soon as those planes are available to come back, then they will." An interim report from Dunedin Airport earlier this year said domestic seat capacity remained limited due to Air New Zealand's ongoing fleet challenges, and it did not anticipate any "meaningful improvements" in the airline's capacity until late 2026. Chief executive Daniel De Bono said the engine issues affecting Air New Zealand's fleet, and many other airlines globally, were easing but remained outside of both the airport and Air Zealand's direct control. "We remain focused on working with Air New Zealand and our other airline partners to grow air capacity from Dunedin. "The aviation sector regularly faces challenges like this and the key is to work collaboratively through them." The engine-related domestic capacity constraints had reduced available seat capacity and limited the airport's ability to grow in the short term. It was a "dynamic situation" not isolated to Dunedin or New Zealand. As a global supply chain challenge, the airport had taken a conservative approach in its forward planning to account for the uncertainty, Mr De Bono said. "We also expect further changes to the domestic network as Air New Zealand navigates the [engine] issues and softer domestic demand. "Shocks like this happen in aviation, but the medium to long-term growth path generally remains steady." Business South chief executive Mike Collins said its main concern was maintaining reliable air connectivity in the region. "Flights are critical for business, tourism and freight — the reality is that ongoing constraints risk impacting local growth. "We encourage Air New Zealand to keep regional centres front of mind in any schedule changes." While the engine issues were complex and global, uncertainty around flight availability hurt businesses' confidence, Mr Collins said. Every cancelled flight or reduced service chipped away at business confidence and reliable services were key to unlocking economic opportunities for Dunedin and the South. "Businesses rely on certainty to make decisions — and right now, there's a real lack of it when it comes to regional air connectivity. "That creates challenges not just for planning travel, but for investment, growth and confidence in the region."
Otago Daily Times
5 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Air NZ's engine issues to persist
Greg Foran. File photo: Tracey Roxburgh lobal engine maintenance issues affecting Air New Zealand's fleet and Dunedin travellers are not expected to be resolved until 2028, the Otago Daily Times can reveal. Air New Zealand chief executive Greg Foran told the ODT yesterday it was "still about two plus years away" from "getting on top" of the engine issues. He shared the news after speaking with the chief executive of international aerospace manufacturer Pratt & Whitney earlier in the day. "It's unfortunate because we've already had about two years of it, but it's a tough problem to solve and there are many factors that are involved in it." In July 2023, Pratt & Whitney disclosed a condition affecting the maintenance plan for the geared turbofan jet engine fleet. Mr Foran previously said that, while the maintenance issue did not pose a safety issue, this had caused the airline to revise its flight schedule. Since late February, it has been using a 68-seat ATR-72 turboprop plane instead of the roomier 171-seat Airbus A320 on its morning and evening flights between Dunedin and Wellington — meaning the first flight of the day arrives in Wellington 50 minutes later than it did before. Mr Foran yesterday said the engines on about half of its Airbus fleet were bought during a period where a batch of "contaminated metal" was used. About 1200 engines were queued up waiting to be checked, which had created a backlog. "We're a bit unlucky. We just happened to purchase engines during this period. "It'll work its way through. They're safe but they need to be checked and hopefully by about 2028 we think we should be through." When asked if there could be further changes to domestic flight schedules and capacity, Mr Foran said there "probably will, but hopefully not as much as it has been as we work through these issues". He empathised with Air New Zealand's customers and the impact on them. "We're over half way. I wish it was going to be fixed by Christmas. It won't, but it will get fixed. "And as soon as those planes are available to come back, then they will." An interim report from Dunedin Airport earlier this year said domestic seat capacity remained limited due to Air New Zealand's ongoing fleet challenges, and it did not anticipate any "meaningful improvements" in the airline's capacity until late 2026. Chief executive Daniel De Bono said the engine issues affecting Air New Zealand's fleet, and many other airlines globally, were easing but remained outside of both the airport and Air Zealand's direct control. "We remain focused on working with Air New Zealand and our other airline partners to grow air capacity from Dunedin. "The aviation sector regularly faces challenges like this and the key is to work collaboratively through them." The engine-related domestic capacity constraints had reduced available seat capacity and limited the airport's ability to grow in the short term. It was a "dynamic situation" not isolated to Dunedin or New Zealand. As a global supply chain challenge, the airport had taken a conservative approach in its forward planning to account for the uncertainty, Mr De Bono said. "We also expect further changes to the domestic network as Air New Zealand navigates the [engine] issues and softer domestic demand. "Shocks like this happen in aviation, but the medium to long-term growth path generally remains steady." Business South chief executive Mike Collins said its main concern was maintaining reliable air connectivity in the region. "Flights are critical for business, tourism and freight — the reality is that ongoing constraints risk impacting local growth. "We encourage Air New Zealand to keep regional centres front of mind in any schedule changes." While the engine issues were complex and global, uncertainty around flight availability hurt businesses' confidence, Mr Collins said. Every cancelled flight or reduced service chipped away at business confidence and reliable services were key to unlocking economic opportunities for Dunedin and the South. "Businesses rely on certainty to make decisions — and right now, there's a real lack of it when it comes to regional air connectivity. "That creates challenges not just for planning travel, but for investment, growth and confidence in the region."
