logo
Kate Forbes should be chair of Highlands and Islands Enterprise

Kate Forbes should be chair of Highlands and Islands Enterprise

First though, I should say there is absolutely no reason to doubt the primary reason for her departure. Standing again means another five years as an absentee parent. I have filled that role and know that there is really no way round it. Politics, particularly with serious responsibilities, is not a family-friendly occupation.
Read More:
Dingwall, for practical purposes, is as distant from Edinburgh as from London. Ms Forbes is surely right to criticise the modesty of creche facilities at Holyrood but the reality is that attentive parenthood and seven, or even six, days a week of heavy political duties do not really mix. A choice has to be made and I respect her for making the one she has.
No matter who is taking such a decision, there are always other factors in play. If independence was round any foreseeable corner, would she stay? If the party dynamics were more congenial would it make a difference? These are all hypotheses which can be speculated upon but should not detract from straightforward acceptance of the reason given.
Why am I sorry to see her go? There are two principal reasons. First, she is patently head and shoulders above those around her in terms of ability and, heaven knows, Scotland needs people of ability – regardless of party affiliation – to be involved in its devolved affairs, whether in government or opposition.
The second runs a little deeper and more personal. There are very few at Holyrood who has any ingrained knowledge of, or care very much about, causes to which I have devoted a disproportionate part of my own political life – the land, the language and the people of our fragile periphery. Ms Forbes was a clear exception.
To most of Scotland, never mind the wider world, these are arcane matters. There is no particular reason why Ecclefechan or Easterhouse should concern themselves with crofting or ferries or Gaelic or land reform or fishing or depopulation of places which could, with wiser interventions, be lively, flourishing communities.
This is, quite reasonably, reflected in those they elect which in turn means that government as it relates to these complex, minority matters is in the hands of politicians with no particular interest or empathy. This void is eagerly filled by civil servants who share the same lack of qualifications. The result is insipid legislation and decision-making which displays no awareness of a bigger picture.
Kate Forbes was very different in these respects and I would have been very pleased to see her elected two years ago as First Minister for the duration of this Parliament. Her competence and the ability to make a difference on matters she personally cares about would have been two welcome breaths of fresh air.
The people who now sit around the Bute House table with her thought differently, from Swinney downwards, and rallied to the standard of Humza Yousaf. In other words, they did what they were told. This is the Sturgeon clone-ocracy continuing; cheer-leaders for all the wokery and Greenery that Ms Forbes stood against, from Highly Protected Marine Areas through Deposit Return Scheme to a convicted rapist in a women's prison and the madness that ensued.
Much was made of Ms Forbes' religious affiliations as if the Free Church of Scotland was some outlandish cult which ate its young, rather than having its roots in radical resistance to the power and patronage of landlordism. The irony was that those who reviled her were themselves much more cultish and gender politics was their false god until that tide turned.
McAllan, Gilruth, Constance and indeed Swinney…. When has any of them demonstrated capacity for an original thought or strain of resistance to whatever orthodoxy was prevailing at the time? In these respects, Ms Forbes was significantly different and she paid a political price. I doubt if she will look back with regret at being out of it.
Anyway, I have a suggestion which, as ever, is intended to be helpful. I cannot help noticing that there is currently a vacancy for a chair of Highlands and Islands Enterprise. It is a three day week job based in Inverness. Personally, I would have absolutely no complaint if Ministers cut through the bogus quango appointment system and offered it to Ms Forbes.
This would serve three purposes. First, it would give her a role to which her talents are well suited. Second, it would give that agency a strong voice in corridors of power, whoever happens to occupy them. Third, it would signal a return to days when people appointed to these jobs were expected to be free spirits, rather than servants of the Scottish Government.
It is 60 years this month since the incoming Labour government fulfilled a manifesto commitment to establish the Highlands and Islands Development Board, HIE's predecessor, with wide-ranging social and economic powers. For decades, one of its qualities was that the people who led it, quite irrespective of party politics, were serious public figures, expected to be thorns in the side of governments.
Under the dull, centralising mentality of SNP rule, all that has gone and HIE is, like all the other quangos, required to maintain a low profile on a shrunken budget. I doubt if Ms Forbes would settle for that which is exactly why I would recommend her appointment. I'm sure the incumbent could be persuaded to hang on for another few months.
I have no insight into Ms Forbes intentions but suspect she would be happier in a role where she can make a real difference without the encumbrance of party politics. Better still indeed if, this time next year, it is a Labour-led government she can be a thorn in the side of while the remnants of the Sturgeon-Yousaf regimes contemplate five long years of opposition.
Brian Wilson is a former Labour Party politician. He was MP for Cunninghame North from 1987 until 2005 and served as a Minister of State from 1997 to 2003.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nicola Sturgeon says monarchy 'should end soon' at book launch
Nicola Sturgeon says monarchy 'should end soon' at book launch