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Letters to the Editor: tariffs, water and racists
Today's Letters to the Editor from readers cover topics including how to skin the US tariffs cat, North East Valley's water worries, and is New Zealand "as racist as f..."? More than one way to skin the US tariffs cat The issues surrounding Mr Trump's imposition of duties on all and sundry in the wider world makes fascinating news, as is his support of American business' right to do anything they like. For example the minimum taxes organisations such as Google, Facebook et al pay from revenue generated in countries such as ours. And of course a country as small as New Zealand is the proverbial weakling v the sumo bully. Currently this tax is around $8 million against total revenue of around $3 billion. Good luck to anyone thinking that goodness of heart and all that will make the biggies get honest. But there is more than one way of skinning cats. Why not just make all advertising by New Zealand business on those platforms non claimable as a business expense? It might, as a spin-off, direct more advertising revenue into New Zealand advertising channels, all of whom appear to be struggling. As an aside, I read this morning that several large beef retailers will not stock US beef. As I said, more than one way to skin cats. Pipes or seesaws I refer to Gillian Macleod's letter (1.8.25): I think she has missed the point of MP Sam Uffindell's comments. I am sure Sam is not wanting to be the "fun police". I certainly enjoy taking my grandchildren to playgrounds around Dunedin. I have had fun on the George St seesaw. However all of us who enjoy the recreational amenities should also give a thought to Lynne Newall in Surrey St. It is totally unacceptable that we have a sewerage system that has repeatedly failed. I am sure Lynne would choose to have her toilet working rather than a seesaw. I certainly would prioritise the former. Dunedin and many other communities have to decide on priority spending. Those of us who benefit from functioning Three Waters should advocate for those who don't and forgo our recreational activities in favour of the health and safety of others. Interestingly the DCC is paying $600,000 a week in interest payments. This is actually the first priority of our spending. Water woes Thank you for the article on North East Valley water worries and congratulations to Mary Williams for yet another thoughtful, well-researched story about an urgent issue. I think there were at least five decent stories in just that one article — the DCC's lackadaisical approach to logging sewage outflows being the most salient. I've lived in NEV since the 1990s. I walked through Chingford Park during the 2015 floods. I think one tree falling there would have been enough, such was the power of the water, to create a dam within minutes. This is urgent, local news. Being forewarned and forearmed against a disastrous flood must be worth millions. Remember Ally It was good to see the sports article in today's ODT (5.8.25) acknowledging Niamh Fisher-Black's fifth placing overall in the Tour de France Femmes along with Ella Wyllie 12th placing overall. Missing from the story was that Ally Wollaston, another Kiwi cyclist, was a member of the best team overall (FDJ-Suez). It was great to see her on the top step of the podium with her team at the finish of the world's greatest multi-day road cycling race. An unseemly stir among the keyboard warriors In your words, "The appointment of Nikhil Ravishankar as Air New Zealand's incoming chief executive has caused a stir, after major news outlets were forced to disable comments on their social media platforms due to receiving a barrage of racist remarks." In an interview Taika Waititi once described New Zealand as "as racist as f... ." Accordingly people were up in arms. How dare he say that, they asked, mostly on talkback radio. This sort of situation proves his point. As an indirect shareholder in Air New Zealand I couldn't care less if an eleven-eyed, multi-tentacled green alien from Planet Byrzzgh4 got the job, as long as they were competently able to lead the company forward. I wouldn't mind betting that all these secret assailants hammering away on their keyboards would be among the first to say "I'm not a racist, but . . .". Turning off The 2017 All Blacks series against the Lions was drawn as a result of an incorrect refereeing decision, the 2023 Rugby World Cup Final was decided by the television match official, the Lions' series win over Australia is shrouded in controversy . And rugby administrators wonder why people are switching off their game? Address Letters to the Editor to: Otago Daily Times, PO Box 517, 52-56 Lower Stuart St, Dunedin. Email: editor@