The National

time11 minutes ago

  • The National

Nicola Sturgeon says monarchy 'should end soon' at book launch

The former first minister was interviewed by ex-BBC Newsnight presenter Kirsty Wark in a packed out McEwan Hall as part of the Edinburgh International Book Festival. As part of the conversation, Sturgeon reflected on her encounters with Queen Elizabeth, a woman she said she had had "huge admiration" for. But she went on to say King Charles and other members of the royal family so not have the same "mystique" as the Queen did, and so people are coming to realise the "absurdities" of the monarchy. Asked about when the monarchy should end, Sturgeon said: "I think it should end probably quite soon." READ MORE: National Library of Scotland debunks claim it 'banned' gender-critical book After a round of applause, she went on: "I think we will look back, and I don't know if this will be in 10 years or 100 years, and history will look back on the death of Queen Elizabeth as probably the beginning of the end of the monarchy because there was such a mystique around her and, with the greatest of respect to the King and the other members of the royal family, I just don't think they have that to the same extent and I think without that, what we focus more on and what we will focus more on are the absurdities of the monarchy." Sturgeon has been under the spotlight this whole week following the release of Frankly, which officially came out on Thursday but has been available in bookshops since Monday. The relationship between Sturgeon and her predecessor Alex Salmond dominated the interview, with Wark asking early on in the chat whether Sturgeon felt Salmond had ever been guilty of "coercive control". Wark claimed there had "almost been a thread of coercive control" from Salmond running through the book which she asked Sturgeon about. The former first minister replied: "I wouldn't describe it as that. "He was an incredibly strong and charismatic individual and for much of my life he was a force for good. He encouraged me to reach beyond what I would have considered my abilities to be, he pushed me on. I once said ages ago he believed in me before I believed in myself and all of that is true. I try to be true to that in the book and not to rewrite history." She went on to describe how Salmond's approval and disapproval of her impacted her greatly, something she came to realise through getting counselling. She said: "What I do think is that I realised a couple of times, even after I was first minister, that his approval mattered to me and his disapproval knocked by confidence and I think latterly, he probably played on that a little bit, but that was something I realised was there through my psychologist." Sturgeon was also heavily quizzed about her leadership around gender reform. Earlier this week Sturgeon said she should have paused gender reform legislation that was going through the Scottish Parliament towards the end of her tenure. READ MORE: SNP demand UK Government act amid Israeli E1 plan in West Bank The Gender Recognition Reform Bill would have allowed transgender people to self-identify and simplified the requirements to acquire a gender recognition certificate (GRC), before it was blocked by Westminster from becoming law. She said during the interview that one of the reasons she may not have paused was to not "give in" to transphobic people. "When it became so toxic, maybe I should have taken a step back and paused to see if we could find a less divisive way through it. Would that have worked? I don't know. "But I guess what stopped me, and I'm not saying this was the right decision, but if I look back on what stopped me at the time [...], every time I say this I get howls of derision even though I caveat it in the way I'm about to caveat it, but I don't think everyone who disagrees with me on this issue is transphobic. But this whole issue has been hijacked and weaponised by people who are transphobic. "I think I perhaps worried that to pause at the time would have been to give in to that."

Sturgeon: I did not appreciate factors behind attainment gap
Sturgeon: I did not appreciate factors behind attainment gap

The Herald Scotland

time27 minutes ago

  • The Herald Scotland

Sturgeon: I did not appreciate factors behind attainment gap

She said that when she promised to eradicate the gap between the educational performance of pupils from rich and poor areas, she 'probably [did not] appreciate' the full extent of the factors that influence it. In a speech in 2015, Ms Sturgeon said: 'My aim, to put it bluntly, is to close the attainment gap completely. "It will not be done overnight, I accept that. But it must be done. "After all, its existence is more than just an economic and social challenge for us all. It is a moral challenge. Indeed, I would argue that it goes to the very heart of who we are and how we see ourselves as a nation.' READ MORE Sandie Peggie: NHS Fife admits breaking law over trans doctor's use of changing room GERS: Can the SNP still afford the social contract? National Library accused of 'cowardice' over exclusion of gender-critical book In their 2016 manifesto, the SNP said 'closing the gap in attainment between young people from our most and least deprived communities will be the defining mission of the SNP in the next parliament.' Ms Sturgeon then said her government would push to substantially reduce the attainment gap by 2026, writing in that year's Programme for Government document that elimination of the gap was 'a yardstick by which the people of Scotland can measure our success'. However, exams results last week revealed that despite some progress, the rate of the attainment gap remains substantial. The National 5 rate dropped from 17.2% to 16.6% while Higher saw a small dip from 17.2% to 17.1% and Advanced Higher from 15.5% to 12.8%. The gap in the number of pupils achieving an A also reduced slightly at all levels, but remained substantially higher than the A-C rate. In National 5, the rate fell from 27.6% to 27.5%, 22.1% to 22% in Higher and 18.7% to 18.3% in Advanced Higher. Asked about the failure to eliminate the gap during the book festival event, Ms Sturgeon said: 'This is possibly one of my biggest regrets. At the time, I made the promise of probably not appreciating as much as I quickly came to do the factors that would influence that. 'And that was not just about issues around the curriculum in schools, but what is the driving cause of the poverty related attainment gap in our schools? It's poverty, it's the conditions children grow up in, outside school." "So some of the things that I am proudest of are the Scottish Child Payment, the doubling or early years education, the baby box. "These are things that are lifting children out of poverty, and I believe in time will make a difference to the Scottish Government." Ms Sturgeon added: 'I think Scottish education is good. I don't believe it is in the terrible state that many say. I believe we saw in the exams results last week that the attainment gap is starting to close. 'I'm not really sitting here saying I don't regret that it didn't go further.' She added: 'On this particular issue, and again, I'm being frank about it, it was probably a lack of appreciation of what you had." Ms Sturgeon said initiatives and putting money into education was not enough. "All of that is right, but unless you're changing the conditions kids are growing up in, then you're not going to have the impact. And that's what I learned along the way."

Edinburgh book shop manager's one-word comment after visit from Nicola Sturgeon
Edinburgh book shop manager's one-word comment after visit from Nicola Sturgeon

Edinburgh Live

time32 minutes ago

  • Edinburgh Live

Edinburgh book shop manager's one-word comment after visit from Nicola Sturgeon

Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Nicola Sturgeon made a sneaky city centre appearance at an Edinburgh book shop on Thursday head of her much-anticipated book. The former First Minister popped into Toppings & Company Booksellers of Edinburgh on Blenheim Place today to promote her brand new memoir, Frankly. Sturgeon snapped a photo in front of the shop after signing copies of the book, which the store's manager said would be "our biggest book of this year and probably several years". The politician was in centre city on her way to the Book Festival when she popped in for just 20 minutes. However, Toppings staff are hopeful Sturgeon will return for a formal event later this year. Manager Duncan Furness told Edinburgh Live: "She's all over the media promoting her memoir. She's working hard." He called the former leader of Scotland "bubbly" and "very open", adding: "She was chatting about books in general, she was positive, easy to talk to." Duncan had met Nicola earlier this year at a dinner in Glasgow and found her to be "the same" as before: "very open, chatty, happy to discuss anything you want to discuss. I thought she was very impressive." In his tenure as manager at Toppings, Duncan had encountered Sturgeon before when she frequented the store as a book lover. Now, staff were thrilled to welcome her back as an author herself. Duncan said the shop received hundreds of signed copies of her book from the publisher and that he was looking forward to reading it cover to cover. He said: "I'm four chapters in. It's quite a big book. We only got them in on Monday like everyone else. I'm enjoying it but she's still in university [in the book]. All the political stuff is yet to come." Toppings staff hope to arrange a formal event with Nicola Sturgeon this November or early December. Her debut memoir, "Frankly: The Revelatory Memoir from Scotland's First Female and Longest-serving First Minister" was released today, August 14. Nicola Sturgeon served as First Minister from 2014 until 2023, when she made a surprise resignation. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sentstraight to your messages.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store